Added: 2 years ago
From: TheClique86
Views: 10,517
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (54)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • how does xy mean heroin?

  • @Masterreese1 he says "ex wife" not XY...and by ex wife he does mean heroin. He quit, and wanted it back

  • all versions of all his songs are each equally amazing. <3love him always.

  • lyrics " it dont matter cuz i have no sex life and all i wanna do now is inject my X-Y I've seen the story and i know what happens.

  • Well Im referring to a person. I know he was not.. I applied it to my own life. Why is everyone so analytical on here?

  • Cause when a guy speaks in metaphors, you're never going to understand what he's saying unless you actually think about it.

  • Comment removed

  • @tillyandthepoo isn't it inject my ex-wife?

  • Comment removed

  • @tillyandthepoo Elliott's "ex-wife" is heroin of course; he's not referring to a person.

  • @goodmusicguy97 Yeah. Not "XY" like someone suggested up there in the comments.......meaning Heroin.

  • seems off to me. song is still genius, prefer the studio version. feel like this version lost its ummph! but i like the enhanced background vocals

  • Just beautiful, R.I.P elliott smith<3

  • where did this come from i thought i had almost everything of Elliott's but i never heard this one

  • @passerby500 there's actually tons and tons of boots out there. search through sweet ady (.net) and you should find some links. but ya, this is just a really really low quality rip from the album... same exact version, no new 'mix,' as from a basement.

  • @awaggenspack no i have the basemeant on a hill version and of heard it a 100 times this version has the backing vocals up more in the mix, but i do agree that the rip is horrible quality

  • @passerby500 it's true, this version is definitely a different mixing. I'd love to hear a more high quality version, it's fantastic =)

  • @awaggenspack but it does sound changed after the fact it's not olny the back vocals up it is that whole range so someone prolly did some mid side on this or just cranked the eq's on on the backing vocal range.

  • @passerby500 ya that's my bet. it would explain why the bass is so muddy too.

  • I rarely get a chance to hear altered music but when it's good as this...........I cant explain it...it gives you tears and chill up the spine ; )

  • not really sure if this is an altered mix, if anything it could be "unaltered"

  • Comment removed

  • oh my god... this was so insanely good. i really wish elliott could have seen his vision the whole way through. this version is so much better than the "offical" one and i love that one. soooo amazing. thank you for sharing!

  • oh snap. this mix just brought tears to my eyes. thanks for sharing this with youtube

  • The backing vocals are a lot closer to the surface in this mix, including the whispering and talking. What sounds like a flanger on the lead vocal is more pronounced. There's some kind of additional, very fast, very brief delay effect in the percussion that's different but I can't quite put my finger on it. I really think this mix more effectively captures the dream-like chaos of the song more than the final master they used for Basement.

  • my thoughts exactly sir

  • yeah i think its sounds creepier and afterlife-ish

  • @Vamphaery ditto. it sounds (ironically) like a live performance, as if it were possible.

  • i have heard someone scream "BECAUSE I LOVE YOUUUU!!!!" in a live version. lol it made my heart sink. that's so sweet! <3 =] and in this version i always thought he said "because i love IT".

  • meant to say 2:20

  • 2:31 when the crazy noises comes in is awesome i love this version, give me one good reason not to do it, because.i.love.you

  • where can I download this version? this is amazing! one of the best Elliott Smith songs

  • Jennifer saying "because I love you" is still in this version. so it had to be mixed somewhat after he died.

  • this was put in the song during its recording, it was not put in as some sort of rememberance for elliott whatsoever

  • From what I've read in interviews and other people she used to go to his shows and say "because I love you" after he'd say that line, so I think it was put in there because it was seen as almost a lyric at that point. Just my opinion, but his girlfriend saying that had been around his whole last tour I think.

  • and his sister would sometime's be there known to scream because i love you as well as his gf

  • I am a musician and have been for about 7 years. My passion has always been writing music, which i was really bad at, until I heard Elliott.

    I owe so much too him and like most of us here...wish I could thank him.....

    As for this song??? Another example of how Elliott had the unbelievable power of giving shivers up your spine anytime you stop to listen to the music...or his lyrics.

    Delivered with that ever haunting voice :(

  • lovely version here, thanks alot for posting. Jennifer Chiba said in an interview shortly after his death that King's Crossing was the very last song Elliott put vocals on, the day before he died. obviously I don't know if that's true, but have to assume it is. somehow adds to this already moving masterpiece.

  • I was always under the impression that Suicide Machine was the last song he worked on, I must not have seen that source. Thanks for sharing

  • hi clique, in the interview, Chiba was referring specifically to adding vocals, so you may very well be correct. maybe Elliott went in to do some overdubs of instruments, etc...either way, it says so much about his music that people like you and I even have conversations like this, about things that might seem irrelevant to some...but not to us. cheers, and great videos! thanks.

  • thanks for posting this. i would love to hear the entire album as he had blue-printed it before his death. sad really that we'll never hear his vision for the masterpiece.

  • Comment removed

  • It's really interesting to listen to this song in particular, very cool mix

  • Personally, I think they should just publish his entire archive of work (in volumes of course, because there has to be TONS of it,) and let the proceeds all go to Inside Out or something along those lines. I think they feel that everything that anyone pays for has to be super slickly produced, but it's just not true. In fact, part of the appeal is that it's NOT pristine. I think that's what he was going for, in fact. Who knows, though.

  • btw, this version is much better than the original

  • no bass? i was waiting for that slide in the chorus

  • Sorry buddy, Elliott was prety anti bass or had other things in mind when he produced this set of songs

  • that's weird. i've always read he had a lot of respect for bass players and i think that the bass guitar was the first thing he picked up himself. i really enjoy this mix because it's less clean than the official. a little noisier, which is what he wanted with that last album, right? i enjoy that a lot.

  • all of this stuff is unfinished though, so the whole no bass thing could be an issue of not getting things done in time compared to any sort of actual musical direction, who knows though

  • I think it has been altered because in the original recording when he says "..a reason not do it, so do it" But in this version there is still the womens voice saying " Because I love you" Before So do it, because that's what his girlfriend would yell durin gthe song when he played shows. The voice was added after he died on the wished of his girlfriend and mother

  • The woman is Jennifer Chiba, Elliott's girlfriend at the time and this was put into the song when it was recorded, not after he died

  • you're exactly right my friend.

  • I'm pretty sure elliott brought them in to record the "because we love you" before he died.

  • i really like the version of "Stickman" from this same session.

  • i have this version actually. its really amazing.

  • Congrats, good job

  • There are added vocals and no bass for one. This song is is all Elliott's mixes and work, no one else has presumably touched it, let alone myself

  • GRAND

  • wow this is amazing.....much more beautiful than the studio version...

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more