Added: 4 years ago
From: iobuffa
Views: 48,146
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (515)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • GH3 is awsome and will crush rock band

  • Rock band and gh3

  • What I hate about Rock Band is the fact that you cannot have 2 guitars in Band Play. I can't even count the times I got into an argument just so I can have the guitar because bass sucks.

  • Mr pregnant is your brother , right? *Note , if u dnt kniw mr pregnant just youtube "mrpregnant" awkay bruthah?

  • Do some research first, because Harmonix also released GH: Rock the 80's before GH3. Get it right tubby.

  • Rock band has a full band and its easier to play (Well to me and my friend who owns it) but theres also guitar hero world tour which has full band. I prefer guitar hero 3 because its my fave from the series. But i heard rock band 3 is coming out soon and their gonna have a keyboard in the band. Still i prefer guitar hero even tho i might get rock band soon for my birthday, I'll have both :P

  • buy them both but rock band exactly it is a band

  • guitar hero!!!!!

    rock band sucks the songs are 2 easy

  • ROCK BAND 4EVER, GUITAR HERO 4NEVR

  • It was a good review or what its called... :)

  • Comment removed

  • rock band i have all the games and i say rockband better songs cheaper and much more user friendly

  • guitar hero the guitar in guitar hero are better and the drums in guitar hero make less noise and in rock band the guitar sucks the drums make too much damn noise you have to waste you money on buy some shit pads Guitar Hero all the way

  • Rock Band was the very first music band game. It was a smash hit because it built on the idea of GH, but it expanded it to the full band concept. It wasn't punished for it's instruments or mistakes because although it wasn't a new genre, it was a new intellectual property. The GH drums are very quiet but they're also lackluster. I never owned a set, but my friend's deteriorated very quickly and became unreliable (dropped notes, etc.). The RB drums are louder, but they are more reliable.

  • rock band, guitar hero has horrible, just horrible DLC. Plus the ion drums work easily for rock band.

  • ROCK BAND

  • ROCK BAND 4EVER, GUITAR HERO 4NEVER

  • rock band

  • ROCKBAND

  • gh drums are better lol there is only 4 drum in the set its rly easy like this

  • Guitar hero guirars are better ,but rockband drums are better. But like the same thing.

  • i say guitar hero wins now cause they got drums with symbols!! singing and 2 guitars. But rock band wins because gutiar hero stole their idea!!

  • not realy becuse Guitar Hero thought on it long before rock band came out It was talk about they were going to make drums to Guitar hero 3 but then they had to use much much more time so they didnt do it

  • guitar hero is so much better!

  • i agree 95%

  • rock band has much better programming on the game. It's just funner.

  • the rock band guitars look cooler and have a better fell to it

  • most of the instruments are compatable with the other game, so the only thing stopping you from getting both is cost

  • bass

  • wow guitar hero let u play song no shit dumshit wait i kno it lets u to suck dick

  • yaay skype is danish and im from denmark :D

  • Rockband and guitar Hero 3 are both good

  • 1- rockband2 is the best ever, 2- you dont have to have like4 people palyin at once... u can go solo and 3 or even 3 you dont need a big party, but yes ur right rockband is made for more then 1 but its just as fun solo...

    i suggest that u get rockband2

  • u dont have to have 4 people playing at once on guitar hero world tour either!!

  • did u even read what u commented to?

    i was just stateing that you didnt have to have a famley play togeather like the guy sed in the video, i was saying that you can 1-4 players playing and its just as fun no matter how many play

    ok?!?

    so stop pmsing!

  • rock band has easy songs even on expert

  • ROCKBAND SUCKSSS

    GO GHWT!!

  • Agreed!

  • no world tour copys sooooooooooo much that rock band should sew for that crap lol i think they are the same in awsomeness tho just the fact that they copyed

  • their made by same people pretty much. so nobody really copied anyone.

  • ghwt has much more better drums

  • expect when it breaks

  • the strumming thing on the rockband guitar sucks, it's weird.

  • yeah no click

  • rock band is sooooooooooooooo much better alone or with company no doubt about it

  • i got guitar hero 2, 3 and world tour and i also have rock band

  • he forgot about guitar hero rocks the 80s...

  • wow. this guy acts like rockband copied off of guitar hero, while the people who made rock band actually made guitar hero 1 and 2

  • wow una persona de color que le gusta GH es increible por que normalmente les gustan esas mierdas de hip-hop y rap es super raro ver a un negro rockero a excepcion de Jimi Hendrix

  • 0.o tienes toda razon

  • RB is far better. the guitar game play is pretty much the same but RB has more songs. playing the drums is possibly more fun then Guitar and the singing is pretty much the same as sing star. the only thing that lets it down is the RB guitar is harder to play but you can always just buy a GH Guitar it works on both games.

  • he looks like the gay version of rick ross

  • GAY!!!

  • i like how he says guitar

    "In GUI-tar hero 3..." lol XD ROFLMFAO

  • couple of things

    rock band cums wit 1 guitar

    rok band doesnt really have a replay factor while GH3 has a major replay factor

    rb guitar is really hard

  • oh yea cause 500 songs compared to 120 is soo not re-playable and 120 songs is so much more re-playable!

  • rock band's replay factor not very good

    but GH3's replay factor is alot better cuz the songs are wayyyy harder and i am still tryin to beat it on hard/expert while i killed Rb on all levels

  • Yeah, but I have over 300 songs downloaded from the store. Most of which I haven't even played yet.

  • rb for wii sucks......... cuz u cant use the GH3 controller on it....... and u have to buy ANOTHER GUITAR....

  • rockband sux and guitar hero world tour rocks

  • *BANG!* Agreed!

  • thanks this has help me 2 choose between gh3 and rock band.

  • What the hell! Gh3 only has GUITAR Rb has Drums+Guitar+Mic Whats the POINT its unfair!

  • I got news for you: GHWT is out.

  • I know dumbass, I have GHWT! Thats such a gy video, because, its unfair.

  • Doesn't really matter... RB2 still beats GHWT. Music game of the year, higher ratings, more songs, etc.

  • no it doesnt thats why i think RB2 sux major dick because the drums 4 pads no symbals GHWT 5 pads 2 symbals more realistic and also th guitar sux

  • No.... It does help to have cymbals, but it's not realistic to have the hi-hat to the right of the snare. I play real drums, so I would know. The bass pedal for GHWT also sucks balls, and the RB2 pedal doesn't. The majority of GHWT drumsets at launch were faulty or broken, not the case for RB2. The guitars are practically the same thing. 5 buttons, a strum bar, whammy, and solo buttons. GHWT's touch slider is horrible because it's TOO sensitive. Buttons are better. RB2 wins.

  • the strum bar is to hard to push and i have to jam it down and also the people look dumb with their size 25 shoes and also i play guitar and i prefer the giutar for GH and also all my friends play with the GH guitar on Rb which is the dumbest note shape a square and my friend plays drums and he prefers the GH drums over RB

  • I love how all of your idiotic reasons are opinions. They all relate to you, or your friends. No matter how realistic GHWT gets, it's still a bunch of plastic/rubber instruments. The Rock Band 2 drums had way, way less broken sets shipped out. I don't care what you people think, RB2 was rated higher than GHWT by Gamespot, IGN, VGchatrz, and was named the music game of the year. No matter how many times you say it, Rock Band 2 still wins.

  • ok ok ok ive figured this out depending on what we think we all have our own option but GH has been out longer and i got all of the games so i have like 5 or 6 guitars

  • The people who made Guitar Hero 1, Guitar Hero 2, and Guitar Hero: Rock the 80s are the same people who made Rock Band 1 and 2. So really, Harmonix has 5 games whereas Neversoft has 3. 80% of Harmonix staff are musicians, so they know what they're doing. That's also one of the reasons why the RB2 setlist is better than GHWT. I do admit though that the GH3 setlist is better than RB1.

  • i think both GH3 and GHWT have better setlist over all

  • Haha! RB2 completely assrapes GHWT's setlist.

  • Rb2 is rad. I dont think GH fanboys have ever played rock band.

  • finally, someone says it

  • are you kidding

    and we can make our own songs and download songs that people mad for free

  • ....? It sounds great on paper, but the truth is, the "songs" you make on GHMix only ends up sounding like a crappy ringtone. I'd take good DLC over ringtones anyday.

  • plus the dudes who made gh 1 gh2 and gh rock the 80's made rock band so pwned

  • rock band is so much better.

  • GH is better than rockband

  • Dude, you have to get one more guitar to have the whole band

  • i think u mean. ghwt or rock band 2....

  • the games are pretty cool, absolutely luv the games...BUT i need to know can you use guitar hero world tour instruments on rock band 1 and 2 i need to know plz send us a comment i need to know

  • thx for the video i didnt know what to choose but i do now

  • The Couloured buttons are the fret buttons and the thing you said was a fret is a strum

  • is a strum?

    on normal guitar its stings, strumming is the action of playing the strings.

    buy a real guitar, you can make songs your own. and its a hit with the ladies

  • the Rock Band guitar sucks :/

  • Who cares about the GH80's game lol.

  • wats ur skype name X[)

  • he 4got guitar heo rock da 80's

  • hey, loved the video, thanks so much,, you helped me out, as i wasnt sure which one to buy, i totaly agree with guitar hero 3. my mates dont come round that often so i would go with guitar hero,

    one thing though, i have been looking around, does anyone know how many players you can play on in guitar hero 3.

    .i.e. on some games they have up to 2-4 players... can u have up to 2-4 players??

    thx alot..

    drums4mat

    matt XD = )

  • dude thanks for the vid

  • forgot rock the 80'sand gh aerosmith

  • i subbed

  • actually your the idiot,you forgot about rocks the 80s

  • GH1 GH2 GH3 AND GH aerosmith ..........forgot about that one...idiot

  • Hehe... Now there's Guitar Hero World Tour, and Rock Band isn't gonna be so big anymore...

  • um ok

  • ROCK BAND IS NOOB

  • ur right. Rock band is shit

  • ur wrong. rock band is fun

    but real instruments are the best

  • it can be fun but the instruments are shit. GH was better

  • rockband sucks

    guitar hero is much better

  • ey man nice preveiw dude u should really try it out guitar hero and rock band is very addicting and alot alot of fun dude

  • guitar hero 4 woooooo get it

  • I Have Guitar Hero On Tour Nd I Don't have Rock Band But......Rock Band Is Much Better Than Guitar Hero

  • So your comparing the Guitar Hero game for the DS.. to Rock band? No duh its better. And dont even try to tell me you meant guitar hero world tour, CAUSE ITS NOT OUT YET. Shutup, GHWT will own RB2. RB2 drums already have a 75% failure rate.

  • i have guitar hero 3 and rock band and i think guitar hero 3 is still much much better. better harder songs, character selecter, guitar selecter, and rockbands frets,(game play) whilst you are playing a song, it seems very depressing in a way because rectangular buttons come up, theres hardly any colour, graphics are crap, and the hardest song in the whole game is green grass and high tides and its so easy.

  • Umm.. You can select your rock band character and guitar, and the "Better" songs are just opinion.. Rectangle = circle when all you have to do is strum when it comes down. The graphics are waay better than Guitar Hero's blocky characters, and not to mention the drummer doesn't look like a robot, unlike his GH3 counterpart.. The hardest song is definately not GG+HT, because there's hundreds of other songs to choose from. Seriously. Get some facts first, could ya? You make this too easy.

  • I have both. and I believe rock band is for when you're with friends and guitar hero is for by yourself.

  • Umm.. Then explain why I play Rock Band a lot more than GH?

  • Lol you dont know much about this, your scripted by somebody else i think. "The fret bar and these coloured buttons" its the strum bar and fret buttons

  • and you also forgot 2 guitar hero aerosmith and guitar hero on tour for gba now soon to be 1 more guitar hero world tour

  • Its not on GBA its on DS..

  • incorrect at that time there had been 4 guitar hero releases u forgot guitar hero encore

  • wow this guy is stupid Rock Band all the way guitar hero time 99999999999999999999 = Rock Band

  • Guitar Hero III vs Rock Band 2

    RB2 doesnt come out on PS3 till October cause thats wat i got and then I heard Guitar Hero III was sweet IDK does rock band have note streaks ? lol

  • I have both I recommend Rockband because the songs you download form the first Rockband will transfer seemlessly to Rockband 2. This is my opinion say all you want.

  • I wish they would compile all the guitar hero songs into one game

  • lol, or just make songs available for download to replace songs you dont want. that would be cool instead of having to go through the whole guitar explorer process. and let people submit fan made charts and songs. so have like a whole database that u can just get and play. that would be amazing

  • rock band kicks ass

  • Wat happened to rocks the 80s

    But Guitar Hero Kicks Rockband's Yellow Belly ass

  • FUCK U ROCKBANDS THE BEST FUCK DA REST

  • 2nd that

  • 3rd that

  • hey can u use the 360 controller on rock band?with out the guitar?

  • well, rockband was pretty damn close to being a "copy" but it isnt a copy because of the added drums and microphone... plus guitar solos and the solo buttons, but the notes were pretty much the same idea

  • he didnt say guitar hero rocks the 80's

  • fuck u

  • fat head

  • gh man

  • rockband sucks gh4 is gonna better things rockband u noob put that guitar up ur as5......

  • gh4 isnt out so atm rock band wins and yall are fuckin dicks be nice wtf??? He took the time to help you out thats bullshit that you guys do this to people grow up....

  • im ur mexican am i right? cause u talk like a faggot... or your a wannabe gangter...

  • thats not what your mother said

  • oh really?

    my moms a hoe anyways

    so she was probably drunk when she said that

  • English and grammar will NOT hurt you in any way. Neither will some open mindedness.

  • 2 people can play 3 parts in rock band

  • GH > Life and anything else.

    Any questions?

  • forgot to tell you guys GUITAR HERO 4 IS ALL WIRE LESS Not "Wired"

  • execpt mic

  • Umm, wireless microphones are not necessarily better. Generally, they have lag time, which makes singing near impossible. A wired mic is just fine. And the rest of RB is wireless.. Good job with that arguement.

  • Umm.. stop putting Umm.. at the beginning of each comment for starts.

    Now, Wireless has been improved greatly in GH4, much better than Rock Band has now. Where did you hear they have lag time? Nothing too serious, what, 0,08 MS? Yeah. Singing is the easiest thing to do, even with lag, so I'd say if you can't sing with lag, you're one huge failure.

  • Umm.. No. Do you have a wireless mic? And have you 100%ed songs on expert singing?

  • Yeah I have both Wired and Wireless mics, and yes, 100%ed Singing and Guitar on expert, both wireless.

    And that " Umm.. " makes you look like a overconfident fag.

  • You've 100%ed songs on singing on WT? Even the best singers are having trouble with that.

  • I don't find it that hard. Most of the time I get 99%.

    I like to hum sometimes, singing the words can throw you off.

  • But that's not really singing, is it?

  • Doesn't really matter...

    As long as you get 100%

    And I don't too it often, only when I don't know the tune/lyrics well.

  • Guitar hero 4 is going to be wayyyyyy better than rookie band 2

  • We are talking about gh3

  • gh is rock bands bithch

  • I like having both..., But I don't, Guitar hero is boring at times, so is rock band, but totaly fun! I like the setlists in them that's why they are almost equal. (To me.) good reveiw, but learn the parts of the guitar, rock band has better songs, RIGHT NOW to me. It depends on the mood and I like rock band more. It's like 3 games in one, it takes longer to beat and master, even though I can beat any guitar expert tour, looking foward to R.B.2 and G.H.W.T., so 5 star reveiw.

  • actually Rock Band has only 1 guitar but you could buy a another guitar and also that was a strum bar and the colouerd butons are called frets

  • (in addition to my comment below) not saying that GH sucks but what i'm trying to say (hopefully from a neutral standpoint) is that, it depends on the person and what YOU prefer to play...since both companies are coming out with additions and enhancements to their games..i wouldn't be surprised if both got an equal rating.

  • u no GH4 is gonna b way better than rock band

  • rock band is awesome, guitar hero 4 is making drums 2 cuz they were angry how many sales rock band got

  • I dont know why people debate over these too, Rock Band OBVIOUSLY rocks so much harder, however im gtting guitar hero 3 soon but its too much money.

  • i think people debate over the two games because i think its a preference thing and that probably some of them are bandwagon jumpers (i don't know) but this guy's review of both games has valid points RB shines through group play while GH is more soloist..BOTH games have both ups and downs from all perspectives (gameplay, songlist, options,features, online play, storage (:P) cost,durability and life in the game market etc.) I "preferably" like RB because of personal reasons.

  • i preffer rock band but this guy have reason

    gh its way better alone

    rock band its way better whit ppl

  • comes with one guitar that doubles as a bass

  • GET A LIFE MAN!!!!!

    Activison, Red Octane, AND Neversoft R MAKIN

    GUITAR HERO WORLD TOUR OR GHIV

  • ROCKBAND!!!! I LOVE IT

  • I guess you like a broken piece of crap drumkit with it

  • he doesnt say guitar he says guiitar

  • GH and Rocl Band beet Halo 3 2 and 1 It beats Call of duty 1 2 3 4, and Gears of War

  • anything beats those games....

    well at least gaylo and gears of asscrack.

  • Halo is actually one of the best games out there. If you're one of those Cock of Doody 4: Modern gayfuckstupid fans, try playing Halo for a change. Oh, and don't tell me Halo is sucks because it's on the Top 5 games in the world.

  • omg what are you saying im sure that you like cock of doody 4 

    halo pwns cock of doody and gears of asscrack

    halo pwns --cock of doody 4

    rock band pwns--gh3

  • nah halo is gay, and cod4 is boring too, but it still owns gaylo.

    top 5 for being complete shit lol.

    gh owns rockband.