Miley Cyrus - Good and Broken - Idol Gives Back

[jisusa0122]

When did you take this?

[Nataliyamusic]

not the whole song, this is sad :(

it's a great song for me, probably one of the best by Miley.

btw they are both so funny, she's amazing, good on the stage.

[jobrosrock32118]

did he purposley mispronounce her name?  lol yeah I think he did!

[Girlgenerationlover]

miley so pretty

[HomeCorner1]

Thumbs up if you're watching this in 2011:P

[ilovephones42]

im sure that when he said "Milly" Cyrus it was a joke, you know just a thought...

[MileyCyrusForeverFB]

0:47 - 0:50 Milly Cyrus? get it right.

[LexissBaaby]

@MileyCyrusForeverFB i am pretty sure it was part of the joke, calm down :L

[MileyCyrusForeverFB]

Milly Cyrus? stupid. seriously, get it right.

[Catherine14595]

Omg she looks older that 15! I have 16 now and I still feel like a child :D :D

[mileyselenafan39]

I didn't know who is was until he said Monsters Inc either!!

[mileyselenafan39]

I love Miley!!

[StuddedSchoelac3s]

I like that the opening is longer than the actual performance haha. I love Billy Crystal, whatta great man.

[StuddedSchoelac3s]

I that the opening was longer than the actual performance. I love Billy Cyrstal.

[ohhowsplendid]

haha jailbait

[PinkStarDust10]

Miley is sooo funny! She did a very good job! Love her outfit to. :D She looks 17 here, not 15!

[Ashleechoi7]

OH MY GOSH I WANT HER JACKET

[Ashleechoi7]

I Love her jacket. Miley is soo amazing. She was only 15 then!

[GermanGirlHannover]

best live perfomance

[katjamohren]

great

[singurr1]

wow 11 people accidentally pressed the dislike button. Miley is amazing <333

[AnimeRox1011]

"Why wernt you invited" lolz wow

[Shelbysummer14]

She doesn't look like she is 15

[EliteZniper]

Miss Milly Sirrus?

[EverythingConnie]

oh come on if u hate miley then why u still look her up?

those rude comments will hurt her everyone want to get some respects shes doing this for her fans just go away if u hate her period

[l34runita]

I LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE THIS <3 <3 ,just realized that she performed when David Archuleta was there on AI 7 ...wow fool me :(

[vertexgirl]

Miss Millie Sirus! bhahhaha

[abbey0kim]

She so funnyy./



[iiLoveMJx]

she one of those people you either Love or Hate...

if you Love her great, you Hate her don't search her and watch videos of her and write childish things about her..

I'm not a big fan well not a fan at all but I think she's funny and stunning and half her songs are brill... leave the poor girl alone she just a young talented girl trying to be what she wants to be...

[Jesant045]

I love her outfit and her hair and she is sooooo pretty there, her voice is kinda weird there I think that's the reason why.. the uvula thingy xD was cut off?

[Schmilerz]

oh i just did a movie...it´s number one at the boxoffices ....HahHAHhahA

[jonasbrosiwish1]

She sure does like that mike-stand. -.- But I loved the first bit. ;D

[mileyismylifee]

when was this/

[lilialou92]

@mileyismylifee 2008 i think

[smileitstephie]

wow shes almost 18 now! time flys by! <3

[ClaraCupcakeCore]

Funny.!

Love it.!

[lilialou92]

@stz2010 that's because they were both acting there....?

[archergal414]

This is just hilarious. This is the first video that made me love her so much.

[subway108]

OMFG! let her sing!! they took so long to let her sing the damn song! lol

[roxysurf23]

lol i love miley heree

[tacobell0004]

Nice dance moves. ha. yeah right

[JBloverforever94]

she sounds really sick/.

[PianoGirl555]

love miley!!!!

she has become so famous and successful at a young age..

her songs are wonderful! :)

[Ayprilstar]

im 15 wow

good age for a star

[themandyshowx]

put that thing back where it came from or so help me ... haha miley is sooo funny i love her

[JinacraZy4celebs]

even tho she was sick here i love her!

[luuujann]

When was this?

[AslamDudeeh]

Miley: "I already did a movie".

Haha, when did a concert became a movie? But that's the only movie you should've done, cause the Hannah Montana The Movie is a disgrace to life. Someone should have seriously stopped you from doing that movie, cause that was the biggest mistake of your life.

[candyluvpotion]

i love you miley cyrus and billy ray cyrus .

[budgiebreder]

best intro ever!

[mierty21]

mileyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy u rock awesome cool perfect great song i luv u omg i luv u sooooooooooooooooooooooooooo much dont listen 2 those i dont think they r a humen they r soooo jealous of u cuz well u got everything i feel so bad 4 ur fans on meebo they think im u hahaha loool i know its funny

[chifour66]

She did a great job with the banter! Those things are scripted and most of time they are really bad. Billy and Miley should present together more often.

[AslamDudeeh]

Miley: They're not called cd's anymore, they're called mp3's.

Go to hell, Miley!! What a stupid comment! You should be really embarrassed for saying that!

It's unfair that talented people who releases just crap music like you got to have a career!

[babydove101]

Wow, jealous much.

[AslamDudeeh]

No, I'm not jealous, I just hate her songs.

[babydove101]

Then why did you bother to look up and watch her video!?

[AslamDudeeh]

Haha... How old are you? Ten or Nine year old? Only a child would speak like that.

And you fans have to accept when Miley makes such stupid, idiotic comments or makes bad songs, she deserves critism. That's how showbiz is, you can't praise everything and everyone. I didn't hated Miley before, but her songs has gotten worse, as with her voice

[babydove101]

Um, I'm16, and no it's not a "childish" thing to say that, it's ridiculous to look up artists and watch their videos if you don't like them. Like rap I can't stand rap, so I don't look them up and leave rude and unnecessary comments because I do know that there are people who like that kind of music and I respect that.

[lilialou92]

@babydove101 thats sooo true u made my day haha

[babydove101]

@lilialou92 Haha, aww...thanks.

[NOLABABE93]

@babydove101 i agreee 100%

[meis2007]

@babydove101 You might be surpised that I'm saying this, but there are no written rules that says that only Miley-fans are allowed to comment. YouTube is a place for everyone to look up and comment, but you Miley fans are too paranoid to realize that. Don't worry, I don't hate Miley, but remember; If it weren't for her fans, she wouldn't have been where she is today. But you must also accept that she has haters. Every celebrity has haters and Miley is no exception.

[fanessencialhome]

@meis2007 yeah all that she is saying is that the haters shouldnt look up her video's on youtube just to say bad things about her.

[themandyshowx]

then dont listen to them

[Holdingouut]

She's the best ?! :) .

[adamdannyidols101]

STOP BRAGING!

[adamdannyidols101]

She sux at acting and singing!!!!!!!!

i can tell that she is faking but Billy acts realistic.

maybe Miley should try dancing!

lol

she bugs me!!!!!!!!

i actually know a lot of people who dont know her but know him!!!!!!!

[babydove101]

Damn, if you don't like her don't waste your time looking up her videos and watching them...watch the artists you do like.

[adamdannyidols101]

I HATE HER!!!!

[iHeartHeathLedger]

She's cute (:

[nylee4evr]

Not her best singing, still love her tho(=

[mileyraycyrusfan657]

everyone knows Miley Cyrus i mean who dosnt...Even my mom who dosnt know a word of english knows who she is and sings Best of both worlds lol....shes even on the spanish news sometimes..like enews but its a diffrent show ..gossiping about spanish celebs...some how they talk about miley haha...

[ZoeyLaura]

in germany she's not that famous! Nobody likes her here!

But i love her xD

[mileymandyshowfan08]

Yeah all my little sister know how to say at the moment is Mommy Sissy Bubby and Hannah Montana it funny and she walks around the hows singing The Best Of Both Worlds

[mileyraycyrusfan657]

HAHA My niece does the same ..she also sings party in the u.s.a sometimes

[newfuture2009]

I liked this Miley better. before she was a good role model and released good songs. now her new songs are awful and she's a slut

[Holdingouut]

You're so jeirk;

Poor Slut ;) :) .

[EmittingPhotons]

OMG!! THIS GUY'S MIKE WAZOSKI??

[kangamooz]

hahaha milly cirus

[kelresende1]

adoreiiiiiiiiiii

[iLikeVanessa7]

he said milly cierus

[katcarbeth]

What happened to this miley?

[XOXXLovemusic1]

Did he say Lilly cyrus?

[eimerie27]

she's great :D

[katafromnyc]

she had cold ouch. but she still was really good

[ClareRubi]

She looked GORGEOUS! Where the crap did she get those boots!?

[MegaFrenchgurl]

and that's what made me love her even more!!! :D <33

[Samantha2762]

that man is lost,seriosly,see a doctor before u make a fool of urself, miley's song rocks, and i cant believe he was voice of mike in monster inc. cool and to tell u the truth mike does look like a floating CBS sighn like that man said at

[jennydu0406]

lol

he actually planned that with her

[Cherone97]

he knew who she was it was planned it was just entertainment i mean seriosuly everyone in the world knows her my grandma even knows her

[penguinchick75]

which movie did she do that was number one?

[xoxo91x]

Bolt

[LuckyLove200]

hannah montana 3d movie concert :D

[EmilyandAlli]

i think it was the concert cuz it was before bolt and hm

[tayl0rrbby]

she is ssooo fxxckin' amazinn' (=

[therockerchic101]

she looks so beautiful and sweet here

[LinnAnneFtw]

Haha, this is hilarious!

"Are you in showbiz? Anything I would know of?"

[eroomhtur]

I can't find any good videos of Miley singing the climb on american idol....could you up load it and then i will subscribe.

[MusicFreakXPanic12]

MIlEy's AWesOM3!

[meis2007]

Billy Crystal seems so sweet

[totalmileyfan1]

I love Miley!! I love this song!!

[amaymiley]

she is os cool i love her ....

[LillReese]

Miley is 16 but you are right..she seems to be older

[wildthangthatsme]

she is so good in concert like katy perry is bad in concert

[TifaLockHeartCute]

If you Hate Miley than don't watch!

[untapie314]

she is 15, i am 15, and she looks so much older than me.

[TifaLockHeartCute]

you got to be kidding me, Miley don't even look 15, she look so grown up...in my opinion

[forbbiidenheaven]

she's 16

[untapie314]

she isnt here.

she is barely 15 in this video.

[forbbiidenheaven]

yeah, you're right... xd

[meis2007]

Billy Crystal: "I used to pretend that these people in the audience were naked when I started out".

Miley: "U-huh?"

[HiSxADDiCTiON]

she didn't do that bad in

my opinion, maybe at the end she did

a little worse, but it was fine!

[SParraga90]

Cuz I like the songs but i dont like her!

[SParraga90]

I hate miley!!!!

[mizbbalstr007]

u gotta love those generational gaps....HAHA

[Demato777]

oh gosh what's wrong with her? is she sick? her voice sounds damaged or something? poor miles

[lucyk310]

am a huge miley fan but when she dances while she is singin she just spoils it like at 5:24 and onwards !!!

AM NOT A MILEY HATER !!!!!!

[OrigionalEggxMate]

she cant sing this song live.

im not saying she cant sing.

but she just cant sing his live.

[Rockinviola59]

it was nerves

[v4n3ssath3b3st]

she was sick

[naomi505salazar]

yeah when its live its sounds weird!!

[chickengoodt]

Ahha I love her

[xXxHoney01xXx]

but she did sing at american idol, didn't she? yeah, she sang see you again

[casser26]

that was after this wasn't it?

[xXxHoney01xXx]

nah, i think it was before

[musicfromusagirl]

Miley is soooo funny

[StrawberryMartaChoco]

she's so funny =)

[tjsoul06]

OMG She is a GREAT performer! That was really good

[LiveInLoveFanVids]

"put that thing back where it came from or so help me!" hahaha

[Karissa1Yoshi]

she is soo good, and the quality rocks, I love the first part :)

[disneymediasource]

sound great go miles!!

[ObsessedwithMusic2]

wat movie is she talking about?

[mynameisdevin]

her 3-D concert movie

[slivenne]

loovve her,shes great

[Tvor1128]

I dont know why but she looks so awesome at 4:57

[xXXOlioXXx]

you can tell she is a little sick.

but i love this song.

[emosmentrox92]

by that u cn tell she gives alot 2 her fans, msot singers wouldnt sing if they were sick

[sweetpink562]

milly seeruss lol!

[btwrocknroll]

she sang great but she like skipped half of the actual song but i still like her!!!she wuz sick i guess

[mileyiscute107]

wow i love american idol and now miley is on it so that makes it more awesome.

[padfoot92]

whoa, she sounds aweful....i'm not a miley hater or anything, but that girl cant really sing

[slivenne]

i think she sang great

[nicolelm25]

i dont like her or her music or her talent..i mean if she had any.!!

[postergirlguitar]

she was awesome n if don't like it don't watch it a again u will do us all a favor....miley cyrus rox great song n voice

[sugarcookie21]

wow. she sucks. i mean, normally her music sounds ok...even good. but this really sucks.

[XoXEmoLiciousXoX]

He Doesnt Like Her =P

[mysterieux26]

is it an act or is that guy seriously pissed at miley??

[jblover126]

ACT!

[LogFshow]

why do you guys think so?? she IS very good! you dont even know her? Poor you.. No life at all.. your just jealous.. thats all! :* haha.

[jonasgal112]

i thought she only sang see you again

did they show this onn tv because i don't remember it

[Emmily33]

I think she was sick that night

[smdx2]

she was sick; okayy

allergies

[smileymiley1444]

yay

[BubblesxLovesxHim]

you people are like "She can't sing live but she's still a great singer"

don't you think if you're a SINGER you should be able to sing LIVE.

duh.

[speedygazelle22]

i LOVE THIS SONG!!!!!!!!!:) GO MILEY!!!:)

[kris10rox12345]

its not that great people demi is a hell of alot better

[sigo3453]

lmaoooo

so funny

and great song i love that song!!!!

woohooo

go milezzz!

x

[MileyCyrusIsSoHott]

he made her sound like a cloud lol

[Keelan1995]

does anyone else realise she is quite a poor singer lol?

[CandiQueen1232]

agreed!!!!!!!!

[slimjimzquinn27]

aww poor billy lol

[ami1043]

Even though it sounds rehearsed its still funny

[jedilamb]

lol this is funny