I Always thought that he was more than just a hitman...in the sense that the ones we see him kill are actually the ones who hired him? He gives them a sweet escape. When their back is against the wall and there is no where too run they could go the hard gross (sin city) way or his way? When he offers them a smoke is when they know they are talking too him but they play along. You see it in both scenes.
@KCArmstrongXIIV The nap didn't help?Well....just make a journal and list as many compliments about yourself as you can and I know you'll think of a lot.YOU AREN'T A FAGGOT.
@KCArmstrongXIIV Keep writing in the journal.Believe it or not,it helps me a lot too lol.Do you have any family to hang out with?Family can really make you feel better.Like you belong in a group ya know.
@KCArmstrongXIIV Hmmm.When's the last time you've gotten away from work?Do you work?If not you just might be bored with life and need to find some sort of hobby.If you do have a career,life may just seem a little repetative and you need to do an activity to just break the cycle.Go on a vacation,spend time with family,or friends.Heck you could even buy a pet(lol I have a golden retriever myself,named him John lol I know that's not a dog's name HA)
@KCArmstrongXIIV If you aren't really much for swimming than you can go anywhere that'll make you feel better,anywhere you can have fun.Me and my mom went to Las Vegas for seven days for her birthday.She always wanted to go there
@KCArmstrongXIIV Well Vegas is pretty hot in summer and pretty cold in winter.Go figure lol.But sometimes the best vacation is a first class seat on the couch at home with a bucket of ice cream right lol.Try that.Anything that'll make you feel better :)
@KCArmstrongXIIV Stop making yourself feel like this.Just remember,compliments ok.Sorry it took me this long to get back to you.I was writing in my journal(it did make me feel better).Have you considered getting a pet yet?
@supertyflash "The big fat kill" happens before this scene that's why she is leaving the hospital because she got shot and hurt during the big fat kill, but she tells her mom she just broke her arm in a car crash probably to protect her mom from knowing that she was a prostitute.
this movie (and the comics) is a masterpieces in neon-noir style! the intense story telling, the characters and everything else! GOD, I love this movie!
Becky totally deserves it: she betrayed the other Old Town gals. However, I don't know why they changed that bit. In the book, she is shot dead in the alley with the mobsters.
Josh Hartnett is one of my favorite actors and I thought it was really cool the way the film starts with his character and ends the film with his character. Although he was in two scenes, I thought he was really good. I hope he appears in the upcoming sequel of SIN CITY.
"Care for a smoke?" Damn, the perfect actor for every single character! Bledel may be a bit too much of a "happy" actress for Becky, but she was still great.
I still don't think Becky was killed!!!!!!! She was my favorite and she wouldn't fall for that!!!!!!! Trust me!!!!!!! She better be in the second Sin City and if she isn't I will seriously start crying!!!!!!!
She hired him to. She was on the run from someone trying to kill her, and she just couldn't stand it anymore, so she hired him to just get it over with. That's why he says "I'll cash her check in the morning." Frank Miller made it all clear in the dvd commentary.
His look is so damn cool when he says "Becky..."
SlickStickJackson 4 months ago
Oh, Josh is amazing in these scenes!
philippehungary 4 months ago
@MrBOOMstick2033 lulz!
Rolfstunner 5 months ago
@MrBOOMstick2033 For the only reasonable thing, money :-)
Rolfstunner 5 months ago
I Always thought that he was more than just a hitman...in the sense that the ones we see him kill are actually the ones who hired him? He gives them a sweet escape. When their back is against the wall and there is no where too run they could go the hard gross (sin city) way or his way? When he offers them a smoke is when they know they are talking too him but they play along. You see it in both scenes.
mangagirl61 7 months ago 4
Josh Hartnett owned these scenes. I hope we get a better story for his character in the sequel, IF IT EVER COMES OUT!!!
Josh0473 10 months ago 11
Smoothest assassin ever.
Spartages 10 months ago 2
therz only one woman
foxypurple12 10 months ago
Josh has the most gorgeous eyes.
He's like a combination of Taylor Lautner and Leonardo DiCaprio
PollyOfficial 10 months ago
i dont get it...
KCArmstrongXIIV 1 year ago
@KCArmstrongXIIV What are you talkin about?He's a hitman
wisewarrior7 1 year ago
@wisewarrior7 faGGot FaiL
KCArmstrongXIIV 1 year ago
@KCArmstrongXIIV Now what are you talking about?
wisewarrior7 1 year ago
@wisewarrior7 faGGot FaiL
KCArmstrongXIIV 1 year ago
@KCArmstrongXIIV I don't get it
wisewarrior7 1 year ago
@wisewarrior7 faGGot FaiL
KCArmstrongXIIV 1 year ago
@KCArmstrongXIIV Would you quit being so hard on yourself dude.You didn't understand the scene.You're not a faggot or a fail.
wisewarrior7 1 year ago
@wisewarrior7 faGGot FaiL
KCArmstrongXIIV 1 year ago
@KCArmstrongXIIV IT'S ALL RIGHT.You're not a fail
wisewarrior7 1 year ago
@wisewarrior7 faGGot FaiL
KCArmstrongXIIV 1 year ago
@KCArmstrongXIIV Just get a good night's sleep.You'll feel better.I promise :)
wisewarrior7 1 year ago
@wisewarrior7 faGGot FaiL
KCArmstrongXIIV 1 year ago
@KCArmstrongXIIV The nap didn't help?Well....just make a journal and list as many compliments about yourself as you can and I know you'll think of a lot.YOU AREN'T A FAGGOT.
wisewarrior7 1 year ago
@wisewarrior7 faGGot FaiL
KCArmstrongXIIV 1 year ago
@KCArmstrongXIIV Keep writing in the journal.Believe it or not,it helps me a lot too lol.Do you have any family to hang out with?Family can really make you feel better.Like you belong in a group ya know.
wisewarrior7 1 year ago
@wisewarrior7 faGGot FaiL
KCArmstrongXIIV 1 year ago
@KCArmstrongXIIV Hmmm.When's the last time you've gotten away from work?Do you work?If not you just might be bored with life and need to find some sort of hobby.If you do have a career,life may just seem a little repetative and you need to do an activity to just break the cycle.Go on a vacation,spend time with family,or friends.Heck you could even buy a pet(lol I have a golden retriever myself,named him John lol I know that's not a dog's name HA)
wisewarrior7 1 year ago
@wisewarrior7 faGGot FaiL
KCArmstrongXIIV 1 year ago
@KCArmstrongXIIV You'll feel a lot better after that vacation.Me,my mother,and my brother want to Nassua in the Bahamas over summer.
wisewarrior7 1 year ago
@wisewarrior7 faGGot FaiL
KCArmstrongXIIV 1 year ago
@KCArmstrongXIIV If you aren't really much for swimming than you can go anywhere that'll make you feel better,anywhere you can have fun.Me and my mom went to Las Vegas for seven days for her birthday.She always wanted to go there
wisewarrior7 1 year ago
@wisewarrior7 faGGot FaiL
KCArmstrongXIIV 1 year ago
@KCArmstrongXIIV Well Vegas is pretty hot in summer and pretty cold in winter.Go figure lol.But sometimes the best vacation is a first class seat on the couch at home with a bucket of ice cream right lol.Try that.Anything that'll make you feel better :)
wisewarrior7 1 year ago
@wisewarrior7 faGGot FaiL
KCArmstrongXIIV 1 year ago
@KCArmstrongXIIV Stop making yourself feel like this.Just remember,compliments ok.Sorry it took me this long to get back to you.I was writing in my journal(it did make me feel better).Have you considered getting a pet yet?
wisewarrior7 1 year ago
@wisewarrior7 faGGot FaiL
KCArmstrongXIIV 1 year ago
@wisewarrior7 faGGot FaiL
Philabobby 8 months ago
@KCArmstrongXIIV wtf
MrNeomaniak 1 year ago
Josh Hartnett should play Superman if they're gonna do it again
spreadthelove77 1 year ago
josh hartnett is a lucky bastard!
he's a great actor, so no offence, but to get to play the opening AND the ending scene in a classic film is just so freakin cool!!!!
baiqp 1 year ago
Josh Hartnett is such an amazing actor! He makes every word as important as the one before it and the one after it.
HWDavis94 1 year ago
i agree hows she going to come back if he kills her in the lift
cilitbosh 1 year ago
@cilitbosh maybe he dosent kill her in the lift ;) we do not see it, so there may be the twist
DexterinHD 1 year ago
Do you people think Josh kinda looks like M. Shadows from Avenged Sevenfold?
xxMandiiVxx 1 year ago
He is so hot!!!!!!!!!!! <3
ghostlyme 1 year ago
Ooooohhh no!!!! Becky is dead? WTF? Damn! Somebody answer me, please... =/
Unidade17 1 year ago
Man...he makes being a hit-man look so cool and slick
Chammy92243 1 year ago 2
One of the most visually stunning movies ever.
MrINeedSome 1 year ago
i love the movie!!
krizzmushan 1 year ago
outstanding!!!!!
Belcebu022 1 year ago
like a G!!!!!
southeastkid12 1 year ago
One thing that makes this movie great are the narrators.
aquanaut145 1 year ago
he Smiles and say Care for a smoke? but in his mind he is like (Muhahaha! Ka-Chiing!)
TheTheo86 1 year ago
Best Scene in the Movie! I think so :)
xxXAppleMisora 1 year ago
stop being so emo
estagonandfire 1 year ago
perfectly designed and executed scene .. the dialogue is like poetry in the opening scene, truly beautiful! Josh Hartnett's voice is so hypnotising!
- "care for a smoke?" *he smiles that smile*
kukidoe1 1 year ago
so wait-He killed Becky?
impossible-Becky Appears in "The Big Fat Kill" or was that before "The Costomer Is Always Right"?
wow this is messed up....
supertyflash 1 year ago
@supertyflash "The big fat kill" happens before this scene that's why she is leaving the hospital because she got shot and hurt during the big fat kill, but she tells her mom she just broke her arm in a car crash probably to protect her mom from knowing that she was a prostitute.
AccordingToGaby 1 year ago
@AccordingToGaby ohhhhh...
so wait, if there will be a second "Sin city" she's going to be dead??
supertyflash 1 year ago
@supertyflash
i saw an interview and she sed shes in the 2nd film...so i guess shes not dead?
KuzumiKun 5 months ago
@KuzumiKun The stories aren't in chronological order, so she could be in one set before the events in "The Big Fat Kill".
Cybrludite 1 day ago
wait-he killed Becky? imposibble..
supertyflash 1 year ago
this movie (and the comics) is a masterpieces in neon-noir style! the intense story telling, the characters and everything else! GOD, I love this movie!
aninnocentman94 1 year ago
he's got style like me
tjohn1986 1 year ago
Can somone tell me the name of the song pls?
deedee9960 1 year ago
Damn Josh is HOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
mdurangoramos 2 years ago 3
turn the right corner in sin city and you can find anything...
Airmakz123 2 years ago 6
music??
mrjazz646 2 years ago
The first bit definatly is the most noir-esque bit of this me.
Cockleduster 2 years ago 5
Becky totally deserves it: she betrayed the other Old Town gals. However, I don't know why they changed that bit. In the book, she is shot dead in the alley with the mobsters.
Celestein 2 years ago 2
So it will begin and end with The Man.
erodog 2 years ago 5
the point with the salesman is that he is a hit man who kills those who have hired him by offering them a cigarette.
pixargod 2 years ago
so he kills those that hired him ? or does he kill people that he has been hired to kill?
becky was a target of his becasue she betrayed the town gals and they hired him to take care of her right ?
thegermanguy99 2 years ago
@thegermanguy99 @thegermanguy99 thats how i understand it.
the girl in the red dress hires him to kill herself and becky is a target probably of the town girls
SmokingBirds 1 year ago
@pixargod He offers quality executions :)
aquanaut145 1 year ago
Josh Hartnett is one of my favorite actors and I thought it was really cool the way the film starts with his character and ends the film with his character. Although he was in two scenes, I thought he was really good. I hope he appears in the upcoming sequel of SIN CITY.
philipdr88 2 years ago 6
how?-neardy girl
ciderella13 2 years ago
i love the salesman, he's slick!
Aidan1300 2 years ago 16
maybe she wasn't killed, i still hope that...
lovelydreams139 3 years ago
sin city is an amazing film...but it is sooooo disturbing and depressing!
rosydonut 3 years ago 41
@rosydonut thats how life is... thats how it goes
MrPopeye232323 1 year ago
@rosydonut its film noir comic book style, of course its disturbing and depressing pfftt
stefanbuza 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@rosydonut its film noir comic book style, of course its disturbing and depressing pfftt
stefanbuza 7 months ago
ggaddict1537 sorry but becky is dead
runs619house 3 years ago
I heard she is in the next 2 though.
RaarZipan 2 years ago
she hired him as her own hitman
nerdygirl359 3 years ago 6
"Care for a smoke?" Damn, the perfect actor for every single character! Bledel may be a bit too much of a "happy" actress for Becky, but she was still great.
FrankRabbit600 3 years ago 8
Best character in the movie.
poppabeow 3 years ago 5
haha she had it coming. she was hot but really annoying. im getting the kiss scene done as a half sleeve.
liloma831 3 years ago
just got the tattoo? anyone wanna see a pic?
liloma831 3 years ago
How does it look?
mxwrdn 2 years ago
it looks great!! people compliment me all the time.
liloma831 2 years ago
I do
MaximumCheeseage 2 years ago
I still don't think Becky was killed!!!!!!! She was my favorite and she wouldn't fall for that!!!!!!! Trust me!!!!!!! She better be in the second Sin City and if she isn't I will seriously start crying!!!!!!!
ggaddict1537 3 years ago
...I'll cash her check in the morning
Guter9 3 years ago 5
Was the elevator scene in the comic?
Gggmanlives 3 years ago
Nope...made it up for the movie
StrungOutFlip 3 years ago
No. It was written for the movie. Originally, she dies in the alley.
WhindSoull 2 years ago
I love Josh's voice, it sounds so sexy!!!
Cziglenyi 3 years ago 41
i agree he yum yum
az19all 3 years ago 5
@Cziglenyi The words he is saying are beautiful too.
The script, as well as the amazing visual effects are what made this scene grip me. :)
BoyWithBlackWings07 1 year ago 4
@Cziglenyi i agree with u, and he's sexy with smoking!
micsasy 1 year ago
this scene is the best (L)
i love sin city!
rubachac 3 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
And how isn't the little punk emo? "I loved her then I killed her" is pretty damn emo. Almost sounds like one of those terrible "emo" songs.
SabreKitteh 3 years ago
Then O.J. Simpson must be the emoist bastard alive.
Denebola171 3 years ago 3
Don't you remember? "If the glove doesn't fit, you must acquit."
SabreKitteh 3 years ago 2
what the fuck is wrong with him?
why would he shoot her?
Bendersrule 3 years ago
She hired him to. She was on the run from someone trying to kill her, and she just couldn't stand it anymore, so she hired him to just get it over with. That's why he says "I'll cash her check in the morning." Frank Miller made it all clear in the dvd commentary.
StepsonOfTheClapper 3 years ago 7
More so, she back stabbed her boss.
thedamned1981 3 years ago
@StepsonOfTheClapper and what happens with becky?
viviebo 1 year ago
@Bendersrule Thats his job, and like everyone else, the city has corrupted him.
aquanaut145 1 year ago
"The wind rises electric, she's soft warm and almost wheightless, her perfume is sweet promise that brings tears to my eyes..."
<3
HugoRochaHGP 3 years ago 8
I hope they go into more detail about this character in one of the sequals they are making, but these are such amazing scenes.
SnowflakeOfTheWuTang 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Bah! Stupid emo twit hitman. The concept is just so lame. He's still a total doosh.
SabreKitteh 3 years ago
I agree, my favorite parts of this movie are absolutely the beginning and the ending. They're both so evocative and beautiful.
Doones 3 years ago 8
This first scene is (in my opinion) the best part of the whole movie. It's so random yet so powerful. Work of art
paddie00 3 years ago 7