Not even close. I dont blame anyone for wanting to cover Townes, but nobody can hold a flame to him. Its great to pay tribute, but you will never touch that level.
Ha ha theres no question as musician this is by far better you may like the original better cause itsmore of your taste but musically this is put together way better and i dont care who you are you have to notice the major up grade in the voice singing on this version
singing was good, guitar wasn't good. yes, i realize this was not the original arrangement. whoever made this arrangement, i assume dax himself, didn't work that hard. it is boring as hell.
Really? I thought it was a pretty interesting take on it. The only other versions I've heard are Townes's own and Steve Earle's awesome cover (which is not dissimilar from Townes's original).
just my opinion. my favorite version is the one on live at the old quarter. they tried something new ill give them credit for that, but i wasn't a fan of the guitar. the beauty of this song's music was how it was better than pretty much everything ever made and was a guy and a guitar. and of course the lyrics.
Definitely agree with you there. That's how I feel about the Allison Kraus/Robert Plant version of "Nothin'". Actually, it's beautiful, but to me, that song has to be just a fingerpicked guitar and vocals. And not Robert Plant's vocals. :S So that's probably how you feel about this song.
I dunno, I mean it's not like Dax or Rob/Al are trying to supplant Townes' versions.
So i imagine all those comments that were removed were the negative ones. I like as many people as possible to be exposed to townes songs, though i think this band is not the best embassador. i'm also just confused and bitter about unorigional run of the mill bands like this getting huge gigs. (and removing negative comments about them from youtube)
unorigional? Do you know who this is you silly fuck? This is sir dax. You have no taste and obviously never heard when the kite string pops. Pathetic.
The thing that's great about this, though I don't even know who Dax is, is that I read that in Townes notes on this song, instead of "alegretto" or something, he wrote "this song should be screamed".
Yeah, "this song should be screamed"!. Reading that made me love Townes twice as much. If Kurt Cobain had done a cover of this on Unplugged like he did the Leadbelly song, that whole generation would know and love Townes by now... and be far richer for it.
I think this is really good. A GREAT cover, because its faithful to the original melodies and lyrics, but changes the style completely. Dax is doing a good job singing, and the guitarist is pretty great. The drummer is awesome, he has a lot of energy.
Very different than Townes, obviously but these guys were not trying to be Townes. Townes may have dug it-its very different but cool in a completely different way.
i wouldn't say "he doesn't have the right to play it" but i would say it's not a great cover. im not sure townes' music was ever meant for an electric guitar, let alone a full band setting, thats why a lot of studio recordings were so awful next to the live versions.
his drummer looks like that ethan guy...the fat actor who's a scientologist.
i really cant understand why everyone is hating on this. if you guys think dax has no right to play this song then you should know that Townes Van Zandt's son, is good friends with Dax, and he play's guitar on Dax's album.
i have been listening to towns van zandt since i was born. he is a fort worth legund and i grew up with his recordings. frankly your all being bitches :/
This version doesn't do Townes justice at all. Sorry to say so, but this just isn't good. For a good cover of this, check out Lyle Lovett's version on "step inside this house".
This song grows on you.I was not sure if I'd like it at first. The first few bars it sounded a little bit boring. Watched it 10 times and liked it better and better. He has a great voice, especially when the song developes. Great tribute to Townes, great grungy tribute. The original can't be beat, that's agreed and I can imagine why people don't like this version. But nonetheless decent version. I liked it. Is it available on a record.
He said these guys were called "The Black Clowns" but I didn't ask him if he gave them that name or if that was their name. I thought they provided excellent support though. I'm gonna see D-R and his band of merry rebels next week, can't wait!
*groan* I appreciate these kids doing this; but it's just painful to hear. This genre of music does not compliment the Godfather of Texas Folk's songs. Lungs is brickwall of a song, stopping everything we throw at it. It's better to leave it alone. But, kudo's for trying.
I totally agree. Yet I cannot help but find myself leaving a comment. This song may not do justice to the original and the way Townes meant for it to be heard. But, me, a fan of both Dax and Townes think this is totally amazing. It just brings the fans of Dax closer to Townes. See it as promoting. A homage to Townes. But I can totally see how fans of Townes cringe when hearing this. Dax does not have your every day country voice ;-).
You do realize not only are Dax and Townes Van Zandt in very good graces, TVZ make appearances on Dax's cd We sing of only blood or love...So I guess they dig it!
I've never heard of this dude before, but I prefer the original. This isn't a bad version, and it's cool if someone hears this and then tracks down some proper TVZ stuff, but this hasn't got the intimacy that I like about the original. I even prefer the Cowboy Junkies version to this.
Okay. But I didn't track down any TVZ stuff after listening to this. I just assumed it wouldn't be as good as Dax's version. Just like Leonard Cohen's stuff...big disappointment there.
i dont mind people covering songs but he didnt capture any essence of that song. no clue whatsoever. i dont blame him for picking that song its a great song- the cover sucked though-
i disagree the cover doesnt suck smallchris. in fact im not sure anyone covers someone's song as good as the original. townes was great but dax's voice is a bit better and on top of that townes' son jt played on dax's new album we sing of only blood or love and if townes' son likes dax then it really doesnt matter what your dumbass thinks.
I am right. My opinion is correct. And you have horrible taste. I bet you heard this version first. I bet you like this bad imitation of pearl jam's whole catalog. Im glad i heard his name so I will never make the mistake of listening to him again. He should cover black hole sun instead. Grunge is dead losers. It would suck to hang out with yall.
How does this guy turn every cover he does into the best music I never heard. I go back and listen to these originals and they all pale on comparison.
Love Townes, who I got into through Dax, and I dig the cover.
BlackSabbathory 5 months ago
Freaking awesome!
TheMagellan02 7 months ago
dude is that drummer that same guy from my name is earl?
thedroogfulable 10 months ago
Long time Townes fan, just found this and love it. It needed to grow on me, but as the song went on I found myself liking it more and more. Well done
grimey82 11 months ago
sorry.....but no....townes would have like it but compared to townes....no lol
seeuat160 1 year ago
jimi hendrix version of townes both would be proud
03HEMI2500SLT 1 year ago
who is the drummer here? :)
Face0fRoadkill1213 1 year ago
@Face0fRoadkill1213 Its the amazing Andy McLeod
KRUB76 1 year ago 2
never heard of townes before I found dax covering him. Glad dax showed respect to one of favorite artists by spreading the word.
supernoog 1 year ago
Anyone who is a Townes fan is an instant friend of mine! Keep the music alive!
Thanks,
Rolland B. Heiss
rbheiss 1 year ago
Comment removed
nothingdrugs 2 years ago
Dax is so badass it makes me wanna fart.
asbestosinhaler 2 years ago 2
This kicks ASS!!!
RastafariPoet 2 years ago
this is so much better than the original
jrodmademedoit 2 years ago
@jrodmademedoit
Not even close. I dont blame anyone for wanting to cover Townes, but nobody can hold a flame to him. Its great to pay tribute, but you will never touch that level.
shelbyloveforever 1 year ago
@shelbyloveforever
Ha ha theres no question as musician this is by far better you may like the original better cause itsmore of your taste but musically this is put together way better and i dont care who you are you have to notice the major up grade in the voice singing on this version
jrodmademedoit 1 year ago
@jrodmademedoit
No. Townes is simply better. I love everyting that Dax ever did but Townes is not of this world. No comparison.
shelbyloveforever 1 year ago
if you don't like this cover, you must like balls in your mouth
jfleshmask 2 years ago 2
Oh dear. What a travesty. Like to see the drummer playing Hendrix's 'Fire' though!
customjimmy 2 years ago
a cover doesn't mean you have to imitate the original artist.
geosurveyor 2 years ago 2
song writers write song for people to sing .people who don't listen to townes music might get turned on to his music this way.
mbsnyderc 2 years ago 8
this is a horrid cover.
guys voice is cool... but they shit all over townes' great song.
baronBirchtree 2 years ago
i think they do a great job , which will attract more listners to Townes
mvagusta750 2 years ago
I hate it when I click a great Townes Van Zandt song on youtube and it sends me to some CRAP cover like this.
davemann36 2 years ago
Good drummer.
undeadplastic 2 years ago
I love Townes Van Zandt, but this guy has a good pair of "Lungs", Great vocals..!!!!
I love the psychodelic edge in this cover as well:-)
Mariekesone 2 years ago 4
i dig the vocals, man
ronnijairunmatt3 2 years ago
exellent, great townes van zandt coversong!!!!!!!!!!!!!
i loved townes
roger
schniene26 2 years ago 7
Excellent! Great performance to jam to!
madsanta 2 years ago 2
Don't mean to be a troll here, but this is awful.
sarber 2 years ago
Agreed man. It's so cool to love Van Zandt but doing his music justice is not easy.
Steve Earle is one of the few who can do it.
kingazzaman 2 years ago
NO worries... You're not the only one who thinks this version is really bad.
verniere 2 years ago
I really enjoyed this take on townes "lungs". Great Vocals especially. It's always interesting to see how other artists perform Townnes Van Zandt.
gah11177 2 years ago 5
singing was good, guitar wasn't good. yes, i realize this was not the original arrangement. whoever made this arrangement, i assume dax himself, didn't work that hard. it is boring as hell.
tompetty832002 2 years ago
Really? I thought it was a pretty interesting take on it. The only other versions I've heard are Townes's own and Steve Earle's awesome cover (which is not dissimilar from Townes's original).
everysinglenamesgone 2 years ago 2
just my opinion. my favorite version is the one on live at the old quarter. they tried something new ill give them credit for that, but i wasn't a fan of the guitar. the beauty of this song's music was how it was better than pretty much everything ever made and was a guy and a guitar. and of course the lyrics.
tompetty832002 2 years ago
Definitely agree with you there. That's how I feel about the Allison Kraus/Robert Plant version of "Nothin'". Actually, it's beautiful, but to me, that song has to be just a fingerpicked guitar and vocals. And not Robert Plant's vocals. :S So that's probably how you feel about this song.
I dunno, I mean it's not like Dax or Rob/Al are trying to supplant Townes' versions.
Agreed, the Old Quarter version is awesome!!
everysinglenamesgone 2 years ago
I thought this was good... Dax Riggs has had an interesting career.
demo23nz 2 years ago
So i imagine all those comments that were removed were the negative ones. I like as many people as possible to be exposed to townes songs, though i think this band is not the best embassador. i'm also just confused and bitter about unorigional run of the mill bands like this getting huge gigs. (and removing negative comments about them from youtube)
allanfraserriley 2 years ago
unorigional? Do you know who this is you silly fuck? This is sir dax. You have no taste and obviously never heard when the kite string pops. Pathetic.
stlnavy314 2 years ago 5
Comment removed
evolution4648 2 years ago
Comment removed
evolution4648 2 years ago
I like it! Has a lot of drama and feeling!
It shows that Townes could write some pretty good Rock & Roll too!!!
Shamagogue 2 years ago
Comment removed
evolution4648 2 years ago
who is this asshole that butchered townes' song?
SUPERDUPERJIMBO 2 years ago 5
Oh my God, this is terrible. I need to wash my ears.
oldirtybanjo 2 years ago 4
The thing that's great about this, though I don't even know who Dax is, is that I read that in Townes notes on this song, instead of "alegretto" or something, he wrote "this song should be screamed".
joknrok 2 years ago
did you read that somewhere? very interesting by the way
mattdean62 2 years ago
Yeah, "this song should be screamed"!. Reading that made me love Townes twice as much. If Kurt Cobain had done a cover of this on Unplugged like he did the Leadbelly song, that whole generation would know and love Townes by now... and be far richer for it.
joknrok 2 years ago
how true.
zachkafel 2 years ago
Dax is the man, he's the one who introduced me to Townes after one of his shows. Great cover too.
espacho 2 years ago
this is a great cover,,,quit your bitchin
pattheflu 2 years ago
Jesus he hacked up a good song, what a douche
enterfailedment 2 years ago
I just didn't believe him. He didn't make the song speak to me like a song should speak to you.
evolution4648 2 years ago
this kinda sucks.
mozzocco1 2 years ago
i love this cover. Both versions are beautifull.
tralalalatum 2 years ago
I think this is really good. A GREAT cover, because its faithful to the original melodies and lyrics, but changes the style completely. Dax is doing a good job singing, and the guitarist is pretty great. The drummer is awesome, he has a lot of energy.
maestrogilberto 2 years ago 5
Comment removed
evolution4648 2 years ago
this is not a great cover, dax riggs is capable of better. he certainly has a right to cover it. of course the original was timeless
tompetty832002 3 years ago
Very different than Townes, obviously but these guys were not trying to be Townes. Townes may have dug it-its very different but cool in a completely different way.
tatran78 3 years ago
i wouldn't say "he doesn't have the right to play it" but i would say it's not a great cover. im not sure townes' music was ever meant for an electric guitar, let alone a full band setting, thats why a lot of studio recordings were so awful next to the live versions.
his drummer looks like that ethan guy...the fat actor who's a scientologist.
imairlax 3 years ago
i really cant understand why everyone is hating on this. if you guys think dax has no right to play this song then you should know that Townes Van Zandt's son, is good friends with Dax, and he play's guitar on Dax's album.
i have been listening to towns van zandt since i was born. he is a fort worth legund and i grew up with his recordings. frankly your all being bitches :/
buzzkilla12 3 years ago 2
this sux, not a patch on townes
Samagorny 3 years ago
This version doesn't do Townes justice at all. Sorry to say so, but this just isn't good. For a good cover of this, check out Lyle Lovett's version on "step inside this house".
This was close to awful.
Helvetehellerdaa 3 years ago
This is the most under-rated song of all time but only because no-one has heard of Dax Riggs or ever heard his cover of Lungs.
ubernewhacks 3 years ago 2
absolute fucking horse shit god damn this sucks fuck you idiots
shameful
x2cmixtape 3 years ago
reminded me of pearl jam too much sorry.
phdecora 3 years ago
Dax is the best.
pos6666666 3 years ago
I thought you guys did a good job, but this is nothing close to Townes.
nebulacafe 3 years ago
oh god what a disgrace.
hellodeer 3 years ago
Comment removed
espacho 3 years ago
Dax fuckin rules!
roseblackcadillac 4 years ago
This is 60's drug music. Nice,now go fuck off hippies until I sober up
ThatsmyYokoOno 4 years ago
This song grows on you.I was not sure if I'd like it at first. The first few bars it sounded a little bit boring. Watched it 10 times and liked it better and better. He has a great voice, especially when the song developes. Great tribute to Townes, great grungy tribute. The original can't be beat, that's agreed and I can imagine why people don't like this version. But nonetheless decent version. I liked it. Is it available on a record.
morphinlounge101 4 years ago
Ecchh... way to ruin a great song.
jacobbielarski 4 years ago
Ha ha.. The drummer looks like Randy from "my name is earl". Cool version though. Townes Van Zandt's music needs to be played.
Melderskin 4 years ago
He said these guys were called "The Black Clowns" but I didn't ask him if he gave them that name or if that was their name. I thought they provided excellent support though. I'm gonna see D-R and his band of merry rebels next week, can't wait!
UnreleasedOriginal 4 years ago
lol, dax randomly called them The Black Clowns..it's a lyric from "Dogheaded Whore"
roseblackcadillac 4 years ago
One of the funniest things I've seen on youtube! Props!
qubixrube 4 years ago 2
*groan* I appreciate these kids doing this; but it's just painful to hear. This genre of music does not compliment the Godfather of Texas Folk's songs. Lungs is brickwall of a song, stopping everything we throw at it. It's better to leave it alone. But, kudo's for trying.
Lerkst 4 years ago 3
I totally agree. Yet I cannot help but find myself leaving a comment. This song may not do justice to the original and the way Townes meant for it to be heard. But, me, a fan of both Dax and Townes think this is totally amazing. It just brings the fans of Dax closer to Townes. See it as promoting. A homage to Townes. But I can totally see how fans of Townes cringe when hearing this. Dax does not have your every day country voice ;-).
th3dge 4 years ago
You do realize not only are Dax and Townes Van Zandt in very good graces, TVZ make appearances on Dax's cd We sing of only blood or love...So I guess they dig it!
roseblackcadillac 3 years ago
eh how did tvz make an appearence on We sing of only blood or love? Townes died in 97'. We sing came out in 2007.
espacho 3 years ago
it wasnt townes it was his son jt
ThyDemise 3 years ago
ah, i see. I was not aware.
espacho 3 years ago
ok, sorry as fuck. JT Van Zandt. Goddamn.
roseblackcadillac 3 years ago
Actually I quite like it.
birdstuckinchimney 4 years ago
and??? what's with all the "jocks" at lala????
fuck college rock
arrcana 4 years ago
I am a huge Townes van. A great song cannot be ruined. You guys prove that---- great cover!!!! pain keeps some of us alive!
I am going with my boots on!!--how about you???
arrcana 4 years ago
shut the fuck up fag. no ones opinion is 'correct'. do you seriously cry like a little bitch over every band you hear and dont like? get a life
ThyDemise 4 years ago
The title says Townes not Dix You tricked me into viewing this garbage.
bigchrisatx 4 years ago
Tricked? Ha! You're a gawdamned idiot for clicking. And I'm an idiot for replying to you.
Andalbanon 4 years ago
he made it his own
FuckY0utube72 4 years ago
I've never heard of this dude before, but I prefer the original. This isn't a bad version, and it's cool if someone hears this and then tracks down some proper TVZ stuff, but this hasn't got the intimacy that I like about the original. I even prefer the Cowboy Junkies version to this.
JimmersThomas 4 years ago
Okay. But I didn't track down any TVZ stuff after listening to this. I just assumed it wouldn't be as good as Dax's version. Just like Leonard Cohen's stuff...big disappointment there.
Andalbanon 4 years ago
Dax has improved every song he's ever covered. I don't know what 'essence' you're talking about Big Chris, but you're dead wrong.
Andalbanon 4 years ago
bigchris is defiantly talking smack to the wrong artist fans. dax fans are crazy. we will kill.
codyincharge 4 years ago
Well, I don't mean him any harm, personally....I just hope that his taste in music improves with time.
Andalbanon 4 years ago
i dont mind people covering songs but he didnt capture any essence of that song. no clue whatsoever. i dont blame him for picking that song its a great song- the cover sucked though-
bigchrisatx 4 years ago
i disagree the cover doesnt suck smallchris. in fact im not sure anyone covers someone's song as good as the original. townes was great but dax's voice is a bit better and on top of that townes' son jt played on dax's new album we sing of only blood or love and if townes' son likes dax then it really doesnt matter what your dumbass thinks.
sigh917 4 years ago 3
enough said.
DrZaious 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This guy's voice is horrible.
chupachipmunk 4 years ago
I am right. My opinion is correct. And you have horrible taste. I bet you heard this version first. I bet you like this bad imitation of pearl jam's whole catalog. Im glad i heard his name so I will never make the mistake of listening to him again. He should cover black hole sun instead. Grunge is dead losers. It would suck to hang out with yall.
bigchrisatx 4 years ago
fuck you this has nuthing to do with pearl jam or grunge for that matter. Dax Riggs is one of the best vocalistst ive ever heard.
buzzkilla12 3 years ago 5
reali?
Samagorny 3 years ago
this really doesn't show the extent of his voice.. just look up dax riggs im sure your enjoy him
buzzkilla12 3 years ago
ok kool will do
Samagorny 3 years ago
Comment removed
evolution4648 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Agree 100%.
chupachipmunk 4 years ago
'Great what you did with a Townes song
5 stars
jacquesmees 4 years ago 2
Townes' version is better, but this is great
hamila832003 4 years ago
I totally agree with Lukeor.
cjist1 4 years ago
How does this guy turn every cover he does into the best music I never heard. I go back and listen to these originals and they all pale on comparison.
Lukeor 4 years ago 3
That's Andy Macleod! It's impossible to show too much of Andy; he's like a 6-year-old playing whack-a-mole.
nadiaaymone 4 years ago
wonderful.
they showed way too much of the druummer though..
who is that?
got anymore from Lolla?
eatshit88 4 years ago
someone told me who he was at the friday show but i cant remember..got the whole set from lola, no other bands tho
ThyDemise 4 years ago