The thing to remember about this scene (and the whole thing with Isildur keeping the ring) has been watered down for the movie. If you really want to know what happened and why Isildur kept the ring check out Unfinished Tales of Numenor and Middle-Earth. The first chapter of the section about the 3rd Age is the tale of how Isildur came to lose the ring (and it is far more tragic than is shown in the movie).
The thing to remember about this scene (and the whole thing with Isildur keeping the ring) has been watered down for the movie. If you really want to know what happened and why Isildur kept the ring check out Unfinished Tales of Numenor and Middle-Earth. The first chapter of the section about the 3rd Age is the tale of how Isildur came to lose the ring (and it is far more tragic than is shown in the movie).
i remember when my uncle bought the video very long ago and that part was in the video but now that we have lost the video we bought it in DVD and the part wasn't there. That is wierd.
@flaminhotz5 because the ring has a mind of its own, its true owner will always be Sauron alone, it will always escape if it has the chance to reutrn to sauron
1. Only Isildur realised his idea to attack Sauron with freakin sword. Isildur survived.
2. Only Isildur realised his idea not to throw that ring into Mt. Doom. Isildur survived.
3. Only Isildur realised his idea to ride with cavarly through thick forest,without sending vanguard or scouts before him. Isildur dead,pwned,you got it freak !
Nah, Arwen wasn't born till 241 of the third age, while Sauron's first downfall was the end of the second age. And Elrond is more like Isildur's great great great (etc) uncle.
@dragon2712 - Actually Elrond is only very distantly related to Isildur. Remember that there is almost 3000 years between the time Elrond's brother Elros becomes king of Numenor and the birth of Isildur.
The ring dont give the power to turn invisible but improves the abilities of the user. Hobbits get invisible cause they are like rogues. This scene is wrong, like many otheres in the movie. And i liked it.
@dorinxxx - Remember that the ring contains part of Sauron's essence (or spirit) and so when a lesser being wears it, it try's to make them like Sauron, causing their physical form to fade so much that they appear to turn invisible. It affects anyone who wears it that way (except for other spiritual beings like Gandalf, it would just corrupt him).
@0IIIIII actually thats not the real matter, what matters here is how the fuck he gets ambushed while bearing the most precious thing in the world on his neck.
@scamslat explains it more in the books, and other texts about middle earth. it extends life, makes invisible, grants control over other ring bearers, grants the abilities of the other rings of power, allows you to somewhat control other people, allows you to somewhat communicate telepathically, foresee the future, makes other people have visions where u appear more menacing/powerful. i think thats pretty much it, but there might b more
it also is only controllable by strong willed ppl(sauron)
@WhippedJay Warcraft 3, Reign of Terror came out 2002 and The Fellowship of the Ring came out just a few months before that game. However, that effect was added after movie was finished so they might have asked blizzard to use it, since Warcraft 3 was also under making when the first LotR was beeing made. It's a hard question though!
I'm curios of the ones debating, how many actually read the novels. I know I tried once but Tolien's righting was, I know this is heresy from a LotR fan, dreadfully boring.
I mean, when things were actually happening it was great, but some parts confused the hell out of me because how in depth they are. I dont think there was a rock in Middle Earth that went without a detailed description. (Exaggeration of course, but my point is there.)
i think that sauron's arrogance is what "killed" him when he dueled against isildur, having the prince at his mercy, he could have smashed him to death right where he lay. enstead, i guess he whanted to see the fear in the princes' eyes before killing him, a major miscalculation if you ask me XD. i would like to hear other's point :D
Read book and you will see that film is bullshit. He died not because of ring but because of his "diamond" on his head ( i dont remember cuz i read this book one year ago). They saw this shiny object and they were scared so they fired few arrow and it killied isildur. 2 arrows, one into heart and one into throat. Thats it.
@Xarras94 No actually if you read about the disaster at the gladden fields in the unfinished tales it says that he left Elendilmir on the east shore. That's also why Saruman found it almost 2500 years later.
Isildur is in some aspects not to blame. he had only good intentions when he went to war, and when he sliced saurons hand he ended that battle pretty quick. But he was seduced by its power, like every other man would of. Even gandalf admited he was tempted. so really it is not isildurs fault. its the rings corruption.
@MrGamedude21 Aragorn is tempted. Like all men he craves power but he controls it and when he does come into contact with it has the will power to hand it back.
@MrGamedude21 That scene where he hands it back to Frodo is one of the events that shows him he's ready to return to Gondor. That he is worthy of being their king and guiding men back into glory restoring their honor.
@legomanic342 Elrond could sense Saurons connection to the ring and that the ring only had one master. He could sense it's selfish nature and knew it had to be destroyed for it itself can only destroy. It can only be controlled by one man. I think it would have been great if Sauron got the ring back and was able to restore his body. A showdown with Aragorn would have been beyond badass. The ring gets cut off again and then Frodo takes it to Mordor and utterly annihilates in the lava of Mt Doom.
@legomanic342 Isildur looked at it like all men did as a weapon. He did not see it's spiritual connection to it's master and its corrupting nature. His pride did him in. He thought he could control that which is uncontrollable.
@spinsky1994 yeah but perhaps he wasnt sure that sauron could be a real threat later again because of this ring, also that action would have started a war between elfs and men....
@lavoie84qc Sauron couldn't be a real threat later? Elrond knew that Sauron would return that's why he was screaming "Destroy it!". Sauron didn't even need the ring to kill people or command armies.
And how can there be a war, if no one saw him get pushed? Rocks inside the largest volcano can be quite unsafe...muwhahahaha
@spinsky1994 Yes the leader of Elves killing the leader of Men on a battlefield would work really nice. He would just explain that their king was too greedy!
@spinsky1994 and everyone else who wants to push isildur into the volcano, try not to forget that Isildur was Elrond's BFF. Elrond, Isildur, and Anarion (who isn't shown but is Isildur's brother) were like the 3 musketeers or something during the war because of the alliance of Elves and Men. I couldn't've done it to my best friend, even if I did know what would happen I think I'd just hope I could somehow change their mind. Which is what Elrond did, and continued to try until Isildur's death.
@spinsky1994 But then Elrond will have to wage war with the Men and then there would be no Legolas or Arwen because their fathers are to busy killing men, or getting killed.
@the3rdjoker Wait, I thought Legolas was like 2,000 years old, or a few hundred years old. Well anyway, if they were alive in this time then they'd still get crap for killing one of the Kings of Men.
I think they should have left it in. The scene flowed better and made more sense without the cut. And it explains how smeagle found the ring in the pond.
Honestly, Isildur had like a company of Numenorian Knights with him. I seriously doubt that a ragtag raiding party of orcs would manage to take them out.
Kekkiki, he cant just kill him and kick him in the fires of mount doom, as then he would most probably be executed, by the gondorions, which would permanentley destroy the allience, and the council of elrond, and the forming of the fellowship would never of happned.
Besides Tolkien would not be succesful like he is.... so theres y :)
@bwashinski bullshit. the short version showed him with arches in his back 0:42. With the narration "it betrayed Isildur" and "Gollum found it" covers the rest.
@bwashinski It would have been a mistake to keep this scene in the final version. For those who knew nothing about LOTR, it suggested the One Ring's sole power was merely making the bearer invisible for a time. They most likely just wanted to leave this a suprise for when Bilbo uses it at his party.
@Badboyben1422 It makes a lot more sense in the book, Isildur's victory over Sauron was one of opportunism (Stabbing him in the back when Sauron stumbles on a rock.).
Yes, but when saying "even Frodo", I think you are overrating them both. Frodo was brave, but screwed up with the Ring, Isildur was kind of a hero, but he also was supposed to be - he was a man of the West, from the King´s lineage. He also screwed up with the Ring. They made the same mistake, but Isildur had way greater potential to avoid making it.
@Riwillion Hey, let's see it this way: If it wasn't for him, the evil would be destroyed at the beginning of the first movie. And, without evil, can there be good?
@InfernumThe Yes, what I ment was, that if Isildur had thrown the ring into Mount Doom, the forces of evil would most certainly be destroyed, either from being hunted down, or starvation. That would mean that the movies would have ended at the start of the first movie.
@mathias510 I get your point. BUT IF Isildur destroyed the Ring then there weren't movies and nobody would think about Lord of the Rings movies, cos there isn't them. And you shouldn't think by the movies, think about the books. Every books of Tolkien.
@InfernumThe All I'm saying is that we can thank Isildur for doing what he did, if he didn't do that, there wouldn't be any movies, which would mean that LotR wouldn't be known by so many today.
@InfernumThe No, I don't think you get it. If you look at my first comment, I was talking about the movies all along. And, as you first replied: "There was evil long time ago before Isildur defeated Sauron..." I don't quite see what that has to do with anything...?
in the silmarillion it is written (lol) that Morgoth Bauglir went among the Elves around the same time that Orome visited them. at this time many elves disappeared. the elves themselves believed that the race of orcs was created by Morgoth by corrupting elves through torture. in the Third Age Saruman was believed to have created a hybrid race by mixing men and orcs. these Uruks were not fearful of sunlight and thus differed markedly from the typical orc.
This makes much more sense with the "Ring betraying him" than the version that was in the movie. In that it makes it seem that ring called those orcs to attack Isildur.
@h5y you do know that the Lord of the Rings was created in i think in the 1970's... right? and this "isildur1" probably copied Isildur in this movie and/or the book
@h5y you do know that the Lord of the Rings was created in i think in the 1970's... right? and this "isildur1" probably copied Isildur in this movie and/or the book
Damn guys... Orc is just a name given to all of their kin by the other races,example "Yrch" is used by the elves,in the Common speach its what we know as Orcs. Goblins are goblins,yes...but in all fairness they are also called orcs (allincluded foul bloody beasts)...hehehehehehehehehe.
@chesney121 that says in the book,that isildur was traveling with his army and 2 or 3 sons and he saw them dying and tried to escape but died in the river while he was crossing it.
@chesney121 Whatcha have to remember is that the ring wanted him dead, it called the orcs, it posessed him to get into a position where he was most weak, and left him to die.
@chesney121 he didn't kill sauron because he was such a great warrior, but because he reached his hand out and he took a sword and cut off his fingers
@chesney121 Thats kind of the point, he had a grand destiny, he did a great thing, but when he gave that up in exchange for the ring of power, he eventually died being shot down like an animal. Its to illustrate what the ring did to him. It ruined him in every way, just as it does everyone it touches.
Ring - "I dont need you no more!"
Isildur - "aw, you bitch"
JDaveD 1 month ago 2
Because a man laden in mail armor would float that easily.
DeadXManXsXStare 1 month ago in playlist LOTR Deleted Scenes
This has been flagged as spam show
The thing to remember about this scene (and the whole thing with Isildur keeping the ring) has been watered down for the movie. If you really want to know what happened and why Isildur kept the ring check out Unfinished Tales of Numenor and Middle-Earth. The first chapter of the section about the 3rd Age is the tale of how Isildur came to lose the ring (and it is far more tragic than is shown in the movie).
DevJannz 1 month ago
The thing to remember about this scene (and the whole thing with Isildur keeping the ring) has been watered down for the movie. If you really want to know what happened and why Isildur kept the ring check out Unfinished Tales of Numenor and Middle-Earth. The first chapter of the section about the 3rd Age is the tale of how Isildur came to lose the ring (and it is far more tragic than is shown in the movie).
DevJannz 1 month ago
it didnt betray him ... he just lot the fucking ring
inhuemanis 1 month ago
@inhuemanis seriously, go watch the fucking movie, the ring does have a will, and can controls someones fate.
TheSouleater66 1 month ago
THE STUP CUNT DESERF IT DICK I SWER IF I EVA GOT MY HAND ON HIM I WUD KICK DA SHIT OUTTA HIM
KiNeTiiCz 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Shows how much Peter Jackson was paying attention to Isilidur's character in making this movie - fuck all! Some facts about Isildur:
1.) He was the one who rescued the White Tree in Numenor and was injured in so doing
2.) He reorganised Gondor
3.) He was travelling to Imladris (Rivendell) to meet Elrond and his wife and son when this ambush took place
4.) Isilidur fought bravely against the attacking orcs until his son begged him to flee
5.) He took his armour off first, NOT being a dumbass
edinscot56789 1 month ago
Comment removed
edinscot56789 1 month ago
i remember when my uncle bought the video very long ago and that part was in the video but now that we have lost the video we bought it in DVD and the part wasn't there. That is wierd.
mniyad 2 months ago 3
Why did it leave him?
flaminhotz5 3 months ago
@flaminhotz5 because the ring has a mind of its own, its true owner will always be Sauron alone, it will always escape if it has the chance to reutrn to sauron
dcfefs 2 months ago
Fuck that shit, motherfuker asshole
WickedTheInsane 3 months ago
The guy is comin' home from defeating Sauron... So what fails him? A band of orcs.
CathannahShowani 3 months ago 2
What is a 'treachy'?
jezmuff 4 months ago 3
1. Only Isildur realised his idea to attack Sauron with freakin sword. Isildur survived.
2. Only Isildur realised his idea not to throw that ring into Mt. Doom. Isildur survived.
3. Only Isildur realised his idea to ride with cavarly through thick forest,without sending vanguard or scouts before him. Isildur dead,pwned,you got it freak !
Citzen92 4 months ago
Nah, Arwen wasn't born till 241 of the third age, while Sauron's first downfall was the end of the second age. And Elrond is more like Isildur's great great great (etc) uncle.
dragon2712 5 months ago
@dragon2712 - Actually Elrond is only very distantly related to Isildur. Remember that there is almost 3000 years between the time Elrond's brother Elros becomes king of Numenor and the birth of Isildur.
DevJannz 1 month ago
@DevJannz Yes, well, if I had room to write 'great' about 63 more times in front of uncle, I would have :)
dragon2712 1 month ago
The ring dont give the power to turn invisible but improves the abilities of the user. Hobbits get invisible cause they are like rogues. This scene is wrong, like many otheres in the movie. And i liked it.
dorinxxx 6 months ago
@dorinxxx - Remember that the ring contains part of Sauron's essence (or spirit) and so when a lesser being wears it, it try's to make them like Sauron, causing their physical form to fade so much that they appear to turn invisible. It affects anyone who wears it that way (except for other spiritual beings like Gandalf, it would just corrupt him).
DevJannz 1 month ago
how could he float when in full armor?
0IIIIII 6 months ago
@0IIIIII thin metal doesn't work like that
childsnight 4 months ago
@childsnight maybe
0IIIIII 4 months ago
@0IIIIII I'm a welder, if thin metal sheet falls into water it'll float. People also float so a person in armor floats
childsnight 4 months ago
@childsnight but why would a warrior be wearing thin armor?
0IIIIII 4 months ago
@0IIIIII actually thats not the real matter, what matters here is how the fuck he gets ambushed while bearing the most precious thing in the world on his neck.
RicardoBatistaPassos 4 months ago
@0IIIIII If he was wearing thick steel plate for armor he wouldn't be able to move. <_<
childsnight 4 months ago
@childsnight it was only a question
0IIIIII 4 months ago
@0IIIIII It was only a answer ?_?
childsnight 4 months ago
@childsnight I was suggesting that your emoticons were a little rude
0IIIIII 4 months ago
@0IIIIII <_<
childsnight 4 months ago
Im glad they kept this scene short :)
MrRubixBunny 6 months ago
What on earth does the dang ring do anyway?
Why is it sooo important?
scamslat 6 months ago
@scamslat explains it more in the books, and other texts about middle earth. it extends life, makes invisible, grants control over other ring bearers, grants the abilities of the other rings of power, allows you to somewhat control other people, allows you to somewhat communicate telepathically, foresee the future, makes other people have visions where u appear more menacing/powerful. i think thats pretty much it, but there might b more
it also is only controllable by strong willed ppl(sauron)
TheMarokii 6 months ago
thats why some people dont like weddings near water
Citzen92 6 months ago
0:22
The peasants on warcraft 3 make the same sound when they die xD
Anubis2445 7 months ago 70
@Anubis2445 yes it is true.unfortunately,movie/game producers are stealing ideas,sounds,etc from each other all the time. :)
Citzen92 6 months ago
@Anubis2445 Holy shit thats so true, who copied who?
WhippedJay 4 months ago
@WhippedJay Warcraft 3, Reign of Terror came out 2002 and The Fellowship of the Ring came out just a few months before that game. However, that effect was added after movie was finished so they might have asked blizzard to use it, since Warcraft 3 was also under making when the first LotR was beeing made. It's a hard question though!
Emz092 3 months ago
@Anubis2445 LOL
TheManofConviction 1 month ago
@Anubis2445 And if you replay it over and over it sounds like the Culling of Stratholme.
Zirabath 3 weeks ago
@Anubis2445 u do relize thats one of the most well known screams in the history of movies and games and theres a lot morw
IsmailAli123 2 weeks ago
this was shown in the ps 2 game
theturokknife 7 months ago
I'm curios of the ones debating, how many actually read the novels. I know I tried once but Tolien's righting was, I know this is heresy from a LotR fan, dreadfully boring.
I mean, when things were actually happening it was great, but some parts confused the hell out of me because how in depth they are. I dont think there was a rock in Middle Earth that went without a detailed description. (Exaggeration of course, but my point is there.)
socomfan555 7 months ago
@socomfan555 People tended to write like that in the early 20th century :)
Try getting an audiobook of the trilogy. That way, you can put it on an mp3 player and listen to it while doing other things.
unifieddynasty 7 months ago
from what I remember in the 2nd age the orcs didnt go no where near the shire.
ezioiswaybetter1 7 months ago
what the fuck....they have cut serious scenes from the ltr
takisanger1 7 months ago
yeah but the part where he puts on the ring looks so fake i don't blame jackson for cutting it.
duskburn 7 months ago
This is why when I go swimming and I have my wedding ring on I close my fist so I don't lose it dumbass.
MrAwesome898 8 months ago 112
@MrAwesome898 Well. Wedding ring is never gonna BETRAY you =)
KlaymenDel 7 months ago
@MrAwesome898 otherwise swimming guards will shoot you in your back ?
Citzen92 6 months ago
@MrAwesome898 the ring betrayed him you fag it chose to slide off his finger
chrisman223 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MrAwesome898 the ring betrayed him you fag it chose to slide off his finger
chrisman223 6 months ago
@MrAwesome898 you swim with closed fists?
rufia75 1 month ago
@MrAwesome898 you know the ring can change size and weight? if the ringe didnt want to stick to him he wouldnt be able to kepp him, even with fist
HunterWoelfchen 3 weeks ago
what can the ring do, does it have little arms and legs???
zilbiol 9 months ago
Ah... common, he faced Sauron and then got scared by bloody orcs?
jayarjo 9 months ago
Eldrond: "Men are weak."
Like letting Isildur leave Mount Doom wasn't a weak move...
CoolGuy62093 9 months ago 3
@CoolGuy62093 elrond said men are weak isildur is a man and he destroyed sauron that wasn't weak
BlackSpittingCobra 8 months ago
@CoolGuy62093 its not like he could throw the King into the pits of mount doom and come out and say "oops he slipped."
war between men and elves would happen.
so not good :P
SumJ23 2 months ago
i think that sauron's arrogance is what "killed" him when he dueled against isildur, having the prince at his mercy, he could have smashed him to death right where he lay. enstead, i guess he whanted to see the fear in the princes' eyes before killing him, a major miscalculation if you ask me XD. i would like to hear other's point :D
Amadeo790 9 months ago
Read book and you will see that film is bullshit. He died not because of ring but because of his "diamond" on his head ( i dont remember cuz i read this book one year ago). They saw this shiny object and they were scared so they fired few arrow and it killied isildur. 2 arrows, one into heart and one into throat. Thats it.
Xarras94 10 months ago
@Xarras94 No actually if you read about the disaster at the gladden fields in the unfinished tales it says that he left Elendilmir on the east shore. That's also why Saruman found it almost 2500 years later.
LimesNorrlandicus 9 months ago
Isildur is in some aspects not to blame. he had only good intentions when he went to war, and when he sliced saurons hand he ended that battle pretty quick. But he was seduced by its power, like every other man would of. Even gandalf admited he was tempted. so really it is not isildurs fault. its the rings corruption.
legomanic342 11 months ago
@legomanic342 aragon doesn't be tempted by it, shown in the movie and books i think
MrGamedude21 10 months ago
@MrGamedude21 Aragorn is tempted. Like all men he craves power but he controls it and when he does come into contact with it has the will power to hand it back.
Luigi84289 10 months ago
@MrGamedude21 That scene where he hands it back to Frodo is one of the events that shows him he's ready to return to Gondor. That he is worthy of being their king and guiding men back into glory restoring their honor.
Luigi84289 10 months ago
@legomanic342 Elrond could sense Saurons connection to the ring and that the ring only had one master. He could sense it's selfish nature and knew it had to be destroyed for it itself can only destroy. It can only be controlled by one man. I think it would have been great if Sauron got the ring back and was able to restore his body. A showdown with Aragorn would have been beyond badass. The ring gets cut off again and then Frodo takes it to Mordor and utterly annihilates in the lava of Mt Doom.
Luigi84289 10 months ago
@legomanic342 Isildur looked at it like all men did as a weapon. He did not see it's spiritual connection to it's master and its corrupting nature. His pride did him in. He thought he could control that which is uncontrollable.
Luigi84289 10 months ago
You know what, if I was Elrond, i would have pushed that fucker with the ring into the fire of morder and strolled out saving millions of lives.
spinsky1994 11 months ago 224
@spinsky1994 I agree totaly.
2unknown21 10 months ago
@spinsky1994 Being an elf it wasn't in his character. All he had to say was Isildur fell in.
Luigi84289 10 months ago
@spinsky1994 yeah but perhaps he wasnt sure that sauron could be a real threat later again because of this ring, also that action would have started a war between elfs and men....
lavoie84qc 9 months ago
@lavoie84qc Sauron couldn't be a real threat later? Elrond knew that Sauron would return that's why he was screaming "Destroy it!". Sauron didn't even need the ring to kill people or command armies.
And how can there be a war, if no one saw him get pushed? Rocks inside the largest volcano can be quite unsafe...muwhahahaha
spinsky1994 9 months ago
@spinsky1994 i thought i was the only one who thought that...i always used to say why not just push him in
Invinciblez18 9 months ago
@spinsky1994 yes but by doing that you would ruin the movie and we would have never ever watched the most epic movie ever!!!!
KingOfSparta123456 9 months ago
@spinsky1994 Yes the leader of Elves killing the leader of Men on a battlefield would work really nice. He would just explain that their king was too greedy!
FlawlessFlaw07 8 months ago in playlist LOTR
@spinsky1994 including boromir...he was badass didnt deserve to die
xxBoRoMeRxx 8 months ago
@spinsky1994 and he would be like, destroy the ring, or die with it, mr anderson,
Isuldur: wut?
AzariahKyras 8 months ago 9
@spinsky1994 and everyone else who wants to push isildur into the volcano, try not to forget that Isildur was Elrond's BFF. Elrond, Isildur, and Anarion (who isn't shown but is Isildur's brother) were like the 3 musketeers or something during the war because of the alliance of Elves and Men. I couldn't've done it to my best friend, even if I did know what would happen I think I'd just hope I could somehow change their mind. Which is what Elrond did, and continued to try until Isildur's death.
duskburn 7 months ago
@spinsky1994 But then you wouldn't have any of these events happening.
XXGDUBSXX 7 months ago
@spinsky1994 call it an accident the motherfucker slipped
yellotheemcee 7 months ago
@spinsky1994 i always said the same thing!
derekgornall 7 months ago
@spinsky1994 But Aragorn Wuld not be here D:!
ItIsmell69 6 months ago
@spinsky1994 damm right
gamegod273 6 months ago
Comment removed
zilbiol 6 months ago
Comment removed
zilbiol 6 months ago
@spinsky1994 Then there would be no Lord of the Rings :(
TheTurkeySlasher 6 months ago
@spinsky1994 But then Elrond will have to wage war with the Men and then there would be no Legolas or Arwen because their fathers are to busy killing men, or getting killed.
hazza3 5 months ago
@hazza3 legolas and arwen were alive at the age of iseldur, probally Arwen and him played games together she is his cousin you know
the3rdjoker 5 months ago
@the3rdjoker Wait, I thought Legolas was like 2,000 years old, or a few hundred years old. Well anyway, if they were alive in this time then they'd still get crap for killing one of the Kings of Men.
hazza3 5 months ago
@spinsky1994 you would push your relitive (nephew If I remember correct) into a volacano?
the3rdjoker 5 months ago
@the3rdjoker I would, but my nephews a cunt!
87mclean 5 months ago
@spinsky1994 Then there would be no such thing as "The Fellowship of the Ring, The Two Towers or The Return of the King" :')
TheTurkeySlasher 4 months ago
I think they should have left it in. The scene flowed better and made more sense without the cut. And it explains how smeagle found the ring in the pond.
flyinfingers07 11 months ago
Who swims with full pate armor on?
MilchSir 11 months ago
what would Isildur thought in 0:34 ?''WTF that damned slippy ring XD !!!
DaCoolCrushIceKillah 11 months ago
the creators from warcraft 3 took the sound you hear in 23 seconds
welibab 1 year ago
Is it possible to drive on the water in an armor?! 0:42
Alphareflex1 1 year ago
0:22 warcraft
aydooknow 1 year ago
I always thought Uruk hai were Half Orc Half Goblin
auzzioiboy 1 year ago
that sucks Numenor got wiped out they were my favorite race.
soukupb 1 year ago
that one archer had a badass helmet
ReverendDiabetes 1 year ago 2
That archer orcs racked up lots of exp :)
d4rthmorgoth 1 year ago 2
0:22 isn't that the sound of people getting killed in warcraft 3 :P
VintageTwisby 1 year ago
Comment removed
yissychan 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hes a man not a god. A magpie could kill you under the right circumstances.
#
chesney121
8 months ago 25
I really don't think Isildur should of died like this, he killed the Dark Lord, and all of that. Then just dies by common enemies.
life0rdeath 1 year ago
nope... Isildur just got lucky by cutting off the rings power...
and for some reason i thought that everybody died wen they showed that blast wave throughout Mordor
goldking22 1 year ago
Honestly, Isildur had like a company of Numenorian Knights with him. I seriously doubt that a ragtag raiding party of orcs would manage to take them out.
Freelancer591 1 year ago
@Freelancer591 That is the beauty of an ambush. Weaker enemies are able take down stronger ones.
Nightrider1367 1 year ago
@Freelancer591 Oh, that was an Army. Sauron put them there to ambush the last alliance if he had won and forced them into retreat.
codafett 1 year ago
No, Isildur did not die as shown in the movie. See "The Disaster of the Gladden Fields" in JRRT's Unfinished Tales.
robhoy1977 1 year ago
@Penguinluver757
the ring tempted his mind into running away.
iHeartAniime 1 year ago
Actually, he was so deep underwater that the arrows wouldn't have affected him. Even bullets lose all effect a few feet underwater.
This is a common misconception.
Soreanol 1 year ago
i saw this scene in the actual movie :S
Keyslayer 1 year ago
@Keyslayer It is the same just a tiny bit exdended, you dont see him put the ring on
r1ch1etheman 1 year ago
@ 0:32
That's a nasty Ring lol
jonapenguin 1 year ago
Kekkiki, he cant just kill him and kick him in the fires of mount doom, as then he would most probably be executed, by the gondorions, which would permanentley destroy the allience, and the council of elrond, and the forming of the fellowship would never of happned.
Besides Tolkien would not be succesful like he is.... so theres y :)
dhernon123 1 year ago
that extra 30 seconds told a lot more about how the ring wound up where it did.....it should have stayed.
bwashinski 1 year ago 84
@bwashinski Ya there are many scenes I feel like they should have kept but hey thats why we get the extended editions.
KingVerdo 10 months ago
@bwashinski bullshit. the short version showed him with arches in his back 0:42. With the narration "it betrayed Isildur" and "Gollum found it" covers the rest.
meNtor890 9 months ago
@bwashinski It would have been a mistake to keep this scene in the final version. For those who knew nothing about LOTR, it suggested the One Ring's sole power was merely making the bearer invisible for a time. They most likely just wanted to leave this a suprise for when Bilbo uses it at his party.
CoolGuy62093 8 months ago 3
@chesney121 very begginig of third one
MrMichaelScotland 1 year ago
wouldnt arrows usually stop after like when they hit water?
Raven69XXXX 1 year ago
@Raven69XXXX
i'll go try it in my pool tomorrow.
elvishskills 1 year ago
Isildur = girl
Elbonanero 1 year ago 2
Fucken pussy man he destroys the dark lord face to face and yet he whimps out to orcs half his size damn how does that happen
Badboyben1422 1 year ago
@Badboyben1422 The ring turns ppl into pussies, thats probably what the black speech engravings on it realy say.
EbsNhexz 1 year ago
@Badboyben1422 It makes a lot more sense in the book, Isildur's victory over Sauron was one of opportunism (Stabbing him in the back when Sauron stumbles on a rock.).
EmperorofCartoons 1 year ago
wow
kewlangus69 1 year ago
the power of the ring lured dark to isildur.
Bythesw23 1 year ago
why did he ran away? couldnt he fight like aragorn? i'm sure if he would he would killed half of them
pfcjmf 1 year ago
This scene is short,they could keep it,but well.
LightFykki 1 year ago
1) he didnt kill Sauron, just rid him of his physical shape
2) he was damn lucky, just blindly swept remain of blade and coincidantelly hit the finger with the Ring
3) he was asshole who doomed propably about hundreds of thousands beings to death by taking the Ring for himself
4) arrows to the back kill you anyway, whether you are a hero or not - who he sure wasnt
Riwillion 1 year ago 34
@Riwillion He was a hero. Even Frodo gave into the will or the Ring when dangling it over Mount Doom.
Ianstrox 1 year ago
@Ianstrox
Yes, but when saying "even Frodo", I think you are overrating them both. Frodo was brave, but screwed up with the Ring, Isildur was kind of a hero, but he also was supposed to be - he was a man of the West, from the King´s lineage. He also screwed up with the Ring. They made the same mistake, but Isildur had way greater potential to avoid making it.
Riwillion 1 year ago
@Riwillion Hey, let's see it this way: If it wasn't for him, the evil would be destroyed at the beginning of the first movie. And, without evil, can there be good?
mathias510 1 year ago
@mathias510 There was evil long time ago before Isildur defeated Sauron...
InfernumThe 11 months ago
@InfernumThe Yes, what I ment was, that if Isildur had thrown the ring into Mount Doom, the forces of evil would most certainly be destroyed, either from being hunted down, or starvation. That would mean that the movies would have ended at the start of the first movie.
mathias510 11 months ago
@mathias510 I get your point. BUT IF Isildur destroyed the Ring then there weren't movies and nobody would think about Lord of the Rings movies, cos there isn't them. And you shouldn't think by the movies, think about the books. Every books of Tolkien.
InfernumThe 11 months ago
@InfernumThe All I'm saying is that we can thank Isildur for doing what he did, if he didn't do that, there wouldn't be any movies, which would mean that LotR wouldn't be known by so many today.
mathias510 11 months ago
@mathias510 Oh fuck it! If you don't get it, you don't get it...
InfernumThe 11 months ago
@InfernumThe lol u mad bro?
mathias510 11 months ago
@mathias510 About what? I'm only mad because you just dont get it, but it's okay I'm not gonna argue with you. I like LotR too of course.
InfernumThe 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@InfernumThe No, I don't think you get it. If you look at my first comment, I was talking about the movies all along. And, as you first replied: "There was evil long time ago before Isildur defeated Sauron..." I don't quite see what that has to do with anything...?
mathias510 11 months ago
@Riwillion
:D
sfeeges 10 months ago
in the silmarillion it is written (lol) that Morgoth Bauglir went among the Elves around the same time that Orome visited them. at this time many elves disappeared. the elves themselves believed that the race of orcs was created by Morgoth by corrupting elves through torture. in the Third Age Saruman was believed to have created a hybrid race by mixing men and orcs. these Uruks were not fearful of sunlight and thus differed markedly from the typical orc.
lebarosky 2 years ago
From the reading I've done, Tolkien himself gave several different versions of the story of how Orcs were created...... just saying..... :)
JustaWyomingGirl 2 years ago
This makes much more sense with the "Ring betraying him" than the version that was in the movie. In that it makes it seem that ring called those orcs to attack Isildur.
mangahawk92 2 years ago
FKIN THEY COPIED ISILDUR1's NAME FOR A CHARACTER IN THIS MOVE. AND DTHEY PRONOUNCE WRONGGG!!
h5y 2 years ago
@h5y you do know that the Lord of the Rings was created in i think in the 1970's... right? and this "isildur1" probably copied Isildur in this movie and/or the book
Arantre20 1 year ago
@Arantre20 the book was written in the 40s actually
thealexstrikesback 1 year ago
@thealexstrikesback lol yeah, i had a brain fart i forgot he wrote it during WWII
Arantre20 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@h5y you do know that the Lord of the Rings was created in i think in the 1970's... right? and this "isildur1" probably copied Isildur in this movie and/or the book
Arantre20 1 year ago
Damn guys... Orc is just a name given to all of their kin by the other races,example "Yrch" is used by the elves,in the Common speach its what we know as Orcs. Goblins are goblins,yes...but in all fairness they are also called orcs (allincluded foul bloody beasts)...hehehehehehehehehe.
AJZulu 2 years ago
I really don't think Isildur should of died like this, he killed the Dark Lord, and all of that. Then just dies by common enemies.
chesney121 2 years ago 55
yeah. he was reduced to just that after allowing himself to be corrupted by the ring's power.
nutbustedhaji 2 years ago 2
@chesney121 that says in the book,that isildur was traveling with his army and 2 or 3 sons and he saw them dying and tried to escape but died in the river while he was crossing it.
pourtalo 2 years ago
@chesney121 do not doubt the will of J.R.R Tolkien... or suffer the consequences *pulls out sword made out of plastic*
Arantre20 1 year ago
@chesney121 Whatcha have to remember is that the ring wanted him dead, it called the orcs, it posessed him to get into a position where he was most weak, and left him to die.
That's how powerful the ring was man.
Glandorray 1 year ago 3
@chesney121 he didn't kill sauron because he was such a great warrior, but because he reached his hand out and he took a sword and cut off his fingers
R4mpZy 1 year ago
@R4mpZy Or if you go by the book, Sauron stumbled on a rock and Isildur stabbed him in the back when he wasnt looking.
EmperorofCartoons 1 year ago
@chesney121 he killed the dark lord by randomly swinging his sword lol
Lechoni21 1 year ago 2
@chesney121 he was a coward he abandoned his men, and was greedy
DazzledRose3193 1 year ago
@chesney121 while he's running away, don't forget that
WulvPawz 1 year ago
@chesney121 Thats kind of the point, he had a grand destiny, he did a great thing, but when he gave that up in exchange for the ring of power, he eventually died being shot down like an animal. Its to illustrate what the ring did to him. It ruined him in every way, just as it does everyone it touches.
EmperorofCartoons 1 year ago
@EmperorofCartoons
Ahh! After 5 months people have answered my question- wrongly. They didn't read it right- thanks! :D
And what book does it say isildur stabbing Suaron in the book?
I'm a 1/4 way through fellowship of the ring (given up on it about 2 years ago) and it have not mentioned it yet.
chesney121 1 year ago
@chesney121 The Ring has a power of its own.....
BAMF5550123 1 year ago
@chesney121 he was kinda ambushed and all.
TheDeathTesters 1 year ago