ViolinistYevgeniya I don't think discouaging this young man is very formitable. I'm disgusted that you of all people have to boast about shit in youtube. So STFU
Personally,I think that a lot of the notes in the Sicilienne could have been more connected, and work on a more connected tone as well as better intonation. Other than that it was pretty good.
Good job, but your intonation could use some work. Slow down the tempo so you can catch all the notes. Just because you can play it up to speed doesn't mean it is better, especially if you can nail all the notes when it is a smidge slower. Work up to the tempo and you will play this song greatly. Keep up the good work.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
You mean 5 years after playing this, or 5 years after first taking up violin? I've been playing for 2.5 years (but on an intense level), I'm going to play Sicilienne and Rigaudon for my exam in a month, and in one of my orchestras I'm playing the Mendelssohn concerto. (Not the solo, obviously.)It's the goal of my life to learn the solo, and I think I can do it in less than 5 years.
totally agree with corruptedkorean (btw, korean people are the BEST!) To be completely honest, if ur playing it after 2.5 years, ur gonna suck at it, and also, boasting about urself on youtube and trying to discourage someone actually talented, is proof of NO EFFIN LIFE! :] thankyou
Oh my God, I'm so sorry if anyone misunderstood that comment. I did not for a second mean to discourage--I think it was very, very well played, a lot better than how I performed it. On rereading my comment, I think you're right, it does sound a lot like boasting, so I'm very sorry. It's just that I want to go into music, and I'm very passionate about it, that's all.
Very good work considering you've only been playing for five years. Nice vibrato and relaxed bowing style too. I agree that more work needs to be done on intonation - slow down and get it in tune!!!
Should work on intonation and the staccato part. You can probably get better if you watch the 5 year old play the same piece, he plays some of the parts better.
nice job!!!! i have 2 play it for a recital! i am not doing so well... lol
i have been playing for 2.5 years, i am guessing this piece is too hard for moi!
cooliopenguin27 1 year ago
Great job!
paytoplaynj 1 year ago
Good Job! I am gonna start learning this piece and I am really nervous because it seems really hard.
elephantxxtears 3 years ago
ViolinistYevgeniya I don't think discouaging this young man is very formitable. I'm disgusted that you of all people have to boast about shit in youtube. So STFU
CorruptedKorean 3 years ago 5
Hey I'm playing this now after 5 years. You look nervous. I'm not gonna say much because of that. =D
godlee25 3 years ago 2
Personally,I think that a lot of the notes in the Sicilienne could have been more connected, and work on a more connected tone as well as better intonation. Other than that it was pretty good.
Mistachinese 3 years ago
WOrk on your dynamics and instead of trying to be able to play it fast make sure that you first are able to play the note themselfs. Good job though.
yoshinerd 4 years ago
his right hand is not half bad for how nervous he looks...but his left hand...
ahsusmus 4 years ago
Consider for each note...if it's not in tune, it is the wrong note!!
markpianoman 4 years ago
Good job, but your intonation could use some work. Slow down the tempo so you can catch all the notes. Just because you can play it up to speed doesn't mean it is better, especially if you can nail all the notes when it is a smidge slower. Work up to the tempo and you will play this song greatly. Keep up the good work.
Vioski10 4 years ago 3
this is really good! im 12 and im learning this.
aml199519 4 years ago
pretty good =D but after five years you're able to play wayyy harder stuff... like lalo or mendelssohn. challenge yourself! :]
dnz820 4 years ago
i agree. it was really good, but you should be able to play much more advanced stuff by now. not bad!
WyPotter 4 years ago
The Rigaudon is quite difficult (if you play it fast, in tune and with dynamic lines).
olga2809 3 years ago
Have either of you ever played this piece before?
mamba21500 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You mean 5 years after playing this, or 5 years after first taking up violin? I've been playing for 2.5 years (but on an intense level), I'm going to play Sicilienne and Rigaudon for my exam in a month, and in one of my orchestras I'm playing the Mendelssohn concerto. (Not the solo, obviously.)It's the goal of my life to learn the solo, and I think I can do it in less than 5 years.
ViolinistYevgeniya 3 years ago
Grats man! I wish you luck. ^^
psychaotic2 3 years ago
totally agree with corruptedkorean (btw, korean people are the BEST!) To be completely honest, if ur playing it after 2.5 years, ur gonna suck at it, and also, boasting about urself on youtube and trying to discourage someone actually talented, is proof of NO EFFIN LIFE! :] thankyou
itheproofofstupidity 3 years ago 5
Oh my God, I'm so sorry if anyone misunderstood that comment. I did not for a second mean to discourage--I think it was very, very well played, a lot better than how I performed it. On rereading my comment, I think you're right, it does sound a lot like boasting, so I'm very sorry. It's just that I want to go into music, and I'm very passionate about it, that's all.
ViolinistYevgeniya 3 years ago 3
Very good work considering you've only been playing for five years. Nice vibrato and relaxed bowing style too. I agree that more work needs to be done on intonation - slow down and get it in tune!!!
anestofleas 4 years ago
Should work on intonation and the staccato part. You can probably get better if you watch the 5 year old play the same piece, he plays some of the parts better.
Slapandrun 4 years ago
Wow, this is great. Keep it up and you'll give Perlman a run for his money.
svenp 4 years ago
you're really good :)
LittleBoyDork 4 years ago
Bravo!!!!! Keep it up, young man. Good posture. One part you played just a little too fast. Let's hear some more.
CMDRinCHIEF 4 years ago