Der 2te Teil flasht einen beim ersten Mal i-wie voll, wenns man noch nicht kennt ;D Ka wie ich jetzt darauf komme Lieder von diesem Cartoon zu gucken ^^" o.o Aber ich kann nicht aufhören ._.
@HalloweenInc Well, I'm assuming it's because English speakers love the feel of the song itself and how the language feels with the song. Germans have heard this all their life, so what doesn't get to the English gets to them, such as how some of the singing is less than stellar and the translation is sometimes worse than YouTube's transcribe audio feature. (I mean, just look at how they say English names which the never bothered to translate!)
I would say it is better if they remove the accent.
They can't reproduce the accent in an other language, and just replacing it with an accent that we have in Germany would sound horrendous. The Fandub of MLP tried an american accent, but that didn't worked well ether in my opinion, especially for the kids is it hard to listen too.
But they did at least tried to give her a hint of an accent, with the choice words and how she speaks, but it really is almost nonexistent.
I think her singing voice is actually better here than in English XD Especially that last note which was always a strain to listen to before.. (still loud of course but less painful xD)
Fluttershys voice is like a nail on a blackboard or piece of glass, it sounds painful.
But Sweetie Belles singing voice is really not bad at all, I quite like it, but I do think it's a bit too adult-sounding for her, especially when she's not singing.
But what I like especially is that you really hear the change in volume in this version, you really feel Sweetie Belle almost yelling/shouting when singing, unlike in the english version where I don't really feel it's sooo loud.
In Germany, Fluttershy is a year younger than you.
Keimori12 1 week ago
Meh...I still prefer english voices
Krati08071995 1 week ago
german flutashy is fine :D
DanielJelonek 2 weeks ago
I like the German version better than the french cause it sounds the most like Sweetie Belles voice.
MsLuna5523 2 weeks ago
The title translates to "Shoo Shoo Lullaby"
xD
xWasabiNekoProx 1 month ago in playlist Liked videos
DAMN! German Sweetie Belle is FINE!
lewa3910 1 month ago
It seems like when songs in English are dubbed over in German they come out ok.
BeautifulObscurity 1 month ago
LOL, is there even a black german accent? oh wait nvm thy all got killed
ModellMeister 1 month ago
@ModellMeister
Uhm, maybe you want to take a look at Sweetie Belle's German voice actor (she also does the singing voice) Giovanna Winterfeldt.
Lusankya2 1 month ago
@Lusankya2 whoa a black german with an italian first name and Prussian last name.
ModellMeister 1 month ago
@ModellMeister
That is absolutly normal in germany...xD
AzureSprite 3 days ago
As if a German lullaby isn't: "ZIZ IS DER DESIGNATET SLEEPINK TIME. YOU WILL SLEEP ACCORDINK TO PROTOCOL. ZAT ISCHT DER RULES."
greenimp111 1 month ago
@greenimp111
Its more like:
"Guten Abend, gute Nacht, mit Rosen bedacht.."
Eckendenker 1 month ago
Wow, I'm seriously impressed. This actually is well done.
donbob 1 month ago
this vid brought me to one conclusion : I MUST LEARN GERMAN ... NOW !!!
ponymcpony 1 month ago
Der 2te Teil flasht einen beim ersten Mal i-wie voll, wenns man noch nicht kennt ;D Ka wie ich jetzt darauf komme Lieder von diesem Cartoon zu gucken ^^" o.o Aber ich kann nicht aufhören ._.
LonleyHeartDream 1 month ago
I'm a german and i don't like the german MLP
felii1 1 month ago
German gospel singer.... o.o
GoTFCanada1230 1 month ago
actually i think this is done pretty well!
ich find das echt ganz gut, kommt recht nah ans original ran :D
RilenaVamira 1 month ago
WOW, die Übersetzung ist echt gelungen.
Eckendenker 1 month ago
They have MLP FiM on NickJR ? *shakes head* I am disappoint.
SpitfirePhantom 1 month ago
@SpitfirePhantom we dont have the Hub :c
Kizuii 1 month ago
it's perfect!
ZeoSuri 2 months ago
Sweetie Belle sounds older, sure. But still, damn that sounded good.
GRFX2510 2 months ago in playlist FiM German
The best sing ever <3
ErithWolf 2 months ago
So the song is the first thing I like in the german version (as a german -.-)
Renekin93 2 months ago
@HalloweenInc Well, I'm assuming it's because English speakers love the feel of the song itself and how the language feels with the song. Germans have heard this all their life, so what doesn't get to the English gets to them, such as how some of the singing is less than stellar and the translation is sometimes worse than YouTube's transcribe audio feature. (I mean, just look at how they say English names which the never bothered to translate!)
inukirby992 2 months ago
The German voices aren't bad actually :D
(Unlike the Dutch >_>)
MatvaNabor 2 months ago
...o_o;;
Damn, that ain't bad at all!
Props to Sweetie Bell's voiceactress,
that came pretty close to the original in my opinion.
I guess usually it's not the actors that do a bad job,
but it simply can't be translated all that well.
...except for the complete lack of any kind of accent.
It may be true every nationality judges accents differently,
but that's no reason to remove em entirely.
Characters like Photo Finish and Applejack are just lacking in german, sadly.
Nephtrien 2 months ago
@Nephtrien
I would say it is better if they remove the accent.
They can't reproduce the accent in an other language, and just replacing it with an accent that we have in Germany would sound horrendous. The Fandub of MLP tried an american accent, but that didn't worked well ether in my opinion, especially for the kids is it hard to listen too.
But they did at least tried to give her a hint of an accent, with the choice words and how she speaks, but it really is almost nonexistent.
KonsolN 2 months ago
Okay sweetie beta...
RedZTag 2 months ago
they play MLP FIM on nick jr?!
FLMovieMaker 3 months ago
Germany appears to be one of the few countries that puts effort into getting their FiM singers.
fxnavarro 3 months ago 7
So, apparently, Germans like the English version better, but Americans like the German version better.
Something isn't quite right with that.
HalloweenInc 3 months ago 7
@HalloweenInc conspiracy keanu moment..
NamxZero 3 months ago
00:11 for a minute I thought she said hey, do you speak kenish? I know it's all in german, but you have to admit...
Imarandomperson1 3 months ago
Seriously... i should post under every German MLP video... The German version sucks! (and im german)
ONeill3007 3 months ago
@ONeill3007 Ich weiß genau was du meinst
Schwertgott 3 months ago
damn...
DrRasenmaher 3 months ago
It's telling that no dub manages to equal the original child VAs. The German CMC voices sound only barely better than the French ones.
slavingerenGerman 3 months ago
Try listening to the french version o.o
supabunny 3 months ago
Sweetie Belle has a manly cough
theprimerib 4 months ago in playlist More videos from Wheeljack2k 7
german fim songs never cease to amaze me.
SillyFillyBrony 4 months ago 52
@SillyFillyBrony im german and for a german...
... IT SUCKS!
The english version is better
julianik07 3 months ago in playlist MLP Music [German]
The vibrato at 0:30 is delicious.
DaemonMcRae 4 months ago in playlist DaemonMcRae's favorites
Kids got the pipes all right. I'd even give the nod to the german version for that note alone.
MattverSSJ3 4 months ago
English is better. :(
fluddly 4 months ago
@fluddly You'r so right!
ThePrincessStars 4 months ago
@ThePrincessStars It's good, but English better :p
fluddly 3 months ago
@fluddly I don't like the german ones.
ThePrincessStars 3 months ago
@ThePrincessStars I only like the opening theme in German.
fluddly 3 months ago 2
I think her singing voice is actually better here than in English XD Especially that last note which was always a strain to listen to before.. (still loud of course but less painful xD)
MizuTakishima3 4 months ago 3
Sweetie belle sounds older than Fluttershy...
sonic7122 4 months ago 78
@sonic7122 Sometimes I think that's the point. Fluttershy is quiet and.. well.. shy. So naturally she'd have a soft, young voice.
001php 3 months ago 6
HOLY CRAP. Sweetie Belle can sing
TalkingRaindrop 4 months ago
I think Sweetie Bell's voice is awesome.
CommanderRizG 4 months ago
Fluttershy's voice actor improved. She is very good now
paxpacis2 4 months ago
Great! Fluttershy is nice too.
nonstopsubber 4 months ago
God I love German. So cool.
CommanderRizG 4 months ago 3
Ich glaube da kann man Wheeljack2k nur recht geben:
Impressing singing voice is impressive. :D
Brascoro 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Fluttershys voice is like a nail on a blackboard or piece of glass, it sounds painful.
But Sweetie Belles singing voice is really not bad at all, I quite like it, but I do think it's a bit too adult-sounding for her, especially when she's not singing.
But what I like especially is that you really hear the change in volume in this version, you really feel Sweetie Belle almost yelling/shouting when singing, unlike in the english version where I don't really feel it's sooo loud.
Dionysus24779 4 months ago
@Dionysus24779 as in the original, her speaking voice is a different actor than the singing ;) but yeah, a lot of the voices sound too old...
elvancor 4 months ago
Comment removed
Dionysus24779 4 months ago