The people that defend Miley's "dancing" (if you can call it that) at her concerts say that she's just "growing up". But look at Hilary, who's way older than Miley. Hilary is all grown up now, and she can perform without grinding on all of her dancers, and nobody is complaining about her not being sexy enough. HILARY is what I would call a real GROWN UP WOMAN
she is good live (i saw other preformances besides this) and club G.A.Y. may not be a gay club...i think it stands 4 something. and if she is singing at a gay club let her.
@viper2rufousgamer Screw off. Just because I'm okay with my sexuality doesn't mean you have to trample all over be like some conservative Texan from the '40s.
@MistrSteezy For God's sake, don't take the to notice... they can say whatever they want on the net... just ignore people who offend you on the net, that's why they have the Flag for Spam button... :)) (Y)
In case you guys don't know, Disney is incredibly strict. They would have never let her sing anything on the show unless it was her real voice, and she is actually singing in the show. Listen to the music video, and listen to her voice. Her voice is actually a little lower than in the music video.
cause of death : At 12:47 AM EDT actress and singer ,Hilary Duff, was found dead in her apartment. Many stab wounds were found on her chest and neck. Police have not yet released further info on the matter
Yeah, I wish they woulda turned down the Backing track, you can't hear her as well on this video. Oh well, I've heard her sing this in person, and it was great :)
DO NOT READ There was a boy named Charlie and he was a smart man. He was killed by an assassain on April 12th, 1975 at the age of 14. If you read this, then tonight while you are sleeping, he will come to your house and go in your heart and stop it from beating, then you know what happens after that. This is was happened to a voice actor at the 4kids company named Maddison Blaustein. If you don't want to end up like Maddie, repost this message to 10 other videos before midnight tonight.
Sorry i hate these things x.x.) If you start reading thins you CANT stop .Once ther was a little girl named Cecilia.She was a little 7 year old who got strangled and raped by a man =.If you dont post this to 15 other videos you will see CCecilia standing at the end of your bed with a knife and she will kill you You have to do this by midnight or you will be dead
this is scary if u read this this far u will die in 10 days if u dont send to any 15 videos in 2 hours good luck hope u dont die !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i love taylor! yall should check out bananaberryz videos! they are super cool! especially Forever and Always, Love Story and You Belong With me!!!!! check them out now!!!
few years ago, two parents went out for dinner. A few hours later, the baysitter was calling to ask if she could cover up the clown statue in the kids' room, the father said,"Take the kids and get out of the house. We'll call the police, we don't have a clown statue." The "clown statue" is really a killer that escaped from jail. If you don't post this on to 10 videos tonight, the clown will be in your bed at 3:00 am with a chainsaw in his hand;sorry i didn't want that happening to me
January 6th is the Official International Reach Out Download day! We (the fans) are trying to make it become her 6th charting single. It's being promoted across youtube and even MOD in Canada! Please support Hilary by buying Reach Out on January 6th!
lol this song does not go with the shirtless men and definitely does not belong in a club
randomxfreak 2 weeks ago in playlist More videos from hilaryduffofficial
The people that defend Miley's "dancing" (if you can call it that) at her concerts say that she's just "growing up". But look at Hilary, who's way older than Miley. Hilary is all grown up now, and she can perform without grinding on all of her dancers, and nobody is complaining about her not being sexy enough. HILARY is what I would call a real GROWN UP WOMAN
bubbles22293 3 weeks ago
playback?
AAameliia 2 months ago in playlist Más vídeos de hilaryduffofficial
Hilary
lyly1999 4 months ago
Now there's someone who isn't faking on stage
Miss you Duff <3
OfunnythingsO 6 months ago 2
She is amazing live
cr1490 6 months ago
i would have lost my voice at this concert if i was their!! well really at any of her concerts!
andalusian247 7 months ago
Is Hilary Duff big with gays?
Lfdjake91 7 months ago
its so great to see this woman is married and happy miss the days when i would sit home and watch lizzie mcguire love u Disney Queen :)
belindapopxoxo 8 months ago
wow i havent herd her music in awhile shes amazing. wat happened to her? i havent seen her in awhile
karencardeno 9 months ago
This is definitely not live
Thismayneverstart 9 months ago
why is the quality so crappy??
RENAxoxoxoxo 10 months ago
@RENAxoxoxoxo its from 2006
EmilyandAlli 9 months ago
what does g.a.y. stand 4?
jewgurl211 10 months ago
@jewgurl211 GAY Obviously
TheJthoma29 6 months ago
@TheStylistGuru You're sooo fucking right!! :)
she's different
and i love her! :D
182RoSexXx 1 year ago
she sings live exactly like the cd
koalabears12 1 year ago 7
@koalabears12 true :)
TiaMuffinx 1 year ago
@koalabears12 I know its like they didnt change her voice in recording or
she lip syncing
kewlgir82 1 year ago
live?
skatepunkgirl 1 year ago
the back up dancers r hot.... luv u hilary!!
XOPockie 1 year ago
this is why like hilary duff
she was highly successful during her time
and she didnt sell sex and romp around in little leotards
cough cough miley cyrus
themichellybelly 1 year ago
live at clb G.A.Y?????? oddiooo
BestSally 1 year ago
she sounds soo beautiful in here.
i love all her old stuff haha.
but what the hell is with her newer stuff ahah? :\
Kimberlyyyxox 1 year ago
I love HIlary Duff !
EyeAmAwesome12 1 year ago
Boo-oogh playback pathetic haha
maurocyrus14 1 year ago
g.a.y is a gay club lol :L
officialchloee 1 year ago
she is good live (i saw other preformances besides this) and club G.A.Y. may not be a gay club...i think it stands 4 something. and if she is singing at a gay club let her.
TheRlk2000 1 year ago
some guy touched her butt at 1.14
hullmees666 1 year ago
what does club gay stand for.
MiaLuvsKisses 1 year ago
love you Hil!
xuvupbj 1 year ago
why is she singing at a gay club?????????,lol
oolilylolaluluoo 1 year ago
@oolilylolaluluoo Because the gays love her.
jjguy23 1 year ago
LOVEEEEEE YOU HILARY!♥
ThebestisHilary 1 year ago
good song
fcamerica100 1 year ago
She isnt lip syncing
Chalie2811 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is some gay ass shit. If she's not lip singing I don't know what. But she's old and she can sing at her gay bars. She don't really have talent.
viper2rufousgamer 1 year ago
Wow... You're pretty homophobic, aren't cha?
MistrSteezy 1 year ago 5
@MistrSteezy. No I'm not pretty and don't label me a Homo. Every guy that drives by your little gay club you wink at. I'm took and satisfied.
viper2rufousgamer 1 year ago
@viper2rufousgamer Failed troll is failed. Now go have some sex with Elton John and cry about your insecurities.
MistrSteezy 1 year ago
It's your crowd here. Elton John is your thing. Queers is your magizine. You digest don't you?
viper2rufousgamer 1 year ago
@viper2rufousgamer Screw off. Just because I'm okay with my sexuality doesn't mean you have to trample all over be like some conservative Texan from the '40s.
MistrSteezy 1 year ago
@MistrSteezy For God's sake, don't take the to notice... they can say whatever they want on the net... just ignore people who offend you on the net, that's why they have the Flag for Spam button... :)) (Y)
3333alex 1 year ago
No your fucking gay and I am not gay talk here, I don't know who you are and all I got to say is what a waiste of my time.
viper2rufousgamer 1 year ago
Comment removed
ZDA151 1 year ago
she is deffinetly not lip syncing cuz you can hear her voice espcally when she starts singing "wake up wake up" anyway she does good Love her
TheShinningStar1 1 year ago
i love this song exspecialy the beat!
musiclyricsstories1 1 year ago
bet u couldnt do anything like that anyway
do u know how hard it is 2 sing and dance at the sametime.. at least she gets paid :)
and shes a good singer shes not lip singing either
amzrocs 1 year ago
1:05.
Playback.
thepinklover1994 1 year ago
shes not lip sinking shes singing along to a the actual song with the vocal track lower then the music. Thats what all pop singers do now.
CassMaxwell13 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lip singing : (
jbcamprocklover 1 year ago
you can tell at 0:56 she isn't. she's just using the song with her vocals as a backuptrack.
ccrzykid33 1 year ago
no !not lip syching at all.she sings live,she's a good live singer -_-
webothcried 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lip syching.
nappvmk 2 years ago
club gay lmao
xbayleelx 2 years ago 3
wow she is a really good singer! she sounds just like she does on the cd! I wish i was her lol
hey check out my vid singing tis song!!
horselover511 2 years ago 3
WOW!!! usually singers dont sound that...well...good but she is GREAT!!!!!!!!!!!
and you can tell she ISIN'T lipsyncing!!!!!!
Keep on rockin Hillary!!!!! <3
Luv you!
Falicity11 2 years ago 3
playback !?
isso eh pessimo
MsMarianacouto 2 years ago
she iz soooooooooo butiful and .......um ....unique
clare450 2 years ago 2
the guys are hot
jeski2469 2 years ago 3
she is so beutifulllllllllllllllllllllllllll
0odanono0 2 years ago 3
I love you, Hilary Duff! Keep shining :)
IDK why she quit her amazing singing carreer and worked for Gossip.
I used to LOVE her... in Lizzie Mcguire.
Keep be amazing!! xoxo.
Have an amazing life, lol.
Iplayguitarandpiano 2 years ago 39
she is soo good live:D
checkmate821 2 years ago 5
She is singing here
She sounds good (:
ToxiccRosess 2 years ago 4
I like her, but come one, you have seen the Reach Out video right?
HoennMaster 2 years ago
she was 19. she's allowed to be a little sexy and seductive. don't ya think?
ccrzykid33 1 year ago 3
Didn't say she couldn't, but the user said that she doesn't sell sex when at times she does.
HoennMaster 1 year ago
she's not actually selling sex. hahhaha
ccrzykid33 1 year ago
Duh, it's called a phrase.
HoennMaster 1 year ago
i think this is her best song yet :D
erin22151 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she is so lipsyncing
kaylayloopsyloops 2 years ago
she looks way betta blonde
sickem101 2 years ago
lol what does club gay stand for :P O_o
purekf 2 years ago 2
She doesn't lipsync she is just singing over her own studio version !
KalB971 2 years ago 5
she is def not lipsyncing.
ive seen her live, front row, so i could hear the sound coming from her mouth AND the mic, and she sings perfectly.
popcorn10124 2 years ago 6
at least shes not a big trying hard on this vid...go Hil..
samaustinable 2 years ago
In case you guys don't know, Disney is incredibly strict. They would have never let her sing anything on the show unless it was her real voice, and she is actually singing in the show. Listen to the music video, and listen to her voice. Her voice is actually a little lower than in the music video.
KissMeAllNightLong 2 years ago
i love hilary duff and her music, but she should learn to sing live. lip singing is gay.
breeloriece 2 years ago 2
hilary is actually real unlike some ppl
beverleajoy 2 years ago 4
She looks finger licking good - Mmm Mmm Mmm :-)
myron24682468 2 years ago
The ppl she touched r going 2 HEAVEN :D
princeroyal001 2 years ago 2
thats a funny club name club gay
iiRock95 2 years ago 5
from 2:53 it's half live you can definitely hear her singing
Hilandro 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'd like to have her amazing legs wrapped around my head!!!
myron24682468 2 years ago
perv
tenshinakai 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is NOT live, because it sounds identically like in the CD !
noemkaisme 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hilary Duff
cause of death : At 12:47 AM EDT actress and singer ,Hilary Duff, was found dead in her apartment. Many stab wounds were found on her chest and neck. Police have not yet released further info on the matter
malditoperro069 2 years ago
okay you don't have to like her but dont be an ass about it
tenshinakai 2 years ago
WOW! i love hilary and she is sooo talented , and a really great singer xp
sinfullgodess 2 years ago
She is singing. Sounds like the soundtrack is overpowering it though.
Jamster8537 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
Jamster8537 2 years ago
I dunno if she's lip-syncing but she is sounding and looking goooood !!!
campervanman1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She is not working that zebra top.
jacer977 2 years ago
wow is she lip singing?????!
softballdiva17 2 years ago
she's singing along with the track. you can hear her voice somtimes.
lukeBAM 2 years ago 2
yeah
NewYorkDoll2 2 years ago
wow most singers in real life suck but you rock :D
inlovelivy 2 years ago 4
Shes so lucky look at her with all those hottie back-round dancers~!! haha
khockballer13 2 years ago
Yeah, I wish they woulda turned down the Backing track, you can't hear her as well on this video. Oh well, I've heard her sing this in person, and it was great :)
Genesis2091 2 years ago
this is playback singing....
sophiex0x01 2 years ago 2
ye, but u can hear her voice singing along to the track.
lukeBAM 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
DO NOT READ There was a boy named Charlie and he was a smart man. He was killed by an assassain on April 12th, 1975 at the age of 14. If you read this, then tonight while you are sleeping, he will come to your house and go in your heart and stop it from beating, then you know what happens after that. This is was happened to a voice actor at the 4kids company named Maddison Blaustein. If you don't want to end up like Maddie, repost this message to 10 other videos before midnight tonight.
123haay 2 years ago
she's singing live with a backing track. shame they didn't turn it down a little.
lukeBAM 2 years ago 4
Ok I know its club G.A.Y. but the backup dancers are really unnecessary
firepants20 2 years ago 4
at the start that is srry xD
firepants20 2 years ago
i thought the shirtless men were a nice touch, would of been an even nicer touch if they'd sent them round to my house ;)
Lisledl 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
omg she's such a tramp. i can't stand her
Xboxgirl93 2 years ago
how is she a tramp?
i think she was one of the best singers in 07' no doubt.
and she sings amazing live,
cutie9499 2 years ago 3
n i bet ur a tramp too!! if u dont like here dont watch her...stupid!!!!!
loamo83 2 years ago
What's it matter if its a gay club?
You all do know Hilary Duff is a supporter for gay rights... & if you aren't shame on you.
Example; Search.. Hilary Duff - Thats so gay commerical on youtube right now.
iDUSTlN 2 years ago 6
playback?...i don't know.but i still love her music soo much.
CCally95 2 years ago
she's singing along to the track.
lukeBAM 2 years ago
she is..its not..like..u know
nickjonasbabe144 2 years ago
wow she's brave, if the people in there are really gay, hilary better brace herself for the girls. lol. jk
futureactress1001 2 years ago
club G.A.Y. ?
tmcgwow 2 years ago
i dnt really get y its called club G.A.Y.
GuMdRoP135 2 years ago
cuz it's a gay club? wow you're smart.
lukeBAM 2 years ago
i was bein sarcastic
GuMdRoP135 2 years ago
i gont get why its called club g.a.y.!!!! do gay ppl go there?
hsm3fans123 2 years ago 4
yea it a gay and lesbien club in london
BrOmOYT 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ok thats really wierd...why would hilary be at that kinda club?
hsm3fans123 2 years ago
theirs been lots of ppl that perform their i think the spice girls did but idk n.e. way
BrOmOYT 2 years ago
they probably requested her to go
she glady accepted hell i'll go i love gay people they're fun! =]
whiteillusion89 2 years ago
YES IT'S A GAY CLUB WOW UR SOO BRAINY
lukeBAM 2 years ago
bellissimaaaaa hilary
gengy100 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this dumb bitch can't sing!!
mariahfan915 2 years ago
lol I want to know what G.A.Y. stands for since its an acronym
0BALLINN0 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
maybe gay and yummy?
or gay and yucky?
or gay and young?
FlyingSmiles 2 years ago
or maybe its yummy
baboonguy1 2 years ago
bellissimaaaaaaaaaaaa
gengy100 2 years ago
i 'thought this was a joke. I wonder is it really a gay men or wemen club or is it jest called that.
GoodAngel445 2 years ago
lol g.a.y
LittleMsPositive 2 years ago
Cheesefactor it is a gay bar, but str8 people go there aswell
Rickie2K7 2 years ago
i think she's lipsinging..but muuuch backvocals so you dont hear her voice that much.
Hannah1494 2 years ago 2
There not LIPSINGING she rocks!!!!!!!! maybee people have the same recoreding voice
DUENICK 2 years ago
the club is for gay cause it called g.a.y?is it
izack012 2 years ago
I think its a gay club, but straight people go too.
FlyingSmiles 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
ø„¸¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º°¨ post to 3 other vids
¨°º¤ø„¸ Copy „ø¤º°¨ press F5 twice
¸„ø¤º°¨Paste ``°º¤ø„¸ OK
¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º°¨¨°º look at ur background
amazing!! :)
OR ULL die Today
dancingturtles970 2 years ago
sick!!
xogennyxo 2 years ago
there's nothing wrong with playback.
a lot of artist use it now.
smrtseal 2 years ago
wats playback?
fuzzycat48 2 years ago
is club G.A.Y. for gay people?
Awesome1d 2 years ago
lol its not for gay people, that's just what its called.
cheesefactor09 2 years ago
yes its a famous london gay club but anyone can get in for concerts like this
ItsJustLifeSoShutUp 2 years ago
lipsyncing!
Shanex36 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Sorry i hate these things x.x.) If you start reading thins you CANT stop .Once ther was a little girl named Cecilia.She was a little 7 year old who got strangled and raped by a man =.If you dont post this to 15 other videos you will see CCecilia standing at the end of your bed with a knife and she will kill you You have to do this by midnight or you will be dead
weendytooshyx 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this is scary if u read this this far u will die in 10 days if u dont send to any 15 videos in 2 hours good luck hope u dont die !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
AllTimeLowProduction 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Cover your mouth with your hand
2. Make a wish
3.Close your hand (fist)
4. Hold your hand at heart for 5 seconds
5. Send this to 3 more videos
6. Tommorrow will be the best day ever
it actually worked
Money- you will find a wad of $200 in cash
Love- Your crush or lover will kiss you or ask you out
Rileyrbr34 2 years ago
play back
bohgabi 2 years ago
Comment removed
bohgabi 2 years ago
if you listen closely in the chours when she yells WAKE UP you can hear 2 voices . The playback and her real singin voice
monsterjuam 2 years ago
play back omg.
Reaubin 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Cover your mouth with your hand
2. Make a wish
3.Close your hand (fist)
4. Hold your hand at heart for 5 seconds
5. Send this to 3 more videos
6. Tommorrow will be the best day ever
it actually worked
Money- you will find a wad of $200 in cash
Love- Your crush or lover will kiss you or ask you out
mizzNISI 2 years ago
True that dancers don't go with that song. =)
TeeKayDee 2 years ago
the dancers are shit for this song
AlanRickmanChannel 2 years ago
its like people care more about the ckub then the actual performance!
hilary your the best
s3bas281994 2 years ago 2
it is a gay club and Hil has always said she loves gay people..and it means nothing...SHE'S A GODNESS
spanish4ever 2 years ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hey !! she is my girlfriend
49574589 2 years ago
haha i almost thought she collapsed
Happy0666 2 years ago
play back
emoxbangxmee 2 years ago
y is it called club G.A.Y. doesnt it mean gay???
KingdomHeartsFanTiff 2 years ago 5
YE GENIUS.
it's a gay club, but they let it out for concerts.
lukeBAM 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i love taylor! yall should check out bananaberryz videos! they are super cool! especially Forever and Always, Love Story and You Belong With me!!!!! check them out now!!!
BananaBerryz 2 years ago
those dancers are firece!
xxxx
hilzaa 2 years ago 2
aww. i love how everyone is sing :)
love this song
teenagelier 3 years ago
yes it isnt a gay club if hilary duffis there
becandchloe 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
few years ago, two parents went out for dinner. A few hours later, the baysitter was calling to ask if she could cover up the clown statue in the kids' room, the father said,"Take the kids and get out of the house. We'll call the police, we don't have a clown statue." The "clown statue" is really a killer that escaped from jail. If you don't post this on to 10 videos tonight, the clown will be in your bed at 3:00 am with a chainsaw in his hand;sorry i didn't want that happening to me
himofthedanube 3 years ago
It's not a club for gay people =.=" stupid people...!
It's totaly LIVE and great :)
LOVE Hil <3
AliskaKiska7 3 years ago 2
what's the big deal where she's playing? they're just people like you and me. grow up.
texantomboy17 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Wow is she at a gay club if so that is so funny
clarinetbulldog1996 3 years ago
are u blind?? it's not a gay club, fag
hzgg12 3 years ago
LOL
THE FANS WOULDNT LET GO OF HER HAND
xxiluvpinkxx 3 years ago
G.A.Y CLUB,WAT KIND OF CLUB IS THAT???
GUINEAIZZY1 3 years ago
OMG a lot of them knows the song LOL cool
sweetface1502 3 years ago
ahh hilary performed at a gay club?!
that must have been so fun!!
haha<3
MorganVictoria92 3 years ago
SO what she sort of lip syncing? Performing on live is not easy, especially when the music are damn loud.
seokhwi 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
January 6th is the Official International Reach Out Download day! We (the fans) are trying to make it become her 6th charting single. It's being promoted across youtube and even MOD in Canada! Please support Hilary by buying Reach Out on January 6th!
crazysilence 3 years ago
so obvious that she;s lip syncing
paydog23 3 years ago
She isnt lip syncing you hear that she makes mistakes
last0nights0rain 3 years ago 3
hilary eres la mejor no cabe la menor duda
nemocrito 3 years ago