Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (179)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • That's right, trolls, wallow in pain and sorrow, as I rock out to this amazing rendition of the song!

  • terrible as always.. Thank u fatnette :)

  • why is she destroying all old nightwish songs :(

  • no..please..PLEASE! NOT THIS SONG!!!

  • @pulcippo completely agree

    NOT THIS SONG!!

  • this sounds so different... btw. horrible sound quality!

  • Single tickets for only 12$ or purchase a 4-pack of these tickets for 40$ .... That is correct 1 General admission ticket for 12$ and 4 pack of General admission tickets for 40$ Onsale now for a limited time only

  • 41 people have a sense of music XD

  • muški 18-24

    ženski 18-24

    ženski 13-17

    kids love this easy stuff :)

  • @ISeeAnIdiot

    ah ye to translate since 95% of people can't use other keys than "tuomas!" and "<3" here :

    "male 18-24

    female - 18 - 24

    female 13 - 17"

  • goodie nightwish.

    you made 2 albums made for anette and you still can't hold back from RAPING old songs.

    good job. i hope you all go mute :)

  • @ISeeAnIdiot Why Im not suprised to see you in here. You must be really attention seeking little baby girl with pms. NW is better than ever now.

  • @MrSorsis

    that's why they are still singing the old songs? XD

    lol hell no. they are bad as usual live.

  • @ISeeAnIdiot eh, are you idiot or what? Ofc bands play the old songs in gigs. They are much better than with Tarja

  • @MrSorsis

    ofc they do, nobody is interested in the new songs :)

  • @ISeeAnIdiot More than Tarjas new ones

  • @MrSorsis

    yeah i mean she sold out her concert :)

    they didn't even fill the half :)

  • @ISeeAnIdiot Its half more than what Tarja would had had

  • @MrSorsis

    i dunno...5000 -8000 sounds much more than 3000 XD

    lolol

    you logic fails. do some research and read a book hun :)

  • @ISeeAnIdiot ye? Did Tarja do a gig in Key Club, West Hollywood?

  • @MrSorsis

    does she need america?

    no she doesn't :)

    only you don't see that.

  • @ISeeAnIdiot She would go there for sure if her talents would be big enough... you know... big moneys over there.

  • @ISeeAnIdiot Because I think Tarja doesnt even try go to USA, coz shes not big there. Shes only "big" in Europe, thus only doing gigs in Europe and South America. So it is YOU whos logic fails again

  • @MrSorsis

    and nw sure has a huge popularity in America?

    you are aware that they are selling for 12$? actually no..they are selling 4 tickets = 12$.

    She is big in Europe, she fills her gigs. South America is important honey you see, they buy albums. nw has bareley any popularity in america. moslty because americans are more into death metal ( the metal crowd part) and not wannabe goth stuff like nw.

    and the rest of the majority are the dumb 12 year old girls that are into pop.

  • @ISeeAnIdiot Neither of NW or Tarja has been "big" in US. At least NW is trying

  • @MrSorsis

    ps: their new video = ripoff of Falling Awake (the whole "making off" thing)

  • @ISeeAnIdiot Its much better what Tarjas new stuff

  • @MrSorsis

    bahahah "nw is trying" bahahahaha who are you kidding, they think that becuase they are "NIGHTWISH" that they are known to everybody bahahaha, they wont sellout in USA, they never will.

    btw learn to type XD

  • @ISeeAnIdiot I wouldnt say that. They will sell a lot more than Tarja ever will at least

  • @MrSorsis

    yeah.,.. i mean she only filled a 8000 people gig i mean...3000 can top that easily,

    bahahahahahaha XD nw are nobodies anymore.

  • @ISeeAnIdiot coz she does all her gigs in Europe. She would get thrown out from stage in US

  • @MrSorsis

    wel as far as i saw her concerts from Winter Storm tour went well in USA :)

    she does her gigs in Europe cause she knows that fans there give her money and popularity :)

    half empty gigs for 12$ = nothing.

  • @ISeeAnIdiot NW Dark Passion Play sold more than Tarjas Winter Strom

  • @MrSorsis only after Tarja NW has get such gigs

  • @MrSorsis

    so? :)

    that still proves nothing.

    Sorosis you dont like to admit it but nightwish are broke honey.

    the movie is what? 6 mil. budget, watching that in critical annalysis 6mil is very little. it's not gonna be a big hit.

  • @ISeeAnIdiot lol, I think Tarja is the poor one here. They have said already that their financial future is secured in Finnish media

  • @MrSorsis

    Tarja is poor oh yeah sure XD

    i mean shekept her finest drummer...one of the best in metal actually and she is broke XD

    sure sure. keep dreaming little girl.

  • @ISeeAnIdiot I find it weird that you keep watching NW official site... you must like NW. You just want attention by this trolling

  • @MrSorsis

    nah, LazyBoy told me that XD

    she did church gigs, ye with her new band she did. she does them every year :)

    tell me, to how many gigs were nw invited in this or the past year?

  • @ISeeAnIdiot tell me, where have you been last years? Havent you heard that NW was recording and wasnt even doing gigs because of that

  • @MrSorsis

    oh yes XD

    bahahahah even when bands are "recording" - they get an offer here and there to come to a big event. oh oops. nw didn't get those :)

  • @ISeeAnIdiot Its a bit different not wanting to do gigs or not getting gigs. Why it is so that NW is asked to everywhere now?

  • @MrSorsis

    and by everywhere you mean the gigs they chose? :)

    honey im talking about events, y'know like being on a tv, singing for a special occasion and so on :)

  • @ISeeAnIdiot You will see NW, if you live in Europe. Even in Romania, arent you from there

  • @MrSorsis

    thank god im not :)

    Croatia, they had a ...not so big sucesss with their gig here, i dunno how many people left.

    not to mention Serbia...

    what did Sara tell me ...ah ye : "it was horrible, lots of us left so we wouldn't have to listen to her, some of us stayed to watch the guys and pretend they dont hear her"

  • @ISeeAnIdiot I bet you will get more ppl to their gigs than Tarjas

  • @MrSorsis

    and no i wont make the same mistake twice, i saw them live...actually came to see the supporting bands they were pretty badass. and left after the 2nd song of nw.

  • @ISeeAnIdiot Oh, you know you want to... I bet you will be in their gig in a month or two

  • @MrSorsis nah. i hated it.

    i did see my friends going to Tarja's gig. they said around 2000 people were there. not bad due to the fact...well my country's music taste sucks hard.

    unforunately for me i couldn't go, heh personal business :P

  • @ISeeAnIdiot haha, I knew it. Tarja is going down

  • @MrSorsis

    bahaha trust me, my country = no big deal for any singers... except turbofolk...god i hate that genre.

    you play one song 2 times on the radio and it's no.1 hahaha, yeah that the part of my country that i hate.

    so you can easily skip my country on her tour XD

  • @ISeeAnIdiot

    but hey 2000...or was it more i dunno i didn't ask specificly out of 4000 is not bad here...trust me -.-

  • @ISeeAnIdiot bth, I dont trust you. I think its pretty bad

  • @ISeeAnIdiot and NWs... I can read between the lines

  • @MrSorsis

    yeah,going platinum here is like going platinu in finland, greece or slovenia = useless :)

  • @ISeeAnIdiot If Im not wrong NW has already sold 3 x platinum and is No. 1 in Finnish ladder. Tarja is nowhere to be seen in the ladder

  • @MrSorsis

    ooh went platinum in finland oh oh wow so they sold 50 000 copies, that's cute. they are still broke XD

  • @ISeeAnIdiot triple platinum hun, its 100 000 copies, I think. Tarja will never get that

  • @MrSorsis

    bahahahaha yeah yeah XD

    no honey. 10 000 is platinum in finland XD

  • @ISeeAnIdiot for Tarjas standards yes

  • @MrSorsis

    pardon me it's 20 000 copies XD

    so they sold 60 000 copies XD

    bahahahaha

  • @ISeeAnIdiot

    gold in greece = 6000 copies XD

  • @ISeeAnIdiot Tarja has always sold less copies in Germany, France, Greece,..., everywhere

  • @MrSorsis

    yeah XD only 500 000 with her first album which everybody said that it's nooooooot popularz -.- XD

  • @ISeeAnIdiot Sold less than NWs album at the same time

  • @MrSorsis

    yeah, her music is more for those who have ears, y'know male and adult female part of the music lovers.

    you should have seen nw fans here...around...2000 12- 16 year old girls XD

  • @ISeeAnIdiot just check Tarjas fan group and you will be sadly suprised.

  • @MrSorsis

    and check out nw fan group = 95% of the comments : we want tarja back.

    LOL.

  • @ISeeAnIdiot Thats odd... coz I have only seen: Tarjaholics leave and get over your 1st pms:s.

  • @MrSorsis

    your spelling is flawless looooooooooool.

    you know what i see? "omgzz nightwizhh is zozozzoo awezome and anette iz flawszelsss and tuomas aisssh sosos hottttt" and ofc "tarja suxxx shesh a gredddy bitach and nw iz perfect"

  • @ISeeAnIdiot Ow, you should go in eye-doctor. You are at least right in one thing: my spelling is fawless, ty

  • @MrSorsis

    an eye doctor?

    yeah... you mean Optometrist?

    you have no good arguments.. im wasting my time on a person's who's brain is smaller than pea.

  • @ISeeAnIdiot yes, AN optometrist. Oh, its bigger than your brain then, lol

  • @MrSorsis

    yeah, my doesn't fit my head :)

    silly little girl, you have no good comebacks, how about you go to wikipedia and reaad something from there :)

  • @ISeeAnIdiot I think I hit you pretty well with my comebacks :). Your brain doesnt fit your head? How small skull do you have? Must be really tiny

  • @MrSorsis

    eh, what comebacks? "nw sold insert number here copies"

    and you repeat that over and over and over and over again. it's old honey, they are not good comebacks. it's plain annoying. and...this one right now has no sense hun :)

    and yeah, i'm short, but my boyfriend is tall. it's odd to kiss though XD

  • @ISeeAnIdiot tall in your standards, I think. Coz if your brain is smaller than pea, he must be a freak too

  • @MrSorsis

    yeah... i mean he is only on the collage for a Cardiologist XD

    but hey what do i know, i should listen to a person who spends most of her time on her youtube, going to every tarja vid in my favorites to dislike it hahahaha

    ps. i atleast have a boyfriend :))

  • @ISeeAnIdiot better doing that than trolling in NW page, which you obviously love, but wont admit in public

  • @MrSorsis

    i do love it :)

    but i dont spend my whole day on yt or the internet :)

    im more like to be drunk with my mates in the local pub XD

  • @ISeeAnIdiot good luck with that, Im over that phase, lol

  • @ISeeAnIdiot and you admitted to love NW... I have proof now

  • @MrSorsis

    "i do love it" refers to " i love trolling nw pages"

    silly little girl :)

  • @ISeeAnIdiot well, it only proves that Tarja doesnt sell even 20 000

  • @MrSorsis

    i doubt that XD

    if she was zoooooooooooo unpopular like you say she wouldn't sellout :))

    you see, your logic still fails. you have no good argument. you rely on wikipedia statistics.

    here's a statstic for you : 95% of the critics that REALLY went by the facts said the exact same thing : "it's average, it couldn't pass for more than a movie sountrack album"

  • @ISeeAnIdiot Im not saying shes unpopular, Im saying NW is more popular than Tarja... even if NW had 4 years break, lol

  • @MrSorsis

    yeah, that's why they sell for 12$.

    ofc :)

  • @ISeeAnIdiot Tarja must have handed freebies... more than in one way... to get that many buyers

  • @MrSorsis

    nah, 12$ is free :)

    not 70$ for her gig XD

    atleast that's how much it was here the last time i checked. that was 1 month ago though

  • @ISeeAnIdiot lol, just wait when NW will come in your courners

  • @MrSorsis btw I belive NW is doing their BIGGEST gig in France in near future, so... you dont really know what you are talking

  • @MrSorsis

    hahaha oh yeah XD i bet they'll sellout. i think it's gonna be "10 dollars for 4 tickets" this time hahahahaha

  • @ISeeAnIdiot It has been already sold out, full price ofc. NW didnt get gigs with Tarja

  • @MrSorsis

    bahahaha oh yeah. only performaed infront of like 100 000 people with Tarja XD

  • @ISeeAnIdiot yes, but they will get their biggest gig in their history this year... so new NW >> Old NW

  • @MrSorsis

    hahaha still nothing good honey. they are broke :))

    is that why they have "donate" on their official site.

    ps i was wrong it's 3,7 mil budget film = even worse, it's gonna be like watching Kazaam

  • @ISeeAnIdiot Better than Tarjas movie... oh wait... she has no movie.

  • @MrSorsis

    aw does she need it?

    she isn't desperate for money my dear :)

  • @ISeeAnIdiot Belive me, she is. She even did some church gigs in Finland

  • @ISeeAnIdiot poor Tarja cant even dream of doing movie

  • @ISeeAnIdiot

    oh i love it when i write one thing and mean other "they are nobodies now" XD

  • @ISeeAnIdiot even tho I havent seen that yet, lol. Im sure its much better than Tarjas

  • fue la unica cancion buena de este concierto,estuve ahi y por poco me duermo,tuve la oportunidad de verlos con tarja y esa si era banda de metal,aparte eran mas humildes

    anette olzon tiene una voz nasal que la verdad no se en que se basaron para elegirla como sucesora de tarja en fin...para la nostalgia estuvo bien..gracias nightwish

  • Good Job Anette! :)

  • This video confirms my thoughts (see my comment at I want my tears back live video :P)

  • Jeez people are still going to be on the Annette vs tarja thing 10 years from now aren't they? So annoying. I agree this isn't annettes best song but I just watched planet he'll and she kicked ass on that one :)

  • @lorelai5000 Cause they just learnt that we walked on the moon, the Berlin wall fell, 911 happened and HOLY SHIT, Nightwish has another singer since 2006!

  • listen the complete version and with a better audio here:

    watch?v=ve2G9USqQ2A

    is a great vesion.

    to the tarja's fans: :D hahaha good look with your opinions, who cares for your bullshit .. anyone needs your opinion... hahaha

    stupid idiots...hahaha XD

  • @TheRicochet4 Yep, she's doing WORSE, that's why the band recorded it and was happy with it, they thought "yeah, she's doing worse, it's what we looked for!". Then they went to sell it and got critical acclaim cause you know, everyone was thinking "my my, it's so much worse, it's genius".

  • @Jillian

    If by critical acclaim you understand a few payed reviews and the lot of early teen fans on YT.. yeah.

    Seriously, if people like you hear this parody and say "It's great", the band will take it as a sign of approval. "If the idiots like it, why not?"

  • @TheRicochet4 I didn't say this version was "great". I'm not a big fan of this cover anyway, and I find it an odd way to finish the concert. All the "idiots" are of course sending messages to NW's management who will sure give a damn and amend the tour and all in consequence. Generally speaking, Nightwish goes on, no matter what people think, there are people to love them, people to give up on them, and you know what? it's fine if you belong to the latter group. Totally fine.

  • @TheRicochet4 Oh and, I just find that funny how you can say "paid reviews", why? What are your sources? Or you mean, the positive reviews must come from a paid webzine and the bad ones are OF COURSE the independent (and therefore) trusted ones?

    And the sign of approval for a band is when their CD sells and the venues are full, not the gazillions of more or less retarded comments on websites and Youtube.

  • @Jillian

    You have no logic man, instead of wasting time writing I suggest you spend it thinking. This is the last reply from me. backed by arguments like all my others (and like none of yours).

    - number of sold CDs means nothing, BECAUSE if it would be an indicator, it will mean that Bieber or Gaga are the gods of music and Callas or Pavarotti are karaoke singers.

    -> ->

  • @TheRicochet4 I have no logic... You can still debate without throwing lame stuff like this at people. I can also quote you what, dozens of reviews from webzines, independent websites, in various languages (cause well yes, there are not only English reviews that matter) and tell you "you see, they like it, they're independent, SO YOU ARE WRONG". Reviews are reviews, I read them to have a description of the music, it doesn't mean they're Evangiles.

  • @Jillian

    He is kind of right you are not following your own logical thread. I was curious and followed your discussion. The "reviews" topic started because you mentioned "critical acclaim". His point was that 1)Critical acclaim does not matter if it's fake; and 2)It did not even receive much critical acclaim but the contrary.

    Myself am not disappointed by the album but if it tries to pass as something more than a movie soundtrack, it fails.

  • @Jillian

    ->

    - number of sold CDs and gigs reflect nothing about Imaginaerum's quality, BECAUSE the fame sold them. Imaginaerum was sold platinum before it was even released.

    - "bribed" and "fan" reviews are such, BECAUSE they do not analyze, but praise. And do it without any argument. And are the same "house" magazines every time (magazines praising all the bands represented under a label). Decent enough explanation?

    - however, most critics were negative, FOR EXAMPLE...

    ->

    -

  • @Jillian

    Here is a blast - a reviewer accusing in face other reviewers of being bribed:

    .

    "At first listening the album by specialists before the official launch, everyone says is a great album and it's the best Nightwish so far. Most likely those specialists were paid to say this, unfortunately."

    .

    Random quote

    - "... revolves around the fact that it has cheap clichés to indulge along its goth fairytale atmosphere and satisfies with bombastically presented mediocrity"

  • @Jillian

    And so on. Most independent reviewers say the same

    "this album is a mix of self-indulgence, over-ambition and at times poor execution, but with some enjoyable songs to balance it out."

    "without comparing Anette to any other [..] she is a very bad singer, and while you could say she's versatile because she can attempt to "sing" in many different ways, she ends up sounding so bad most of the time [..] it's simply painful listening to her"

    .

    Whatever, I am bored of this. Cya

  • Oh yes and the "harmonizing" towards the end is the painful part and the most hilarious!!

  • I prefer Tarja's version, but i am not deaf, i think Anette did a very good try; she did train her voice during this years :D

  • Dammit... Anette got so much better! It's unbelievable :o

  • I am so sorry.. but i really can't like this :(

  • hm, quality is not that good, but I think, I dont like this version... I imagined Anettes voice would fit this song really good, as she has a such a nice and warm voice, but she doesnt use it in here - whhhyyyy? ;)

  • Thank you so much! All of you, Nightwish and the guy who uploaded the video. :)

  • @Jillian did you know Tarja was ill during that concert? why don't you listen to ever dream by anette when she sang in Australia? Anette was also ill in that concert and she did a hideous performance. I congratulate Tarja because even if she is ill she can give decent performances, unlike Nettie.

  • @TheAmaranthObsession I hope this is a trolling spree...if not, you must be so desperate

  • Comment removed

  • @TheAmaranthObsession Do we make a contest of "who sings better when they're sick"? Ideally singers should keep the bed when they're sick, they can't most of the time so you just have to deal with their performance. Doesn't mean you can't critique it.

    And why do you keep bringing a singer who's out of NW for 7 years now? She saved your life or something? Get over it. No one's forcing you to listen to post-Tarja Nightwish. Plenty of other bands out there for everyone.

  • @MrNakhrul My opinion of her version of Over the Hills is no "lies", it's my opinion. I loved the show overall but didn't like this song and some little other stuff Tarja did at this show (like her bits on The Siren). I'm no Tarja hater, Anette hater, Tarja holic or whatever stupid label people love to put on themselves, I happen NOT TO LIKE one freaking song of a concert and I explained why. Get over it.

  • @Jillian

    You're no hater, just aphonic

  • @MrNakhrul If you want. I do not really mind what you may think of me.

  • The only perfmormance from this show I don't like. Maybe it's becouse of quality.

  • i can only hear Marco! she sings really bad in this song! maybe she should stick to imaginecrap stuff

  • @TheAmaranthObsession If it's that bad to you then simply don't watch it :)

  • @TheAmaranthObsession They sell ear cleaner at most pharmacies. You should try it out!

  • @DerMetalKrieger crap, it's the troll XP They were spamming another clip of this show, someone else's recording of scaretale. Anette really showed everyone up here eh? She's to have settled down real well with the band

  • @DerMetalKrieger well go get it. my ears work perfectly ^^

  • @TheAmaranthObsession If you hear only Marco, how can you tell she sings badly...? "I can't hear her but it's so bad" > "LOL"?

    And she doesn't make the setlist, the band does, if it's not to your taste, too bad. Send them an e-mail, sure they'll amend their future shows to your liking.

  • @Jillian it is obvious: she will always sing like shit! haha

  • @TheAmaranthObsession So let me get this straight. You come to a video of a Nightwish concert from 2012, almost SEVEN YEARS after Tarja and Nightwish parted ways, just to bash Anette?

    You need to 1) Get over the fact that Tarja's not in the band anymore, and 2) Get a life.

    And this still doesn't explain why you have Amaranth in your username, which was on Dark Passion Play. Which, as I recall, was sung by ANETTE.

  • @cml9023 well played!

  • @TheAmaranthObsession "Imaginecrap" - I agree.

    They have totally changed.. Songs are just OK and nothing more.. :(

  • @EscapingWind you are not the only one. even some die hards i know weren't satisfied with the album.

  • @TheAmaranthObsession Yes. We have reasons ..

  • it is funny that one of the complaints i read from nightwish fans is that Tarja fans go and name Tarja on nw vids. Well, just see how YOU all are naming Tarja! you just wish Anette could sing like the goddess! hahahaa

  • Comment removed

  • @TheAmaranthObsession No, the funny thing is how you're bashing Anette when you have an Anette song in your username.

  • @cml9023

    no honey. The Amaranth is a song far better than "amaranth" by nightwish.

  • the audio is not the best, but Is great to enjoy this new version.... what can I say??? AMAZING!!!!

    And Anette did it so wonderfull.... she said that she wanted to sing this song, so I was completely sure she was going to do it great.... I WAS RIGHT!!!

  • @GrissyPink7y9 realmente me pregunto por qué te enfocás en la cantante siendo que Nightwish es una banda. recuerdo que te quejaste de la versión de Tarja de the siren que si nightwish esto, que si nightwish lo otro. Bueno, deberías comenzar a nombrar a todos, dado que cuando Tarja canta una canción te quejas de la banda y ahora que el resto de la formación de nightwish está presente, sólo te enfocás en la patética cantante que tienen!

  • @TheAmaranthObsession porque Anette dijo que deseaba cantar esta canción, por eso fué que comenté sobre ella. Sobre la banda, el arreglo de gaita está genial, me gustó que suplieran el efecto del teclado con la gaita de Troy, Emppu excelente y con actitud estupenda, lo mismo Jukka, Tuomas tocó estupendo, y Marco estuvo excelente en los coros y también en el bajo, todos lo hicieron estupendo y entregaron el alma en el escenario, todos brillaron estupendamente, salieron a matar y entregarse.

  • @TheAmaranthObsession Por otro lado dije, esta nueva version (por mencionar el arreglo incluyendo a Troy) es maravillosa, y lo es. ¿Anette Patética? alguien patético y tan malo podría haber mejorado tanto como ella? no creo

    Y "the siren" de Tarja, repito, la parte vocal DE ELLA es maravillosa, pero lo instrumental es un desastre, el intro lo despedazaron y los solos de teclado y guitarra les quedó horrible, y el "chico Marco" ese si es patético, solo Tarja vale la pena de esa version

  • Fuck, Anette improved SO MUCH *-* I would fall to my knees hearing more old Nightwish songs if I saw them live *-* Haha, I thought Tuomas said Over the Hills was never gonna be played again, because the band played it a bajillion times XD

  • I never believe to hear this great Gary Moore cover from NW but Fuck...here it is better than ever even the sound is not the best...this band really Rocks!

  • I was waiting for this since I heard a first single with Anette :)

  • @flowerzofblood NO U.

  • If sound would be better, than it would be amazing, but anyway nice video!

    Nightwish forever.

  • Awesome version! I like this version even more than Tarja :)

  • Anette x Tarja? Bitch, please. Both are great!

  • Anette IS good. By the hell, compare to her earlier performances, she has improved A LOT <3. And I dont want to be a troll, but she dresses much better now too :)))

  • Much BETTER than TARJA !!!!!!