Hilary Duff Beat Of My Heart Live

[EvelynOM]

I love her because she has an actual voice! She is great, like if u agree!

[EvelynOM]

Like if u r watching in 2012!

[HilaryDuffARG]

The girl at the end isn't Haylie or Britney, she's TAYLOR.

[heleneaware]

She looks embarrased here but she's not that shy.

[ThereforeStand]

wow the words to this song are hard,I could never memorize it

[munroG7]

@ThereforeStand are you serious ? my first language's spanish AND I can memorize it xD

[tenzintenzin]

THE DANCERS. I just nearly died laughing

[GirlGoneJuicy25]

Those dancers looked stupid..no offense

[Alexzandraponce]

lets jump like bunny rabbits lets jump like bunny rabbits i have scary dancers oh yea eh yeaa

[checkmarkedprod]

I love Hilary even though shes clearly not singing live here and I don't blame her.. This song is ugly. The words are stupid and the notes are weird. Hahah I also love at the end when they showed that random girl who WAS NOT haylie duff

[Xnico29]

para los que dicen que ella no canta en vivo, como no se va a escuchar igual si su voz no es falsa como britney gaga madonna katy etc, ella xtina y demmi son las mejores

[PiliBadili]

The dancers make me scared...

[PiliBadili]

The dancers make me scared...

[ZombieGamer5k]

This was back then when people could sing.

[mermaidified]

Does anyone else realize that she's lip singing? Rediculous.

[Princezza0]

@mermaidified she isn't ;)

[MissDignity90]

‎.. beat of my ❤ ..

[mach65337]

lame

[philipearlwilliams]

i love hilary .. she is soo talented ♥

[miaspell]

i loove her hand at 2:55 its soo tiny and beautiful!! love hilary duff <<3<3<3

[jintheband]

she sounds amazing and it was an awesome performance!!!

[DrSeussPwns]

I thought it was kind of a

cute performance.

It sounds like the only possible

'live' part was the 'Away, away' part.

[jintheband]

@DrSeussPwns

yup

[GOREFANATIC27]

she did really good singing.... its just....the dancers WTF!?

[stereospotlight]

lmao WHAT THE HELL ARE THE DANCERS DOING!



[saentific]

lololol

Black and white XP

Just kidding, I love her singing.

[RoxyRockz360]

She sounds exactly like on her album! :D

[bevsrogan]

LOL THE DANCERS!

[DuffSpiriana]

stuepndaaaaaaaaaaaa

[Jarviness]

how did she get away with this shit for so long im sorry i love her and her music..but its really not her singing i hope everyone knows that i just looked at like 100 videos of her live and she never really sings she will sing the beginning of fly/ and cuts some parts out of it cuz she cant hit the notes.and when she does sing live she looks sooo awkward

[cookierockstar8]

@Jarviness u do know that none of the non talnted poser singers u like can never come close 2 her singing and besides she was better than the singers now and days that cant sing at all like miley cyrus and katy perry

[cookierockstar8]

@Jarviness u do know that none of the non talnted poser singers u like can never come close 2 her singing and besides she was better than the singers now and days that cant sing at all like miley cyrus and katy perry and i think she sounds just like the cd get that shit out of ur ears!!

[beckyjokerwhite]

@Jarviness thankyou finally sme1 talkin sense - most of her songs if u get sme1 who is trained in singing she is basically singing a note n then it goes an octive higher n then back to the same note again - i liek hilary duffi do but shses not a naturel singer at all - i just looked at alot of her videos and they are all lip sinked but hey if youve ever tryed singing live its alot harder than it looks and for sme1 who is not a naturel singer shes doin fine n also guilty pleasure i gto her album

[xOtaliOx]

she IS lipsyncing. A majority of Pop artists do, she is. :P

[selenague]

@xOtaliOx no she isnt if she did how come in t begining when she said to te beat of my heart it dint sound like a radio type in t album

[silentbrax1]

@xOtaliOx

it is real live

can you proof it?

[americanidolfan55]

@silentbrax1  its identical to her album, and even the best singers don't sound exactly identical to their albums.

[KanonPk]

TE AMO HILARY PORQUE TUVISTE QUE CASARTE !! :(

Bueno solo queda decirte Que Seas Muy FELIZ !!! T_T

[IloveHilaryandAshley]

Hilary Duff is my role model!

[Sassypug2]

Hilary is really singing she just plays the the background part of the real song. Big whoop..shes STILL singing. The only thing it says in the background is "to the beat of my" So shuy up and face the fact that shes really singing. Go away haters.

[SarahElaine1]

I want that outfit. Or at least the boots.

[hilarysfun]

i think joel madden said "she's Hot" at 3:45 lol

[MzTwinkle100]

@hilarysfun it sure did look like it

[TheGizmo4382]

Tat girl at the end was in no way in Hell Haylie Duff. Haylie resembles a horse. This chick looks like Kelly Clarkson or maybe Julia Stiles.

[daviddiabetik]

This was all live you idiots. This was at the American Music Awards, which doesn't allow people to lip sync. You can hear this better if you go watch @marronero video of this. Plus when she steps over her voice goes down because she almost trips on one of them. Stop trying to bash her. She sings amazing live.

[BlackSkullz09]

only live part is wen she yells 'i went away', everything was playback

[BlackSkullz09]

omffg this isnt live , its playback track that is filterd without the cd music. it's too ovious she doesnt even pull the mic from her face. hilary stop lip syncing i can tell you are doin it lol im not easily fooled

[LARockHeart]

Pretty sure thats not Haylie Duff :s It looks nothing like her!

[debbie264]

the dancers seriously made me lol and then lol some more. Love her shoes!!

[fame0506]

She's just...... AMAZING !

[TexasLover7]

was that really her sister at 3:40? It sure doesn't look like her.

[TexasLover7]

catchy tune!

[CodyBabii4evaa47]

america's sweetheart :)

[therealALYS09]

you can tell this one is live but there is another one where her hair is in a pony tail and you can tell she is lip synching there

whatever she did a good job i still love her

[zulemanice]

Muy bien Hilary duff me fascina este video... Lo que más me gusta es su vestuario muy bello yo quieroooooooooooo

[TheGizmo4382]

Hilary does sound pretty good in this but she looks like she had a rough night. Her hairs messed up her eyes are all poofy and her dress makes her look like a skank. And that ain't Hailey at the end.

[nenita1793]

wow first time i actually hear her sing live...

[emo4053]

the dancers are awesome 

[emo4053]

shes really good at singing live

[jacobsgirl1391]

Hilary Duff is a very few people who CAN sing live.. She is amazing i have looked up to her while growing up. still amazing and i hope she keeps going.

[destinywwwwww]

it is live because as she sings the away part in the middle of the song you can hear her take a breath

[h44512]

shes awesome liveeee. and ive actually seen herrr, so i can say that :)

[TheNivKo]

Hilary and the dancers are amazing... bue the choreography's rediculous :X

[perdedora123]

I LOOVVEEE her back up dancers

[SyedaLittleOne4Life]

Awesome!!! I Love Hilary she performs sooooo good unlike other singers like miley,selena, etc....

[LoveAj03]

@SyedaLittleOne4Life Thank You, lol. Good comment!

[SyedaLittleOne4Life]

@LoveAj03 Ur welcome!!

[SyedaLittleOne4Life]

@LoveAj03 Ur welcome!!

[LoveAj03]

@SyedaLittleOne4Life Haha.. Have a nice day.

[daniel15jeims]

guauuuuuuuu q belleza de mujerrrrrrrrrrrrrr

[Crossfire92x]

This just might be live.....

[TheQueeenb]

Hilary Duff is absolutley AMAZING

[Jridden2009]

lol Whats up with that choreography??? the song is a hit

[dudette1113]

I remember seeing this preformance when I was little, I was disgusted with it because of 1:31 to 1:37

haha wasn't I a prude child? irs nooo biggie now!!

[OhhFantastic]

This was so awful... the singing was okay (not sure if she lip synced it or not though), but her performance overall was just awful. She walked around a bit, stepped over a few dudes, walked around some more, attempted some pathetic dance moves... and the dancing in the back was atrocious. I love Hilary Duff with all my heart, but this sadly looked like a joke.

[OhhFantastic]

Grow up, dude.

[TheGizmo4382]

Whoever did the choreography for the dancers should be executed. They look stupid.

[kimbizzler89]

i love this performance!!! but those male dancers crack me up :) love u hilary!

[4066jks]

@happyorangey12 lol thats just gross!!!! lol

[isaboo2]

the way she hold's the micro is like she doesn't us to realize she is lipsinging...

[PiliTatiMissesJonas]

Aw is awesome

[TheGjkcity]

she rocks

[doegrl103]

I just have to say...that's not her really singing! She is lip singing!

I have been to one of her concerts and she did NOT sing good at all!

Not live at least...sorry

[omfgplea]

For some reason I feel like the corp. that distributed this video dubbed it with a prerecorded audio track.

[lladyhope]

yay! haha =) i love this :p

[DJMusic16]

This is my favorite performance from her.

[TheGizmo4382]

She looks like she had a rough night and she sounds horrible. Just saying.

[webothcried]

she is real singing.she's a good live singer though.

[1issi]

i tihnk this is actually her

[Airallstar]

dat wasn't haylie duff at the end, it doesn't look like her at least in this video

[KynsleyOmega]

Loved this Vid and the song but...WHAT THE HECK?!?! That Was NOT Haylie Duff...lol

[gymelissa01]

the man dancers made me giggle

[StoneyEnd444]

is she lip syncing?

[nklover24]

gud song..the men behind her are acting crazy! lol

[whopppie]

how long ago was this she is so young hee and this song was out years ago

[worldcomander]

GOD! i want this drum set!!!

[lerileria]

hahahahahhahahhahahha 1:43 her dancers are so strange :) hhahaha

[punkbasuriego666]

1:11 haHAHHAHA her dancers look so stupid

[Almajhool2008]

@punkbasuriego666

you right LOOOL

[y98741g]

@punkbasuriego666 I agree, Til 1:18 I cant stop laughing. lol

[amandaandconniemedia]

lol shes not lipsynching this time, in everyone of her live performance's she lipsynchs but this time shes not cuz her voice dosen't sound exactly like the track

[hilarycutie45]

fuck off she does not lip sing asshole

[whopppie]

hey is that really haylie duff at the end cos it looks nothing like her

[ohhemgeeitzmickey]

ur right.

[susoy]

Sorry to say, but she does in recent videos I've seen. =(

[whopppie]

that serously can't be her cos he face and hair look nothing lik her

[hollistorlover]

pretty girl but very weak voice.

[1DanielChristensen]

Yes that is true; her voice is in the sixth octave range. And the upper fifth but not as naturally sounding.

[KevAnime]

this is one of my favorites performances!... and this is NOT Playblack, ok?

I love Hilary!

[1992kkw]

nice dress

[taliptain]

well shes not the best singer in the industry ..but at least she can sing live well

[izzahpinkybuterfly]

hilary duff really greta in singing live

[1hilaryfan4life]

that wasnt haylie it was one of their friends... i wonder what haylie thought. lol

[xSopxiex]

This is friggin cool....If you're familiar with the original version then you can tell she's really singing and she sounds fine. Hilary is a gem.

[jubbzy09]

i dont think that it was haylie...

and she can sing...i think she was really good

[0212Camilla]

she singing horrible!i not undrestand,t´hat she is singer

[thanz33]

her voice is very bad !!! my god!!

[LennoxA777]

she really good

[HugeFanOfBritney]

huys,this is exactly same as the cd version,they just make Hilary's voice clearly so it sounds live but it's not live! I know she can sing but this is not live,ok?

[CATKILLTHEMALL]

YOU CAN"T FUCK WITH HILARY DUFF!!!

[DignityB19]

I KNOW RIGHT?! Hilary Duff is absolutley AMAZING

[teesa2009]

that was haley at the end?? o.O it didnt look like her at all

[stephenwee]

Jesus i just realised how silly the dancers are in the background after watching this video for years now haaha (: I love this performance :D

[hilaryannduff22]

lol at the end thats not her sister

[renlex]

you should know this girl can really sing, i thought she was one of the hundreds pop stars that sounded great on the album but shit live, but if you get to see more videos of her live, like the aol sessions, you'll see what i'm talking about, she sings so good that it'll be really hard to tell if she's doing playback or singing live =)

[xxxJewBoyxxx]

HAHAHA Those dancers are fucking amazing! Hilary did a great job. :D

[XxlozxX123]

can i also say if its not live how come shes proper out of breath at the end..

[gengy100]

bellaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

[mileycxfan]

i loooooove this song

[TheSweetB]

This IS live

[JeffreyJ4242]

Songs a bit annoying.said Beat of my heart like a billion times in this song. I know it's the title but it's a little too repetitive. Good singing though at least :)

[XDarkFantasyX01]

i agree..this is not even one of her best songs in my opinion (a million thumbs down coming my way lol ) (:

[1DanielChristensen]

Nope, 4 months later; and all you've got is one thumb up; by me.

[XDarkFantasyX01]

thank you!

[1DanielChristensen]

your welcome!

[smallsponge1]

I HATE DUFF!!! this isn't even LIVE!

[crazymalala]

She's falling? WTF? O.o I almost die laughing here hahahahahahahahaha

[crazymalala]

LIVE? HAHA is a joke? Obviosly this is playback; She can't sing live... her voice is a fu***** shit!

[XxlozxX123]

if shes shit then im taller then the twin towers when they wer still standin the only thing thats full of shit is you,, you dont go to the toilet enough mate

[HDrocks92]

how can she be lip singing if shes out of breath in the end

[sharonwillmann]

wow shes good as.xx

[mevrouwtaart]

She's such a good singer that you can't tell when she's singing live or playbacking. And here she's obviously singing live.

[Crossfire92x]

Yep, it's live.

[irakooo]

at least lindsay sang live...

[britneyrox93]

Yeah shes got some work done to her face!

but i love you Hilary!!

[mikespikekite]

she did really really good!! better than any of you guys that are saying shit about her. she is really professional and has improved so much.and this is live because when she yells AWAY AWAY she cuts off her voice before she is supposed to because she ran a little out of breath.

[Kinggeek12]

shes good a good voice, better legs and if her cd went No.1 then she does not even recognition as a bonafide pop star

[HugeFanOfBritney]

Hilary,you CAN sing 4 sure,why use playback?

[bayismail93]

lukeBam totally has a point and she naturally has a great voicee GOO HILARYY

[toxicobritney]

This is obviously PLAYBACK!!!

the song is recorder whit another differents sounds!! PLAYBACK!!!

[Crossfire92x]

Believe it or not, it's live. The sound is distinct from the playback...She did a great job.

[WittyDuchess23]

She hasnt lost her fame at all!! JUST GOTTEN BETTER. i luv her :]] keep rockin on hilary. p.s. ur rlly preetyyy love th heels.

[lukeBAM]

at 1:32 you hear the volume of the microphone lower as she steps over one of the dancers. it's live.

[tomyorke26]

I Love Her, I Really Lover Her.

[dktaipapalet12kew]

she's good live

[cRaZyPuNkR3beL]

I think this is her actual voice, she IS singing live, the difference b/t the cd and this performance was clear to me, but that's just my opinion lol She sounds good live btw xD

[claire846]

what happened to the drum part. it made it sound a lot better. it seems like something is missing big time. hilary rocks

[jonathonamy]

1. Take a deep breath

2. Think about the one you love

3. Press ''F10'' 5 time

4. Send it to 5 video on youtube

5. Look at your background

[drops00pool]

バックダンサーが面白すぎるｗｗｗｗ

[HelenJGzmn]

I LOVEE HER SINGING THIS !!

[ESP4382]

She looks trashy in that dress. Any higher and you can see her "stuff".

[Touchy57]

Lol,don't be mean,she was obviously loking 4 her own style:d.Love the song,such a shame "at the time' Hilary didn't really sing during 'live performances'.

[alanacarr]

wow she is totaly lipsincing

notice how this sounds EXACTLY like the cd

[15joel22]

luv hilary she can be with jesse!!

[ESP4382]

She should be with Jesse instead of that loser hockey player she's dating. What is he, like 35? Or I'd date her. :)

[dktaipapalet12kew]

who jessE?

[StrangeRapunzel]

she cant sing, but she's a nice girl

[480singa14]

i love this song... and her boots((:

[TennisProducer]

Song is a lovely one... But...... the live performance is a little..... xxxxxx

Well... that explains everything! Right?

[dopeclown]

boring as hell

[KarsTeM22]

canta bn pero la presentacion 0 aporte pf

[lukeBAM]

listen to 2:20 onwards it deffo is.

[lukeBAM]

don't like her but i think this is live coz the start usualy starts off techno dosnt it?