I like the french version better- I am sorry, but while this cover has a beautiful voice, she has absolutely no emotion in her voice at all- it seems so determined to hit the notes the words lose their meaning...
Lovely lovely song! I have the Notre Dame de Paris cast recording in English. It always help me calm down. Thanks for uploading some of the performances!
Prefiero la italiana, pero la voz en ingles me gusta mucho. Es una lastima que al no ser una lengua romance (como el italiano, el español, el frances) no pueda ponerse a la altura de estas versiones, pero la verdad es que la voz es preciosa. Simplemente, el idioma no casa mucho con la historia, a pesar de que el inglés me encanta. La voz expresa mucho mas que la francesa de todos modos, pero claro ese es el talon de aquiles de esa version: la interpretación es muy mala, no dice nada.
no really, I found every version very beautiful but italian one is something wonderfull! Specially characters like Gringoire, Frollo and Fiordaliso... :D If you want, watch songs as "Val d'amore", "mi distruggerai" and "la cavalcatura" =) [this is just my point of view]
@BlackMambaKillsBill The Italian versione's the best!!! Zigara, a nessuno io parlo di me... zingara, zingara... la mia mano sa tutto... di me!! and then i'm italian^^ I love sing the italian version! Maybe i'ts for that that i love my langue version:D
I'm sorry but the French version is the best by far...the words are not quite so beautiful in English and so much meaning is lost. This is lovely, but just not the same.
wow this song is soo cool this song is sooooo great for my french musical in my school!!!! and i am esmeralda and i love this song the most some people might think its stupid but i dont.
is it so important?i think in some pieces it's pretty dynamic,moving like i would like to dance to this song, if Ave Maria is queit, calm this is pretty dynamic from 2:44 to my mind!And sound is like become stronger and stronger it's not only about beauty but about rhythm too!Anyway i feel like that.Especially it's in russian versions(they are more passionate)
no i agree the staging is stagnant but you do know this video is just a voice over there isnt an english video so i coiuldnt say, i will have to have a look at the russian version :)
ok i am a self confessed lover of the music however this entire musical is so repetitive its verging stupid! it seems they only had a few ideas and ran out of time to develop! maybe not this song actually but the majority of all the other songs are!
okay people, everyone is good with thier own opinion but i think after so long we start to get that everyone likes the French one better, heck even i do! but i think after twenty million times of people saying it i think everyone gets it! and the vidio is great! :)
fantastica voce questa tina arena. peccato solo che è stata montata sulle immagini francesi, dato che a livello interpretativo sono i meno riusciti... l'unica cosa buona della versione francese erano proprio le voci, dato che questo è un doppiaggio sarebbe stato meglio scegliere la versione che dava di più in espressività (italiano e coreano, a mio parere...!)
I like the French version better, I think. Though I like Tina's voice better than Helene's. Tina's voice it's much stronger, and eventhough Helena's tender sound is very pretty, I think the strong sound fits a gypsy girl better...
I like the french version better- I am sorry, but while this cover has a beautiful voice, she has absolutely no emotion in her voice at all- it seems so determined to hit the notes the words lose their meaning...
ShatteredxSpiritx 1 month ago
Beautiful song both in French and English.
laurenguthrie85 4 months ago
飯島 愛・・・
ここに隠れていたんだね・・・
早く出てこいよ・・・
RATIONALRDZ 5 months ago
sounds like Tina Arena
miar0xurj0x 8 months ago
@miar0xurj0x it's tina arena !
maryg12121985 7 months ago
i love you :)) can't find these songs anywhere until I reached here
is it possible I can have all the English songs pls? Nowhere's selling the CD at my place and I can't buy online :(
Starlight007 10 months ago
@Starlight007 type in google "youtube to mp3" and you'll find couple of sites converting vids to mp3s. Sorry but I can't send them by email
Cossynieur 10 months ago
La voix de Tina me rappelle celle de Noa
Loubna59 1 year ago
The translation is wrong. Very, very wrong. They changed it so it'd rhyme. The French version is so much better.
PoisonedTongue 1 year ago
Lovely lovely song! I have the Notre Dame de Paris cast recording in English. It always help me calm down. Thanks for uploading some of the performances!
29DramaQ 1 year ago
Prefiero la italiana, pero la voz en ingles me gusta mucho. Es una lastima que al no ser una lengua romance (como el italiano, el español, el frances) no pueda ponerse a la altura de estas versiones, pero la verdad es que la voz es preciosa. Simplemente, el idioma no casa mucho con la historia, a pesar de que el inglés me encanta. La voz expresa mucho mas que la francesa de todos modos, pero claro ese es el talon de aquiles de esa version: la interpretación es muy mala, no dice nada.
Nana1990sama 1 year ago
I Like this version *-*
But I still prefer the italian one... ^^
Muartua97 1 year ago
One of the best song translated among the english versions. They raped "Belle", but this one is very beautiful in english.
LadyQGinny 1 year ago
where my story begeeeens
Liddaofzo 1 year ago
"I was born on a road that bends"? Really?
juliajones92 1 year ago 5
I love Tina's voice !! It's different from the french version, but not less good!
jenilly20 1 year ago
The french version is the best.
glousman62 1 year ago
no really, I found every version very beautiful but italian one is something wonderfull! Specially characters like Gringoire, Frollo and Fiordaliso... :D If you want, watch songs as "Val d'amore", "mi distruggerai" and "la cavalcatura" =) [this is just my point of view]
BlackMambaKillsBill 2 years ago
@BlackMambaKillsBill The Italian versione's the best!!! Zigara, a nessuno io parlo di me... zingara, zingara... la mia mano sa tutto... di me!! and then i'm italian^^ I love sing the italian version! Maybe i'ts for that that i love my langue version:D
mffcastle27 1 year ago
@mffcastle27 sono d'accordissimo con te :D I'm italian too :)
BlackMambaKillsBill 1 year ago
i love this song its amazing my friend got me hooked on it lol
clowcole 2 years ago
Tina a une voix magnifique mais la version francaise est bien meilleure.
2emma1 2 years ago 2
Would be nice to have the english lyrics
Livelovecherishelife 2 years ago
Voila ;)
Cossynieur 2 years ago
Hard for me to hear this version, I start singing the French lyrics instead...xDD...god though :D
BurningCorsets104 2 years ago
italians!!!
eleonoya 2 years ago
iTALiANi SUPERiORi!
WrEnAtOzErO 2 years ago
bellisimaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
esmeraldina90 2 years ago 2
Any music-store or check the musical-store.
southafricaness76 2 years ago
I'm sorry but the French version is the best by far...the words are not quite so beautiful in English and so much meaning is lost. This is lovely, but just not the same.
msxxaliciaxxj 2 years ago 30
@msxxaliciaxxj I agree perfectly. This version is nice, but the French version is so much more beautiful, not to mention it sounds better in French!
crazyloverofcats 1 year ago
mmmh...I'm sorry, Italians do it better! xD
707nana91 2 years ago
Or maybe you could upload the music from here dunno how you do that?
southafricaness76 2 years ago
Her voice is beautiful...
dansleau778 2 years ago 4
wow this song is soo cool this song is sooooo great for my french musical in my school!!!! and i am esmeralda and i love this song the most some people might think its stupid but i dont.
lalehk1 2 years ago 3
it's not stupid at all, very dymanic and beautiful song!
0Immortelle0 2 years ago
how exactly is this song dynamic ??? its beautiful but its anything but dynamic!
pineapplenum1 2 years ago
is it so important?i think in some pieces it's pretty dynamic,moving like i would like to dance to this song, if Ave Maria is queit, calm this is pretty dynamic from 2:44 to my mind!And sound is like become stronger and stronger it's not only about beauty but about rhythm too!Anyway i feel like that.Especially it's in russian versions(they are more passionate)
0Immortelle0 2 years ago 2
and may be if u saw like Svetlana Svetikova dances or Diana Saveleva u would agree coz Helena is just walking and so does Lola
0Immortelle0 2 years ago
no i agree the staging is stagnant but you do know this video is just a voice over there isnt an english video so i coiuldnt say, i will have to have a look at the russian version :)
pineapplenum1 2 years ago
nevertheless i like Tina Arena and think she is one of the best to my mind=))everyone is good by some thing=)
0Immortelle0 2 years ago 2
ok i am a self confessed lover of the music however this entire musical is so repetitive its verging stupid! it seems they only had a few ideas and ran out of time to develop! maybe not this song actually but the majority of all the other songs are!
pineapplenum1 2 years ago
thats not the actress singing in english its Tina Arena cause ive got the cd!
iluvhopndballet 2 years ago
where did you get hold of the english version because i cant find it ANYWHERE!
pineapplenum1 2 years ago
well ive got the cd! English version starring tina arena and garou (esmeralda and quasimodo respectively)!
iluvhopndballet 2 years ago
how!!! lol and where ive actually searched all over london can get hold of it!
pineapplenum1 2 years ago
Hi, I'm not sure where you live, but if you live in London you can get the CD from any music-shop or search the net for the original London cast.
Starring Tina Arena, and the other CAnadian girl St.Pierre?
southafricaness76 2 years ago
yeah ive tried literally everywhere will give the internet a go thanks for your help
pineapplenum1 2 years ago
Really???? Oh Gosh!!
There isn't writen on the description!
By the description:
French video with English dubbing. Esmeralda: Helene Segara (voice: Tina Arena) Song taken from London cast CD
DavisBlue 2 years ago
i really like this one
angelgurl10145 3 years ago
i love her voice but for some reason, i dont think her style fits this show. too showtune-y?
jae149 3 years ago 21
@jae149 I agree, her voice is OK, but she's NOTHING like Helene Segara.. not even close..
rosamirafly 1 year ago
She is preety good. 5 stars.
longman718 3 years ago
Oh!Very beautyful!
Ayssel07 3 years ago
where's the short solo Phoebus has before this song where he asks Esméralda where she's from?
donfrollo2 3 years ago
I love this video! But do you have a video of the dialogue between Phoebus and Esmerelda before she starts singing the Bohemienne song?
firestar54 3 years ago
La version française de "Bohémienne" est plus jolie à entendre que celle en anglais. =/
19Kuremansu 3 years ago 5
J'adore la version francaise...mais je pense que Tina a un bon voix aussi.
Tallonest 3 years ago 3
okay people, everyone is good with thier own opinion but i think after so long we start to get that everyone likes the French one better, heck even i do! but i think after twenty million times of people saying it i think everyone gets it! and the vidio is great! :)
OracleKiya 3 years ago 3
bello... e poi c'è helene che a mio parere è la più brava interpretatice di esmeralda.... davvero... la più brava bohemienne....
bohemienne19621994 3 years ago
fantastica voce questa tina arena. peccato solo che è stata montata sulle immagini francesi, dato che a livello interpretativo sono i meno riusciti... l'unica cosa buona della versione francese erano proprio le voci, dato che questo è un doppiaggio sarebbe stato meglio scegliere la versione che dava di più in espressività (italiano e coreano, a mio parere...!)
ragnettopaladino 3 years ago
I like the french one better, but her voice is amazing.
lymangirl123 3 years ago 2
I think that the french sounds better but the voice in this one is nice.
buttmuncher13 3 years ago
I like the French version better, I think. Though I like Tina's voice better than Helene's. Tina's voice it's much stronger, and eventhough Helena's tender sound is very pretty, I think the strong sound fits a gypsy girl better...
Chajagirl 3 years ago
I have the same opinion!
The French Version fits better, but the voice of the english woman is much better and prettier than the one of Helene's!
pooja6515 3 years ago 2
i hate the english bit it so much better in french!
fruitbowl123 4 years ago
I couldn't agree with you more
TwilightGeisha 4 years ago 2
The French version is realy better in spite of I dont understand french nothing.
Kludis 3 years ago 2
I don't understand French either.
TwilightGeisha 3 years ago
exactly. lol.
tingobingo09 3 years ago
beautifle
crazychicken332 4 years ago
it's not english it's french videoa (helene segara and julie zenati) with english voices ... really ugly.
of course helene segara and julie zenati sings in french but not in this ugly montage.
leojenaceb 4 years ago
it's english, obvious
AnaVonSlyth 4 years ago
thanks for trying but this is actually the french video lol
glorialucia 4 years ago
No.... duh....
It's nice to hear the English version! Thanks for posting.
They do perform this play in English, Russian and Italian as well as the original French. There is all 4 versions of each song.
Vancy17 4 years ago 2
dont forget spanish :)
glorialucia 4 years ago 2
and korean
joyhorse13 3 years ago
im a fanatic if the show... I your stating what I already know... thank you
What I DONT know xD is if it's tour at all now or anytime soon? anwers anyone????
glorialucia 3 years ago
don't forget the Korean version:)
joyhorse13 3 years ago
She is singing in french, it is obvious.
Rogerisateur100AD 4 years ago
When I can get this DVD?
And does she singing in English?
Lihie 4 years ago
Probably the only song to rival the original in French! I think Tina does a great job here!
Nilie 4 years ago 3
When was this filmed?
(I want to buy the rigth dvd)
DKzina 4 years ago
i love that you post these in english because they're hard to find. Although I love the french version the best. Thanks!!
TheUsedAngel 4 years ago 2