All the mentioned artists have their gifts for sure. The Sibelius is a concerto that has a transparency allowing for different interpretations that are quite different and yet valid. Heifetz or HH use an icey serentity....the Northern lights....while SC or ASM will put the heart and soul of Finlandia into it. All wonderful..all appropriate. So enjoy a little salsa with your pickled herring, and stop the pious judgements.
No doubt that Sarah Chang is a great violinist, but I am not a big fan of overly dramatic vibrato she does almost all the time... Her passion is great, but sometimes her passion goes over the top and loses the overall beauty and structure, and I think sometimes Less Is More. Well, it's a matter of taste after all. I love Kyung-Wha Chang, Oistrakh and Midori on Sibelius.
As much as I love this version, I prefer Jascha Heifetz's the BEST. I bought a CD containing this concerto and several others, and Heifetz just has an effortless, graceful fluidity in his technique that no other violinist ever had(or has). Not only that, but he plays every single note like if it was written for him! That's why he's the greatest violinist ever!!
Nevertheless, I LOVE Sarah Chang. Korean violinists really rock my world!
Ah ha. Around 6:03 min into this, you see flute players playing. When Kavakos and especially Vengerov play the piece, they PLAY that part. Flutes or orchestra do not play it. The violin plays it. That section was also in the too-difficult version of it Sibelius first wrote. All other versions are the "new" version, except for Kavakos who was given permission to play the original. The last part, tho, HE is playing that section - but Vengerov plays it too - and better, clearer, crisper.
Try Vengerov's version. And if you want to hear the original one Sibelius wrote, try Kavakos. the version was so hard that the original performance in early 1900s was a disaster! Guy could bearly play it, red faced and sweating, he struggled through! Live, on stage. Embarassing!
@Keette I totally agree, Hahn's playing sounds a little robotic to me. But Chang FEELS the music, she makes you feel the emotion with which the composer wrote every double-stop, every whole note, every beat....
@zucchini2007 True but Hilary Hahn's playing is just like a guide. I always refer music pieces which have sophisticated rhythm to her playing. It's just..near perfection.
AMEN. hilary hahn's interpretations may not be as distinctive as others, but her playing IS mind-blowingly perfect and it's very soothing to listen to every time. she can't disappoint:)
Sarah is so musically GIFTED and beautiful, I just want to go up to her, introduce myself to her, give her a nice little peck on the cheek, and tell her that I think she's an incredible violinist. And then maybe after the concerto I can interview her over a nice candlelit dinner. I need her help to improve my violin-playing skills, I think she would make an awesome violin teacher.
WOW, I think that Chang belongs in the same league as Heifetz, Perlman, Oikstrakh, and Mintz. She's one of the greatest violinists of modern times, her intonation is PERFECT, her tempo is right on target, her vibratos sound great, her fingerings are very accurate, and her dynamics are beautiful. And then to top it all off, she's a beautiful Korean woman.
Although he may be a renowned conductor, I don't think Sarah Chang and this orchestra complement each other. For me, I felt at various parts throughout the piece lacked energy and vivacity, like other recordings. Sarah Chang, however, is, as always, an amazing performer and highly respected in my book. This is solely my opinion, so don't take it out of context.
This piece is actually really fun to play in the orchestra (at least for me, I've played the timpani part).
There's no BS in the soloist's playing. So often you see the violinist overdramatize this one. Sibelius never goes out the way to write impossible stuff, so you learn it nd letthe music speak for itself.
i always love sarah chang's majestic stand when she is not playing the violin....with her left hand hand at the back and her right hand in front holding the bow and the violin....so majestic....wowo....
Me too! She could definitely take more time on it. It's a shame, cause since it's a cadenza she can obviously take however much time she wants. ah well
All the mentioned artists have their gifts for sure. The Sibelius is a concerto that has a transparency allowing for different interpretations that are quite different and yet valid. Heifetz or HH use an icey serentity....the Northern lights....while SC or ASM will put the heart and soul of Finlandia into it. All wonderful..all appropriate. So enjoy a little salsa with your pickled herring, and stop the pious judgements.
jhglobal1 1 month ago
the ending of this movement is breathtaking!
Soloiszt 1 month ago
She has mad bowing skills and I love all the emotion she puts into it. :D
gharrison4ever 3 months ago
falta interpretação ....a hilary hahn é melhor
MrJeanlima19 6 months ago
6:57 Que sonrisa tan picara!
1luisva 7 months ago
No doubt that Sarah Chang is a great violinist, but I am not a big fan of overly dramatic vibrato she does almost all the time... Her passion is great, but sometimes her passion goes over the top and loses the overall beauty and structure, and I think sometimes Less Is More. Well, it's a matter of taste after all. I love Kyung-Wha Chang, Oistrakh and Midori on Sibelius.
tyo1973 1 year ago 2
Have got to say that, this is one of sarah chang's best performances in a lot time.
kuvhlubkojibleegxwbo 1 year ago
As much as I love this version, I prefer Jascha Heifetz's the BEST. I bought a CD containing this concerto and several others, and Heifetz just has an effortless, graceful fluidity in his technique that no other violinist ever had(or has). Not only that, but he plays every single note like if it was written for him! That's why he's the greatest violinist ever!!
Nevertheless, I LOVE Sarah Chang. Korean violinists really rock my world!
zucchini2007 1 year ago
You can clearly hear people coughing and clearing up their throats between the movements, LOL. At least they don't do it during Sarah's performance.
zucchini2007 1 year ago
Bravo...
rorizjoel 1 year ago
Close your eyes when you listen to this music, and it paints a landscape of the Himalayas in your mind. It's an exhilarating, uplifting experience...
zucchini2007 1 year ago
@zucchini2007 Hahaha That's funny because Sibelius was Finnish :-)
numbuh1bassclar 1 year ago
A beautiful Korean American lady playing the violin so skillfully...I LOVE IT!! :-)
I hope that I can be as good as her very soon....
zucchini2007 1 year ago
virtually flawless as per usual =)
ghettofab831 1 year ago
Ah ha. Around 6:03 min into this, you see flute players playing. When Kavakos and especially Vengerov play the piece, they PLAY that part. Flutes or orchestra do not play it. The violin plays it. That section was also in the too-difficult version of it Sibelius first wrote. All other versions are the "new" version, except for Kavakos who was given permission to play the original. The last part, tho, HE is playing that section - but Vengerov plays it too - and better, clearer, crisper.
TeeJayMarsh 2 years ago
Try Vengerov's version. And if you want to hear the original one Sibelius wrote, try Kavakos. the version was so hard that the original performance in early 1900s was a disaster! Guy could bearly play it, red faced and sweating, he struggled through! Live, on stage. Embarassing!
TeeJayMarsh 2 years ago
a lot of famous violinists do masterclasses like josefwitz, and midori, etc. in tsyo
babycow12345 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
she's prettier from far away
Joebzzz 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I agree with you, i heard better performances...
I didn't say i play better, but that's not criterion point...
kosmamkosmam 2 years ago
Comment removed
kosmamkosmam 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Not good at all...Average.
maxhansendk 2 years ago
Why dunt u play it and show everyone what u're made of.
bountyhanz 2 years ago 7
This version sticks with me, I love Hilary Hahn's too but Changs gets under your skin (In a good way).
Keette 2 years ago 18
@Keette I totally agree, Hahn's playing sounds a little robotic to me. But Chang FEELS the music, she makes you feel the emotion with which the composer wrote every double-stop, every whole note, every beat....
zucchini2007 1 year ago 2
@zucchini2007 True but Hilary Hahn's playing is just like a guide. I always refer music pieces which have sophisticated rhythm to her playing. It's just..near perfection.
bountyhanz 1 year ago
@bountyhanz
AMEN. hilary hahn's interpretations may not be as distinctive as others, but her playing IS mind-blowingly perfect and it's very soothing to listen to every time. she can't disappoint:)
lee4ivy 1 year ago
She is wonderful
I hope I will be as good as her, in a couple years
dadygirly2 2 years ago 5
you will. I'm trying to be as good as her, too. just keep pushin' and you will. I promise.
amargeaux 2 years ago 3
I saw this conductor do Bruckner 5 with Chicago Symphony in October (or novermber). Wonderful conductor. very clear. Chang is wonderful as always.
fiddlinmatt 3 years ago
Sarah is so musically GIFTED and beautiful, I just want to go up to her, introduce myself to her, give her a nice little peck on the cheek, and tell her that I think she's an incredible violinist. And then maybe after the concerto I can interview her over a nice candlelit dinner. I need her help to improve my violin-playing skills, I think she would make an awesome violin teacher.
zucchini2007 3 years ago
She should give lessons! I would immediately sign up for them.
Nyquilhero 2 years ago 6
That's assuming you could afford them lol. I highly doubt many people could...
lolwhat777 2 years ago 3
if shes reasonable, then 200 dollars a lesson sounds right, thats the going rate for conservatory teachers in New York at MSM of Julliard.
gnatural 2 years ago
lol...you're not alone! :)
crazycadenza 2 years ago
ya es de mis preferidas esta chica
SUPERPAGANINI 3 years ago
WOW, I think that Chang belongs in the same league as Heifetz, Perlman, Oikstrakh, and Mintz. She's one of the greatest violinists of modern times, her intonation is PERFECT, her tempo is right on target, her vibratos sound great, her fingerings are very accurate, and her dynamics are beautiful. And then to top it all off, she's a beautiful Korean woman.
zucchini2007 3 years ago 2
Although he may be a renowned conductor, I don't think Sarah Chang and this orchestra complement each other. For me, I felt at various parts throughout the piece lacked energy and vivacity, like other recordings. Sarah Chang, however, is, as always, an amazing performer and highly respected in my book. This is solely my opinion, so don't take it out of context.
MyMemories19 3 years ago
This piece is actually really fun to play in the orchestra (at least for me, I've played the timpani part).
There's no BS in the soloist's playing. So often you see the violinist overdramatize this one. Sibelius never goes out the way to write impossible stuff, so you learn it nd letthe music speak for itself.
Very good performance.
TheDanceOfMaternity 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
how disrespectful of the audience, why isn't there an applause?
shirusubemonaku 3 years ago
Because you're not supposed to clap between movements.
alkaster 3 years ago 2
LOL noob
gowiemeister 3 years ago
disrespectful XD zuahahahha
iluminada333 3 years ago
lmao *headdesk*
Orchadorkcello 3 years ago
and i hate how people just can't help but cough in concerts... so annoying.
PeterChang0414 3 years ago 4
yea i hate them too, there should be a rule forbidding coughing
shirusubemonaku 3 years ago
i think she lost grip of her violin at end of he first movement
vlhere 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Why most of the time, the soloist is Asian and the accompanists (orchestra/pianist) are mostly whites
shirusubemonaku 3 years ago
Why most of the time, people care about musicians' race? just enjoy the music...
PeterChang0414 3 years ago 19
well she IS playing in Amsterdam...
OriginalMoonbeam 3 years ago
i always love sarah chang's majestic stand when she is not playing the violin....with her left hand hand at the back and her right hand in front holding the bow and the violin....so majestic....wowo....
vlhere 3 years ago 3
Me too! She could definitely take more time on it. It's a shame, cause since it's a cadenza she can obviously take however much time she wants. ah well
Bernsinator 3 years ago
i feel like the cadenza is rushed a bit.
PeterChang0414 3 years ago
hm, i agree to an extent, but i think it's effective how she does it. it keeps and intense feeling with it always moving.
concertolover81291 3 years ago 2