This song is cursed with remakes, hell Dave Mustaine wrote the riff and Lars did what Lars does best. I admit, as a metal fan, its by far the best remake compared to the original.
@MetallicAM93 Sonata Arctica did an EXCELLENT cover of this. It doesn't have the ending solo (one of my favorite parts), but it's very good nonetheless.
@VideoMask93 I have that cover on my computer, and it's good. But guitars in Metallica version are way better than in SA version. And solo... one of best solos of Kirk, so i still think Metallica version is better
@VideoMask93 me too. But i think the best covers are these brutal. were young heavy bands play fast and brutal songs of Metallica. like Master (trivium), Battery (Machine Head), Creeping Death (don't have good cover, but i'm still looking for), No Remorse (Cannibal Corpse), or Disposable Heroes (chimaira), Metallica 4 ever \m/
If you read the liner notes the band wrote for this song it says they purposely played less notes in the intro solo than the original, and out of key as a homage to Kirk. I think it's basically just a piss take for the band.
I actually find it hard to belive this is Steel Prophet, They are a great band, but this cover-version is perhaps the most crappy cover I've ever heard!! And that includes the christmas carol renditions of Metallica!!
@IronMetalHead150 It doesn't need to have a solo. You ever heard the Sonata Arctica version? It's brilliant. Although I think a solo at the end just sounds like it fits anyway.
The intro solo is painful. Whoever these guys are, should really stick to originals and forget killing other people's songs. Vocals are godawful. I'm not sure why metallica didn't tell these guys never to cover them x.x The final solo...fucking sucks. All in all, how are these guys getting albums out? They fucking suck.
u say Justin Bieber-I say ACDC You say Miley Cyrus-I say sonata arctica You say T-Pain-I say Slipknot You say Flowers-I say Metallica You say Pink I say Iron Maiden You say HipHop-i say shut the fuck up You say Pop-I scream Heavy Metal You say hanah montana-i fucking punch you in the face 92% of teenagers have turned to HipHop and Pop.If you are part of the 8% that still listen to real music, lets fill all the videos to wake them up! DON'T LET THE SPIRIT OF ROCK DIE
its a good cover and all, but the vocals dont sound that great to me idk and the solos kinda feel drug out and slurred.. but it does show that they can put their sound into it
@Huoha You have no idea what you just asked for.. There is no way in hell you can do a better Metallica Cover Better than them.. how can you when Band's like Trivium can only do a Master of Puppets that is Good. but Metallica's is EPIC.. likewise goes to Iron Maiden , Megadeth like bands.. you can't beat the Original's dude.. You come talk to me when you make a Cover of Holywar's by Megadeth Better than them.. it's like saying you're superman.. when you know you can't fly
@MeTaLiXe lol lars drumming is bullshit... and ye holy wars is another thing... nick menza is fucking beast drummer but lars just sucks... this has way more energy on drums wich lars lacks alot. and wtf trivium? trivium fucking sucks ass dont come to me with that shit :D but if you listen to that emocore or whatever it is then its your shame
@Huoha What the fuck is a emocore? stop talking about emo craps. and who is comparing Lars to Nick menza ? you can't compare it. Nick Menza Pwns. like i said. you come talk to me WHEN YOU do a cover of HolyWars better than Megadeth's Rust in Peace Version.. than you got my respect. other than that.. you better take your comment back about other's making better cover's of these Big four than them..
@Huoha You made me laugh to be honest. Lars is a good drummer, nothing more. he isnt bad, BUT. Lars is a fucking GENIOUS. All of his writing in the first 5 MetallicA albums? You joking? Also, no one can do a MetallicA cover better than them, and most of them who try to do a better or even a good cover, they fail. I know a few good covers like.. Trivium - Master of Puppets & Dark Angel - Creeping Death. Also, Trivium are the best metal band of this decade along with Machine Head.
This song is cursed with remakes, hell Dave Mustaine wrote the riff and Lars did what Lars does best. I admit, as a metal fan, its by far the best remake compared to the original.
m3diazombi3 1 month ago
I <3 This.
LUXXXable 1 month ago
I am the one singing on this, and yes, I might have over sang on this, I can't speak for the guitarist.
Rick Mythiasin
mythman666 2 months ago
@mythman666 who whas the drummer?? please tell me who was drumming on this song.
LUXXXable 2 months ago
Kirk will be very disappointed.
MaFiaZai 4 months ago
Comment removed
LUXXXable 4 months ago
Comment removed
LUXXXable 4 months ago 6
Comment removed
LUXXXable 4 months ago
Comment removed
LUXXXable 4 months ago
Comment removed
LUXXXable 4 months ago
Love the entire song except the solos. They are putrid.
brianhardaway1984 7 months ago
Lead guitar was kinda week for me, Rythm guitar sounds great but the leads uhhhg! What were they thinking man!
Metalmanmania357 7 months ago
could be more acceptable if they didnt changed the intro solo , its like the signature solo of the damm song...why change it?
Dragonslayergnr 7 months ago
I really like the singing alot my personal opinion but your right the guitar work is bad why i thought they had great guitarist
omnadrener 8 months ago
its a pretty cool to bad this isnt rick singing the original singer from Steel Prophet dont know much about this guys voice anyone know about him?
omnadrener 8 months ago
Seems like this song doesn't fit their vocals so much. It just doesn't sound right to me.
TheHellfireQueen 8 months ago
Meh, its good but i like Sonata Arctica's cover beter
M3ta1Head1 8 months ago
steel prophet ? wow that's original. But I think Iron Maiden copied your idea...
bgnalm 8 months ago
The vocals, the vocals, the vocals and the vocals c:
eLMagoxd1 8 months ago
only Metallica can play theirs songs like Fade to Black, One, Welcome Home. Covers of this songs are just worse. No way to do it better.
MetallicAM93 8 months ago
@MetallicAM93 Sonata Arctica did an EXCELLENT cover of this. It doesn't have the ending solo (one of my favorite parts), but it's very good nonetheless.
VideoMask93 8 months ago
@VideoMask93 I have that cover on my computer, and it's good. But guitars in Metallica version are way better than in SA version. And solo... one of best solos of Kirk, so i still think Metallica version is better
MetallicAM93 8 months ago
@MetallicAM93 That's what I love about the cover. It's great, but can't replace Metallica, so I have no problem listening to both.
VideoMask93 8 months ago
@VideoMask93 me too. But i think the best covers are these brutal. were young heavy bands play fast and brutal songs of Metallica. like Master (trivium), Battery (Machine Head), Creeping Death (don't have good cover, but i'm still looking for), No Remorse (Cannibal Corpse), or Disposable Heroes (chimaira), Metallica 4 ever \m/
MetallicAM93 8 months ago
@MetallicAM93 Bullet for my Valentine did a good cover of Creeping Death. Check that out.
VideoMask93 8 months ago
@VideoMask93 i heard that. guitars are good, and moment when they scream DIE aut he's voice... terrible
MetallicAM93 8 months ago
The solo still sounds better than live metallica version
vlodzimir111 9 months ago
temazo!!!!!!!!!! la hacen bien
floresfrana 9 months ago
well but they are better than you all.
DarkDevilTV 10 months ago
uh whats so bad about it other then the solos i think its pretty epic sounding but ofcourse not better then the original
Mockingbird115 11 months ago
my ears started bleeding when intro came on
Marchelorap 11 months ago
What is wrong with this band and its solos? I'm sorry but I sincerely think they messed up those parts.
marc825 11 months ago
not dat much badd. good attempt....
nileshpablemetallica 11 months ago
this is the shit...and not in a good way -_-
ixotec 1 year ago
even the intro is fucked up in this tune!! worra pile of shit! i have top give them credit for trying :)
jdotofbangor 1 year ago
Seems like every single (missing) note on the solos is a curse upon Hammett.
shinLucassensei 1 year ago
omfg, the solo made gave me an headache... it really hurts ;(
marco5sir2 1 year ago
I don't know what everyone has against the vocals,they rock,the solos were the only bad thing about this.
Videostar1another1fa 1 year ago
Omg, solos are terrible!
obsidiumtitan 1 year ago
I think the Rob halford scream was a little too much lol but thats just me
vladdracula3 1 year ago
Good, but nothing beats the original =/
rutelover 1 year ago
at the no one but me... part i got the feeling that it was bruce dickingson singing for a sec
Videostar1another1fa 1 year ago
Why the hell no band plays the solo good?
Videostar1another1fa 1 year ago
@Videostar1another1fa Because Kirk Hammett is a god dude.. =)
GodheadsDamnation 1 year ago
The solo really sucked.
moviemaker3000 1 year ago
If you read the liner notes the band wrote for this song it says they purposely played less notes in the intro solo than the original, and out of key as a homage to Kirk. I think it's basically just a piss take for the band.
cekfek 1 year ago
Sonata Arctica FTW...i would love to hear BFMV how screem this :D
LayconBG 1 year ago
saw metallica play this song live and this is nothing it is a joke
parklabwho 1 year ago
not bad :D
MGSHREDD24 1 year ago
I actually find it hard to belive this is Steel Prophet, They are a great band, but this cover-version is perhaps the most crappy cover I've ever heard!! And that includes the christmas carol renditions of Metallica!!
lyngwar 1 year ago
Ok, so they fuck the solo up, but at least they've tried it! every other band just end the song without playing any form of solo
IronMetalHead150 1 year ago
@IronMetalHead150 It doesn't need to have a solo. You ever heard the Sonata Arctica version? It's brilliant. Although I think a solo at the end just sounds like it fits anyway.
moviemaker3000 1 year ago
though nice, i perfer the original. or the sonata arctica version.
sweepeezee 1 year ago 3
@sweepeezee MEGA BUMP
badsmog 1 year ago
The intro solo is painful. Whoever these guys are, should really stick to originals and forget killing other people's songs. Vocals are godawful. I'm not sure why metallica didn't tell these guys never to cover them x.x The final solo...fucking sucks. All in all, how are these guys getting albums out? They fucking suck.
freakfreak12345 1 year ago
thonguch371 1 year ago
@thonguch371 Seriously, shut up.
bloodybastard25 1 year ago
@thonguch371 Slipknot? I'd take pop and hip-hop over those.
imperiumdiaboli 1 year ago
God man why do most people say "life it seems to fade away" James clearly says life it seems will fade away"
ochawkbeard 1 year ago
Honestly that intro solo sounded like me when I first started playing guitar. That was just disgraceful.
TarbleSauce 1 year ago
its a good cover and all, but the vocals dont sound that great to me idk and the solos kinda feel drug out and slurred.. but it does show that they can put their sound into it
xjoinxmexinxdeathx1 1 year ago
i dont see what everyone is talking about, that solo kicks ass!
IronMetalHead150 1 year ago
@IronMetalHead150 have you ever heard the original?
Videostar1another1fa 1 year ago
hmmm not bad but sonata arctica kicks there ass
BASSER911414 2 years ago
So what, am I like the only guy that thought this was awesome?
Justice4AllOne 2 years ago
@Justice4AllOne I like it too.. but the solos are kind of messed up
mrmclovin3475 2 years ago
my fav. cover is Sonata's, when Tony screams, HEEE'SS GOOONEEE!!!!! Epic
brunoharris95 2 years ago
SUCKS SO MUCH
brunoharris95 2 years ago
wow, when the solos started I actually laughed... :(
WilsonGuitar 2 years ago
vocals are crap:(
everything else is good:)
imawesome432 2 years ago
the solos fucked a good cover
BASSER911414 2 years ago
Nothing Beats The Accoustic
Nothing Beats The Solo
Nothing Beats The Vocals
Nothing Beats The Drums
Nothing Beats The Bass
Bottomline :
Nothing Beats the original Metallica Version. (:
Good Cover though the solo killed it
MeTaLiXe 2 years ago 45
@MeTaLiXe For be techno , this cover it´s to great...
throll2008 1 year ago
@MeTaLiXe The version of metallica is perfect, no one will ever beat it!
basbas63 1 year ago
@MeTaLiXe this has alot better drum track than lars did... well its not hard to do better :D
Huoha 11 months ago
@Huoha You have no idea what you just asked for.. There is no way in hell you can do a better Metallica Cover Better than them.. how can you when Band's like Trivium can only do a Master of Puppets that is Good. but Metallica's is EPIC.. likewise goes to Iron Maiden , Megadeth like bands.. you can't beat the Original's dude.. You come talk to me when you make a Cover of Holywar's by Megadeth Better than them.. it's like saying you're superman.. when you know you can't fly
MeTaLiXe 11 months ago
@MeTaLiXe lol lars drumming is bullshit... and ye holy wars is another thing... nick menza is fucking beast drummer but lars just sucks... this has way more energy on drums wich lars lacks alot. and wtf trivium? trivium fucking sucks ass dont come to me with that shit :D but if you listen to that emocore or whatever it is then its your shame
Huoha 11 months ago
@Huoha What the fuck is a emocore? stop talking about emo craps. and who is comparing Lars to Nick menza ? you can't compare it. Nick Menza Pwns. like i said. you come talk to me WHEN YOU do a cover of HolyWars better than Megadeth's Rust in Peace Version.. than you got my respect. other than that.. you better take your comment back about other's making better cover's of these Big four than them..
MeTaLiXe 11 months ago
@Huoha You made me laugh to be honest. Lars is a good drummer, nothing more. he isnt bad, BUT. Lars is a fucking GENIOUS. All of his writing in the first 5 MetallicA albums? You joking? Also, no one can do a MetallicA cover better than them, and most of them who try to do a better or even a good cover, they fail. I know a few good covers like.. Trivium - Master of Puppets & Dark Angel - Creeping Death. Also, Trivium are the best metal band of this decade along with Machine Head.
Youguysezwut 9 months ago
@Huoha & with Lamb of God
Youguysezwut 9 months ago
@MeTaLiXe I like the singing alot i jjust agree with you with everything else
omnadrener 8 months ago
wow that is rick i hear the scream i was waiting for that
omnadrener 8 months ago
Ah, I used to have this CD!!!
This is my favorite cover of Fade to Black, even with the different solos!
Justice4AllOne 3 years ago
But the "He's gone" scream is pretty epic, can you both admit that?
Smacster88 3 years ago 15
definatly, i love it =D
metalhead1451 3 years ago 5
that was pretty good but my favorite "he's gone" scream has to be Sonata Arctica's. You ever heard that version?
Beatudown2666 2 years ago
@Smacster88 Yeah,sounded like King Diamond.
Videostar1another1fa 1 year ago
I agree with you the solos simply suck. The worst cover of this track I've heard so far.....
eguitarstar 3 years ago
I dunno. Have you listened to Boy Sets Fire's or that awful industrial cover?
Nashtak 2 years ago