Unfortunately some of his followers told me once "whosoever doen't read the risale i nur is an ignorant".. i told him "ive read the glorious quran" No other books compares to it
@DJSHAHIR of course but bur risales are explanation of quran, a key to get deeper and deeper into it. this rises the value of quran, and directs us to read more and care about quran. and we know that we cant learn every detail from it, its a bigger source of everything. sometimes we need a strainer.
@goodideawins First, can you please answer me if i'm ignorant if i don't read the Risale i nur? I don't disagree that if we don't know, we have to ask people who possess the message (as per the quran). How many times they've told me not to read tafseer Ibn Katheer or any other tafseers. That definitely proves that ONLY their way is right according to them. It goes against Said Nursi's teachings that says "you can say you are the best, but you cannot say you are the only one"(something similar)
@DJSHAHIR of course you'll never be an ignorant.. and they may love it so much, but no one has a right to say this. Thus, Risales are written very very close today. So approaches to the material, religion, today's perception, human being, and critisizing with other sciences is more accurate than older (14th century for instance) tafseers. And Risales had opened their eyes inshaallah. THIS is getting them to provide Risales so much. Risales also mentions of other scholar's perspectives.
@DJSHAHIR (2) ...and of course you have the biggest right to read whatever you want. forgive them, they want your goodness, today we as islamic world became weaker than ever happen. So Risales are giving you another "action" behavior to solve things and our problems from minor to major; from person to public, it gives a task everybody to complete. Older sources may not be because of that day's enemies are different of today's. Allah changing time and rivising duties like this.
@goodideawins As a Muslim, i have to forgive my fellow Muslim brethren. Risale i nur is just another explanation. i've read it. No problem with the book itself. Can u please tell me how do they deduce that Said Nursi is the last reviver? different muslims have different opinions.
@DJSHAHIR Said nursi says, "Risale-i nur may probably be the spirit reviver of this age; i am far from it, maybe as i write it down, my life can be a little kernel.(...)i was a kernel, languished and gone. All value is the meaning of precious Quran and its real tafseer, Risale-i nur." if i could translate it correctively, he did never feel any value from himself but he held this and write these books, under arrestments, tortures.. we can say he is a reviver, but he wouldnt like us to argue this.
@DJSHAHIR we sould listen him and care about problems of islam civilization, (as mentioned in "The Damascus Sermon") also by reading solutions of today's perceptions... and take action with peace, opening our hearts; with pleasant language of dialogue to everyone on earth...
Dear brother, ifouzia is right, we cannot say that Allah SWT is everywhere, since that amounts to pantheism (which goes against Islam). Unfortunately, the translator may not have been aware of this and therefore did not correctly translate the words of Bediuzzaman - see 2nd comment:
Bediuzzaman said: "her mekânda hâzır, mekândan münezzeh" - which literally translates to "in every place 'hazir', from every place free/ untainted"
hazir can be translated as "present, in attendance, attending, ready, prepared" - since even bediuzzaman used the words "from every place free/ untainted" - then the word hazir in this case cannot mean present, rather it means something closer to ready/attending - (little bit more)
so He is ever-ready, ever-attending to matters in every place but He Himself is not "present" in it (since He is "free" from it).
I wish the translators would pay more close attention to such things- I know for a fact that some people shy away from reading Risale-i-Nur because they find such grave errors in it, when in fact in Turkish those errors are not really there.
Gerçekten Uğraşılarak Yapılmış Bir Slayt Gösterisi Resim Geçişleri Ve Yazılar Tam Olarak Oturmuş Tabi birde Arka Plandaki Akustik Gitara Deyinmeden Geçemicem Tebrikler Yeni Videolarını Bekliyoruz ...
Unfortunately some of his followers told me once "whosoever doen't read the risale i nur is an ignorant".. i told him "ive read the glorious quran" No other books compares to it
DJSHAHIR 8 months ago
@DJSHAHIR of course but bur risales are explanation of quran, a key to get deeper and deeper into it. this rises the value of quran, and directs us to read more and care about quran. and we know that we cant learn every detail from it, its a bigger source of everything. sometimes we need a strainer.
goodideawins 7 months ago
@goodideawins First, can you please answer me if i'm ignorant if i don't read the Risale i nur? I don't disagree that if we don't know, we have to ask people who possess the message (as per the quran). How many times they've told me not to read tafseer Ibn Katheer or any other tafseers. That definitely proves that ONLY their way is right according to them. It goes against Said Nursi's teachings that says "you can say you are the best, but you cannot say you are the only one"(something similar)
DJSHAHIR 7 months ago
@DJSHAHIR of course you'll never be an ignorant.. and they may love it so much, but no one has a right to say this. Thus, Risales are written very very close today. So approaches to the material, religion, today's perception, human being, and critisizing with other sciences is more accurate than older (14th century for instance) tafseers. And Risales had opened their eyes inshaallah. THIS is getting them to provide Risales so much. Risales also mentions of other scholar's perspectives.
goodideawins 7 months ago
@DJSHAHIR (2) ...and of course you have the biggest right to read whatever you want. forgive them, they want your goodness, today we as islamic world became weaker than ever happen. So Risales are giving you another "action" behavior to solve things and our problems from minor to major; from person to public, it gives a task everybody to complete. Older sources may not be because of that day's enemies are different of today's. Allah changing time and rivising duties like this.
goodideawins 7 months ago
@goodideawins As a Muslim, i have to forgive my fellow Muslim brethren. Risale i nur is just another explanation. i've read it. No problem with the book itself. Can u please tell me how do they deduce that Said Nursi is the last reviver? different muslims have different opinions.
DJSHAHIR 7 months ago
@DJSHAHIR Said nursi says, "Risale-i nur may probably be the spirit reviver of this age; i am far from it, maybe as i write it down, my life can be a little kernel.(...)i was a kernel, languished and gone. All value is the meaning of precious Quran and its real tafseer, Risale-i nur." if i could translate it correctively, he did never feel any value from himself but he held this and write these books, under arrestments, tortures.. we can say he is a reviver, but he wouldnt like us to argue this.
goodideawins 7 months ago
@DJSHAHIR we sould listen him and care about problems of islam civilization, (as mentioned in "The Damascus Sermon") also by reading solutions of today's perceptions... and take action with peace, opening our hearts; with pleasant language of dialogue to everyone on earth...
goodideawins 7 months ago
mashallah!
omerfaruk555 1 year ago
Dear brother, ifouzia is right, we cannot say that Allah SWT is everywhere, since that amounts to pantheism (which goes against Islam). Unfortunately, the translator may not have been aware of this and therefore did not correctly translate the words of Bediuzzaman - see 2nd comment:
ReadSurahsnDuas 1 year ago
Bediuzzaman said: "her mekânda hâzır, mekândan münezzeh" - which literally translates to "in every place 'hazir', from every place free/ untainted"
hazir can be translated as "present, in attendance, attending, ready, prepared" - since even bediuzzaman used the words "from every place free/ untainted" - then the word hazir in this case cannot mean present, rather it means something closer to ready/attending - (little bit more)
ReadSurahsnDuas 1 year ago
so He is ever-ready, ever-attending to matters in every place but He Himself is not "present" in it (since He is "free" from it).
I wish the translators would pay more close attention to such things- I know for a fact that some people shy away from reading Risale-i-Nur because they find such grave errors in it, when in fact in Turkish those errors are not really there.
Selaam aleykum.
ReadSurahsnDuas 1 year ago
cool video
UNSHAQ 2 years ago
This is really pretty and the music is so fitting...but Allah (swt) is not everywhere.
iFouziaLobster 3 years ago
Mashaallah!
Allah razi olsun!
Yeni videolar bekliyoruz, Inshaallah!
AleynaAz 4 years ago
tesekkürler... Elimden geldigince yenilerini yapmaya calisiyorum :)) iki benzer videoyu daha sayfamda bulabilirsiniz...
voldem99 4 years ago
Allah razı olsun...
gerçekten güzel çalışmalar...
tobesaide 4 years ago 2
Gerçekten Uğraşılarak Yapılmış Bir Slayt Gösterisi Resim Geçişleri Ve Yazılar Tam Olarak Oturmuş Tabi birde Arka Plandaki Akustik Gitara Deyinmeden Geçemicem Tebrikler Yeni Videolarını Bekliyoruz ...
barisfirat 4 years ago 2
Maaşallah Kardeş
barisfirat 4 years ago 2