@Cader1dris2 hehe i wont tell! i think its such a shame that they never made films of the 4th book, me and my mum (who read them shen she was little and got me into them) decided tht if we were to re make it now we would have eric banner as mark, orlando bloom as will (kinda sweet but a bit weedy aswell lmao) and we thought of a yound leonardo di caprio as dick! we chose all the others too but they were the most fun! they rly should make a new one tho, it would be awsome!
@Cader1dris2 hehe i wont tell! i think its such a shame that they never made films of the 4th book, me and my mum (who read them shen she was little and got me into them) decided tht if we were to re make it now we would have eric banner as mark, orlando bloom as will (kinda sweet but a bit weedy aswell lmao) and we thought of a yound leonardo di caprio as dick! we chose all the others too but they were the most fun! they rly should make a new one tho, it would be awsome!
up untill reading the 4th book i was really undecided as to which i liked the most but after reading the last book id deffo have to go for will! dicks cheats and although mark comes a close second hes still a bit to a prat lol so yh will all the way! best books ever and a really fun vid!
@littledancer14 aww thankyou very much :) I wanted to make a fun silly video about them :) and thought it was brill song to go with it- so I apprecieate your comment :) and Im so glad your loving the books! Flambards is def the best ever and so is will ;) he's my fave too but *shhhshh*
@Cader1dris2 hehe i wont tell! i think its such a shame that they never made films of the 4th book, me and my mum (who read them shen she was little and got me into them) decided tht if we were to re make it now we would have eric banner as mark, orlando bloom as will (kinda sweet but a bit weedy aswell lmao) and we thought of a yound leonardo di caprio as dick! we chose all the others too but they were the most fun! they rly should make a new one tho, it would be awsome!
@Cader1dris2 hehe i wont tell! i think its such a shame that they never made films of the 4th book, me and my mum (who read them shen she was little and got me into them) decided tht if we were to re make it now we would have eric banner as mark, orlando bloom as will (kinda sweet but a bit weedy aswell lmao) and we thought of a yound leonardo di caprio as dick! we chose all the others too but they were the most fun! they rly should make a new one tho, it would be awsome!
@littledancer14 aw yeh def! i think it would be really interesting if they did a re-make! You chose a good choice of actors too. Me and my brother talk about that too, if they re-made it who would be good to play in it. You never know they might do soon! it would def be awesome :) take care.
@Cader1dris2 hehe i wont tell! i think its such a shame that they never made films of the 4th book, me and my mum (who read them shen she was little and got me into them) decided tht if we were to re make it now we would have eric banner as mark, orlando bloom as will (kinda sweet but a bit weedy aswell lmao) and we thought of a yound leonardo di caprio as dick! we chose all the others too but they were the most fun! they rly should make a new one tho, it would be awsome!
erm I have no idea to be honest, unless you buy it on DVD on amazon or ebay...you could try searching it and just see if the interent comes with a download or something?
My recollection of the series. . .Dick wasn't trying to impress Christina, he was a common servant, William knew Peter was to be her future wife for her families money and Peter wasn't really into Christina's type. . .but good veedio
Your right it's Mark. . . just reviewed the entire series on DVD, more than 10 hours and couldn't stop 'till I viewed entire set. . .great series. . .great ending. . .
@JaneAustendiamond Yes, I have read the books. I know that most of the time Mark acts like a bully. But have you read Flambards Divided? In this book, Mark is a completely different person and Christina does eventually marry Mark in the end.
When I said Mark, I was kinda refering to when he was a changed character after the war and well, because it's easy to fall for someone like that, a "bad" boy as well as in the TV series. Hope that answers your question....
@somesuperandomperson Yes, I have read Flambards Divided. When I think of Mark I generally think of his portrayal in the earlier books. I wish they had adapted Flambards Divided as well.
@JaneAustendiamond I know!! It's so sweet when they run off together (but predictable). William is so friendly towards Christina in the book but in the TV series he comes over as taking her for granted and not respecting her enough where as Mark kind of worships her in a way, especially in Flambards Divided :-) So yep, I like both the 2nd and the 4th book. The 3rd in my opinion is a little suffocating because of the death of William and the fact that she was left with virtually nothing :-)
@somesuperandomperson It is predictable, I agree! But very sweet too. I love happy endings but if it had ended with Christina and Will being happy-ever-after we wouldn't have the 3rd and 4th books, so in that respect it's good that he dies!
@JaneAustendiamond I certainly agree. Sometimes deaths are the only way for the plot in the story to move on! So in that respect it is a good thing! And as Cader1Dris2 was asking, which of the three would you choose? I'm guessing William? :-)
@somesuperandomperson Both. I read the books first, then saw the TV series a few years later. I was kind of joking about being in love with him since 11 though, but a William Russell would suit me!
I really didn't expect Dick to have an affair in the 4th book, it was quite confusing actually. In all the other books he's really sweet and caring and I wouldn't have seen him as an adulterer, but K.M. Peyton seemed to change the characters a lot in the 4th book.
Well, I know. But it's got to be William in the long term. If Christina had married Mark to begin with she would have divorced him within a few years.I didn't expect Dick to have an affair either, but he knew that Christina had fallen in love with Mark and he was quite subtle, going off with another servant and everything. Im not sure i really like the age differences of the characters in the books/series. In the first book, Christina is about 12, in the series she looks about 27!!!!!!
@somesuperandomperson Hmm, I know what you mean about the age differences. I suppose they thought it would be easier to make Christina older for the series (I think she's meant to be about 16 at the beginning of the series, whereas in the book she's 12 as you say).
Yes, probably. I'm sure she looks a lot older than 16 in the series. I know Christina is young and naive in the books but I don't see why they couldn't translate that on screen. Oh well... I wonder what happened to Christina McKenna, I haven't seen her in anything new recently. That goes for Alan Parnaby and Steven Grives.
I think they're all great - I have watched this series over and over again (since I have the video's at home). I cry everytime :'( when Willian dies. The series = amazing and I love!! :)
I loved this show years ago, and agree with eugeneonegin09, it's William all the way. Even now, I occasionally dip into the books, still prefer The Edge of the Cloud and cry each time about Will's death.
I loved Dick until he cheated :/
Eyelaashh 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I've always been a Will girl!
Iampa1963 7 months ago
I've always benn a Will girl!
Iampa1963 7 months ago
No contest. Will all the way!
I wish he had come back instead of Mark.
sunnitimes4 7 months ago
@flybreath *Ahhhhhh* :DD glad you enjoyed the video! :D
Cader1dris2 1 year ago
@Geddaway
he's also very good looking lmfao :3
StephTheShootingStar 1 year ago
Comment removed
MissMe1203 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is brilliant :D thank you!!!! could you make a mark/christina tribute? please :D
MissMe1203 1 year ago
This is brilliant :D thank you!!!! could you make a mark/christina tribute? please :D
MissMe1203 1 year ago
Comment removed
MissMe1203 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Cader1dris2 hehe i wont tell! i think its such a shame that they never made films of the 4th book, me and my mum (who read them shen she was little and got me into them) decided tht if we were to re make it now we would have eric banner as mark, orlando bloom as will (kinda sweet but a bit weedy aswell lmao) and we thought of a yound leonardo di caprio as dick! we chose all the others too but they were the most fun! they rly should make a new one tho, it would be awsome!
littledancer14 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Cader1dris2 hehe i wont tell! i think its such a shame that they never made films of the 4th book, me and my mum (who read them shen she was little and got me into them) decided tht if we were to re make it now we would have eric banner as mark, orlando bloom as will (kinda sweet but a bit weedy aswell lmao) and we thought of a yound leonardo di caprio as dick! we chose all the others too but they were the most fun! they rly should make a new one tho, it would be awsome!
littledancer14 1 year ago
Okay - so you're rich asshole foxhunter.
THAT DONT IMPRESS ME MUCH!
Dude - she totally marries him in the book.
This puts PBS on a whole new level of strange.
amazonx42 1 year ago
up untill reading the 4th book i was really undecided as to which i liked the most but after reading the last book id deffo have to go for will! dicks cheats and although mark comes a close second hes still a bit to a prat lol so yh will all the way! best books ever and a really fun vid!
littledancer14 1 year ago
@littledancer14 aww thankyou very much :) I wanted to make a fun silly video about them :) and thought it was brill song to go with it- so I apprecieate your comment :) and Im so glad your loving the books! Flambards is def the best ever and so is will ;) he's my fave too but *shhhshh*
Cader1dris2 1 year ago
@Cader1dris2 hehe i wont tell! i think its such a shame that they never made films of the 4th book, me and my mum (who read them shen she was little and got me into them) decided tht if we were to re make it now we would have eric banner as mark, orlando bloom as will (kinda sweet but a bit weedy aswell lmao) and we thought of a yound leonardo di caprio as dick! we chose all the others too but they were the most fun! they rly should make a new one tho, it would be awsome!
littledancer14 1 year ago
@Cader1dris2 hehe i wont tell! i think its such a shame that they never made films of the 4th book, me and my mum (who read them shen she was little and got me into them) decided tht if we were to re make it now we would have eric banner as mark, orlando bloom as will (kinda sweet but a bit weedy aswell lmao) and we thought of a yound leonardo di caprio as dick! we chose all the others too but they were the most fun! they rly should make a new one tho, it would be awsome!
littledancer14 1 year ago
@littledancer14 aw yeh def! i think it would be really interesting if they did a re-make! You chose a good choice of actors too. Me and my brother talk about that too, if they re-made it who would be good to play in it. You never know they might do soon! it would def be awesome :) take care.
Cader1dris2 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Cader1dris2 hehe i wont tell! i think its such a shame that they never made films of the 4th book, me and my mum (who read them shen she was little and got me into them) decided tht if we were to re make it now we would have eric banner as mark, orlando bloom as will (kinda sweet but a bit weedy aswell lmao) and we thought of a yound leonardo di caprio as dick! we chose all the others too but they were the most fun! they rly should make a new one tho, it would be awsome!
littledancer14 1 year ago
dick, no question!
hersheyboo03 2 years ago
Do you know where I can watch this online? They don't have it in Singapore where I come from.
Littlemisshavoc 2 years ago
erm I have no idea to be honest, unless you buy it on DVD on amazon or ebay...you could try searching it and just see if the interent comes with a download or something?
Cader1dris2 2 years ago
My recollection of the series. . .Dick wasn't trying to impress Christina, he was a common servant, William knew Peter was to be her future wife for her families money and Peter wasn't really into Christina's type. . .but good veedio
duinnerfs 2 years ago
its not peter -I think you mean mark dear ;) but fanks
Cader1dris2 2 years ago
Your right it's Mark. . . just reviewed the entire series on DVD, more than 10 hours and couldn't stop 'till I viewed entire set. . .great series. . .great ending. . .
duinnerfs 2 years ago
@duinnerfs Peter?
Malibuthunder 1 year ago
@Malibuthunder my mistake, Mark. . . .
duinnerfs 1 year ago
William! woo! until he dies :'( xx
Id probably fall for mark if it were me tho!
somesuperandomperson 2 years ago
yes definatly thats what I think too :) thanks for watching! x
Cader1dris2 2 years ago
Ok :-)
You should really make some more videos out of these clips they are awesome !! PLEASE!! :'D
somesuperandomperson 2 years ago
Also, the song goes really well with the clips.. clever!
Will - brains
Mark- looks
Dick- ? Eh>? Machines? that kinda works with the horses i guess, please make some more vids out of these clips they are AWESOME!! pretty please?!?
somesuperandomperson 2 years ago
Why Mark? Have you read the books? Most of the time he's arrogant, unpleasant and a bully. Not my ideal suitor.
JaneAustendiamond 1 year ago
@JaneAustendiamond Yes, I have read the books. I know that most of the time Mark acts like a bully. But have you read Flambards Divided? In this book, Mark is a completely different person and Christina does eventually marry Mark in the end.
When I said Mark, I was kinda refering to when he was a changed character after the war and well, because it's easy to fall for someone like that, a "bad" boy as well as in the TV series. Hope that answers your question....
somesuperandomperson 1 year ago
@somesuperandomperson Yes, I have read Flambards Divided. When I think of Mark I generally think of his portrayal in the earlier books. I wish they had adapted Flambards Divided as well.
JaneAustendiamond 1 year ago
@JaneAustendiamond So do I. But Mark in the books wishes to be kind when it suits him and that's what Christina could fall for.
I really wish they'd adapted Flambards Divided too. Was Flambards Divided your favourite book?
somesuperandomperson 1 year ago
@somesuperandomperson Yes, I agree. Kind when it suits him (but usually not to servants!).
I like all of the Flambards series but The Edge of the Cloud is probably my favourite, because I like William best. :-)
JaneAustendiamond 1 year ago
@JaneAustendiamond I know!! It's so sweet when they run off together (but predictable). William is so friendly towards Christina in the book but in the TV series he comes over as taking her for granted and not respecting her enough where as Mark kind of worships her in a way, especially in Flambards Divided :-) So yep, I like both the 2nd and the 4th book. The 3rd in my opinion is a little suffocating because of the death of William and the fact that she was left with virtually nothing :-)
somesuperandomperson 1 year ago
@somesuperandomperson It is predictable, I agree! But very sweet too. I love happy endings but if it had ended with Christina and Will being happy-ever-after we wouldn't have the 3rd and 4th books, so in that respect it's good that he dies!
JaneAustendiamond 1 year ago
@JaneAustendiamond I certainly agree. Sometimes deaths are the only way for the plot in the story to move on! So in that respect it is a good thing! And as Cader1Dris2 was asking, which of the three would you choose? I'm guessing William? :-)
somesuperandomperson 1 year ago
@somesuperandomperson Yep, definitely William! ;-) I have been in love with William since about 11. lol.
JaneAustendiamond 1 year ago
@JaneAustendiamond Really? William in the book or in the TV series?
somesuperandomperson 1 year ago
@somesuperandomperson Both. I read the books first, then saw the TV series a few years later. I was kind of joking about being in love with him since 11 though, but a William Russell would suit me!
JaneAustendiamond 1 year ago
@JaneAustendiamond Ok... William is it then! I mean, let's face it; Dick's kind of a jerk and Mark's too dominating.
Oh and by the way, I left you a comment on your channel.
somesuperandomperson 1 year ago
Oh I thought you liked Mark!
I really didn't expect Dick to have an affair in the 4th book, it was quite confusing actually. In all the other books he's really sweet and caring and I wouldn't have seen him as an adulterer, but K.M. Peyton seemed to change the characters a lot in the 4th book.
I saw your comment, thanks. :-)
JaneAustendiamond 1 year ago
Well, I know. But it's got to be William in the long term. If Christina had married Mark to begin with she would have divorced him within a few years.I didn't expect Dick to have an affair either, but he knew that Christina had fallen in love with Mark and he was quite subtle, going off with another servant and everything. Im not sure i really like the age differences of the characters in the books/series. In the first book, Christina is about 12, in the series she looks about 27!!!!!!
somesuperandomperson 1 year ago
@somesuperandomperson Hmm, I know what you mean about the age differences. I suppose they thought it would be easier to make Christina older for the series (I think she's meant to be about 16 at the beginning of the series, whereas in the book she's 12 as you say).
JaneAustendiamond 1 year ago
Yes, probably. I'm sure she looks a lot older than 16 in the series. I know Christina is young and naive in the books but I don't see why they couldn't translate that on screen. Oh well... I wonder what happened to Christina McKenna, I haven't seen her in anything new recently. That goes for Alan Parnaby and Steven Grives.
somesuperandomperson 1 year ago
i think she should go with dick i h8 mark and william annoys me!
cloudybubble 2 years ago
I think they're all great - I have watched this series over and over again (since I have the video's at home). I cry everytime :'( when Willian dies. The series = amazing and I love!! :)
kpeter66 2 years ago 3
hehhe yes me too! and your right The series =amazing :DDD thanks for watching!
Cader1dris2 2 years ago
I loved this show years ago, and agree with eugeneonegin09, it's William all the way. Even now, I occasionally dip into the books, still prefer The Edge of the Cloud and cry each time about Will's death.
rockc68 2 years ago 2
aww me too! thankyou for watching :)
Cader1dris2 2 years ago
i love mark he can be sweet when he wants to be! :)... great vid x
rosiebear14 2 years ago 2
thankyou Im glad you enjoyed it, thanks for watching :D and yes mark can be sweet when he wants to be, think he would win me over lol
Cader1dris2 2 years ago
WILLIAM!!! DEFO!
horselover100 2 years ago
Hahahaa agree!! :D thanks for watching!!
Cader1dris2 2 years ago
Got to be Dick everytime, down to earth, strong and oh those eyes...................
but maybe with a bit of bad boy Mark on the side
24jobi 2 years ago 5
haha indeed :D thanks for watching! and getting lost in dick's lovelyyy eyes!
Cader1dris2 2 years ago
@24jobi i thought that until he cheated lmfao :L
StephTheShootingStar 1 year ago
Will or Dick? Every girl should have such a decision to make in her life! Love them both!
BabsLongfellow 2 years ago 2
hehe indeed :D thanks for watching!
Cader1dris2 2 years ago
no question, william hands down
eugeneonegin09 2 years ago
hehee definatly! thanks for watching!
Cader1dris2 2 years ago
Dick ... he helped save her horse Sweetbriar getting fed to the hounds lol .
20mrcasper 2 years ago 2
true true and he's always really sweet and lets her have her way- will is more "its his idea"---lol :)
thanks for watching!!!
Cader1dris2 2 years ago
@20mrcasper so did Will! :P
musiclover128 1 year ago
My vote goes to Will. I loved Will and Christina together.
samgracesmom 2 years ago
they do have such great chemestry! :) thanks for watching! :)
Cader1dris2 2 years ago
yes very much :P :)
Cader1dris2 2 years ago
Mark definanatly haha
Stephehxx 2 years ago