Sugababes - Who sings it better

[BreyerBlackie5]

Mutya, Amelle and Jade/Sibohan!

[LintangRinastiti]

Siobhan is the best, she has the most natural voice.. Original babes are the best, Siobhan+Mutya+Keisha!!

[gazster83]

persoanlly i think the original babes were the best, howver in the comparisons i think siobhan is much better than heidi. as for the other two songs its hard to really say. i mean in ammele and mutya both have strong distinctive voices and keisha too but then you have jade who has a powerful sound in her. would be good to see both bands compete with each other. but i think the babes are on a break again as thats jade just said she is back and i think is workin on her solo stuff again.

[gslipetekci]

Keisha!... <3

[spike14786]

original, liked heidi but original all the way Mutya is the best! the new line up shouldnt b allowed to sing the songs the originals did

[FLRSKLVR]

Mutya Keisha Siobhan! Original babes only! I feel like they just got more and more commercial after each original member left.. it's a shame really cos they had such an unique sound. But rumour has it they r coming back together. Does anyone know more? Would be great

[LigerZeroPanzar]

^-^ Mutya, Keisha, Heidi and Amelle.

They're pretty awesome, it's my absolute dream that someday they could all work together and create a solid group, but given the situation, never gonna happen.

[slanis]

2nd line up is the best.

[KiddoEX]

I live the 2nd line up...

Mutya, Heidi and Keisha.

The also sound good together, at least in my opinion.

[Luvabledonna26]

i think mutya ,keisha siobhan and heidi beee 2gether

[BenJMartin95]

Heidi, Mutya and Keisha. All of their voices complimented each other.

[mindinsolitude]

Amelle is better than Mutya but all in all the original line up was better.

[naconnell1]

siobhan, amelle, jade (but on wear my kiss, keisha). it just depends song by song but siobhan is always my fave.

[TiBoy86]

Keisha, Amelle and Mutya!

[airnes94]

MUTYA KEISHA SIOBHAN ANS HEIDI

[AllThingsSoap]

It is unfair what they did to Keisha but I think Jade did sound better than Keisha but just in that song, Keisha sounds better than Jade in Get Sexy

[seanapeezy]

Keisha,Mutya and Heidi

[SaiLodge]

heidi, amelle, and jade

[TheLAURENCODY]

Mutya, Kiesha, + Heidi the're so amazing!

[MatthewMobscene]

Keisha, Mutya and Heidi

[hurtboy83]

siobhan , mutya , keisha!!!!!!!!

[jimjam572]

jade



[lara2925]

i think the best is siobhan, mutya,keisha 

[dtzms1]

I say " THEY ARE ALL THE SAME"

[ThisAintCamiIsIT]

originals all the way! including Heidi she was there basically from the start. 

[JayBadcunt89]

HEIDI AMELLE JADE

[ijay22]

i genuinely think they all have great voices in their respected ways but i fancy siobhan so i'm biased and so i think she does

[blockbluezz]

all of them o-o

[TheBrittaPerry]

I actually like Siobhan, Amelle and Heidi just with this video.

[Ferrami]

Amelle Keisha Jade

[baloghszoreny]

Keisha Heidi Amelle

[xunahealyfanx]

the originals.

[sindycurry]

Siohban > Mutya > Amelle > Keisha > Jade > Heidi

[sindycurry]

Siohban > Mutya > Amelle > Keisha > Jade > Heidi

[M3devac]

The Original lineup is best. Oh, they're reuniting, by the way. They're in the recording studio right now.

[ulzmiwa]

heidi, mutya, keisha

[Tresfres]

the original line up has more interesting voices. The new ones are too slutty and common

[johnjjst]

Keisha, Heidi, Amelle!

[Demzie98]

Siobhan,Mutya and Heidi are the best

[fonkelster]

jade keisha and muyta

[GhostGardens]

Siobhan Mutya and Amelle as Sugababes, then Jade, Heidi and Keisha in another group :P

[iatjefTV]

wow jade is hella skinnay

[geran71]

I like all of the voices (except for one) who each bought something to the sugababes sound.

The only one in my opinion who should never have been a sugababe was Amelle who brought nothing to the band's sound. She is practically talking her way thru her singing... practically as bland as porridge

[am3lya]

Mutya's voice is just so unique, it can't be compared to anyone elses. Most singers (especially in the pop category) tend to sound like each other but Mutya is just Mutya.

[MaRiaRaFaeLLa]

i like the lineup as it is now.

[olibetty]

HEIDI- Keisha and..... Mutya or Amelle

[bonkec25]

siobhan! <3

[mrjackydejong1]

heidi, mutya and keisha

[KayceeSparks]

Mutya definitely, Siobhan and Jade ... sorry, but Jade was incredible at Eurovision and she has an incredibly strong voice.

[xpeaceandpopcornx]

heidi!! :)

[StephenJarveMusic]

Siobhan, Amelle & Jade.

[andylungut]

Heidi best , Jade and Keisha tie but jade would blow her off live. Amelle better than mutty.

[eikieljefe]

MUTYA BUENA <3

[ROSSSS5]

Mutya of course!

[ceear14]

Mutya and Amelle has the same voice.

[FunFabiuz]

my favourite is mutya, but listen also to siobhan solo songs.. she's really great!! anyway the perfect formation to me could be: siobhan mutya keisha and heidi

[sweetheartangel8]

MUTYA all the way...BIG VOICE...and flexible

[JRGrange25]

The best was and still is.....the orginal Babes, Sibohan, Mutya and Keisha, no comparison.

[aleyshababe]

I totally agree with you mate.

[sweetheartangel8]

Original line up of sugababes the best....Mutya and Keisha

[JonnieDubYa86]

They all have awesome voices in their own rights and each of them suit their 'Sugababes Era'.

I've always loved the Sugababes and I have totally agreed with their choices of new members. Heidi, Amelle and Jade are worthy of the 'Sugababe' title.

Although I have to slip this in, I was shocked to find out the Mutya doesnt really want anything to do with music anymore!!! Her solo album was fantastic!! :(

[ricpoa84]

jade, amelle and heidi

^^

[cocosheno]

I Love All Them..

[shantife]

Mutya

[MischeM6]

The first one's a little unfair, 'cos Siobhan's singing it in a studio, but Heidi's doing it live, so obviously Siobhan sounds better there. Then I think Amelle's voice is better than Mutya's, and the last two is very hard, as they both have very strong voices, but I think Jade's just edges it. 

[IAdiictedd]

keisha

[billicent1219]

Mutya and Amelle... TIE.

Siobhan beats Heidi!

Keisha puts Jade on big SHAME!

[sweetheartangel8]

@billicent1219 Amelle is a copy cat of Mutya

[billicent1219]

@sweetheartangel8 I think so too. Mutya seemed better and prettier than Amelle.... GRR

[JillValentinesFE]

It's funny how everyone talks about the first line-up being so great but then no one bought their music xD. U fakers....

[ThePrideman11]

mutya ,keisha,heidi

i thort they wher the best

[XHandsoffateX]

Heidi, Amelle and Jade, Siobhan has such a pretty voice but Heidi fits the songs better then her, Mutya is really over hyped yes she was good but her voice was not as unique as people made it out to be while Amelles voice really does stand out unfortunately gets a lot of hate because she is not Mutya, Keisha had one of the best voices in the sugababes but if comparing her voice with jades to the song about a girl Jades voice fits in a lot more

[billicent1219]

@XHandsoffateX why do you ya prefer the replacements over the originals???

[XHandsoffateX]

@billicent1219 just because they are the "originals" does not mean I have to like them better and as I said below I gave my reasons~ yes I still think the originals are good especially Keisha but like I said with her, I felt Jade fitted the about a girl track better~~~

[Mileena992]

Jade? Who the fuck is she?

[shostak]

off course the sugababes 1.0 mutiya , siobhan and keisha

[simon2k4]

Siobhan IS talented,

Mutya IS talented,

Keisha IS talented.

Heidi can't sing to save her life, though she still tries anyway,

Amelle is just NOT Mutya and never will be so she really ought to stop trying to be!

Jade She's just awful!

[buzzybuzzy777]

#1_Mutya

#2_Keisha

#3_Heidi

This line up are so much Great!

mutya and keisha was sugababes

[ryan1blanchard1]

Keisha was the sugababes! Thats All!

[aquablast101]

Siobhan,Amelle and Jade

[botolarak]

Siobhan, Mutya, Keisha

[kennyxxy1]

the best  sugababes Siobhan mutya Keisha <3

[philitusam]

they all have beautiful and powerful voices! I would go for Mutya, Keisha and Heidi..

[maritta2504]

I always thought that Heidi sings the chorus of About a girl. Is that really Jade??? (I also thought that Heidi sings the "RedOn .... Sugababes" bit). Confused now.

Personally I think, that Amelle could not sing Mutyas verses well. She always struggeld with that and especially at Gotte be you, which only can be sung by Mutya (as the lyrics also named Mutya and had to be re-written for Amelle). I like Siobhans voice more, but my favourite line-up is (and ever will be) Keisha/Mutya/Heidi.

[buzzybuzzy777]

Mutya >Keisha,heidi,siobhan (Amell jade LOL)

[buzzybuzzy777]

Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya  Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya Mutya

[MyCrazyVampire]

Mutya <333

[fireybubblegummonkey]

Siobhan, Mutya, Keisha ^^

[RaDDoSt]

Mutya is best , best , best !!!

[JasmynRose7866]

I like Siobhan the best

[Punkaholicish]

In these battles, I would pick: Siobhan, Mutya and Jade. Personally I loved the Heidi/Keisha/Mutya line-up, those were the real Sugababes.

[ehisosariemen]

Mutya



[helencarterable]

heidi is way better than siobhan, amelle and mutya are about the same and keisha is way better than jade... keisha was the best sugababe they're not good at all now

[Slaychelle]

@helencarterable You need to search Siobhan Donaghy Don't Give it Up or Medevac and tell me Heidi is "way better". Siobhan's solo albums shit on everything the Babes have put out since Amelle joined.

[cotocott]

@Slaychelle i totally agree, Siobhan is so much better. i just love her 'don't give it up' song.

[IvonRocks15]

Jade, Keisha And Mutya would be the most amazing band in history!!!!!!

[smithyisalegand]

heidi, amelle and mutya

[buzzybuzzy777]

JADE !

[DeniseMakaba]

mutya



[R11097034]

Siobahn, Mutya and Amelle

[xxwtsxx]

Siobhan

Amelle/Mutya

Jade

[wozniacki15]

all six women are brilliant singers who bring different things to the table

[cdtmoran]

Jade, Heidi and Amelle. Best vocals. Best looking. Most likable. Least moody. If there wasn't a huge media backlash after Keisha got herself booted out for bullying they would be major by now. Freedom should hopefully serve them well.

[GhostGardens]

here they're all good. just get them all to be together

[blonde970218]

Keisha, Mutya, Heidi!!!

or maybe.. Keisha, Heidi, Amelle... huh.. teh Sugababes worst now :( I'm so sad!

[WARNINGxMurder101]

In my opinion, Siobhan, Mutya, and Jade. :/

[rishfordforever]

This is only for the songs in question. Siobhan sings "One Foot In" better. Mutya sings "Gotta Be You" better and I got to be honest here Jade sings "About a Girl" better although Keisha sounds good on the 2nd verse and sings it differently to Jade which I also like. What would have been really interesting is comparing Keisha and Jade's opening verse to "Get Sexy" which Keisha wins hands down cos Jade's version is an EPIC FAIL!!! :D

[nwt1234]

@rishfordforever why would that be interesting if she wins hands down surely a more evenly matched song would be more interesting as they would both be good and be a better comparison.

[rishfordforever]

@nwt1234 Just to show that All girls have their own style and Jade sounds better on some songs but Keisha sounded better on some of their other songs. Get Sexy is definetly Keisha's song. It's good to hear new stuff from the girls, Jade sounds great on Freedom. They never sound right singing other girls bits. Amelle never really sounded great until About You Now which is when she stole the show! So the more songs Jade gets to song the better it will be for her and the fans will move forward too,

[12345678910sham22]

i think:

Keisha is actually the strongest singer out of all of them n has the best control.

mutya had a unique soft yet powerful voice which is why she got alot of fans

Heidi has a soft high good for harmonies kind of voice but she cant hold solos as well as singing with the others.

Amelle has a fun bass sounding voice which could be used for rap aswell

Jade has a strong poweful voice but isnt as strong as keisha vocally

Sionhan voice is different from the others but interesting n fits well

[MARKWHITEofficial]

all this "sugafakes" comments are boring...

1. Jade is the best out of the lot of them!

2. new line up is the best! - have you heard freedom?

3. Siobhan - who the hell is she? i never heard of the sugababes until Hiedi came into the trio!

4. Amelle (when joined) took the sugababes to get their highest achieving album! - so mutya was no big loss - was she!

concusion :New sugababes: BEST! Hiedi = made them known Amelle = brought success! and Jade = gives the best voice to the trio!

[nwt1234]

@MARKWHITEofficial I agree with this being the best line up but don't be cussing siobhan she was an original and was the main singer when she was in it. listen to overload it's a song with siobhan in it you'll probably know it. :P

[MARKWHITEofficial]

@nwt1234 yeah i have heard it before - but it has nothing on other songs, its rather boring if you ask me.

she is no big loss really and it was her decision to leave... but i liked the sugababes when Hiedi came in, thats when i started listening and liking.

[ashleycallhowucit]

Keisha vocally is actually stronger and richer than Jades.... Jades voice is thinner but she has a nice vibrato... both have belting power and the abillity to do runs and acrobats.. If you hear the live version of about a girl you will notice that Kiesha caries the chorus by herself.... While Jade has to have her support in the chorus from Amelle and Heidi

[fififane85]

The part of Jade, is not her but Heidi who singing this part !!

[fififane85]

Heidi, my favorite <3 <3

[IvonRocks15]

to be fair they can all sing but i think everyone agrees that Keisha Mutya and Siobhan are the best or at least Keisha, Mutya and Heidi!!

[DanielDOA4]

it just doesn't feel like SUGABABES anymore. too sexual in image.

[DanielDOA4]

Did Mutya & Keisha choose Heidi to be in the group? ooh BAD choice. 1 thing that comes out of this: Keisha releasing SOLO material. It'd be good to hear some KEisha and Mutya duo stuff too.

[ItsRudyInnit]

Bad example of Heidi's singing ability IMO. Interesting video nonetheless. Heidi, Keisha and Mutya are still the best line-up and I think most Sugababes fans will agree.

[vf2005]

Heidi sounds out of tune

[andria0705]

@vf2005

how Heidi actually has a career as a recording artist still baffles my mind. She has an incredibly weak voice, boring sound, & no sense of pitch.

[vf2005]

@andria0705 - I probably would agree with you if she always sounds like that, as proven in your video, but as I have not proof, it would be wrong of me to comment. I say bring back the ORIGINAL SUGABABES. The present lot pale into insignificance IMHO.

[relmnz]

I LOVE ALL OF THEM !

[joshandelliot1234567]

1 heidi

2 amele

3 jade

[chloboshoka]

I love them all. It would be epic if all six of them did an album or a tour together.

[28Zeppelin]

@chloboshoka Hell yeah!!! It's really interesting to hear each voice compared like this but It would be fantastic to hear a line up of all six babes. ( god knows how they'd distribute the verses though)

[MICHAELHOLLYWOOD]

While the new girls are fantastic singers, hopefully with the 8th album they're known as not just sexy girls who can sing but FEMALE EMPOWERMENT vibes to their media persona just like how Mutuya & Keisha have done putting their mark in the cement where 20 yrs from now when you see a sugababe clip you'll see Mutuya Keisha's distinct faces

[MICHAELHOLLYWOOD]

Mutuya, KEisha's & Siobhan's personalities and sass are so well known through their fans you can't ever compare them to others singing better than them because like with most girl groups their personalities & sass is more popular than the actual talent itself.

[Jaackyxstaar]

Keisha is best :)

[j1701why1]

MUTYA KEISHA AND ANYONE ELSE WHO CAN HOLD A NOTE.

THEIR HARMONIES WERE THE BEST.

SO DISAPPOINTED WHEN MUTYA LEFT AND HAD TICKETS FOR THE NIA.

[dwswh2]

i think my favourite lineup was mutya keisha and heidi, although i loved the 1st album with siobhan, the 2nd lineup made the group a success with lots of great songs and i think after mutya left it started going down hill, they still do ok songs but nothing like they did years ago and i agree that although heidis there (albeit not an original sugababe but now the longest serving of the group) the sugababes aren't the sugababes anymore :(

[bunniesfrightenme]

SIOBHAN + MUTYA + KEISHA

[atributetomusic]

why not get all together?

[hangshimkim]

I really like Keisha, I have always liked her writing style, she's very creative and involved int he writing processes. However, on the "Sweet 7" promo where her vocals are present, she is so auto tuned, as where Jade is auto tuned, but it's merely more for sound effects. Jade can sing circles around Keisha if you want to compare it to that.

[cocosheno]

i love all the sugababes girl...

[Kelmurf313]

heidi for the first one

amelle the second

keisha third :)

[Mystikal94]

Heidi+Mutya+Keisha!!!!



[2ejs9]

Jade is soo much better than Keisha. Mutya and Amelle are hardly that different at all. Heidi kicks Siobhan to the curb. Siobhan's voice is too baby-girl like.

[mckenzieman123]

the line up now is the best line up they look good together and Heidi and amelle seem happier now they also defo have the right to be called the sugababes because

1. Heidi has done 7 of the 8 albums

2. the best selling album was when amelle join the group

[xpeaceandpopcornx]

heidi!!!

[irx62]

siobhan over heidi

amelle and mutya pretty even

jade over keisha

but seriously, no original cast in the new sugababes? just change the band name then.

[DeeMinion]

The current line up is my favourite

[stevencbaker]

Jade is actually the best singer

[cruzkris22]

"SIOBHAN+MUTYA+KEISHA=SUCCESS" - i'll second that motion, nothing bits the original

"HEIDI+MUTYA+KEISHA=PRETTY OK" - like ugly

[stephs06]

Mutya, Keisha and Heidi are my fave line up :) they are the most well known I think.

[RowdyStomp]

Siobhan+Mutya+Keisha= I didn't liked this Line-Up.

Mutya+Keisha+Heidi= The second Line-Up but I'm glad Mutya has left the band.

Keisha+Heidi+Amelle= For me the Sugababes, this was the best Line-Up ever.

Heidi+Amelle+Jade= Not the Sugababes anymore but I will give them three a chance.

[Sugaspain]

Mutya, keisha & Heidi 4ever ^^

[Sugaspain]

en about a girl canta heidi?????

[giggles628000000]

whats everyone so mad at jade when she joined for. i know shes not one of the originals but she sounds awesome

[hgjkllsssss21233]

Watch the video for Katy Brand v.s. the sugababes. You see all the new ones talking and they're all very nice people.

[amazingchange]

Siobhan + Mutya + Keisha = super the best

Mutya + Keisha + Heidi = good enough

Keisha + Heidi + Amelle = mwah it's so so

Heidi + Amelle + Jade = indeed nothing left of the sugababes what a shame

[nicksmith128]

Umm this is difficult. I like them all with the exception of Jade to be honest! (Although she did do a good cover of Rabbit Heart) Heidi ROCKS!

[ThallieJJ]

Mutya <3

[Horsepower15]

When Siobhan, Mutya and Keisha performed together, it was real fantastic, and it wasn't so bad when Heidi stepped in, I really love the Liverpool voice in the songs, Amelle gave the songs a what do we call it? Yes a real weird and new sound.. Jade... well, it broke the real sugababes....

[wipcreamistasty]

keisha!

[hooy1234567890]

Jade <3333.

[camog]

personally i thought Mutya, Keisha and Heidi had a better and more successful combo. Although Siobhan was good aswell. Once amelle came in i just didnt get the group anymore.

[WhoIsJohnPaul]

Siobhan + Mutya + Keisha = Dull Lets Face It Album 1 Was Shit

Heidi + Mutya + Keisha = Fab

Heidi + Amelle + Keisha = Good

Hedi + Amelle + Jade = Beast

who cares if keisha left heidi is more of a sugababe than siobhan

[mangox5]

what I think

SIOBHAN+MUTYA+KEISHA=GREAT

HEIDI+MUTYA+KEISHA=PERFECT

HEIDI+AMELLE+KEISHA=WORKS

HEIDI+AMELLE+JADE= NO SUGABABES!

[frencatko]

SIOBHAN+MUTYA+KEISHA=GREAT

HEIDI+MUTYA+KEISHA=FINE

HEIDI+AMELLE+KEISHA=PERFECT

HEIDI+AMELLE+JADE= NO SUGABABES!

[chriskid04]

favorite sugababes are siobhan and amelle. love them

[xMilennx]

The end of this video is very well done! My favourite Sugababe is definitely Mutya, but I'm also a big fan of Siobhán Donaghy's solo songs. According to me, she's way better in her own style. And the new babes? I actually don't feel much for them..

[donshan123]

Siobhan, Mutya, Keisha and Heidi = THE NEW OLD SUGABABES

Jade = SOLO CARRER

Amelle = DRUGS, CRACK, COCAINE, AND EVERYTHING WRONG...I REALLY DISLIKE THIS GIRL. I REALLY FEEL LIKE IT'S HER FAULT THE SUGAGBES SUCk. EVER SINCE SHE JOINED THE GROUP, THEY HAVE WENT DOWNHILL WITH MUSIC AND POPULARITY.

[pinkypie33]

mutya n amelle dnt sound that much different - heidi kills the first song n keish n jade r both good at about a girl :)

[xMilennx]

@pinkypie33 No, Amelle doesn't sound even a bit like Mutya. That's the same as saying there's no difference between Keisha and Jade. Listen to other songs, then you will notice! I prefer Mutya's style, but I can't say which voice sounds better, 'cause they're really too different to compare ;)

[pinkypie33]

@xMilennx i didnt say they sound the same, i said they sounded simular cos of the style they were singing in.