At the Opera tonight!

[Ihateyou77982]

Very nice

[phantomloves17]

i really liked it! good job! :) Meg could have been a great Shilo... Keep Christine as Mag!

[phantomloves17]

i really liked it! good job! :)

[cheezitchunky]

That was excilento

[ZeldaGiygasLord603]

I loved the fast editing in this; great video!

[Heavylight17]

YAY!!! I was hoping someone would do this.

[TeyrianTimelord10]

Just realized that my last comment wasn't much. I loved Carlotta as Amber! Every time she showed up (even with Raul XD) it was timed perfectly and she fit the role so well. Raul's facial expressions also matched Graverobbers

[TeyrianTimelord10]

Madame Giry would have made a great Blind Mag.

[SweeneyToddVids]

time for a word from a hard critic:

good choice of movies/musicals

love the way you do effects; simple yet enough.

points off however for using christine as both shilo and mag

and i couldnt tell who was pavi, who was rotti and who was luigi..

hmm...all in all, 4 and half stars! excellante!

[Lenedit]

@SweeneyToddVids

thank for being honest, i admit i'm not proud of scene with largos, and use christine as shilo and mag, but i didn't have better idea;( maybe someday i'll make a better.

but thanks for so high note :)))

[Wearenature1]

SOOOOOOO COOOL! Fantastic idea. Wonderful work.)

[mariadarkfuture]

This was pure awesomeness!!! I thing Meg would have made a nice Shiloh though ;) just a thought still amazing video!!!! <3

[angelwolfchild16]

NICE JOB! I love this! It's wicked! Just an idea, you could have used Madame Giry as Blind Mag.

[RCDeschene]

Nice!

But I would have made some obvious differences. Even though Sarah Brightman was the original Christine, I would have made Madame Giry as Blind Mag.

[pharmacoepi]

Betrayal! You made Graverobber Raoul! Just Kidding. Good job. The timing was wonderful.

[velovera]

i love repo the genetic opera and phantom of the opera so i LOVE zis!

[broanna4ever]

you could put meg as mag

[StellaShuriken]

This is now thronging as my favorite video on youtube as a whole. You did splendid work on this and now I will check the rest of your videos.

[Ropieroo]

Brilliant!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

5/5

[meggiemufin]

Chills! So good!

[likeaclock]

I love this video - the fast paced scenes match the rougher music and Carlotta as Amber was a really good idea! Basically - really well made video that i've just watched three times in a row :)

[SCHU50]

One of the finest vids I've seen on YouTube, and that's no idle compliment. I came across it after making a more or less the same movie based on the 1943 version of Phantom of the Opera, and I reluctantly have to admit that this is without a doubt the better movie. Keep it up.

[JessPhantomYlonen]

OMG YES!!!

This is made of Win and Awesome!! I Love you~ =D

[galaad90]

Brillant !

[camplazlo22]

yes, finally someone made this

awesome job.

meg could of been shilo or mag...maybe shilo

[TheHorrorfreak]

wow asomeness. i alays knew that carlotta would be a good amber sweet

[harrypotterultralord]

one of my favs

[Lenedit]

thank you both :)

[SnapeHermioneshipper]

Awesome! You know the fact that Sarah Brightmen also played Christine maybe me laugh. Also lugi and patvi going with thos perverts was great! LOL Love it. Favs

[monpetiteange13]

Awesome!

You should totally think about enter my new musical contest:)