Added: 3 years ago
From: craigrose007
Views: 44,996
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (243)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Were you stoned when you played this? Because that would be crazy.

  • how do you get your sound for this?

  • @HybridStoner ...this particular song? (amp settings, delay, distortion, etc?)

  • do you know where i can get a back track for this song, just like the one on this vid? this was really good!

  • Great video!...

    Do you mind tell me where can I get this play along track?

    - I am learning to play this piece myself. very challenging....

  • too much reverb, not enough comp...great playing though :)

  • How does it feel to be able to play with this kind of emotion, in an effortless way. How did you learn this song so well? Furthermore, are you in a band? You should listen to my version of this song, and let me know what you think. I played all the instruments on it. 

  • bravo

  • Pink Floyd is a different genre by itself

  • This is Animusic does Pink Floyd. lol Awesome.

  • SOrry but you kinda messing me up....lol,..but you have your own version which is cool.

  • @JeromePoyer you know hes playing the pulse version right?

  • @XxscenekidzrulexX OOh ok cool I guess havent seen that verion thanks " I 'm like DUh..!..lol"

  • @JeromePoyer lol yeah its my favorite performance of the song

  • you miss one solo and the best solo of the song

  • it´s perfect...

  • Nice solo bro.

    extremely difficult.

    Pink Floyd has produced one of the best mucic in history ever

    playing it is really a gift of life that requires a LOT of talent, dedication and will

  • @Hollandvancewright Never mind, I got to watch the rest. That was an excellent performance.

  • My bandwidth went down 4 minutes in and I couldn't watch the rest, which was a disappointment.

  • Dude, awesome job.

  • is this an american strat? or mexican, because im looking at the neck work and im thinkin its genuine american, standard strat.

  • Great job.. but man you should play on your own (with a real backing track and without Dave's guitar, I really feel that his guitar is almost louder than yours) there are great real backing tracks on the net

  • what key is this song in?

  • excellent job pal

  • Awesome cover!! By far one of the best on youtube.

  • Comment removed

  • You killed it! Absolute awesome job! Wish I had the talent...

  • Hi, Really enjoyed your cover. What equipment are you using?

  • Látom, hogy 6 embernek nem tetszik ez a zene. Ezek az emberek nem normálisak!

    Csak egyszer vennének gitárt a kezükbe, megtudnák, micsoda teljesítmény volt az

    előbbi számot eljátszani a gitáron. Fantasztikus! És fejből az egész, nem ám

    kottákból! Szerintem míg normális emberek lesznek a Földön, ezek a zenék

    mindig élni fognak és tanítják őket az iskolában!

  • you forgot the third solo and is that an alternate version

  • @Rorschachxx1985 Later versions of this song played live omitted the 3rd solo. This is the version from PULSE which was the live concert in 1995 at Earls Court to promote their last album Division Bell. The last time the 3rd solo was played live was 1977. The 2006 On An Island tour version of Shine On amalgamated the 2nd and 3rd solos into a new bluesy solo followed by a scaled down vocal and clean guitar only for verses with the band coming in for the 2nd chorus ("wore out your welcome...")

  • Nicely done!

  • very well played.... :D

  • why do 6 people not like this?? sounds amazing!

  • @jimbosbimboshoes cos people are jealous most probably

  • Great playing!

  • Your guitar is a fender classic player 50 ? :D

    Good job !

  • @ludo1890 judging by the finish, and saddle type Id say its a standard american

  • @Noseheros Mexican standard judging by the color and headstock decal, this a 60th anniversary.

  • @stratocasterfranck I suppose you're right! I hadn't seen the decal when I last posted and remembered the color from some fedner american standard ads I read in a few old guitarcenter pamplets they send me...but I bet you're right, and Im glad someone knows what they're talking about, because most people on here (me included) don't know as much as we think we do

  • Here's a guy that has his act together, great sound and playing as always and thanks

    for posting your musical talent, thanks Craig

  • i play guitar too,, and i play that song too but you do it better than mee because your bends and your vibratos are better than mine.....exellent...

  • Excelent my man!

  • I know you probably get asked this a lot, but what guitar do you have there? it's got an awesome sound. Gilmour would be proud of your playing! While i'm at it, how much reverb do you use? cheers!

  • GREAT PLAYING!!!!!

  • This is the best cover ive seen of this song. Great job. Amazing just amazing.

  • Nice, I'm at the 3rd solo now :D god job!

  • Best song in the world

  • man you are one of a faw Pink Floyd Players in the whole world...

  • marooned. please and thank you.

  • this is fuckn crazy perfect

  • one thing i dislike ! is guitar players playing along with the original recording !!!

    play it along with a backing track .. yes ..but with the main guitar taken out ! then we can hear your take on the track .. other wise it gets masked by the original guitar playing in the back ground !!

  • @papalazerus22 most of the backing tracks unfortunately have guitar in the background, which I realy dont get

  • @Bluesguitar247 great job !! respect chris

  • I'm a big disappointed. Your playing is fantastic, but I wanted to hear the entire whole thing, all the way to part 9 or whichever part Gilmour uses a slide.

  • Thank you.

    That is all

  • Holy Shit!

  • Hell of an awesome song! Keep rocking on.

  • AWESOME!

  • Pleasure to watch, thank you..

  • awesome man! i love the light effect

  • dammmmm dude i just love your covers!!!!

  • You are fantastic guitar player !!!Amazing-Can i please tab-please!!!

  • awh shit i watched this for the bit at 7:07 and u cut it off!!!!! :(

  • This is the version from the Royal Albert Hall concert if I'm correct? :) well done friend

  • DUDE THAT WAS FUCKING AWESOME U BLEW ME AWAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • muito bom, parabéns.......um abraço do Brasil !!!

  • Nice.

  • I have some killer calluses on my fingers from playing this album

  • hey man:) awsome cover;) can i ask you what your setup is for this song and what pedals you are using?? i know you have flanger but : bass-midd-treeble?? and are you using other effects?

  • 6 dislikes really? i guess there are 6 ppl who can do it better where are their vids?

  • amazing, im subscribing!

  • great strumming pattern at 2:31

  • Wow! This is an awesome cover!

  • Yeah this is fake. The music has been EQed to sound like its been recorded in this room. It's actually from Pink Floyd Live. Had me fooled for a bit though.

  • @Neyowolf OR HAS IT???

  • @Neyowolf not fake. you can hear the tone change when he changes pickups. also you can hear a mistake in the deginning

  • You need to get you Strat outfitted with the EMG-DG20 pickup set that David used throughout the 80's and 90's. Those pickups help bring this song to life!!!! Great playing though!

  • that's a sexy guitar? what kind of fender is it I can't really read it?

  • @hockeyMVP4life I think it's a Fender 50's Classic Player in Shoreline Gold

  • how did you get this sound? and tone!?

    thanks

  • All I can say is.....WOW!!!!I LOVE your cover.It's one of the best I've heard,if not THE best!I'll have to do a cover soon.Gilmour is God!!!!Keep up the good work!!!!

  • Lol, this is just Gilmour himself; didn't film his head so he can be like ''lol everybody on youtube thinks some dude can play awesome like me but naaaah!! Only I can xD''

  • love your cover dude, keep on..

  • ha people think this is fake? ha i admit the sound is incredible but if you know anything about guitar playing you can tell this is 100% real. good job bro keep it up!

  • The only difficult thing about playing this song is remembering the whole thing.

    Good job Craig!

  • You sir.. are a god lol.. I would die to acquire your amazing talent. Do not stop playing that guitar man.. You are awesome!

  • Great sound , Great playing, my ears gone crazy :P

  • Could you tell me where did you get the backing track?

    I think I'm gonna need this one for the cover that I'm going to make

  • Really well played mate! On those long-held bends and notes during the start bit, try a tiny bit ov the old vibrato arm (whammy bar) just to add some depth.

  • what are you doing wasting your talent on here?

    your really good man.

  • Which pedals are you using here? I must say, your tone is superb

  • 1 word........ Beautiful.

  • Very good, but try to use the whammy bar more, then it's perfect!!!!!

  • my guitar teacher learned this by ear and he finger pix it

  • this is sooooooo sick dude best on youtube fo sho

  • this is david gilmour in disguise lol jk ur good man!

  • Shame that this isn't the FULL song, the full song is 24.01 minutes lol.

  • @SirPwn4lot it's the cover from PULSE version

  • Ouch. That is so good it hurts. 6 Stars.

  • HOLY SHIT!!! :OO

    you blew my mind dude

    incredible

    you really have something going

    keep the good work

  • Dr. House playing !!! Amazing !!

  • Just freakin' awesome! and it's one of my many Pink Floyd favorites.

    Just another question, what is the setup in both your guitar and amp, and if you have an effect pedal, which is it? I've been trying to get that David Gilmour sound but I seem to be missing something.

    Thanks

  • beautifl

  • Sick dude.

  • Great Job!

  • però non sei tu a suonare, o sbaglio?

  • è lui... ha la base sotto

  • this isnt the original from the album. the real one from wish you were here has an extra solo and if i were you id check it out. i personally like the studio album one better forgetting the extra solo but very nice job

  • beautiful song, well played

  • I normally hate seeing these, but could someone comment on my cover as well? its been around for a while but not many people have seen it

  • Hey man what pickups do you use? please tell me and my dad are restoring my strat and while its apart i wanna put some pick ups on it.

  • I`d like to see you do Marooned from Pink Floyd.

  • that song is fucking amazing.

  • motherfucker,im tryin so hard and im not 1/0 as good . :)but after all ite my first month with a guitar :D

  • much respect

  • Man oh man! I wish I could play my guitar as well as you do... hell that'll come. But not anytime soon I'm afraid x)

  • Are you sure you didnt cut off gilmours hands and attach them to your arms?

  • I just love your covers !

    You gave me motivation to learn this master piece.

  • How long have you been playing? And how long till I can come close to this LOL =P I have been playing for a year... =(

  • I've been playing for 5 and I still don't have this down all the way.

  • guys.. he's been playing for 25 years..

    so i say we have a lot to do before we get to his level :D

  • Awesome =D Great job with the timing at the beginning man!

  • WOW. that about says it all. wish i could play it that well. all ur vids are awsome

  • Deserve more views !!

    Awesome !!

  • very good solo!!!!!!!!

  • VERY GOOD MAN!!!CONGRATULATIONS!

  • All I can say is WoW!! I've been listening to Pink Floyd for years and have listened to many versions of this song but you just fucking blew me away, the timing is 99.9 perfect in my opinion and the passion you put into it would make David Gilmour proud I'm sure; this is the first song I'd like to play as soon as I buy my first electric guitar and I'll look to your video for guidance. Thanks for such a beautiful rendition and look forward to other Pink Floyd songs in your repertoire. Play on!!

  • @braindamage70 I agree ! 100% Great one ! I playing these one since my first guitar too ! They correct me on a lot of things !! = D Alright now it sound goood !!

  • this sounds realy great you play almost just like in the real version good job this is amazing !

  • nothing less than awesome (not surprising since everything you play is).

    I am a newbee that appreciates the inspiration. By the way, is this song in standard tuning ? Keep it coming man - you sound great.

  • bravooooo ;) 1

  • Man, a lot of these guys making bad comments have no idea what they are talking about. This is a great cover, I wish I could play like that, will get on practicing this song now.

  • This is close to perfection. I'm very impressed.

  • Amazing Guitarist, enough said. This the best from the best of YouTube.

  • As a great Gilmour and Knopfler fan myself, I must say you're doing one hell of a job!! When I read most of the comments here, I notice there's a lot of envy comming from people who haven't posted a decend video .... such a shame, a little pathetic also! Keep up the great work. I'm a fan!

  • Make a cover then, asshole.

  • Im having troubles with the Guitar effects for this song, I have a BOSS ME-50 pedal... can you help me?

    Anyway, REALLY GREAT JOB!

  • ahah, i can assure you its not fake...

  • @craigrose007 Why would he play all the notes flawlessly on the guitar then mute it and put on the song?

    That makes NO sense.

  • You fucking douchebag.

  • @viper4525 It's called a backing track...

  • @viper4525 u r being an ass u retard so screw off i can tell hes actually playing it

  • @viper4525 you don't understand nothing about guitar.

  • @viper4525 You can't hear his playing?

  • @viper4525 plz, dont be ignorant in your selfish ways just because you cant play as good as Craig here doesnt mean you have to b a dick

  • @viper4525 Well, even if u're not trying to be an ass, you ARE. Don't open your mouth when you don't know anything about what u're trying to talk about, asshole.

    Oh, sorry, did not mean to be rude:) And pardon my language, English is not exactly my mother tongue

  • @viper4525 And if you have no idea how it is done go this site and learn a little, asshole:

    guitarbackingtrack dot ( you know what to add at the end)

  • wow amazing i have never heard a cover this close to gilmour great job! 5 star preformance two thumbs up!!!

  • Absolutely perfect 5/5, David Gilmour would b proud. this is my favourite pink floyd song and u did it a great justice. :)

  • smoke one and listen in the dark while watching this video. You do Gilmour proud brother!!

  • got your on crowed and everything... good job bro!

  • this is a sweet song !

    well cover (Y)

  • if only gilmour had played the bit from the original song at 7 : 40... he skipped that part and straight away sang the song in PULSE.. i was waiting for it, and was terribly disappointed.

    btw, nice cover man.

  • are you playing along to pulse?

  • This is amazing. Inspiring :-)

  • excellent playing but something's wrong with your sound. I think I hear a bad feedback and perhaps you should put some more bass and middle frequencies in it.

    Still an awesome video though!

  • nice job bro!

  • great job dude...i play it a little different but its the exact same shit...floyd is purly geniouse...

  • sorry but it sounds not so good tome.

    you are playing with the original song together and your guitar is double with gilmours guitar. you must play alone to show us your technic.

  • WHAT???

  • Is it Shoreline Gold?

  • Wow! absolutely fantastic, best cover I've seen

  • Awesome work mate. Sounds wonderful. You did a fantastic job covering this mate. Played well and the feeling comes through :)

    Going to have to get me a Fender strat now, just can't quite get the sound right on my rich with humbuckers :(

  • awesome! 6/5:)

  • What pedal effect do you use for this Gilmour' song? It's awesome.

  • Music is expression. Screw these people who don't own a guitar, have never played hot, have never recorded a minute of music, but know more and can critique so well. Jam on. Do you think they even know what Sound on Sound is? Point them to the AC/DC covers.