See the thing about sampling is it means actually using part of an existing recording.. while I hear similarities here with one or two LCD songs, none of the elements are actually _the same_ as on an LCD song. Thus, no sampling. That seems to be the beauty of LCD though.. he freely takes ideas he likes, changes them up a bit and (here's the key bit) brings them together in a way that could only be described as genius.
@midkay a sample is still a sample even if you don't use the audio recording of the original. if you do use the audio recording, it's called a Master Use Sample, but if you don't, it's called an Interpolation (different type of sample), and it means you have to get permission from the original artist (not to mention pay him half of your publishing royalties). what evskin said about another version being taken down makes it seem like dude just bought the original, which is another possibility
@lolocaustz@midkay@Evskin In fact, sampling refers strictly to the use of a portion of a previous audio recording. It's very clear on listening that, for "Dance Yrself Clean", LCD's James Murphy didn't just load snippets of this song in his auto-sampler and record away. The jungle-y beat and fuzzy synth bassline are easily recreated by someone with Murphy's electronic production chops. The intro to "Dance..." is an interpolation, a cover of sorts, NOT a sample.
Guys this really isn't that similar. lots of songs have in them full note 3rds. Plus the LCD soundsystem song develops into something far more fun and intricate than this.
@refo09 Im not suggesting these songs are the same. I would agree that LCDs version is constructed better and provides for a more enjoyable listen. The question, however, was "did LCD sample this". The answer, without a shadow of a doubt, is yes. If you think tho two songs just happened to sound this similar without someone from LCD soundsystem sampling this then thats ridiculous.
@Evskin Also, when Dance Yrself Clean was released. Some versions of this song were taken offline for copyright reasons which I found interesting. Perhaps LCD tried to destroy the original :p
I like this Original version much, much better. ; )
ITSFULLOFSTARS1 22 hours ago
:):):):)
Datkylekid 8 months ago
See the thing about sampling is it means actually using part of an existing recording.. while I hear similarities here with one or two LCD songs, none of the elements are actually _the same_ as on an LCD song. Thus, no sampling. That seems to be the beauty of LCD though.. he freely takes ideas he likes, changes them up a bit and (here's the key bit) brings them together in a way that could only be described as genius.
midkay 1 year ago 2
@midkay a sample is still a sample even if you don't use the audio recording of the original. if you do use the audio recording, it's called a Master Use Sample, but if you don't, it's called an Interpolation (different type of sample), and it means you have to get permission from the original artist (not to mention pay him half of your publishing royalties). what evskin said about another version being taken down makes it seem like dude just bought the original, which is another possibility
lolocaustz 1 year ago
@lolocaustz @midkay @Evskin In fact, sampling refers strictly to the use of a portion of a previous audio recording. It's very clear on listening that, for "Dance Yrself Clean", LCD's James Murphy didn't just load snippets of this song in his auto-sampler and record away. The jungle-y beat and fuzzy synth bassline are easily recreated by someone with Murphy's electronic production chops. The intro to "Dance..." is an interpolation, a cover of sorts, NOT a sample.
HenrockCav47 9 months ago
Guys this really isn't that similar. lots of songs have in them full note 3rds. Plus the LCD soundsystem song develops into something far more fun and intricate than this.
refo09 1 year ago
@refo09 Im not suggesting these songs are the same. I would agree that LCDs version is constructed better and provides for a more enjoyable listen. The question, however, was "did LCD sample this". The answer, without a shadow of a doubt, is yes. If you think tho two songs just happened to sound this similar without someone from LCD soundsystem sampling this then thats ridiculous.
Evskin 1 year ago
@Orangeflava,yes indeed
djlobose 1 year ago
Did LCD Soundsystem sample this tune?
Orangeflava 1 year ago
@Orangeflava I think they would prefer people not to know. But what do you think...
Evskin 1 year ago
@Evskin Also, when Dance Yrself Clean was released. Some versions of this song were taken offline for copyright reasons which I found interesting. Perhaps LCD tried to destroy the original :p
Evskin 1 year ago
Ace tune!
MoutinhoNuno 1 year ago