Spiritual and Material Aspects of Hinduism

[ruzickaw]

The Carvakas are right. Enjoy this life, there is no other life. All religions are delutions.

Liberation from what? There is no proof of rencarnation.

Religious duty ? Just a waste of time.

Carvakas did social work , gave laws to improuve this life.

And what did they say about women? If women should restrain their desires, men should do the same. But all religions, without exceptions, always supressed women.

So, give up dharma and mokhsa, and enjoy life.

[topbluffa1]

@ruzickaw

you want proof of reincarnation? im guessing you want scientific proof so here you go The law of the conservation of energy states that energy can never be created or destroyed only converted from one FORM to another you ultimately are not defined by your current form.

Life is Religious Duty we are working as agents of Brahma (Creation) Vishnu (preservation) and Shiva (destruction) for Brahman and you CANNOT escape these dutys.

[ruzickaw]

@topbluffa1 I dónt need any "scientific proof" for reencarnation. Nature recycles us, that is true. But you will not be you

anymore.

"Life is religius duty?" Who says that? The priests, because it is their business. We are no agents of anybody.

If i do not accept any duty, i have already escaped.

You seem to be a Hindu and they have brain washed you with this "duty and Dharma " stuff.

Become a Carvaka and you will be free.

[topbluffa1]

@ruzickaw

you say "Nature recycles us, that is true. But you will not be you" this just shows your misunderstanding of the Self you think of yourself as your current form which is not you so you believe when your current form dies "you" will no longer exist this is a big mistake.

and i font have enough words left to explain to you why you thinking you can escape religious duty like i said life itself is religious duty have you escaped life?

[topbluffa1]

@ruzickaw

unlike you i do not define myself by my current form or ego.

this is one of the main points of Hinduism/Buddhism and needs to be understood

[topbluffa1]

@ruzickaw

im already free brother and i have not been "brain washed" unless being brain washed means cleaning my brain and removing the impure and ignorant thoughts.

i was raised as a Christian and then turned into a atheist because of scientific accidence but then i became a Hindu as just like Christianity i had disproved atheism with science.

[topbluffa1]

@ruzickaw

do you not accept that life can only come from death.

why do you think that your death will not lead to life?

your main problem is your idea of yourself as being "john smith" or whatever your name is when that is just like your 999.999.999th form why is just that form you? and not the form before or the form after.

[pixusbubblejet]

This is excellent, and shows that Atheism did not simply come from 19th century western science. Carvaka shows that Atheism was around thousands of years before in ancient india.

But the voice recording is not good. The narrator is speaking too close to the microphone and hard to understand sometimes. I hope the voice recording can be improved. Thank you.

[topbluffa1]

@pixusbubblejet

this is not atheism , atheism believes in no supreme being or universal self (god) and believe in no after life... which is now scientifically proven to be wrong using The law of the conservation of energy proves your matter/energy has been manifest since the big bang and was not created by your mother father and will not be destroyed by your death.

[pixusbubblejet]

@topbluffa1. "atheism" is nothing new.

[ramaraksha01]

Moksha is earned, not given, and that is the essential difference between Moksha & Heaven. One can beg for Gods mercy, grovel like a dog, and then be allowed to taste the pleasures of a flesh-happy heaven, but one cant beg for Moksha, because Enlightenment is acquired thru knowledge. Even if the Teacher takes pity on a student who turned in a bad paper, and passes him, it doesnt mean the student had suddenly acquired the knowledge. Reach for the Higher goal, reach for Moksha

[malav1988]

thank you so much for uploading...

[dracentsparkle]

thanks for the kind sharing*

[TheLonePantheist]

Great video, very informative.