Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (285)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • It looks like she's not singing since 2:08. Just look at her mouth and listen, it sounds totally as the record, and she's not doing that mouth moves she should do for those sounds

  • @AlerSlays Oh my goodness, nit picking a pregnant woman?!? Unbelievable!!! Pay more attention to the music rather than that = =". She sang live here 100%, there are undubbed videos of this show on Youtube, do some research!!!! 2:50 sounds like the recording version my asssss! Get some new ears!!!! Chinese ones are not recommended!!!!

  • @truongphan90 butt-hurt?

  • what an incredible voice !!!!!!!!!

  • She  is SSSSSSSSSSSSOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOO BEAUTIFUL!!

  • Is she fatter than she was!!??? OMG

  • @melanieyoyis are you dumber than you were??? she was pregnant here....idiot

  • Go @MCLAMB4LIFE

  • yupp charice is more better than regine....

  • its like religion how people believe she sings live. Give me one clip of her LIVE performance of Through the Rain. Please. And how am I supposed to believe this is live, when every other performance of hers these days is all lip-synched? tell me.

  • @sohlgh52 She can sing, therefor she can sing live. Its very simple, and irrelevant.

  • @sohlgh52 THEN WHO SANG IT FOR HER IN THE FIRST PLACE BIRD BRAIN???

  • She is one of the VERY FEW that can sing live!

  • Mariah is the best! Merry X-mas everybody.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • no lip sync to this... ABC can pay ^_^

  • she stole me and my friends song! meanie...

  • lol @ 1:09/1:10. The pianist was gettin it! Hahaha He felt that note..

  • @JLoftin1 Uhhh, baby. That's a Hammond B3 he's playin' and Yes. He's jammin'!

  • Mariah Carey and Christina Aguilera are it... best strong voices with amazing range. Beyonce is there too, but there is a teenager that sounds just like her... there is no one in the world that can sound like Mariah or Christina! They are perfection.

  • ohh damn I love this

  • this is my favorite song after O Come All Ye Faithful!! Yeah, truly amazing :)

  • If Mariah act cute when singing an emotional song live it mean she was lipsynch...

    But she moved her hand wildly... :D

    She did it live... :D

  • @steve0ks lolol exactly ull always know when shes syncing or not, when her hands move all over the place its 100% her

  • @DMJV101 Yup, you right. Even I know Mariah was so amazing, sometimes she did lipsynch too... :)

    Look at her hand and her face. If she act cute and always trying to look charming (waving hair, touching hips, move her butt, open her arms like flying, always winking her eyes), it means she lipsynching. But if she looks serious (just open her eyes in a short time, eyebrow look so serious, her hands move in a special way or waving it so wildly), it means that she do it live... :)

  • i think its ridiculous how many people take the time to watch her videos only to comment that she is lip syncing. if these fools heard her album they would see its abundantly clear this is live. mariah is amazing.

  • @MrChrismaniego weh? your just the only one who don't accept the fact that regine's cannot be compared to those 3 divas,, lol,, regine is nothing.. not only the american's that can't accept regine but the entire world,.. !!!coz she's less talented.. accept that!!

  • #1 Queen Forever and always, Forever and always, CRT FOREVER!!!!!! Even past the end of time No one on this entire World can take that away from Thats a TRUE FACT FOREVER CRT FOREVER

  • @Chrismaniego: u are so ignorant. Refine cannot even sing as good as Mariah. Ur also saying Oprah and Foster is using charice to fool u? u don't make any sense. I'm full Filipino who was born in the Philippines. Ur very ignorant, Regine is a nobody and is only a somebody compared to u!

  • @MrChrismaniego Regine cannot be compared to them!! Celine and Mariah are LEGENDS known worldwide for their voices and singing "their own" classic songs. Regine will forever be an irrelevant, "Wannabe" Karaoke Singer" who is only known in Asia. and Charice the first Asian singer in history to land in the Top 10 of the Billboard 200 albums chart, has Regine done that? NO! have a seat!!

  • @MCLAMB4LIFE1 Amen Brother Mariah has more talent in her pinky finger nail than regine has. Plus what songs does regine choose to sing??? Mariah's mostly hmmm... can we say adoration

  • @MCLAMB4LIFE1 Who is Regine ?

    

  • @MCLAMB4LIFE1 hell no, you're so wrong, Regine is very famous.....only in the Philippines, i'm an Asian but she's no one to me LOL

  • @MCLAMB4LIFE1 its true that Regine has no comparison with Mariah and Celine but she has this talent that no one can have. She may not penetrated being international singer but she gained respect here in PI and she's a huge icon here =)

  • @asiagalang27 yeah for yelling. lols.

  • @asiagalang27 yep she has a talent. she's the KARAOKE QUEEN

  • @MCLAMB4LIFE1 dragged lol

  • @MCLAMB4LIFE1 The truth is she's not even known in Asia except Philippine. I'm from Hong Kong, had not some jerks spammed Mariah's footages with her ugly voice I would never ever know who the hell this Regine bitch is.

  • @MrChrismaniego Dear, if Regine - who I love so much - is "more DIVA" than mariah, WHY THE HELL SHE COVERS MARIAH OVER AND OVER?! o.O

  • @MrChrismaniego the world don't accept Regine as the best diva in the world because shes not! mariah is a class A singer don't compare her to a low class local singer like Regine! i'm a Filipino it's so shameful to compare the artistry of mariah to Regine's lack of creativity..

  • @mikhaldavid2010 tangina nyo mga pinoy pa naman kayo wala kayong suporta sa mga artist naten. edi lumipat kayo ng bansang mga putang ina kayo. di naman kayo kilala nyan ni Mariah Carey.

  • @beelzeeboo666 bakit ikaw kilalala ka ni regine mo?FYI kilala kami ni mariah coz we are her fans!! kung gusto nyu iangat ang mga talents ng pinoy edi tigilan nyu pinag gagawa nyu,, ang lakas ng loob nyu i compare si regine kay mariah,, mahiya kayo sa balat nyu, kahit anong gawin nyung panlalait kay mariah,, hindi parin aangat si regine!!!

  • @mikhaldavid2010 e gago ka pala ee. i'm a fan too. kaso makapanglait kayo sa talents ng pilipinas parang di kayo mga pinoy. tangina mo. mamatay ka rin. haha.

  • @beelzeeboo666 eh kayo naunang ipasok dito si regine sa vid ni mariah at kayo ang unang nanglait kay mariah,, bakit kayo lng ba marunong manglait?? ang kakapal kasi ng mukha nyu ibibida pa dito si regine,, kaw ang mamatay!!dapat lng din kayong laitin para mataohan naman kayo,,

  • @MrChrismaniego  I want the same drugs you used when you wrote that, man !!!! they must take you to the space and beyond ! on a dimension where Mariah is not the best singer in history, which is obviously not happening in this dimension where she IS DA SINGER !!!

  • @MrChrismaniego REGINE IS NOTHING, SHE CAN SING... WELL ITS JUST KARAOKEING and COPYING OTHERS HARD WORJ, SAME WITH OTHER FILIPINO ARTIST they copy new artist over and over and over and over again. CHARICE IS ORIGINAL ARTIST NOW! BTW.

  • @MrChrismaniego <-----ha ha ha ...Damang-dama ko ang sama ng loob mo....lol Hilaw na hilaw ang style ng pagpo-promote ng idol mo...lol Inuna mo kasi yang yabang mo kaya walang epekto...lol Effort pa Tsong, maging creative ka naman..lol

  • @MrChrismaniego you are completely unaware of what you are saying. Go start your research. My God....

  • @MrChrismaniego All humans are the same species. Race is a social construct, not a scientific one. WE'RE ALL HUMAN but REGINE REIGNS only in KARAOKE, NOT ACTUAL MUSIC.

  • @chesleycareystar LMAO, agree

  • Beyonce is our modern Tina Turner. . . Mariah: can one be compared too, one of a kind :)

  • :) cant wait on christmas day !

  • I Iove this woman!

  • u wouldnt see beyonce sing any of these songs, coz she b lovin her illuminati bullshit!! Mariah Carey will always be the best singer!!

  • I believe is live. Look carefully to the veins in her neck. they get bigger when she is hitting the higher notes. Every time you sing and is using air and notes get higher that naturally happens.

  • This doesn't come across as live but I don't know for sure.

  • @jamstrings100 its live, mariah don't have top lip, she is mariah after all. she is just that good

  • i randomly pause at 1:10 i found sth funny :))

  • @keiomi81 someone obviously doesnt know the orginal all too well.

  • i just don't see how she can lipsync over live orchestration... kinda makes absolutely no sense lol.

  • @jakey1126 def agree. this also differs considerably from the cd recording. this is live!

  • Mariah is one of the few pop artists today who puts out a Christmas album with classic/traditional Christmas songs...I prefer the classics over the poppish/auto-tuned remakes anyday!

  • her face is so angelical <3

  • @keiomi81 she is dummy. go you think she is lypsinching??? so where is her playback then with a live choir and orchestra? use your brain

  • @123465249 why bother answering a failyla fan? obviously the screaming and cat screeching made her fans deaf.

  • Mariah' s haters can't believe that someone can be this good live. well get this, If your hero is bad, stop thinking that every other person is bad.

  • MARIAH FOREVER I LOVE U SO MUCH

  • The Greatest women singer and women legend that has ever Lived, No this is 1000000% Live if you were a true true Fan Like Me, Then You would know.. Haters will be Haters Just Like The Greatest Women Legend MC says. You have to love them STILL! Love you from The Bottom of my Heart, Forever and always CRT FOREVER

  • This is 100% LIVE I was there peoples

    ]

  • @cempla how lucky of u

  • the last word " Peace " MIMI sang different so it's not lipped !

    it's live!

    " their watch of " is too

    please listen to this song PRECISELY !

  • the last word " Peace " MIMI sang different so it's not lipped !

    it's live!

  • im not an expert.. but how would she lipsych if all the music being played is live acoustic music?

  • @jakey1126 Because it is not lipped :)

  • @stewardlie that's what im saying....

  • @jakey1126 lol right.. I think they want us to believe even the cellos are .... um.. string synced?? >.<

  • @caszidy215 lol exactly! people are such skeptics and critics even if she did lipsynch, what the hell does it prove? 

  • @jakey1126 I am starting to believe the reason why they accuse her of lip syncing every song she sings because they just can't fathom that angelic voice being live. It is pretty amazing when you hear her sing because no one that famous can sing like her. But what I don't get is she has been doing it for so long.. obviously she can really sing that way lol.. I mean do they really believe she lipped in front of the President???

  • @caszidy215 lmao ANY money there are people that cried "lipsynch" when they saw her perform for him

  • Mariah should make a full version of little drummer boy

  • REAL LIVE.......DIVA....CAN BEYONCE DO THIS????

  • She's so cute ^_^

  • lovely rendition of the song Mariah did it again nothing else to say what a wonderfull voice im speechless

    Daya from Austrailia

  • I'd die if Mariah started marching around to the drums in the beginning HAHA <3

  • 2:50 i love it!

  • 2:51 i love it!

  • I LOVE HER, SHE´S TE BEST, HATERS GO HOME AND REST IN PEACE, MARIAH IS MARIAH.

  • she already mastered the whispered voice ,she sings effortlessly in live

  • i just listen to the song and enjoy her amazing voice. people who watch every lip movement and breath she takes must have very boring lives. just enjoy the damn song!!!!!!!!!!!

  • i remember watching this live on TV, i was literally jumping on my bed with chills all over my body, i never felt so excited in my life, not only i was happy for her baby bump but also for magnificent voice which got better after a long rest. THANKS TO THE TWINS!!! they keeps her healthy and happy. I think this was 100 and 10% live, looking at the way she sang and her gestures, unlike the time when she sang My All in Russia, that was lipped (Russian singers lip sync a lot and ppl don't mind)

  • this woman is amazing! this live version sounds almost exactly as the cd version. think that is why some people (haters) thinks she lip synchs - no that is just pure TALENT people!!!!!

  • @123465249 Delusional...she sings live in this until the first high belts (2:08),it is so obvious,the mic is still so close to her mouth even if she is belting like crazy,she is smilling like "Hey it is nothing,i'm smilling"and we all know when she is really beltingshe does the face "OMG it is so hard"I'm sure you don't even believe in what you said. By the way,the end does not sound LIVE at ALL,it has that track quality,but however it is mixed with somedifferente vocals than the studio version.

  • @theoneandonly2503 you need to sit down somewhere,you've been trying to prove that Mariah always lips for how many years now?im tired of seeing you on her vids.

    We don't want to hear your theories on her performance.You are dismissed.By the way this whole special is live,just dubbed.Also you act if smiling and belting is impossible,must Mariah always make a constipated face when sinigng.She doesn't always struggle,and you should know that.she rested vocally.

  • @aquamarine11500 If I'm dissmissed you are delusional, which is worst in my opinion....And your friend 123456789 is even more dumb, which is sad. I'm so tired of her dumb lambs

  • @theoneandonly2503 You always have something negative to point out,and you're always critiquing her.What are you,obsessed?

    are you bent on her voice,fascinated perhaps?

    You know what your problem is? Your problem is that you have a difficult time just believing and you don't want to feel tricked so you constantly go searching for something to point out,but alas no one cares.

    Im tired of coming to MC video and cant even read the got damn comment section without some idiot hollering lipped!

  • @aquamarine11500 So what's your point? I'm not obsessed, it pisses me off that she is pretending and lipsyncing the belts ALWAYS. You are tricked, and you don't even care, that's crazy, what kind of "fan" are U?

    When she sings live, I give her props (she did in lots of her songs during the AA Tour), but that lipsync shit has to stop. I'm searching for nothing to point out, for example I have no doubt that ALL her live performances between 90 and 96 were really live, unlike now!!!

  • @theoneandonly2503 then check the O HOLY NIGHT UNDUBBED VIDEO where her voice cracks and then she goes back to belting u can´t deny that´s live otherwise there wouldn´t be any cracking.

  • @theoneandonly2503 then check the O HOLY NIGHT UNDUBBED VIDEO where her voice cracks and then she goes back to belting u can´t deny that´s live otherwise there wouldn´t be any cracking. Plus at 2.51 u can notice it´s perfectly live, she goes from high mixed voice to head voice and u can tell the difference from any other version . admit it Mariah is recognized for her voice by artists such as Tina Turner, Whitney , Patti , Stevie Wonder, Mary J+blige and so many others, do you think that they

  • @theoneandonly2503 would praise her voice if she needed to lip the hardest parts? please they all are experienced artists with decades of music industry knowledge , if she needed to rely on pre-recorded parts, they wouldn´t even take their time being amazed as they all do when she delivers a powerful performance

  • @theoneandonly2503 then check 2.51 if you don´t realize this is live, than your ear is deaf certainly plus she had to be singing the whole previous part because you can tell it´s continuous . don´t blame her for being the best

  • @pedy19 I don't thinks my ear is more deaf than yours, she was the very best during the 90's, now her live performances are fake ==> Delusional. End of the story. I've seen your other comments,and they have less value than my toilet paper to be polite.Mariah's mic stays open and she switch between lipped parts and live parts, that's why even if she is lipsyncing things,not the whole thing will be lipsync.

  • @theoneandonly2503 For Oh Holy Night, that's exactly what I think it would be, part live, part lipsync, that's so easy to tell the difference, the lipsync parts are not even as loud as the live parts, and she is supposed to be belting like crazy and right after all those incredible lipsync belts, her voice cracked for a note who is not even that high? hahaha, truly you are deaf, delusional if you believe the whole things was live, but hey you are a Mariah lamb, what did we expect?You need EARS

  • @theoneandonly2503 THEN I GUESS THE CHOIR LIPPED AS WELL RETARD

  • @123465249 Oh Gosh you know nothing. The choir and Mariah's voice are two distinct things, the choir can be live and Mariah's voice can be lipsync (well part lipsync), it is as simple as that.

  • @theoneandonly2503 and i guess you are the expert - not likely

  • @theoneandonly2503 you are not polite so don´t even try because that´s something too far from your reach. Then you have no musical education and that is reflected by your comments. face the truth, loser

  • @pedy19 Actually you all dumb lambs are losers, Mariah tricks you since more than a decade with her fake belts and you are still praising her "heavenly" voice, who sometimes sounds more like hell in live performances. Mariah's voice has nothing heavenly out of the studio recording now, she has some good days, but she does not even compare to her 90's version. This is a never-ending debate, I will not change my mind, you can call me loser or whatever adjective , I don't care :)

  • @theoneandonly2503 Honey, say whatever you want. It´s a pity YouTube allows people such as yourself to comment

  • @123465249 Ignore him,he's one of the people who always wants to say lipped,yet deep down he really likes Mariah and it struggling with an inner conflict within himself debating whether it's live or not.

    He has no idea that Mariah was pregnant here,and had not been drinking for months and i had a lot of rest physically,vocally etc..You are right, this was live.Mariah lips,and alot of other artist do it ,but this was one of her special concerts that she did live :) she luvs Xmas time.

  • You Better sang that song gurl!

  • oh damnnnn!!!i know the drummer....hes mariahs personal drummer...he came to the high school im in...i talked to him too....damnnn thats crazy.....but that guy really gets down with his shit....he busted some sick shit with the drums at our school....

  • She talk really low and raspy... Thats sexxy :):)

  • Her voice has really changed for the better now... It's astonishing to me. Notice how her speaking voice has changed slightly too. :O I'm sure it must be her not drinking. She sounds PHENOMENAL. Always did, of course. But still. PHENOMENAL! <3 <3 <3

  • Amazing! So angel voises !

    

  • Amazing!

    

  • I LOVE MARIAH CAREY!!!! U r such a great singer and inspirational!!!

  • I LOVE U MARIAH I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE U I LOVE UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU­UUU

  • She did sing live but it is dubbed like her Performance @ the Proctor Theatre. But, you can find the undubbed version on youtube and she sounds wonderful. Minor mistakes but still stunning.

  • @prettyboi101 link?

  • her voice is pure as gold, she sings with passion i love that! :)

  • one choir singer I swear is omarosa.

  • @vistaprime i agree. looks just like her and the camera keeps showing her as if the camera guy thinks she looks like her too!

  • This is such a Great Album.. And song!!~~ I love you from the bottom of my Heart!!! CRT forever. my hero

  • Why does the audio sound really strange during this whole concert? It seems part dubbed part mimed to me but even when she's speaking she sounds weird...I can't get me head around what it could be. Some are saying live auto-tune but I' not sure...Thoughts??

  • @mariahmadrileno I think it's just the way it's recorded or uploaded or whatever. It sounds like the user put it on a function that picks up vocals better. It sounds crazy in my headphones. Kind of like if I turned my surround sound on 'concert hall' or something.

  • @mariahmadrileno I really think it is just something that got messed up with the sound equiptment while they were recording it cuz u can hear that is does go in and out sometimes.

  • She´s using Auto Tune!

  • @elciozoo no she is not!!!!

  • @ILoveMcWhMj4ever People seem to get very upset when someone says she's using auto

    tune, which enhances the quality of the voice. It's so clear! specially in the beginning of her speech. I'm a huge mariah fan and I'm not being mean or something when I say she's using. she ain't 20 yo anymore and her voice has changed. Everybody knows that she doesn't like to belt and therefore she uses a lot of breathy effects, which made her loose some voice quality. that's it.

  • @elciozoo I'm not meaning to sound patronising, but a lot of people don't seem to know what auto tune actually is. A lot of people confuse it with filters and reverb. I'm not saying you definitely have, however Mariah didn't use any enhancing tool for her belts on this album. If she had, her voice would have sounded a lot lighter and thinner. Also, if you listen carefully at 2:07, she belts live (only for a few seconds) and evidently isn't using auto tune.

  • 2:43 that was cool sounding lol

  • Haha, I just sang that song I as ran up the stairs and was just at the part "fall on your knees" as I tripped and actually fell on my knees :D

  • 2:09 - 2:13 & 2:32 - 2:52 this is my favorite song on the album because of these bars :) MC4EVR I effing love her pitch there... eee! Driving...I do the hand motions and mimic her....lol ---I see people watching me ALL the time!! I live it loud and proud....this album, just brings me so much joy and I bcome giddy with it <3

  • @aldoaldo5 me too!

  • Comment removed

  • Haters; I can only allow you to critize about on this site but if you tell me in my face you better be strong person to receive my left and right hand lolz. Even my friends knows that I always bark @ people talking bad things about my fave singer. Better be watch out with your stinky mouth.

  • @vnaulivou :D , We both have the same situation, my friends also dislike mariah.

  • @vnaulivou you tell them!!! hahaha i love your pluck!!! that's the spirit!!

  • PLEEEAAAAASSSSSEEEEEE VOTE FOR MARIAH ON VIRGIN MEDIA MUSIC AWARDS!!!!!!!!! She is 2nd!!!!!!! Best Solo female!!!!!!!

    @VirginMedia

  • @boucledora Shes First, Foreve and Always CRT

  • @boucledora 1st

  • I don't understand how come some people talk about her drinking issues. Are we not supposed to give opinions on the performance ?

  • She sounds GREAT

  • i dunno how ppl could mistake this as not being live. i mean you hear her sucking in her breath...great performance. finally she is back to herself, there were albums that i never liked cuz of her hmm how to discribe..'whining' voice. i liked her alot when she started and thats the mariah i LOVE..and here she sounds like her old self again..

  • @natti80 . here she sound so fantastic, her falsetto , cest voice , i never heard from another artist ...

  • @natti80

    I strongly agree w/ you about the 'old' Mariah slowly coming back to us... at least vocally/musically; Memoirs is one of her best albums to date in addition to Merry Christmas II You. And that's the way it should be.

  • the TONE of the word "sleep" at 1:02 is just BANANAS!

  • @chrisanthemum7 It gave me chills @ 1:02 "sleep"

  • Screw the Haters, I love you Forever and Always CRT. the best singer on the entire planet CRT forever

  • wonderful diva!!!!!!

  • If anyone wants to judge for themselves, visit the Mariah Daily website, where you can download the raw, undubbed audio recordings of the whole concert. As far as I can tell, nothing has been dubbed except one note in Oh Holy Night where her voice cracked. Have a listen and decide for yourselves.

  • @sfogfgokjsogjsdfks i been looking for it i dunno where to look for it on the site lol 

  • @8jaMie7 keep scrolling down until you see 'News Archives' on the right, and click on January 2011, then scroll almost to the very bottom and you'll see 'MDJ Exclusive Full Audio - ABC Christmas Special Taping' then just click the part you wanna download, click 'free downloading' and wait for the timer to go down!

  • @sfogfgokjsogjsdfks thanks so much

  • Think it this way, if this was lip sync or pre-recorded, just tell me how much is the effort that they have to put just to make sure the musicians' body gesture were synchronised with the playback music..

  • Wow, powerfull, I was speechless 

  • Wow. I did not remember it being this amazing. I got chills at the end (2:50-3:13). "And PEACE to m-EEEEnnn on Earth!" Lol. 2011 will yield some amazing songs from Mariah. I can tell she is going to give the fans one hell of a year with this restored voice.