Carnation

[kingham4]

is that steve white on the drums (alan white's brother) ???

[elfrontmanrd]

@kingham4 yes

[kingham4]

is that steve white on the drums (alan white's brother) ???

[Wacko1a]

7 people plugged it in the wrong socket.

[sparkybulldog]

Brilliant. Where can I download the song

[TheCharlatan74]

wellers great liams an arsehole noel and craddock are talented but they do a fuckin great version of this!!!

[frjdoasis2]

TOO MANY GODS IN ONE ROOM

[ScottWP1994]

WOW! stunning volcals, should be a b-slide right?

[TheNicholas0202]

Liam's a shit singer. Oasis suck. The Jam are brilliant and Paul Weller is a genius.

[belbatron]

@TheNicholas0202 Weller is a genius, which is why he realises Oasis are a quality band!

[alfonsoelficus]

@TheNicholas0202 try to sing like Liam, and then talk, wanker...

[MrJimenrique]

truly an amazing song.

[boliboy2299]

What kind of microphone is that? or what kind of mic does Liam Gahllaguer use to sing live?

[emcool333]

the best, just amazing x

[mishka1305]

my song! LOL!!!!

[eatmypies]

liams mars ouse,they leave them on the mantle piece when they go for a piss

[azzad1985]

Anybody know where ya can buy the hats like liam's and steve craddock's?

[eggoo11]

@azzad1985 -- pretty green, its Liam Gallaghers clothing lne, have a look on there, google it

[gene101303]

This performance is a reminder of why Liam is up there with the rest of them despite not playing an instrument and not being able to write a song.

[loyalbrummie]

another bit of quality - everything weller touches turns to gold

[cblaaa]

shut up

[bigammoblue]

ah really cant understant ur reply 2 that??? the song carnation was taken from an album called the gift in 1980, and 2 be honest, oasis, ocean colour scene, reef, blur, and many more....... would not have had the inspiration to even consider music if it had not been for Weller and T

[oasarse]

The drummer and guitarist learnt the music for this in a day but they couldnt perform it for two weeks because liam couldnt learn the lyrics.

[Sirsamwise]

This is Liam when is at his best.

[pbuk]

Great sound.

[UnleashedHunter]

No two instruments will ever be the same. There will always be differences, whether they are subtle or extreme. Thats what makes them unique. And its the same thing for singers. No two singers will ever be the same, but what they contribute to the song is a part of their own personality. I think this version is great.

[policientaaa]

liam's song...so rude lyrics & he looks so identify.........

[bigammoblue]

not liam's song, wellers version on the the gift is well better, and if u want it live try trans global unity express tour.

[josh9wwfc]

good cover.

[bigammoblue]

wish noel took lead, think he would av bn closer to wellers dedication to ah superb lyric song.

[ikswona]

such a fave

[celt67]

Although the Jam were brilliant, they all hated each other offstage...you get the impression the guys from Oasis is the kind of guys Weller would have preferred to hang out with.

[cblaaa]

what?

[kingshahine]

you can tell this was recorded the same time as standing on the shoulders, his voice sounds exactly the same

[GallagherLady]

LIAM TI AMOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!

[SerNismolay]

XDDDDDDDDDD

[GallagherLady]

Ke canzone stupenda...Liam quà è stato proprio bravo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Grz fabio x avermi consigliato sta canzone, è MITIKAAAAA

[cheesebuttylol]

legends

[braddersthemod]

Liam, noel, weller, steve cradock, damon minchella, steve white, almost all my musical heros in one room!

[Elt071]

wow, i never thought i'd see a white rickenbacker,, i want one now :P

[lozmod1]

Weller is God!

[simonfowler81]

@lozmod1 Yes he is, mate...

[Pooyoumf]

All you need is Oasis.

[dadswizz]

it would be fun in that room just jamming around eh !

[unclegregus]

if your wondering by now who i am, look no further than the mirror, coz i am the greed and fear and every ounce of hate in you - genius

[themasterplan16]

good singing

[guessone75]

those are songs that stand out for me too

[oce1989]

"If you gave me a dream for my pocket.. You'd be plugging in the wrong socket"

Genius songwriting.

[SisPsychosis]

great lyrics

[hoopsyachunt]

what a fuckin supergroup!

[mfcstevenson]

i want that hat

[liamantox]

one of liam's best performance...

What a voice!!!

[leflow07]

The Jam & Oasis....

Need anything else?

[jackcoffey]

one of liams best moments!

[Jairaimi]

Liam's ever the best !

[wopman1010]

God, this song's great. It's been in my head for days, due to this video! Haha :]

Brilliant.

[Jupiteloota]

Liam sounds great.

[MadForItOasis]

amazing

[Wislor]

awful

[2106hey]

Vesper

This song is for you.

I'm so sorry. i miss my best friend and i'm lost without you.

Please come back to me.

i cant go on without you.

Mr. Beech xxxx

[cockneywideboy2008]

excellent

[joeymod135]

Had to kick the prick , to do the out.

[2808vikkenny]

pure lucifer, i fucking love it!!

[amypunkerina123]

liam gallangher nei secoli dei secoli, amen

[kingshahine]

i like it more than the original

[yermusicsshite44]

classic! weller & the gallaghers. great song.

[sherbets1sekilala]

まじで好き

[agitalo16]

muy buen cover! la voz de liam es increible!

[dannyrocko22]

What a great cover.... Liams voice on this is the dogs bollocks

[mikezor1]

where can i buy this tune ?

[2808vikkenny]

u can buy this as a single! it fuckin' blows my mind!!

[LeRock0]

EXCELLENT TUNE!

[ezemaster89]

aguante oasis........Liam canta mejor que el de The Jam......

[joeymod135]

I know I keep on , Sorry, But needed to mention that this Version pisses on Any other version that I have ever listned to, Be it Jam or no.

[joeymod135]

cool as fuck aswell !!!!!!!!!!!!

[joeymod135]

Just a pity it did'nt do fuck all when it was out !lol

[1001polly]

went top ten that o.k

[joeymod135]

The rest of the scene,

[joeymod135]

Weller's a bit of a douch Self lover TO mE though, NOW A DAY.

[oasis9867]

liam voice is beck to form just like the 90'.

[bigwellers]

the lyrics are amazing.

[rjbride]

was paul weller involved with a single around 96 that featured a sitar in it Im going crazy tryin to find it,I think he had some part in it,a side project or something like that.

[Kristofferho]

amazing vocals!

[MichiganRJRIII3rd]

liams vocals on this song is fucking nothing short then amazing

[TheModfather32]

nowhere near as good as wellers

still good but...

[youmustbemyluckystar]

This is a brilliant version of The Jam classic!

Im a Paul Weller AND Oasis fan, but got to say, Liams voice suits this song better than Weller on the original.

Great to see The Modfather together with Oasis.

[Cunners82]

And also this was around the time of Knebworth so thats fucked you're other point up mate!

[219970]

Released it in 1999, so after Knebworth enough to not "fuck up" my other point since this was also the time they released Standing on the Shoulders which was SHITE

[219970]

Same old plodding style, like being stuck in a field of treacle.....no progression....no innovation....average lyrics.....

Should have stopped at Knebworth when they were awesome. Love Def Maybe. Oasis now are a parody of themselves.

[Cunners82]

and people who think its fasionable to slag the best band since the Beatles are now a "parody of themselves".

[219970]

But I have never slagged off The Stone Roses mate

[Cunners82]

ha ha ha!

[m0deration]

ffs this isn't even an oasis song that you are slagging off

[Cunners82]

Whose slagging it off numpty?

[hrhadam]

You like the 1-album roses but not Oasis? You're complaining about the lyrics? This is a cover, idiot.

[morninglory1095]

way to slag the lyrics as being oasis'.

it's the jam's. and the lyrics are fucking mega dumbass.

[joeymod135]

No, m8 I disagree there, They have meening certainly.

[jaredzc]

heee souund greaat

[DUMDUM2007]

they're bsides are good but...

I can see why they wern't released as proper single/album tunes.

[vitaminology]

Liam loves this song.

[robteale23]

liam and noel rule and always will so up yours to ne 1 who says n e thing different

[rickster1983]

that Rickenbacker Noel is playing was given to him by Johnny Depp after he played slide guitar on fade in out! Hence the "P" sign.. its J.D's band name!

[blotalot]

don't know where you got your info from but the Guitar Noel is playing was a birthday present from Paul Weller Hence the P However it is a Rickenbacker so ya got that bit right. Check the Oasis DVD Familiar to Millions its all on there.

[webby127]

i also saw the johnny depp info on totp2 whrn they featured oasis. noel was using a guitar with a P on it

[BOmusicB90]

kicks the originals ass

[bigwellers]

Liam can sing. This is amazing.

[valokuva2001]

ok...how old are you 12?

[joeymod135]

What's with the nastieness then? not funny or clever, plus You'll have to av a good look in the shop . The Doosh !

[valokuva2001]

where i can get the single?

[joeymod135]

Notice the little kick towards the end, funny .

[joeymod135]

Steve doing His thing is what I look for in the video (12 strings)& Damon (chilla) on the bass, watch the way it comes together Man it's wicked ! :)

[Cunners82]

fuckin love this.can remember when they did it,but then i forgot about it.Can you download it anywhere?

[Glitchio]

When you say the greatest Oasis song that never was people will think you're talking about one their classic b-sides, haha.

You need to watch what you say when you're talking about what could have been with Oasis.

[Anderlei82]

is it possible to buy the oasis version of this. It'd be cool if oasis brought out an album of covers, they do some good smiths, stone roses, beatles and other band covers that i've seen on youtube and concert

[SKWalrus]

In late 1999, this video was our first glimpse at 'mature' Oasis - and the look/mood that would shape SOTSOG and HC. Having been there since 1994, I have very fond memories from this "cooling out" era of theirs.

[giles1990]

noooo

[giles1990]

the best version u can get is if u buy "the jam live" album its £5 in hmv and its track 20

[mad4oasis]

this is immense,the greatest oasis song that never was! iv got the single,this is faster tho,still great!

[stevo1908]

its a jam song you fuckin stupid cunt! oasis my arse

[mad4oasis]

i said the greatest oasis song THAT NEVER WAS,fukin hell u dont think i know my oasis????????

[Liambich]

if you give me a fresh carnation

[GuntoterAnderson]

this song is colossal! lol

[Proficience]

man!!!!....How good is Liams voice in this!! Brilliant!

[chas2599]

best voice

[sparkybulldog]

what a tune. Trouble is can't get it anywhere

[ostilad81]

its on fire and skill-songs by the jam

[sparkybulldog]

where can i get this version. Oasis and friends

[ostilad81]

id just go in hmv or wherever and ask them.i cant remember where i got mine off the top of my head other wise try limewire

[smartalec247]

das sum meatey side burns u got goin on there liam boy. northern monkeeeeeeeeyyyy.

[giles1990]

liam fuk off paul weller l.egend

[oasistheshiat]

Dude i wanna blow your head off!

[cntmin]

Good~ i like his voice~

[roryhouston09]

liams voice is poor?!?! ur herd it now? liam does an amazing vocal on this tune, what r u listing to buddy

[harryismod]

no liam sounds good on this track man and its a fucking top tune by weller from his jam days

[wallsmightbreak]

The music/instrumental part/band is absolutely amazing, but I'm afraid that Liam's singing is rather poor.

[everlasting123]

this live version is amazing, the studio version is rather poor. Top lineup!!!

[rathcooligan2006]

nice peice of music

[morninglory11]

hey alguien q ponga algun link para dskargarlo...somebody please post a link for downloading this tune!!

[hrhadam]

Man what happened to the 4:10 version?

[juniorpatrick]

One of me very favourites.

[Toret87]

pero pero pero, si esto no lo encuentro en ningún disco, de donde viene????

[LovePainDeath]

wow, this live performance is great, shame the studio version is crap :(

[gav240z]

Yes please that link no longer works :(

[Tomasch]

Could someone repost a Download link for the mp3-file?

[Cigarrette88]

Liam best voice ever, great song

[BriceClem]

liam in this most beautiful interpretation ever

[VANIT]

TUNE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[winstonoboogie1980]

Ah classy! I'll keep checking in. Cheers!

[definitelysupernova]

http://www.yousendit.com/trans­fer.php?action=download&ufid=2­574DE9D47E0C258

here's the link to download it

[winstonoboogie1980]

Anybody know where I could get this live version as an mp3 or mpeg to download? Desperate for it!

[definitelysupernova]

i have it :) i'll post it here soon so check it out

[killkennyrogers]

download soulseek. it's a good program you can find a lot of stuff.

[micka017]

naprosto dokonalá písnička....Liam je tam úúúžasne a jeho hlas nemá chybu

[revolvercoquette]

Liam's voice is damn sexy... and so is he

[VANIT]

the nuts

[idela]

As close as you can get to a modern day super group!

One of the few cover versions that comes close to the original. FANTASTIC!

[Bizarrre]

One word....PERFECT