Added: 4 years ago
From: yanglintw
Views: 3,524,581
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (7,315)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Amazing cover of a great song

  • Why has this shitty band got more views than the Pink Floyd version?

    Nightwish lol terrible

  • I think it's a unique take on a great song. I love it and I'm a Floyd fanatic!!

  • ROLE

  • PINK FLOYD

  • That's Tarja on vocals? Her beard is way better than I remembered.

  • check out captain jack sparrow on the keyboards!

  • This song with a guy that looks like a wizard....kinda scary lol

  • Good try but i still prefer the original version!

  • Aaaaawesome. Love It, Maybe the best cover of this song :)

  • This is Beautifull.... AWESOME.... One of the best songs in the fucking World.... Ohhhh Yea...

  • THE SHIT WAS CHEAPER

  • @mcvit hahahahahahaha

  • THE RINGING OF THE DIVISION BELL HAS BEGUN!!!! Ive got chills everytime I see this.WOW!!!!

  • THE LIGHT WAS BRIGHTER!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 5:00 Emppu is fingering the guitar :D

  • i heard pink floyd did a cover of this! (:

  • @metalkingdom100 hahaha :P just asking for a comment ... :P

  • Best Tarja's performance xD

  • Love Nightwish! of Course Marco being hot hot hot is a + :)

  • druum Julius what is julius

  • THE GRASS WAS GREENER!!!!!

  • This version really cought me :) It´s amazing, strong and more energetic....love it !!!

  • Примитивный ход. Смотрите хоть Варлок, хоть Джудас прист, хоть Айрон Мейден - мозоли уже от! То, что Найтвиш до сих пор не пользовала пошлостей не оправдание.

  • Dit is echt schitterend en wat een stem! Gaat dwars door je heen!

    Zelden zo iets mooi gehoord en wat een prachtig drum en gitaarwerk kortom,schitterend!!!

    Heb dit nummer al heel vaak beluisterd en het blijf mijn favoriet!

  • @moste322 i wounder how many people are understanding what he is saying

    lol, ik denk dat het overgrote deel hier geen nederlands spreekt

  • @100metalhead100 Maar wij wel en met ons nog 17 miljoen! mooie tekst!

  • @100metalhead100 Ik wel :)

  • 6:06 That Ritardando riff (slowing it down) doesn't suit there :-/...Otherwise Very great song and performance :-)

  • In the beginning the crowd is leading Thuomas out of the rythm

  • Ämen!!!

  • Gilmour's touch is missing, but, hey, it's a metal cover, and magnifically done. These guys rock

  • beautiful choice of song

  • Nightwish einfach geil!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • from conscience to dark in seven minutes, a masterpiece

  • FOREVER FLOYD FLOYD FLOYD...

  • this version is the voice the thunder..

  • Of pretty much every metal band I can think of, nightwish is the only one I would expect to be able to cover that song, even though I find them annoying. I think it's a pretty good cover. They capture the melancholic energy in the chorus very well, but it's not the same as Floyd, that managed to get that energy even without the use of strong drums or electric guitars.

  • @herowithpsp de... A refrénnél sokkal jobban beleéli magát.. De ez személyes vélemény. Te dolgod hogy neked mi tetszik mi nem...

  • Idols of Idols, forever Pink Floyd

  • I feel bad for raping a song earlier from NIGHTWISH so I had to listen to one of their best covers. Since Tarja isnt coming back, then let Marco do ALL of the singing.. That other girls voice (I have vowed to never say her name) is a great voice but not for this sound..

  • WOW!! TERRIFIC!! YOU ARE FANTASTIC AT LIVE!! BETTER WITH TARJA TURUNEN!!!

    WITH NIGHTWISH AND TARJA TURUNEN FOREVER!!

    Finger Up & direct to my favourites.

    A BIG HUG BY YOUR SPANISH FRIEND & FAN:

    NACHO ESPEJO ;)

    "I invite you to listen my Songs and watch my Videos"

  • Mysticism at it's very best...Bravo Nightwish!!!

    

  • I guess it's not a matter of which version is better, but rather that this version is just plain bad according to any possible standard of what counts as a minimally good piece of music... (please don't reply; replies will be dismissed)

  • @vicanflo Why even write if you can't take that people reply?

  • I really like this version but is not better than Pink Floyd!

  • I'm not a fan of Nightwish, I've just listened to some of their song, But here's my thought: singing Pink Floyd, it takes guts.

  • it's so fucking brilliant *-*

    nightwish is epic

  • Comment removed

  • Here is the fact...

    When you are in a concert, and the singer has personality at the stage, its nice...

    When you are in a concert, and the singer, and the guitar have personality at the stage, its its very good and enjoyable...

    When you are in a concert, and the singer, the guitar and the bass and piano have personality at the stage, its Amazing...

    But when you are in a concert, and the singer, the guitar, the bass, the piano AND the battery have personality at the stage...you are in heaven

  • @calalix but when you are in a concert and the entire band plays like this you cannot help but be deeply disappointed...this is pretty much a established fact... I guess...

  • @Jyrki1964 pretty pink floyd has quite a bit more than 2 hits...

  • not bad but i have to go with pink floyd for the win though, the song isent the same without the slide solo at the end

  • Ez sokkal jobb mint az eredeti!

    This version is better as Pink Floyd's

  • @MrEgoblue

    Nem.

  • Awesome! I love it! Never heard of Pink Floyd's original before I heard this one first and instantly fell in love with it. I love everything about it including the bells. :) Marco's voice is great. And imagine someone waltz in here like me who never seen Marco perform before but loves heavy metal music. I was awestruck. I think he sings and looks awesome like a viking. For those who think that Pink Floyd's version better I say this - sure, since you heard it first.It's win-win for both of us.

  • They fucked it up...

  • I need 841 condoms and a time machine.

  • Since when did rape (even if it is musically) become legal?!

  • holy shit... they ruined it

  • this sucks :(

  • niesamowite!

  • Tarja ♥

  • @GloriaAleman Idiot ♥

  • @theblackmelody FUCK YOU! ¬¬

  • Jebać system!

    Zapuszczam włosy!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • what the fuck....... it's a disgrace to one of the best songs ever made in history of music.. fuck u nightwish.

  • i don´t like... they are all of them fuckers...

  • Comment removed

  • It's an okay cover, but I prefer the original version of Pink Floyd. It's much better...no offense.

  • I love Nightwish ;-)

  • this cover kinda killed the song :/

  • not even close to pink floyd! try again... this blows

  • @Thonhaugen It's a cover. Covers aren't supposed to be exactly like the original. It's Nightwish's way of showing respect to their influences in their own style.

  • Beyond the horizon of the place we lived when we were young In a world of magnets and miracles Our thoughts strayed constantly and without boundary The ringing of the division bell had begun There was a ragged band that followed in our footsteps Running before times took our dreams away Leaving the myriad small creatures trying to tie us to the ground To a life consumed by slow decay The grass was greener The light was brighter With friends surrounded The nights of wonder...
  • What the FUCK:

    EMI links are not allowed to me.

  • yes nice ,but not as Pink floyd !!

  • @iaarrekvetina I agree!

  • @Tjoppy thanks , No one can replace Pink Floyd , by the way old nightwish was a great band :D

  • great version

  • Close enough

  • good enough...but not FLOYD!

  • holy mother of god !!!! i got an eargasm that lasted 6 minutes and 52 seconds !!!

  • MARCO AS THE NEW VOCALIST = NEW FANS, OLD FANS AND REAL FANS ALL HAPPY :)

  • Am I the only one who things Marco is a bit better singer than Tarja?

  • @AncientMorrigan be cool if Marco was the main singer, he does a good job. Hes my modern viking :D

  • @AncientMorrigan

    Nope!He is Better! :)

    

  • @AncientMorrigan Incomparable. They're both exceptionally good IMHO.

  • @AncientMorrigan No. Tarot fans ^_^.

  • No one beats pink floyd !

  • Marco is a high pitched man

  • I wish....a Night Wish...with Tarja...again...eternal

  • This is really good ,amazing in fact but it doesn't beat Pink Floyds version please don't think i'm trying to troll on this video because i'm really not its very good better than most covers it has feeling but its lacking that tiny piece that Gilmour puts into the song i find the original/gilmour version to be much more light , suple ,intellignet a breath of fresh air.

    Night Wish version is Amazing

    Pink Floyds Version is Out of this world .

    Sorry if i seem rude i'm just putting my point across

  • @Fendergreats19933

    in my opinion this version is much much better then pink floyd. It has "power".

  • @arekdbz3 It has Marco! ;D

  • gandalf is good on vocals

  • @TheAgregister Lol,where is Frodo?

  • Comment removed

  • I love how their choruses falls in the song like hammer on an anvil

  • yes

  • This new and amazing band will blow your head off!!

    watch?v=js6TBze6vNA

  • I found the Beauty !

  • so cool

  • For sure this should be taken as a tribute, not as a basis for an argument about which version is better.

  • melhor que a tarja!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

  • perfectttttttttttttttttttttttt­tttttttttttttttttttttttttttt

  • Marco loistaa tässä. Ei tää bändi tarvi sitä eukkoa laulamaan...

  • this is a pretty good cover,

  • is a good version but is beast the Pink Floyd version... Pink Floyd forever <3

  • Just waw... 

  • rockroll muito massa d +

  • i love this song i have seen them two time all ready i like to know when they are comeing back to kentucky

  • I thin Judas Priest voice would be perfect to cover this song....

  • MArco has a fkn' voice !

    Im in love with this vid, omg. Emppu's guitar is awesome, ESP Horizon FR II, omgg

  • rubbish! i guess that all of you who think that this is good have never heard the orginal version...

  • The best version 4 ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • i used to have high hopes,then i took an arrow in the knee

  • Maybe the best cover ever. Still the original is epic too

  • @multivitamin24 Idiot.Das ist supertolle Musik

  • i can't stop listening to this song,it's a masterpiece! i am addicted!

  • Macro 's so great! love the voice so much! 

  • Vocals:Tarja

    Keyboards:Tuomas

    Guitars:Emppu

    Drums:Julius

    Bass & Vocals:Marco

    Why call Jukka (Julius) by his name, and not Emppu (Erno)? :O

  • @Martijnhaah Actually, Jukka is his real name and Julius some obscure nickname that is never used.

    @Vethuleion Marco is indeed an awesome singer but, without female vocalist in Nightwish we'd end up with two Tarots :)

  • it is okay.. but nobody should try to do any pink floyd things

  • Emppu - pity he cant compose his own solos

  • Emppu solo is the most perfect I've ever heard!

  • Love marco and especially his voice!!! He's the one!

  • Was very wierd to hear this stuff even though i am a Pink floyd and Nightwish fanatic.

  • Marco!!!!!! The King of the North! \m/

  • i die everytime i hear marco to scream

  • If it would be The End of An Era.....this would be the Song to End it With!!!

  • Oh wow this is so so great....I like...I like ♫☆❤♫ "Pink Floyd" the version here is so so fantastic !!!

    ♥ڿڰۣღ♥♥ღ ❤ԼƠƔЄ❤ღ♥♥ღ ♥♥ڿڰۣ♥

    1 000 000 thumbs from me. Greetings Corviniana

  • God I love Marco's voice.

  • fan de pink floyd,j'adore cette version...bravo et merci Marco!!!!

  • Great version, great vocal... Pink Floyd like this

  • Now I am not understanding why people are disliking and criticizing about this song??We all know who Gilmour is..so stop comparing this song and floyd's one in deep way..this one is cover and a cover only sounds good when it's of different taste... and this one is the best cover till now of the High hopes and Nightwish had showed respect to the legends...so respect Nightwish too...and other best thing about Nightwish is its Drummer's passion and attitude..Respect !!....

  • nope! Its Better ! i do not like pink Gilmour's version, the refrain is bad(in the Pink Floyd version) and i should say...

  • its better than Pink Floyd's version!

  • @MrEgoblue Hahahaha...it may be good...but never better than Gilmour and Waters...

  • They are soo good!

  • magnifique!!!!

    

  • I don't care if this is nighwish or Chuck Norris himself, without Gilmour this is worthless..

  • Nobody should touch a Pink Floyd Classic. Nobody.

  • @alb2006 @qubiq3 @Dreadiekuruga You know what? I'm a true Pink Floyd fan. It was my favo-band for a long time, and still Us and Them is one of my favo-songs. But this song. This version. I like this better than the origional one. Yes, Pink Floyd's one is good. But this one is amazing.

  • @IkTheNew I agree, its amazing! But its not Pink Floyd... As a PF fan you must understand what im sayin'...

  • @alb2006

    Why they shouldn't cover a song that they like? I'm sure Pink Floyd didn't make this song so no one wouldn't be allowed to play it...

  • Definitely love Tarja Nightwish... not saying that Anette isn't a great singer but the original lineup was epic! Love this cover soo much!

  • Knowing that i never can watch NW like they used to be makes me very sad :( this is epic.

  • @Dubelosix

    well it seems like?

  • This band does not need female singer, Marco is doing awesome job!

  • @Vethuleion marco rules but tarja is the best. was...

  • @Vethuleion -> Tarot... Nightwish is about female singer,and always will be ;)

  • @Vethuleion that is very very true...

  • nightwish foreveeeeer

  • Never tried but I've heard that if you smoke the joint from the like/dislike bar this will sound like the original :)). Ok now this is not Pink Floyd version and they wanted to make it something more original , that's why is soo damn different. But is special also , Nightwish is no Pink Floyd so stop saying shit 'bout them is a beautiful song. And is in honor of the original GJ \m/ Marcoh , Bad job that you fired Tarja ,Annete sucks!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • @alan26930

    it seems your not a serious fan of pink floyd

    cuz a cover is a sign of respect

    so you beter go fuck youself

  • @GrimJoeReaper and Hillary Duff covers "My Generation" to show respect for The Who. Nice idea.

  • @alan26930 I agree lol. I wanna go rip their heads off.

  • I have to give him credit for playing a slide solo without a slide...

  • For a long time James Hetfield was my favorite singer. I think I changed mind. Well, actually I know for sure.

  • They gave it a different feeling to Pink Floyd's original but its awesome

  • I like this!

  • Well i'm a fan of Nightwish but... TELL ME THEY DIDN'T DO THIS. TELL ME IT'S JUST A NIGHTMARE. Oh-my-god. Never do a cover of Pink Floyd. Please.

  • Marco rules \m/