Pink Floyd - Is There Anybody Out There

[cosmos00us]

Beautiful...

[davemustainee2]

far out

[GeneralCambronne]

vous etes vraiment tres cons ceux qui disent que c 'est faux ...il joue tres bien et l'important est de reproduire l'atmosphere originale ....et ca sonne parfaitement juste je trouve ...he just transposed the tab on another cord and only good musicians do that ...good job man

[jbstoneking]

good job but the last chord is wrong it is little e (1st string) 12 fret ,2nd string (b) 10 fret, 3rd string 9 fret, and 4 th string 10 fret. and every string should be strummed from 4 to 1 strings. and before it should be b string fret 1 slide to fret 5, 1st (e)string fret 5, fret 7, fret 8 and the chord as above to finish it off.

[H3lbrixs360s]

Wow nice!Im doing this at school but your finger picking is amazing!Just your last chord isn't quite right :)

[mrblueboxers]

press 0 continuosly to get scratched

[mmapunk26]

That sounds awesome!

[guitargo64]

Thanks so much! I'm learning this piece and your rendition is extremely helpful! Keep up the awesome playing! I felt the emotion in the piece. Not every performer can capture it. You are truly gifted.

[TheGiantTampon]

half of you here cant play like that, stop hating on the guy that sounded good to me except for the ending pickings

[PringDaddyPring]

What I find funny about all the haters on here is that they clearly don't understand the first thing about Pink Floyd... Ask Roger Waters to play this song! He'd have no idea how to play it... And he could really care less... He admits that the only person in the band who knew anything about playing an instrument was David... So take solace in the fact you can play this song exponentially better than the mastermind behind the band

[cedricmayotte]

You are good... but not that good to be playing on internet... go practice else where...

[dosience]

that was great.enjoyed watching the hands

[Kerouac4fan]

First Class!!!

[qwer19961996]

u failed

[eaqui1]

learn to play guitar...

you suks homosexual

[MeWakey]

@eaqui1 and you like penis. stfu or reply with a video of you playing it better, you goatish dizzy-eyed flap-dragon

[eaqui1]

aprende a tocar puto



[wombatpacker]

anyone who can play for fun has gift -wish I could

[mardar18]

Don't say he's playing it "wrong". He just customized it, like what Pink Floyd does in soloes a LOT.

[maxime324]

very nice :)

[danny9837]

excelente 

[AlexBadsmile]

All the thumbs down are just from some jealous guitarist... Its a great cover ! =D

[xenorocker73]

Yep, I'd love to know how many of these people who say "You suck", "It's wrong", etc. can actually play this song themselves? Fuck all at a guess!!! He played it well, better than I can. Well done man!

[FAMExNUKEZZz]

Dam he does it so wrong it's really sad

[cgdstkz]

watch?v=D1EJ-4mukqA watch it please

[billy959]

the formation on that song is so hard

[plasterdbastard]

The guy's finger picking and assholes come on YouTube to say that it's wrong.

Those cheesedicks probably can't even play 3-chord punk rock, let alone finger pick this masterpiece.

[watchmen119]

that was brilliant, love this guitar work so much :)

[vretenartyler123]

great videos =)

[ZoeHaylee321321]

You suck!!!!!!

[NethabyMidgeban]

you've made it so no one can play along with you! :( I tried and you've changed some of the notes!!! You evil person!!

[rubbersole79]

Wrong?? Where am I? What, do you want your money back?

This is just some dude having fun with his guitar. Give me a break.

I'm gettin' real tired of youtube hating trolls out there. You want perfection? Then either listen to the original, play it yourself, or shut the hell up.

[Queenannsrvnge9]

very good, you did make sorta play some parts wrong, but its much better than i could have done. i suggest just listening to the real version to see what you played wrong. you have the skill to play it, you didnt :P but very well done!

[Diverge]

I was gonna say great job until the ending was butchered

[Diverge]

I was gonna say great job until the ending was butchered

[1111111111sword]

waaaaaaaaaw man

that was unreal waaaw

u r so talented good luck

[FLoading00]

ta errado !

[OrthodoxGod]

@FLoading00 dai ele dizer ke e uma cover XD

[NikoMezmerize]

la verdad esque esta enc ciertas partes erronea ...

[MrXavy7]

chale mano eres un pendejazo

aprendetela bn no chingues]!

[MrXavy7]

chale mano eres un bil pendejazo

aprendetela bn no chingues]!

[hamsteradorable]

94 people that gave a thumb down are jealeous and ignorant idiots

[niko90ist]

not correct

[abarthman73]

Nice! Well played.

[Girlaloudfannui]

fast and no feeling.. slow down love

[METALLICA7757]

he does teh same thing i do, constantly keeping an eye on his fingers

[ashtincorkum100]

Missed a whole intro bit dude.

[2100darkar]

hai una camera di merda

[MissPummarola]

datti all'ippica

[bebitajj]

that was really really good :) im learning how to play this song and i suck at it right now haha

[lugachov]

I LOVE that song

[macker151515]

very good

[jordanbeaulieu]

Is that a seven string classical? also, nice work.

[Darksideofthemachine]

Noto il cambio di posizione mano quando passi dal MI al Fa.

I purusti direbbero che è sbagliato.

Io sto imparando il pezzo e mi chiedo quale delle due posture mi spacchi meno le dita!

Bravo

[brautigan1]

Hey, I really enjoyed your playing of this fantastic old tune. I have a version up on my channel if you wouldn't mind stopping by -- thanks!

[TheSavage493]

great job man

[danlukedenise]

check this version out,, type "danlukedenise" or clik my name,, look for the topless dude

[Tucktuck99]

Nice!

[crookhunter]

Very Good!

[rnrhc10]

Great compliments to you dude. You did a hell of a job and kept me focused from the first until the last second.

Greetingzzz

Rob

[rumblegemfighter]

All of you need to shut the fuck up he is good and your saying oh he missed alot of notes i want to see you play this

[MarcBeckK]

@rumblegemfighter come on man. Don't sink to that level. How are you gonna tell people on youtube to shut the fuck up. And that old "I want to see you play this" argument, that is totally invalid. How does their ability or inability to replicate this piece a 100% change the fact that this was either okay, or pretty good?

[hellomydeadfriend]

english



[theKaarvaag1]

I am speechless. This is just amazing!!

[vohaz77]

malisimo :S Muy rapido, arruinas el tiempo

[takesometokes]

propssssss

[WildLife312]

You played it really good dude i cant do it that good. Your way better than me

[Sbavni]

??????????????????????????????­???

[dhylanspano1]

Amazing!

[soccerlovesit]

ok that was amazing, make an album i will buy it

[RECRUTAzl]

não é tirano vc cara, + esse som seu tem umas partes erradas em ... comendo parte da musica! abraço

[Laneclin]

sucks



[rdmtb123]

PLAYED IT Wrong? can anyone else play it that goood?

[saltek2]

isto é uma porcaria foda s.

[dollydolly1990]

è sbagliataaaa...!!!!!!!!

[oneznzeroz]

I think you did a great job

[herberekenen]

a bit slower! Well played! I do it to! 

[tttemma]

I am currently learning this song and I have to tell you, you did a really great job

[mussie302]

Very nicely done. It's a little bit different to the original but it's your own version and played very well - good rhythm and sound, which really make this particular piece good to listen to. I've just posted a version of this on my own channel and I'd be interested to know what you think, if you wanted to have a look. Cheers.

[herberekenen]

Just a tiny bit to fast played...solo on Am..!

Thanx for posting!

[solvazquez]

Mr. J. Deep is playing guitar....!

[valkiri360]

god song, but its wrong, but you are god n.n player, nice, see yo just careful whit notes seeya

[snuffying]

very nice !! almost like the original !!

[C00Lcat69]

defiantely fucked up at the end mate

[simonevanzi]

il finale non è così!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[weeslipknot1]

è un pò tuttta alla cazzo

[distantworld]

Nice going. Not a great cover, but a good attempt nonetheless. I remember when i was starting to play the guitar, and i was a lot worse, you are quite decent :)

[QwertyLesPaul]

no tocas mal, pero el tema no es asi.. lo lamento pero no me gusta..

[madeofscars117]

this version is straight..from watching different ppl play this song, i see a pattern of where everyone seems to make the changes. its not wrong since its a cover, but on the same token, its not right. i like it tho. I like steeventintine's video response the most out of all the covers ive seen, cuz thats how i play it, haha :p

[Kancernova]

aprendete la cancion aweonao ql

[milehighmayhem]

You can't play anything wrong, only different. I have heard versions where the cover is note for note like the original and still lacks all emotion. I think the playing was beautiful. Not a carbon copy of the original, and not wrong.

[yeagis911]

horribly wrong, the special motion and rhythm in this song is ruined by his altercation of the piece.

[irena7777777]

@yeagis911 Altercation?? You mean, alternation? An altercation is a dispute.

[yeagis911]

@irena7777777 you're right. Sorry.

[irena7777777]

@yeagis911 No need to be sorry, easy mistake to make!

[HardRokMiner]

Hey @irena7777777, lets have an altercation about the word alternation. lol

[irena7777777]

@HardRokMiner Haha

[kweli25]

lots of mistakes....

[chaseman100]

in comparison i would have to say that this is one of the worse videos... you did a good job but it was different... mabye thats what you wanted but if something works dont fix it...

[onimusha514]

@chaseman100 u eem like an epert i ould love to ee u playing the ong better than him

[ruskiantonov]

@chaseman100 what a stupid comment

[elmntskate3]

@chaseman100 dont be a dick......

[gaya1323]

sweet guitar :)

[tierrahueca]

is a diferent version of it i like it

[dwiseraven]

You're not playing it properly...is reaaly close to the original one but is not perfect...anyway is a good job dude...congrats :)

[bmxmattylemoth]

thats not how the tune properly goes.

check out my version of it.

[Stormbla]

this dude looks like steven wilson

[paixmondiale]

hm..congrat.. but there are some bad cords.. sorry..

[steveski74]

Yeah, many wrong notes, but the tone is outstanding.

[TheLandJames]

Who cares if he played it wrong most people change up a few notes when they do covers, this is by far one of my favorite covers hes a great guitar player.

[benarneberntsen]

@TheLandJames he plays to much wrong, i can play this self, and this is bullshlt

[yeagis911]

@TheLandJames great guitar player? First of all he missed one note, second, he is STARING at his fingers while he's playing. The playing part should not be something to concentrate about, it should be automatic. The thing you should concentrate about is the rhytm, you want it to sound great not just play the right notes in the right order.

[HardRokMiner]

Hey @yeagis911, why don't you post a video of you playing it while staring straight ahead? If theres one thing that makes me sick its ppl downing others for doing something that they cant even do themselves. Your a waste of skin and oxygen.

[gyselboy]

very good liked it very much and for all the people putting this down where are yor versions? if you cant put up stfu!

[benarneberntsen]

@gyselboy i have play this live on the school where i live, and this is totally wrong

[klarolivia]

Everybody says that it's not even close, and it's wroooong, and stuff... But why does it have to be close and just the same? Where's the art, then? I think you did a great job, and you managed to do you rendition of the melody. So don't listen to the others, they're just trolling! And it's a beautiful guitar, by the way :) I haven't seen a guitar like it!

Peace out .

[liverpool80000seater]

kuro

[gabrielsaks]

MASTER!!!!!!!!!

[ccmoyls]

he didnt play it right

[lucypinkfloyd]

no inventes el final es una porqueria

o.0

[tomtomwolfwolf]

is that adn 8 string guitar??

anyway you play it great but wrong.

especialy the ending

[FlyingSquirreI]

i love your technique and how you posture yourself playing the guitar. for those who don't know, check out his right hand technique. for this song i see countless people leaving their pinky resting on the guitar making the vibrations from the guitar sound wack :P i like how your finger style, however.. the tabs for this song is horribly incorrect. you played it well, but this version isn't close to the original!!

[Marisa799]

Flying squirrel, that sounds strange, like he plays it sounds exactly the same as on a live recording I have from Pink Floyd ("The Wall")!! Look for it, it´s great! Pioneer, I loved the intro!!

[Surfurplex]

@FlyingSquirreI I agree with every word

[al3gzand3r]

the ending's terrible..

[oneznzeroz]

The assholes criticizing probably don't know what an A chord is, go fuck off.

[saladfingers123243]

Fuck the haters man, you played it spot on!

[rehill00]

omg man that was bang on perfect!!!! i salute you dude!!!

[Matsbrbrbrb]

This really sucks! guys, hear the orginal version then you know what i mean ffs. go screw yourself MattHood

[MattHood]

@Matsbrbrbrb you're an idiot troll. please respond to me so i can point this out some more.

[MattHood]

@Matsbrbrbrb P.S. - post your vid of you playing it better on classical guitar. kind of one of the rules of talking shit to somebody if you don't want to come across as a complete ass.

[donottawaguitar]

great stuff merry christmas fromDONOTTAWAGUITAR

[Matsbrbrbrb]

To hell with your version! your destroying a Great song!! Try something else than guitar!!

[MattHood]

@Matsbrbrbrb "you're"

[Cyrus747]

great job!

[Frayzzou]

Congratulazioni, suoni bene ;)

E cosi puo aiutarmi a suonare questa musica =)

[MadSound321]

gj legato slide more faster and its perfect i think

[DaydreamNation8622]

it looks like a bitch to play with that wide neck. props

[xerxerxex]

IIFrankSinatra fuck off man, this is excellent.

[IIFrankSinatra]

It was all wronge i think you should probably not try to play anymore of David Gilmours songs......

[MattHood]

@IIFrankSinatra

next time you try to look like a douchebag, know what you're talking about. this is a waters song. gilmore didn't play it.

[dffctK]

nice cover but you dont play it like the orginal song you miss notes and you play it a littel faster but anyway nice cover :D

[Vanodi]

this is an easy song and you played many parts wrong dude, make sure you can play the song perfectly well before uploading it...

[nautiluspompilus]

too fast ;)

[1StoryMagnet]

@nautiluspompilus you're an ass ; )

[KiaHope]

Complimenti, suoni davvero bene questo pezzo...molto bello

[mguirro1]

Congratulations, you play very well !

Regards,

Roger from Brazil

[asabougies]

I think you played it very well despite all these people on here saying you played it wrong. Is it exactly like pink floyd's version, no but why would we want exact copies of everything. A cover is supposed to be unique and you are unique.

[14AL3X]

@asabougies covers are not unique because they are a different versions of the SAME song but i do agree about that its not a bad thing that its been p,layed differently :)

[asabougies]

@14AL3X I totally agree.

[Coopersboy7]

Hey man sounded good!

[Rovrin2]

you also play it too fast

[ypFr3ncH]

you seem to play alright though you have some work to do but learn the song right you do some noticable mistakes to anybody who has ever heard this song i will upload my cover of it in a few days and send you a link maybe it will help :)

[guitarjunky612]

That is like totally wrong

[valegro93]

ci sono un po' di errorini qua e là comunque niente male.

[jonpbody]

too fast and parts were wrong, but decent

[backulaa]

que fea vercion... wacala...

[Misieek91]

So, where is mistake?

Tell me cuz i want to learn to play it on my guitar...

[tconnsteezy]

the ending was major

[lucifer8912]

I'm really sorry dude, you seem to master the basics of playing guitar, but you don't play the song right at all. Maybe you were nervous or something, but if you do think you played it right, listen to the original please....

[woodsonmovies]

omg that is amazing

[Ladiestreat]

I can play this song with my penis doing the strumming but youtube won't let me post it because of the pornographic nature.

[PsiBrr]

I really enjoyed your interpretation of this fine song!

[CAVERRAT]

la song esta mal tocada sos muy malo para tocar

[pachendrix]

Well, obviously it ain't perfect, plus you seem a little nervous BUT, you did a great job. Really I don't, know why everyone keeps insulting you. You just need a little improvement and you can nail it perfect.

PEACE

[falloutboyfan49]

the solo is wrong

[blakeylad]

If you can't say anything positive, then say nothing at all. Oh and can you give me the link to your version?

[oOMaSuZOo]

I did my version listening the song..you can do it too..

ah, I wasn't serious, his solo isn't perfect but i'm not going to kill he! xD

he only has to listen it better..

Stay rock

[Chewbernaught]

Wouldn't it be hilarious if about 2 millon of us went before parliament and started playing it.

[harimaugoblok]

Superb! Well done...

[jmann57000]

Esta mal ejecutada amigo

[iSheeTzu]

Bravo, questa canzone l'ha suonata una mia amica come esame in terza media. L'aveva sentita all'esame di un'altra tizia quando eravamo in prima e aveva deciso di farla anche lei. Stupenda questa canzone, davvero.

[jnjoblon]

Close, listen harder to the song.

[masterxz1]

What version are you playing.?

The ending sounded different than what i play.