Nicolai Gedda - Amid the Noise of the Ball (Tchaikovsky)

[Kwinta52]

Хорошее исполнение.

[semme01]

wow, what lovely phrasing. this is magnificent

[juskisiberiano]

In my opinion the piano, being good, is not at the level of the singer, and in that this is a slower and quieter version than the usual, but then I don't find it too quiet not halting at all, . As a matter of fact I certainly like this version much more. The reflection, subject of the song, is a reverie, made in a musing way.

And certainly, and this is what I would suppose vstasov refers to when he says that Gueda "is trying to say something", I find this rendering particularly expressive.

[vinllga]

It is really the best interpretation of this song on youtube. If he will follow only notes, as usual, it is boring and monotonous. Gedda have the surprising scent in Russian which is absent to our shame beetween our own singers. And you instead of low bowing to him, direct the silly and incompetent criticism.

You cant understand the the main difficlties and specific of this romance and Lieder at whole

[Roam665]

@vinllga The last interpretation of Hvorostovsky is better for me.

[vinllga]

@Roam665 are you listen Zara Dolukhanova?