Pole and line fish can be slow and probably could not keep up to the world demand for tuna. its also an expensive exercise, but along with Hand Lining it is the most environmental way to fish for tuna. owners building P&L vessels should be given all the tax breaks and incentive they need- where as other types of tuna catching vessels should be highly taxed and made to pay extremely high annual license fees to discourage their construction - but that's all wishful thinking it will never happen.
Hits on free schools are also a lot less than hits on FADS. The ratio of success on average for free school fishing is around 50-60% compared to FADS where it success is around 95%. This is the reason FAD's are preferred to fish on rather than free schools. Filling the boat up in 15-17 days fishing on FADS makes business sense compared to 30-35 days fishing on school fish.
It is well known Philippine purse seiners created the Payao (FAD) and that their entire fleet of thousands of small coastal and hundreds of large purse-seiners fish fish on FADS. The truth is that fishing on free schools is an art and many Philippine captains would not have any idea on how to fish on Free Schools.
i havent brought any tuna or cod for around five years these enginered industrial big boy boats have something to answer for this is greenpeace acting like industry we need to eat smaller fishso even if you have an osteo codition the throwback problem needs dealing with hhhmm how much does it take to fed a couple of cats over a lifetimemaybe they could be trained to eat pigeons
@shri03992 - and the more people that recognise this and reflect it in their buying then the sooner the whole market will move to pole-line - supermarkets will soon get the message if the non-pole line tins are left on the shelf. Just spending 5 seconds making the right choice in the supermarket can exert real pressure to change this industry - check the tin and ensure you pick the pole-line caught fish.
Fair enough that use of FADs attracts a diverse range of fish and therefore increases the risk of by-catch, and avoiding use of FADs helps to reduce this. However, where tuna schools to occur and can be targeted by purse-seine nets they will often be targeting schools of prey species themselves, and this attracts other fish varieties, sharks and dolphins, so there is still a significant risk of by-catch. The optimal fishing technique in my opinion is pole-line caught fish.
@LouisianaGatorGirl there should be a complete ban on tuna fishing for a couple or more years with gradual return to sustainable fishing.When they bitch about losing employment, the answer is there will be no employment for eternity in that field once the tuna go extinct, better to sit out for a few years for the population to recover.These fishermen should then be employed in programs to help tuna stocks to recover.Has worked with tribals in many developing countries who used to hunt them b4.
poor fishes
soulreaperichig0 1 month ago
Pole and line fish can be slow and probably could not keep up to the world demand for tuna. its also an expensive exercise, but along with Hand Lining it is the most environmental way to fish for tuna. owners building P&L vessels should be given all the tax breaks and incentive they need- where as other types of tuna catching vessels should be highly taxed and made to pay extremely high annual license fees to discourage their construction - but that's all wishful thinking it will never happen.
CemyDonger 2 months ago
Hits on free schools are also a lot less than hits on FADS. The ratio of success on average for free school fishing is around 50-60% compared to FADS where it success is around 95%. This is the reason FAD's are preferred to fish on rather than free schools. Filling the boat up in 15-17 days fishing on FADS makes business sense compared to 30-35 days fishing on school fish.
CemyDonger 2 months ago
It is well known Philippine purse seiners created the Payao (FAD) and that their entire fleet of thousands of small coastal and hundreds of large purse-seiners fish fish on FADS. The truth is that fishing on free schools is an art and many Philippine captains would not have any idea on how to fish on Free Schools.
CemyDonger 2 months ago
i havent brought any tuna or cod for around five years these enginered industrial big boy boats have something to answer for this is greenpeace acting like industry we need to eat smaller fishso even if you have an osteo codition the throwback problem needs dealing with hhhmm how much does it take to fed a couple of cats over a lifetimemaybe they could be trained to eat pigeons
psyclonought22 2 months ago
Dont support commercially caught fish
CATCH YOUR OWN!
like I do :)
alekscee 2 months ago
There's just a simple solution: Don't eat any fish!
They feel pain and fear as we do.
natija08 2 months ago 5
@u4987 I totally agree with you! pole-line catching is the only option and I'm always glad to pay more for these fish
shri03992 2 months ago
@shri03992 - and the more people that recognise this and reflect it in their buying then the sooner the whole market will move to pole-line - supermarkets will soon get the message if the non-pole line tins are left on the shelf. Just spending 5 seconds making the right choice in the supermarket can exert real pressure to change this industry - check the tin and ensure you pick the pole-line caught fish.
u4987 2 months ago
Fair enough that use of FADs attracts a diverse range of fish and therefore increases the risk of by-catch, and avoiding use of FADs helps to reduce this. However, where tuna schools to occur and can be targeted by purse-seine nets they will often be targeting schools of prey species themselves, and this attracts other fish varieties, sharks and dolphins, so there is still a significant risk of by-catch. The optimal fishing technique in my opinion is pole-line caught fish.
u4987 2 months ago 4
When Mankind has poisoned the last River and chopped down the last Tree he will learn that money can not be eaten.
BrowseMyChannel 2 months ago 14
@BrowseMyChannel Let's make sure that does not happen!
isakohrlund 2 months ago
There is no such thing as "sustainable" tuna fishing. Tuna stocks are depleted worldwide and the fish are in danger of extinction.
LouisianaGatorGirl 2 months ago 3
@LouisianaGatorGirl there should be a complete ban on tuna fishing for a couple or more years with gradual return to sustainable fishing.When they bitch about losing employment, the answer is there will be no employment for eternity in that field once the tuna go extinct, better to sit out for a few years for the population to recover.These fishermen should then be employed in programs to help tuna stocks to recover.Has worked with tribals in many developing countries who used to hunt them b4.
sushanalone 2 months ago
@sushanalone* used to hunt them b4, them=creatures they are now conserving.
sushanalone 2 months ago