Paul McCartney - Hello Goodbye (Live in Tel Aviv, Israel 25.09.08)

[RavivTal]

Please Come Back Again !!!

[PERUTECHNO]

no puedocreer!! pero es elmismo video que se hgixzo en el peru! hatsa la mano del amigo tb sale waooo esto es coincidencia adem as la toma de la cam es cais en la misma posicion, todo es igual, ah ese cuanto ganara en dinero haha porque cada concierto que hac elo llena

[kfir430]

Paul has to come to Haifa and then all the North of Israel will show, I wish he would come to Haifa!

I hear it from my house

[ReviewCam]

Paul McCartney must have been on cloud nine after a reception like that!

[ReviewCam]

Thumbs up for Paul! Thumbs up for TA and thumbs up big time for ISRAEL!

[owen2300]

the 11 people who didn't like this I ask you why?

[TheMTAforever]

@owen2300

Arabics people... they hate israel and everything about us.

[amarildojesusalmeid1]

Sensacional, Beatles ainda nessa época quebra barreiras.

[40gilad]

justin biber made 11 losers dislike this video...shame

[israelbp]

More about the biography of Linda Mccartney and her judaism

see at wingspan ru bookseng linda 03 html

Greetings

[doubled1961]

@queenofcourt thugs and murderers are the Palestinians that you do not read the news? who cross the border to kill a Jewish family (even a child a few months of life)? who are throwing missiles at beer sheva? and try to blow up a crowded bus station teminal of civilians in jerusalem?? for whoever you think? Chinese? nooooo the fucking crazy bastards Palestinian murderers. I would love to see ya reactionary if someone launched a rocket to 100 feet of your home, you will love it!! sure yes sir

[gmcken99]

@doubled1961 Its you that doesnt keep up with the news. The "Palestinian" that killed the family was actually an asian former employee of the family that had been cheated out of money. That event itself was a terrible, terrible thing especially the murder of a 3 month old baby and I hope the murderer gets the death sentence. All this killing is wrong.

But I promise you one thing, that Paul McCartney wont play to you zionist shitbags again. Paul believes in justice and peace.

[IhSeeFuckinDeuboliah]

Big thumb up to the Israel crowd ! We did a good job in France in 2008 when Paul came to Paris but this is awesome ! Congrats !

[MrsBeatleLover05]

@itai444 i mean sorry =]

[MrsBeatleLover05]

itai444 not as good as ringo...

[LODGE4444]

@queenofcourt Paul Mccartney sings for the peace loving Israelis - NOT the CHILD MURDERING PALESTINIAN TERRORISTS, you Jew hating piece of shit.

[10brownblair]

Wonderful crowd participation

[israelbp]

There is a good reason for Paul to play in Israel: his wife Linda was jewish ( Epstein) from a New-York jewish family .Also, their daughter Stella received her name from the two jewish grandmothers of Linda ( both of them were Stella

[doubled1961]

@israelbp she was not epstein, she was named Eastman she was photography and her family are the owners of Kodak, Brian epstein was the manager from the beatles is he was jewish

Gretings

[israelbp]

@doubled1961

please look at wikipedia

The parents of Linda Mcccartney were Lee Eastman and Louise Sara Lindner Eastman

Lee Eastman was born Leopold Vail Epstein

Thus the family name was originaly Epstein

Sorry but no connection to Kodak

Today there is internet to verify

Greetings

[iretrovia]

somebody can tell me who is the drummer in this video?

[itai444]

@iretrovia

Abe Laborial Jr

great drummer!

[AlbondigasDeMierda]

@iretrovia

buddah

[gmcken99]

So disappointing that Macca plays in Israel. Ok Iknow it was a few years ago but he must be aware that Israel is a rogue terrorist state that slaughters civilians. Sir Paul is a great humanitarian so Im certain he wont play in this vile shithole again. C'mon Sir Paul show your class!!!!

[N9BJJ]

@gmcken99 Disappointing??? What the fuck are you talking about? The Beatles Manager was jewish, Macca's wife Linda was jewish ... and actually.... their kids are jewish ..... What is he doing in Israel?? Duh ... I would have thought he'd have more than a passing interest in the place. That's the Jewish contribution to some of the music you listen - now go and find an arab that can make that kind of a difference to the world.

[doubled1961]

@gmcken99 thugs and murderers are the Palestinians that you do not read the news? who cross the border to kill a Jewish family (even a child a few months of life)? who are throwing missiles at beer sheva? and try to blow up a crowded bus station teminal of civilians in jerusalem?? for whoever you think? Chinese? nooooo the fucking crazy bastards Palestinian murderers. I would love to see ya reactionary if someone launched a rocket to 100 feet of your home, you will love it!! kiss my balls

[August8th1969]

I wish Paul would play Lebanon.

[Rodliverpool]

Macca rocks

[Jazzawray]

Some terrible comments on here, peace and love people , peace and love what would John and George say about that ?.

[mcgooo1]

i dont belive i fucking missed it !!! what an awesomeee show

[predatorinstincts]

The crowds voice is overpowering sir paul mccartney's voice. Where can you see that in a concert! greatest band of all time

[TalDron124]

אין כמו ישראל

[Nefarioso]

Morons singing along. Did they come there to hear themselves?!

[GoddamnMYPstudent]

9 Gaga fans watched this

[Rawego]

i guess these people paid to hear themselves sing :))

give Paul a chance!!! 

[dani1928]

@Rawego

most of the people there waited 40 years to hear this song live,

i guess they deserve it.

[gmcken99]

Whilst it is disappointing to see Paul play in that place at least we know he will never go back after the rogue terrorist state (Israel) murdered the peaceful aid workers.

[germino777]

if you go to a concert, let the performer sing, not you

[CrysisGamer23]

@germino777 hello? on every Paul McCartney's concert I saw everyone sang.

and we waited for this moment more than 40 years.

[woody12i2]

they should be quiet and let us hear him sing the song

[326bpm]

que bueno que no cayó ninguna bomba.

[JettRink50]

What did you pay $5,000? You can't even get a good seat at a concert

these days.

[jigbuilda]

...Warm!

[LoveManMusic]

dont believe i was there

[pokemaniac7654]

lol paul is the most talented one he can play base and normal

[yacasi200]

paul, paul, paul, paul,,,.....the beatles.....hello goodbye...o man is great.

[husseinbaghdad]

Tel Aviv????????

I love Paul but I dislike Isarael

any way nothing about politic ...

I love the Beatles

[senorcardgage678]

Why can't you just give peace a chance?

[tomgi859]

@senorcardgage678

Because we're busy on not being dying, but generally we do want peace.

[brabon1]

fuck you, you jew hating bastard

sir paul rules

and he hates the sand niggers

[husseinbaghdad]

@brabon1 what r u talking about , what sand niggers

[ThatBritGuy]

@brabon1 You know, someone should actually show your comment to Paul McCartney so he can be ashamed of you too. Paul spoke to the Palestinians during this concert too - it was aimed at bringing PEACE to the region, not - as you put it - "hate the sand niggers".

[BlueLeopard200]

@brabon1

if arabs are sandniggers then so are jews since they come from the same region

the only reason euro-jews look whiter is because of the non-jewish european blood they got while in europe for thousand or so years but their jewish part is just as much sandnigger as the arabs

so as a jew, I assume you are one, you are half sandnigger and the other half is non-jewish

[dean89]

u r stupid... tel aviv is amazing and paul had a great show!

[NaCcache100]

tel aviv is the besttttttt

[onthemoveagain]

This is R.Nix Pop Composer/Reviewer here.

This is an excellent Paul McCartney composition(recorded Oct.2,1967)that Paul is doing live here with his band-the studio version features 'varied choruses' throughout the composition which keeps 'HelloGoodbye' really interesting with my fav. chorus being: the particular one which has George singing a countermelody to Paul's melody-completely clever subtle hook there.

Also to be noted is Ringo's excellent drumming.

[babasonico7]

how poor mentality modified61 :/

[modified61]

would you be a little more specific ? why is my mentality poor ? i'd love to hear from you.

[Xmenfan246]

Ringo should have been there to do his drum solo.

I would LOVE for Paul + Ringo to do an album together.

[yacasi200]

this is my favorite song.....i love the beatles....paul is the number 1.

[fr33t0killy0u]

The beatles are more popular than god and jesus thanks john

[Thursday196]

haha very true

[dean89]

can't imagine what it's like, to come out to cheerings of 50,000 people...

[hayabusafmw]

imagine he did this all his life.............

[juanbeatle1]

he's god =´)

[mikedemilo]

your point? why would they even like progressive music when they force their women into burkas. backwards savages

[WhoaJ30]

exactly!

[jacksy83]

Borderline!

[modified61]

they dont perform in islamic states or countries because it's simply forbidden. thats not too hard to figure out.

[azjeff1971]

Fuck the palpigs!!!!!!

[modified61]

i agree 100 percent. you cant trust them at all.

[DittoKunGmail]

I was there, And now I've started to cry from this video! I love you Paul!!!!

[ScorpionsandBells]

the environment in this show was incredible!!!!

even waiting for about 6 hours outside and standing i the lines to get in was unforgettable..

[luiisluiis]

oh no !

[yameviahi]

this is my favorite song

[WiltatKansas]

freaking genius

[hotstephanie]

wh-wh-wh-wh-wh-why do you say goodbye, goodbye.......

[bavlibabe]

it still gives me the chills..... paul mccartney gave a wonderfull show and many of the songs were dedicated to his loved ones - jhon, Linda and george RIP. there were all kinds of people there - grandpas , teens, religious people and even fans that travelled with himall the way from kiev. tears, laughts and sweat mixed together in unforgetabale performance. sir paul - visit us again !!

[aon3t]

this song is one of beatles' best

[MrSharkey11]

hey aon3t,This song is very far from being one of the beatles best. You got to be kidding, right? you're probably very young so you really would'nt know, it's not your fault.

[aon3t]

@MrSharkey11

sigh, it's one of MY favorite beatles' songs.. get smart

[MrSharkey11]

Hey aon3t, Sorry about that my friend! Everyone has their prefrences. I did'nt mean to critizise you.Peace to you!

[maxwellchandler]

The bass drum is booming!

[orseha93]

i want to be there again. i'm writing this comment and crying. BEATLES WILL LIVE FOREVER!!!

[juuukka2]

understand

[juuukka2]

please come back

[sxcxk777]

watching this gives me chills....the beatles are amazing....

[cyklonb1989]

fuck off retard

[zoolrule]

Fuck off you retard.

[suburbangal]

I was ll yrs old when the Beatles came to america. I cried when I saw them and wanted to run to England to marry Paul. I lived the magic of Beatlemania. It was awesome beyond comprehension. PLS go to my favs and click on ALL MY LOVING. these are 2 fellow "original beatlemaniacs" I grew up with singing a tribute to our favorite guys. THE BEATLES MUSICAL MAGICAL GENIUS WILL LAST FOREVER.

[urlove2b]

wow, i wish i had lived in ur times!!!!!!!!! the music today is so stupid, anyways i love the beatles and everything about the 60's! i'm 21 and wish, like i said, i had been this age in like 63!!!!!!!

[BOSS7977]

Ohhhh yyyeeeeaaahhh aaaaaalllrrriiiiiiiigghhhttttt­ttt!!!!!!!!!!!

[itamarscomix]

Oh man, this takes me back. I was there, like ten feet from the stage, and it was freakin' amazing. Best concert I've ever been to, and an amazing experience.

By the way - a few notes to delacerdaa:

A, the concert was some time before the war started.

B, the war was in Gaza, some rockets were fired to the far north of Israel. Tel Aviv was completely safe for the duration of the war.

C, there is no law against having concerts while there's a war on, it would be sad if there was.

[Nnoukkiejj]

I wish I was there!!

[Desmond4956]

This is INCREDIBLE! Listen to that crowd singing along...

This clip makes me very emotional. They FINALLY got to see him in Tel Aviv...and they're SO happy about it!

[finaltrooper]

it made me very emotional too.. especially the part : "and i say Go Go Go...!"

[RoomOfMusic]

looks so fun to be there

[delacerdaa]

It`s so sad that Gaza and Isreal can`t seem to get along. They have no idea how lucky they are to be there, where our savior was once before.

I love all my brothers and sisters from there

VIVA MEXICO Y LA PAZ

[bluebeatleviolin]

eres de mexico vdd??

[MangoMan14]

dudes , I was there from about 12:00 , AND they opened the gates at about 6:00 , and then I had to wait 3.5 more hours until Paul showed up , but still it was the funnest thing I ever did in my life time

[delacerdaa]

I never knew they allowed concerts in Isreal? isnt there a war over there? I pray for peace over there. I wanna visit the holy land but I`m too scared to go

[brandinator22]

there's a war going on in Gaza but not all over the country!

Tel Aviv and Jerusalem are filled with tourists and quite safe

[lolothe2nd]

בירושלים יש פיגועים

אז זה קצת בעיה לו...

[babinator99]

there is no war

there are rockets from gaza into Israel which is a direct violation of the ceasefire

why wouldnt they allow concerts?

PLease, go visit, it will be one of the best things you ever do

[suepalam]

I SAID NO

[Michaelas11]

Omo zaken

[PilMcCartney]

HA! i sat closer!

[PilMcCartney]

wasn't it the first song?

[BeatlesGirlXD]

I was there. It was so amazing. I still can't believe that this is over.

Paul, I love you!

[AmitGendelman]

that was so awesome!

it's like , after 4 hours of standing , the show started , and i get new powers, i danced and sang like crazy!

that was so freakin awesome

[hadas930]

I LOVEEEEEEEEEE PAUL

[shineday455]

israel loves paul!!!!

[RowPK]

oh yeah we do!

[awsomeadi]

my aunt, two of my cousins, and my cousins boyfriend went to this concert!

[hahahathebeatlesrock]

man, that gig was great!

i saw it :)

[beatlevicke]

I love Sir Paul and Beatles!

[JaysonJeremyShow]

both paul mccartney and tel aviv rock

[Oriki5]

THE B-E-S-T SHOW E-V-E-R.

I still can't believe I was there.

Paul McCartney is LIVE!

[sunking2001]

Oriki5...congratulations...Pau­l's shows are the "Best"...I know..I've seen him 6 times!!!

[MISTACASALS]

me too

[Verdiez]

THE BEST SHOW EVER IN ISRAEL

[PaulieMyDear]

I was there, and couldn't stop crying during Hello Goodbye.

[TailsSpain]

"itsMyyyLife", get a life

[itked3]

I hate myself for not going there. :'(

[MrsVanderblit]

I was there, it was great.

thank you Paul.

[amithorn]

to gliderama... Dissgusting, just dissgusting. People like you should burn in hell, I thought comment like that had left the word since 60 years ago...

[TheMugava]

I was there

WOW

[rockshow21]

Lol...This gotta be the coolest guy on the planet.

I love Paul

[edennishri]

what a show!

[masterdad123]

you are awesome!

[mateusschaffer]

"and no religion too"

Religion: humam being fighting for nothing...

Paul (and The Beatles) rules!

[dnselmer]

Paul, sorry for all the crap, but I think that positive influence of your music developed spiritual life of world much better than missionaries. :)

[dnselmer]

3) Jews aren't Karaim. So they don't believe in "Bible's God", they make amendments to basic princnples of ancient law in every generation according to the new social values.

Missionary does tilt at windmills and miss real enemy. :)

[ensentidocontrario]

Simplemente Paul es un gran amigo mío y quiero saludar a todos sus admiradores, lo que hizo en israel, como to lo que hace es increible!!! yo tuve oportunidad de platicar con él en la ciudad de México

Alejandro Orihuela En sentido contrario

[masterdad123]

זה ממש לא הוגן אח שלי הלך ואני לא?????

[missionarysarahbarry]

When you approach a city to fight against it, you shall offer it terms of peace. If it agrees to make peace, then all the people who are found in it shall become your slaves and shall serve you. If it does not make peace with you, but makes war against you, then you shall besiege it. When the LORD your God gives it into your hand, you shall kill all the men in it with the sword. Only the women and the children & all that is in the city, you shall take as slaves/booty for yourself. Deut 20:10-14

[dnselmer]

TO: missionarysarahbarry

Thou shalt not kill.

Neither shalt thou commit adultery.

Neither shalt thou steal.

Neither shalt thou bear false witness against thy neighbour.

Neither shalt thou desire thy neighbour's wife, neither shalt thou covet thy neighbour's house, his field, or his manservant, or his maidservant, his ox, or his ass... Deut 5:17-21

[missionarysarahbarry]

when people believe in bible's god,even killing children becomes moral: Moses was angry with the officers of the army who returned from battle. "Have you allowed all the women to live? They were the ones who followed Balaam's advice and turned the Israelites away from the LORD in what happened at Peor, so that a plague struck the LORD's people. Now kill all the boys. And kill every woman who has slept with a man, but save for yourselves every girl who has never slept with a man. [Num 31:14-18]

[dnselmer]

1) People can "believe" whoever or whatever they want: in God, in Satan, in Jesus, in Mohamad... It's not sufficient. Sufficiant is not to make obstacles to another people

with your holy faith, pure intentions and dirty deeds.

2) Much useful it would be not to BELIEVE, but to KNOW, that object of your faith not a hero of ancient delusions. But it's very hard work to be intelligent, and not ignorant believer.

[BeatlesRulz]

וואו, אני מרגיש כ"כ בר מזל שהייתי שם.

זאת הייתה הופעה כ"כ מדהימה, אני לא אשכח אותה בחיים!!!!

[omrihagaimaor]

הופעה בלתי נשכחת... מי שלא היה שם הפסיד הופעה של פעם בחיים, וגם כנראה לא יראה הופעה מושלמת אי פעם ! sir paul rock!!

[dean89]

amazing!

[brandinator22]

אנשים יותר צעירים ממנו בישראל היו מתנהגים כאילו הם בני 80. הוא, כמו כל מיני אנשים מבוגרים זרים אחרים, מתנהג כאילו הוא בן 10

[123colte]

this is poop

[hblizard]

this is the best song ever you rock

[OferKrief]

רעיון נחמד. הכלבה שהלכה לאיבוד..

אבל גם אם היא הייתה עוברת לידי עכשיו לא הייתי שם לב.

אז שכחי מהכלבה,יש כאן את פולי..

[atvdou]

Felicito al pueblo de Israel por haberlo cuidado a PAUL, y que todo salio sin problemas despues de tantas amenazas.PAUL MCCARTNEY el mas grande.

[ScoobyDoobie76]

אבדה כלבה העונה לשם לונה

שלשום בערב בשער שלוש אבדה כלבה טריירית בינונית בעלת שיער לבן/בלונד מתולתל

העונדת קולר פרעושים ועונה לשם לונה...

נישמח עם תוכלו לעזור במציאתה.

ניתן להשיגנו בטלפון-

050-7649404

050-3353588

נאיה

[EagleXL]

היה פשוט מושלם.

הייתי שורה שלישית ככה, ושיעשע אותי שבשני שירים הראשונים הוא כל הזמן סימן לאנשי סאונד להרים לו את הקול, כי באמת שמעו בהתחלה אך ורק את הקהל.

[muranoxx]

my brave hero!

[beatlessssssssssssss]

היה גדול שמעתי בלייב

[MangoMan14]

פשוט לא קליט . זה היה פשוט כמו חלום . כל רגע חשבתי שאני אקום ואמצע את עצמי במיטה. זה עבר לי כל כך מהר ! זה היה הדבר הכי כיף שעשיתי בחיים שלי !

[BackStagedLady]

אני אתך. אני עדין מרגישה כמו בתוך איזשהו חלום, זה לא יאמן. רבע מהלהקה ששמעתי מאז שאני תינוקת, שאני הכי אוהבת בעולם! לא נתפס כמה גדול היה, וכמה טוב הוא ביצע הכל! יש אנרגיות של בחור בן 20!

[DittoKunGmail]

חח הוא דפק קול עבה שבכלל לא קשור לשיר, אבל ככה זה נשמע יותר טוב

[floxine]

Love sir Paul!

[kofiko98]

ואללה מי שאמר שהוא נראה לו אחד נחמד כזה אז ואללה אח שלי יש לך עוד מה ללמוד ( למה אתה עדיין ילד) !

לנון היה נחש קוברה ומקרטני זה קוברה מלכותית

אתה לא מבין הוא מלחין גאון אם התכוונת מוסיקלית וזה שיש לו שירים

קליטים כאלה אז רק תקשיב לדברים כמו הלו גודביי או i saw her standing there

[laurentbernier25]

awesome

[crystalmjonas]

Aw Paul is so awesome :)

[joeyc09]

this is a true testament as to how timeless this mans music is ......as far as his voice ,c'mon bro give him a break he's 65 or so......