Carly Smithson- Without You

[lovegxx]

i remember kelly clarkson

[MrJudube]

heh Mariah was giving bad tips to all the girls to sabotage their performances

[kelldyl]

I love David Cook but Carley should definitely been runner up...

[CassiSmash]

Kelly and Leona can't hold a candle to Carly's version of this song...

[qg6ff]

I think the problem was we and her herself were trying too hard to pay attention to how "angry" she looked during her performance as just the previous week she was told she looked too mad during her songs... seems like she focused too much on that to truly enjoy and enthuse what she was singing

[McDwayne1709]

She almost nailed it.. not her best vocal..

[jenndiva1]

carly is great but kelly is the queen at this song!!

[xXTorres113Xx]

Really good version of this awesome song =)

[shadysadie55]

i think she should of been in top 3 not jason!!! shes awesome

[thereaintnodoubt]

Jason wasnt in the top 3...he was in the top 4...but i agree...i think the top 5 shoulda been Carly, the 2 Davids, Michael Johns and Syesha

[slemete2000]

when she got to the higher notes, the lights should have changed for more effect

[skank3000]

great job !!!!

[cbotten106]

Very nice video quality on this clip but the audio has just a touch of sibilance. Carly singing doesn't get any better than that. What a fantastic voice.