Added: 5 years ago
From: ARMYGUY1777
Views: 67,844
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (208)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • @Escention Contrary to popular belief, not every fan of any band puts down covers, I love Nirvana, and Evanescence, and I think this isn't half bad.

  • i think its amy lee's way of saying she admires nirvana

  • Hmmm... people saying that this cover sucks - Evanescence are Evanescence, not Nirvana, they did it their own way. It won't sound identical to the original, that's why it's called a cover.

  • I love this song

  • Puissant ,i think it's difficult , because Kurt it's inimitable .... I'm french , Sorry for the orthographe

  • "I wish I could eat your CANCER when YOU TURN BLA-A-A-ACK!" (3:47 - 3:57)

    I love it how she sings that! Cool cover!

  • Agreed.

  • amy lee is awsome!

  • RIP kurt cobain.

  • no band should ever do a nirvana cover. if i was in a band i wouldn't coz i have way to much respect for them

  • they do a cover because the song is so great. aka is a tribute -.-

  • I know i understand that. I'd just be a little scared i'd mess it up. umm btw i was kinda depressed when i wrote that my mind was in all sorts of places

  • thats fair enough, lucky Evanescence haven't done that hey? stupid people....cant see past your own likings, face it, people wont always like what you do.

  • It sounds like she's trying to make the song depressing...

  • lol! Amy's soooo funny! "You can laugh at me, I only look scary!" lmao

  • Nirvana's version is better than this SHIT

    RIP KURT

  • iono im such a fan of Evanescence, truly i am, im OBSESSED, ask my family or friends if youd like, but really, this cover...her voice isnt suited for it. it sounds like she didnt give out all that shes capable to. iono, but i dont care, watever she wanted to do is fine :)

  • evanescence is so much better than nirvana

  • evanscence is not even comparable they are good but kurt cobain is god of all music

  • You're out of your mind.

  • Damned stupid. AMY LEE Sing very well...

    Besides;I am sure that Kurt Cobain would like this version.Because

    !!!!!AMY LEE RRROOOOOOCCCCKKKKSSSSS!!!!!

  • bitch!!!

    anda matando toda la musica, como se le ocurre hacer un cover de un tema como este!, pobre kurt cobain, debe rebolcarse en su tumba de pura pena

  • OMG!!!

  • I love Nirvana and Evanesence- they both TOTALLY ROCK.

  • its really good but the original by nirvana is better...long live nirvana

  • cool

  • the original is better

  • This is SWEET!!! I knew there was an acoustic version, but I NEVER thought they'd do this with all the heavy stuff. I love it!

    Evanescence and Nirvana forever!

  • All you people saying how it's nothing like the original, go do something constructive with your time. It's a C-O-V-E-R. It's not meant to sound like the original. Amy does a fine job of giving it a new meaning. If you want to hate on videos, go do it somewhere else.

  • its only cause its crappy quality!!

    go download the song sung by amy lee - she does an amazing job of it...

    thats from a nirvana + evanescence fan.

  • omfg

  • stupid assholes!!!! amy rocksss!!!i have the original version !!!

  • so wut if amy lee cant sing this song shes amazing at singing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • well she is amazing at singing but, she is GREAT at this song!!

  • to the idiot who said shes bringing rock back: rock was never and will never die, and shes killing it even more

  • shut up idiot

  • Yeah, she's hot, but... defiling a dead man's song with something not even comparable to the original version should be a sin.

  • wow...

  • the sound it's bat but a had the version and is beautifull estupid asholes!!!

    amy is the BEST♪

  • amy lee fucking sucks. she is mutilating good songs! she sings the same damn way over EVERY song she does, she cant even change her voice, shes just always doin that high note shit, and that doesnt cut it on a song like Heart Shaped Box. she needs to stop mooching off everyone elses talent and learn how to write her own damn songs.

  • fuck you bastard

  • is that all you can say? you can't even defend her, because its true. when she does anything BUT a high note, come talk to me. but evanescence slaughtered this song.

  • !FUCK YOU!

  • Dude I wanna smex Amy. x]

    Nirvana fucking rulesss!!!

    Best band, Ever!

  • everybody who says amy can't sing screw you b/c she is the best singer and she is bringing both rock AND classical back from the dead!

  • She has a terrible voice.

  • you wish

  • No, he's actually right.

  • thanks :)

  • nirvana is the best and this is so awful!!!

  • marjattalainen is 100% correct. fucking worst cover ever!! :@

  • worst fucking cover song..ever,go and die

  • yes tourniquet was from soul embraced but u see that song would of never gotten famous if it wasnt for evanescence and plus 2 former band members from evanescence were in the band soul embraced so how could evanescence ruin that song? they just tuned it down into an evanescence sound which came out rather good

    oh yea why do u have to say "she" when its evanescence doing the song =/

    its not all about amy

  • Hell, yeah, this rocks!!!

  • learn to speak, you dumbass

  • tourniquet is amy's you dumb shit!! she did NOT cover that one! jesus fucking christ your dumb!

  • i think all the haters of amy lee should CHOKE b/c she is the best singer in the world and she's the reason i sing today. and no shit she's not going to sound exactly like kurt [God rest his soul] b/c she's a fucking girl, you idiots! i adore nirvana, still have everyone of their cds, but i don't hate people for trying to remake anyone's music and you shouldn't either, morons! and thank you, manakete5324, sticking up for amy sort of. fuck the rest of you

  • haha that's what i was going to say she's a girl! of course it sounds different i think it's awesome and i love nirvana but i've barely even heard any of evanescene's songs so yeah...

  • booooo booooo, amy lee should choke for fucking this song up

  • geez, whats with all the haters? I mean ya, Kurt Cobain was AmAzInG and Amy does this much differently than he did, but thats kinda why you cant realy compare the two. They're so different in style, Amy does a wonderful job singing this but is very different, people shouldn't say shes 'horrible' just because she doesnt sing it exactly like Kurt. They're two different singers, w/ 2 different styles, both were/are Great

  • Mmmm they messed up the song!!! ¬¬ stick to your songs amy... and i mean it in a good way you know kurt sang it like ... so...angry she's just singing.

  • kurt was a messy / sloppy guitarist, which is why he was in a unique goup of people...this just sounds too neat...and too slow...if you play guitar then youll know what i mean

  • Kurt is the best! No one can be like him!

    I usually like Amy Lee's songs but this time.. I really hate!

  • I miss kurt. I like the nirvanna version not this version.

  • Why did you have to leave us the way you did Kurt Cobain

  • "pleaseregister" for 5 mins..?? Use FRAPS instead

  • NIRVANA FOR EVER !!!!

  • the vocals are ok, the guitar also, but the weird metal-double bass drum sets me up!

  • hey, i'am a huge nirvana fan.. but i also like evanescence. The live version sucks... there's an acoustic version that Amy Lee did thats pretty good

  • ...I'm going to cry. The original is so much better than this atrocity.

  • i agree --20120e129e810ewd percent

  • at Mrjak. 1. She's singing Freak on a leash WITH Korn, 2. she covered Thoughtless, and 3. she's not ruining it. Why would there be fans then? Two different styles, I like 'em both, say something useful, or just shut the hell up

  • this cover makes me want to cause bodily harm to myself, the original makes me feel happy inside...want to know why? BECAUSE NOBODY CAN DO A COVER OF NIRVANA AND FREAKING SOUND GOOD!!! and for the record I didn't search for this version I searched for the NIRVANA version and found this crap!

  • EVERYBODY WHO LIKES/LOVES EVANESCENCE LISTEN UP!!! EVANESCENCE CLUBHOUSE OPENED!!! GO THERE!:youtube. com/group/evanescenceclubhouse JOIN TODAY...WE TALK ABOUT EVANESCENCE AND HAVE MUSIC VIDEO AND SINGING CONTESTS!!!!! AMY LEE/HARTZLER &&& EVANESCENCE....ALL IN ONE CLUBHOUSE!!! JOIN NOW!!! please!

  • i'm going. =]

  • Freak on a Leash, Heart Shaped Box. Want to ruin any more songs, Amy Lee?

  • lmfao! XD...omfg! She doesnt do the song justice...it's kinda killing my ears too lol...i love the orignal an infinite times more lol

  • Glade you agree.

  • Shit...I was pissed when she NAMED a song the same as nirvana...

  • Evanescence is perfect!!

  • it just sounds a bit weird cause its recorded at a concert. the studio recorded version is fucking brilliant and amy lee rules so stop saying she sucks cause she respects nirvana and decided to do one of their songs

  • hmmm seems odd i have to admit that amey lee is a great singer but she cant pull of this song it takes angainst and she can show it in her music ive noticed

  • I love Nirvana and don't like Evanescence particularly, but I still think Amy Lee sings this nicely.

  • OMFG they ruined such a great song!

  • blairwaldorf777 im with you man NIRVANA BEST COMMERCIAL GRUNGE BAND listen to nirvanas version u hear the grunge screams then u hear amy lee's shitty voice on this one KEEP TO EMO amy we dont need emo grunge rockers

  • id like it if evanesence never played this again...

  • bitch! she stole my boyfriend... now i hold a grudge 'gainst her!!!!!!!!!!

  • there's no way that evanescence is better than Nirvana. I'm sorry, but face it, Nirvana's the BESTEST BAND EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and i really respect Nirvana

  • compared to nirvana she suxs i luv amy n all but ya it just killed da song

  • compaired to nirvana, evanesence SUCKS, this was just horrible

  • Not Bad.....not bad....not bad at all. Still, I like Nirvana's original version better, but this is a very good cover.

  • fyi flyleaf made a nirvana cover and i think its cool that bands are actually covering songs of nirvana they were the best band ever and for evanescence give them credit cause they respect nirvana alot so therefore they did a cover of heart shaped box to show how much they like nirvana

  • thank you!

  • ur welcome? lol

  • dude why did she ruin one of the best songs by nirvana she needs to die and stealing lithium as a title god shes awful

  • fucking don't listen if you think she sucks!!!!!!!!!!

  • hey darkinuyasha quit sucking dick and stfu complaining about others

  • i am only complaining about you and who's dick am i sucking

  • your moms

  • that's pretty sad cuz i thought that somepeople were smart enough to know that females couldn't have a dick plus i don't even know my mom.

  • you knew your mom last nite oh burn

  • I think she did the song really well You have to take into consideration it was originally performed by a guy. So Amy had to tweak it to her pitch I think its a great new twist to an awesome song!

  • that's why it's call a COVER... ¬_¬ may be not this particular performance, but I heard it recordered with better quality and It Is Great... of course is not nirvana, that's why it's call a cover...

  • he is man....he is...

  • the voice actually fits the lyrics. It almost sounds chant-like and it seems to fit the song. the only 3 things wrong are the snare drum, it cuts off too soon and it doesn't have that ring the original had, the weird voice pitch at 3:48 onwards, and the double-bass in the chorus (it just doesn't fit). otherwise, it was pretty good

  • horrrrrible covering.. she sings really bad on the stage

  • actually not really the person recording it just did it bad..

  • In what way can we say that his indulgence in making music so bland and rather uninspirational to be a real musician? Was it the lack of being an extensive person of ordinary talent to lead many through an image and not music, but rather a wave bunched up by media hoarding and all those that ride it comfortingly for the notion that it is a trend. You tell me.

  • You guys shoudl be ashamed.

    This is coming from a Nirvana fan, as well as Evanescence, so don't give me lip.

    I think Kurt would be honored for a fan to cover him, and by such a talented artist at that. I don't think Kurt would be anything but honored because she isn't into streotyping and the norm, she goes to a beat of her own drum, and that's what Cobain was all about.

  • This makes me sad.

  • Kurt Cobain and his music is overrated regardless. Its great to see they cover his songs for the fact they are meaningless self loathed lyrics.

  • how VERY dare they

  • Thank god Kurt never had to hear this

  • that was awesome. all the haters can go f*** themselves. nice video anyway.

  • See, the thing is, Evanescence is more of the "Gothic" type of rock.. Nirvana is more of the classical Rock. But Evanescence did an OK job at this. That's all I'm saying.

  • i like evanescence but they fucking suk @ nirvana songs, they killed it

  • when she sings in tune she gets this spot on stop pickin on them!! Grr

  • wow i dont like this one bit this really blows. i think some of there shit is good but there killin one of my favourite songs BOOOO

  • the voices cant be compared

  • Immaturity at its greatest. No wonder half of you aren't getting far in life.

  • Give Them credit! They tried hard, and they sound good and guess what, they're working their way up to become the Nirvana of our generation...you can believe it or not, but this band would be biggest thing to hit the world siince NIrvana.... So if you like them or not, remeber one day you'll see them everywhere!!!

  • go you!

  • So Evanescence aren't the same as Nirvana? There's nothing wrong with them giving it a shot, and it is actually possible to like both versions.

  • everyone needs to chill and take a pill it's just a cover and it doesn't help that the audience is also screaming. and for some one who called evanescence emo..they are not. they are rock. and this cover was done awhile back, before fallen even came out and they have improved alot since then. so give the some credict okay?

  • Give them credit? that's what i was trying to do :D I'm a huge fan, they take up my bedroom wall, sorry if I was a tad confusing

  • i wasn't really directing my comment on you, just the people that are fussing.

  • Yeah OK, I feel exactly the same :)

  • GO YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • its NOT nirvana kobain was still is A god

  • tribute...?

    I will hope so

  • first of all buddy fuck u and ur mentality..and second of all fuck evanescance cuz there the gayest shit ive seen in years

  • O.K. why dont you go and die a horrible death. YOU SUCK!! evanescence is the COOLEST band in the WORLD!!!!!!!!!!!! SOOOO GO AND DIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • kurt is the best !!! rest in peace !!!

  • the real version is WAY better altho this is okay the real song is my favorite song ever and wat r u talking about righthandjack nirvana is grunge and evenacence is emo/slow god learn music loser nirvana roolz!

  • shut the fuck up you retarded dip shit, evanescence is but a mainstream piece of shit, dont you dare disrespect nirvana, and kobain comparing then to evanescence, have more respect for REAL artists.

  • COBAIN you fuck witted fake stuck up ignorant asshole.

  • Way too cool! While Kurt G-Bang's version was the best, this is a faithful rendition.

  • Yep kurt is the man for this song and amy is ...well .. the woman.

  • It is good but Yeah Kurt was the man

  • No frakind video only that gay please reg

  • Nirvana's version is way much better ^_^

  • yeah nirvana's is way better but this isn't bad either

  • its good but nirvana's version is better

  • awesome song..amy lee rocks!!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more