Added: 5 years ago
From: applegrassdude
Views: 202,411
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (617)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • oh god oh god otp feelings from 2006 coming back...

  • just amazing!

  • Matt Smith can only dream of standing in David Tenant's shadow.

  • @1996Coaster He is good. He is not as good, but he is still good. Just differently good, I think. :)

  • I luv this song! Great video : )

  • 33 people are in hell right now.

    And I totally, 100% agree with @CeruleanFawkes.

  • This vid is great in all other respects but the picture does seem to be squashed in from both sides

  • I can't tell you how much I cried when Rose and the Doctor were separated like that. x( Beautiful vid. ♥

  • Brilliant!!

  • This video and song is put together so well just perfect, I must of watched it 100 times now

  • Comment removed

  • Wow,truly a remarkable first class video,and I loved every moment.

    Especially when it's sung by one of my favourite bands!! =)

  • Beautifully done, but the aspect ratio is awful :/

  • love this song. too bad she went on to play a a call girl after this lol

  • Fantastic!!!

  • This is the best DW fanvid I've seen on youtube.

  • all right, I admit it. I cried.

  • wow! Sooooo good! Kudos!

  • awesome

  • what episode was 1:07 to 1:13 from?

  • @tiapest126 the beginning of the army of ghosts i do believe

  • @RavenclawGirl29 thanks

  • " I'm burning up a sun just o say goodbye "

  • I'm sorry but he was the best doctor and thats final. She was his best acompanist(don't know how to spell) I died inside when she didn't get to say I love you back. & when there touching the wall together & When they're both crying. Now theres a stupid new doctor. :/

  • Oh shit the "how long are you gonna stay with me?" "Forever" gets me EVERY time. I watched it and I grabbed my little sister and sobbed, but I was wearing ear phones so she was like "WTF???? WHY are you crying?"

  • i've only ever watched one episode with rose and that was the one where she lost her face and i really want to finish watching the rest with her she seems like the perfect compainion for him actually lover but hey that'ds just me

  • Excellent & thanks for not using that Leona Lewis travesty ;o)

  • would'nt it be nice if you had someone as careing as the doctor to hold you're hand.

  • What episode is the "How long are you going to stay with me?" "Forever" from?

    Gaah I love the, "Oh she knows" part. Gaaaaaaaah

  • @Schwanheld Beginning of Army of Ghosts as Rose is giving her narrative

  • god i favourited this like years ago and just rewatched it again!

    i can remember why, its a beautiful video :)

    & what you say in the descrioption, the exact same for me as well! After watching doctor who confidential ive loved it since!

    Eccleston and tennant were both amazing, they made doctor who something i have to watch now!

    This is a brilliant video well done :D xxx

  • long live the 10th doctor!!!!! love DT sooo much going to miss him but i will give MS a chance.

  • Beautiful, thank you for this!

  • she was on the episode when the doctor fell in the blackhole and met the so called devil, any way she died in the episode

  • yeah its called 'the impossible planet'

  • i dont remember the lady at 2:41 who was she?

  • que lindo...

  • good job, i loved it !!!

  • I love David Tennant, no one can compair to him :D

    I almost cried when he said "I don't want to go" in the last episode :'(

    We'll miss him!

  • Almost?

  • yeah, i'm not the crying type. Never cried at a movie so almost crying is sort of an extreme :L

  • Then you've clearly never met me.

    I'm like Chandler from friends I very very rarely cry (especially not in public), but I love Doctor Who so much and it means so much to me, that it affects me in that way (actually more than events in my own life).

  • erm OK :D that you and you are entitle to that, i'm not going to stop you :P

  • i love this song now, because of this video. so thank you to the creator!! and whenever i'm listening to it, i can hear them saying 'how long are u gonna stay with me?' 'forever'

    this is amazing. love rose and the doctor

  • I actually say it usually...I'm always surprised when the Doctor doesn't ask it, when its on the radio.

  • this song makes me sad everytime and then rose and the doctor :[

    that was so heart breaking, I mean she kind of ended up with the doctor but not the real one, a copy

    so sad :[ she was his best companion the other girls dont compare. I am hoping I like the new doctor they picked out

  • i really do not see how there can be a better doctor than david tenant. The new guy has some pretty big sneakers to fill.

    Also... Rose Tyler i know your in another universe now, but would you marry me? lol

  • yea i no what ur sayin. especially bowt rose!

  • We shall not see his like again.

    The rest is silence.

  • A real heartwrencher of a Doctor Who episode!!. Billie Piper yumyum!! :)

  • billie piper yumyum alrite!!!!

  • Doctor Who is the best.

  • ok i am officailly a sap cuz i have tears in my eyes now lol

  • same ive watched it like 10 times- tears every time lol

  • me too made me cry :[

  • love it, love the doctor and rose ,cant wait for xmas episode ,does anyone no if rose is in it.?

  • i severely doubt it

    She's all safe and happy with her 'other' Doctor

  • @Icestar663 thanks 4 your reply

  • She is! Its confirmed! but its notthe rose from journeys end. The doctor goes to 2005 and visits the 2005 Rose which I love the sound of! :) hope I helped

  • @Aqua3marine thanks 4 your reply

  • Great Great Video,Loved It ;) ;) Made me cry

  • This was incredible. I have always tried to not ship the Doctor with his companions because of how it always turns out, but this may have just about pushed me over the edge.

    But I did cry when I saw Doomsday, and this totally captures Rose and her Doctor/s.

  • fantastic x

  • aw how cute :).

  • I just finished the second season of Doctor Who where this all comes to a climax.

    I saw this video years ago and I remembered it.

    Right after the episode ended, I came here and saw it again. I don't think a television program has ever had me this emotionally attached to two characters.

  • Comment removed

  • Loved it, loved it, loved it!

  • I CAN HARDLY SPEAK AT ALL...  Fab video with ace soundtrack. That final scene on the beach.....OMG So sad.........I loved it!

  • I almost cried!!!! You did  a fantastic job! I had bever heard snow patrol before, but I love this song. It fits them perfectly! Five Stars!

  • First watched this 11 months ago.Then my dad died & I couldn't watch it.

    Now I can watch it again but the scene with Rose & the Dr. on either side of the walls of time & space still folds me up.

    Be the best you can, as often as you can, with as many people as you can, because over is over.

    The rest of your life is just trying to find a window into a parallel universe. Just like Rose. Or not.

  • @Rooti1 I accidentally pressed the thumbs down button when what I really meant to say was that I agree a 1000% with what you said. People get sidetracked by thinking about the future or the past and forget to make their lives fantastic, as they should.. Sorry about your dad, hang in there and I guess, be the best you can knowing he would want that for you.

  • @Rooti1 Outstanding comments.

    "The rest of your life is just trying to find a window into a parallel universe."

    I've been thinking that, too.

  • great vid, but why did you squash it to 4:3?

  • Absolutely loved the video...brilliant song by Snow Patrol there...excellent clips from Doctor Who to make this video...5 stars for this...thanks very much!!

  • cette vidéo est magnifie, pareille pour la musique, je l'écoute sans arrête depuis ^^

    j'adore doctor who, et rose

  • absolute wow!!! i particularly loved the theme running through it of the fireworks...and as they became increasingly present, the doctor and rose became so much less in need of such an enjoyment.....spine tingling stuff :p 5/5 without question!

  • five stars!

  • This video makes me wish I owned series 2 so I can see all the happy times 10 and Rose had. Brilliant video.

  • Rose was the best companion to the Doctor from the Beginning of the series...she is better than any other traveler, he knows her better than any one else...Dooms Day proved that!

  • cuts me up. Every single time. *schniffle* Even people who hated Rose had to cry when she left :( you could see the doctors heart breaking :(

  • my friend once told me she liked donna better than rose i just said well if you had been there the whole time and watched and waited for her return like the rest of us you would have cried just as much

  • I have to say though I love Rose too and have watched Doctor Who from the start but I have to agree in my opinion I preferred Donna too and cried more at her end then Rose's. The Doctor's reaction and fate after Rose is more heartbreaking but Donna's just the next level!

  • You've watched from the start have you, so a 46 plus person is called tenants angels.

    sorry that might've seemed callous but my point is that if you've been watching since Rose, then you haven't seen doctor who at all, that said I love the "new series" even though it is actually series 27 of when the first episode airs. Very confusing

  • For me from the start is with Rose, I know full well of the "classic" series, Ive seen a few episodes my dads a big fan, so I know the background and can understand enough when they make older references. My wording evidently has been misinterpreted, Im a "New Who" fan and I'm sorry if I upset you I understand fully of the cultural significance of the show.

  • Some younger audiences have not been able to watch the classic series in general, I myself, at 14, knows quite a lot of the significance of something this old and famous but a 'new who' fan like me is just as much a fan as any classic fan, just because they havent been around to watch 700+ episodes, as long as you enjoy doctor who, then you are a fan, whether you grew up with the old series or the new. I reckon RTD has done a fantastic job at reviving such a classic and inviting newer audiences.

  • 'How long are you gonna stay with me?'

    'Forever'.

    Cuts me in two every time.

  • David Tennant is fantastic as the Doctor.... I'm very worried the show will be destroyed when he leaves as the script varies in brilliance from great to not so good...its then that he carries the show. Good acting!!!

  • this is bloody brilliant!!! i watch it quite often and it gets me every time. what a great video

  • oh my gosh i thought i was the only one who watches this over and over!!! thankfully there's some one else out there

  • Third me on that.

  • WOW!

  • Wow i watch this vid like a tousand times and it still gets me, great job!!!!:)

  • *sniffle* I miss Rose so bad. *cries*

  • great video best i have seen love it

  • No-thank you. Thank you so, so much- there is no other Ten/Rose video on YouTube that can make me cry.

  • I LUVE THIS SONG i miss rose so much it makes me tear up when i watch these videos.

  • The most sad thing i have ever seen was when the doctor lost rose

    I still cry now it was so powerfull. And i hate seeing david cry :(

  • looove it.

  • doctor who rock  it was good when rose gam bk to him she was cry because he was dieing

  • I love this song so much is so sweet. And love doctor who to :)

  • great video.the part where the doctor is crying in the tardis brings a lump to my throat every time and ive seen that episode loads of times!!! im gonna miss david tennant,the best doctor ever!!!

  • Is he crying because of Rose?

  • yes he is crying because he loves rose and they have been separated because rose went to a parallel universe,and he is sad because he thinks he will never see her again.hope this helps,

  • This has been in my favourites for months now and still makes me cry.

  • still the best video on youtube methinks

  • omgg i luv dis videoo

    it made me cry the first time i saw it.. but i still love it

    goodd job x

  • It really has to be said this video is amazing, i have seen it so many times and i still love it

  • simply terrific^^

  • Brilliant

  • Absolutely amazing!

    Couldn't have been done better, thank you

  • I'll be honest, this made me cry. Beautifully done, mate! A definite favorite!

  • Two and a half years later and I still can't get enough of this video. I just love how sad this song makes me feel, but at the same time, so elated for Rose and the Doctor.

  • fifty million out of five stars lol^^ great job,

  • Gave me goosebumps!

  • my favorite video of all time - no doubt about it - thank you for keeping it posted!

  • Why does it look squished?

  • just how my clips came out...'twas ages ago :D

  • Great!!

  • Singularly the best thing I've ever seen on YT - excellent!

  • OMG that nearly made me cry. It so well put together!!!! Thumbs up!!!!

  • very good work!

  • i may have already commented on this, but oh well.

    OH MY EFFING (Time) LORD. That was stunning. I am sniffling.

  • ROSE AND THE DOCTOR ARE AWESOME!!! :-D

  • thought this was lovely bubb! must have taken so long! nice to see someone actually putting time and effort into their vids! FULL MARKS! :-) X

  • You've already heard time and again how brilliant this is, but I had to add my own comment letting you know how you brought me to tears. I love that you included parts of them truly happy with each other, but then also included the dramatic moments that, in the end, tore them apart. It was really beautiful and I loved it!

  • I swear.

    I listen to this song and i do not watch the video, it is on a playlist.

    When i hear the first voice of non musical incorporation, with my head in a cloud of separate thought, it scares the shit out of me.

  • I love the Snow Patrol version of this, Leona Lewis killed it for me, she's a good singer, but this voice needed something a little more low-key than what she has. Nice vid =)

  • It's an amzing video,I love doctor who speacily 10.

  • hey this is harry from band its really good

  • "harry from band" <- lol, as you are also my friend's brother and my neighbour(ish) XD

    Why thank you Harry!

  • OMG! I understood all of that! :D

    muchas gracias senor(a)

  • Did you hear my "Run" spanish version? I hope you like it... I name it "Adios, Amor (Goodbye, Love)"....

    Go to my channel and watch it please... have a good day...

  • 106 patches on leona Lewis. Plus they really wrote the song.

  • I have seen this video at least 1,000 times probably! It's amazing! GREAT job :)

  • i like leona, but her voice is all whiney and she adds on all the oooo's to every word.

    snow patrol, definately more amazing!

    he has SUCH a beautiful voice!

    x

    great video(:

  • I know , Thomas.

  • This song is so much better than the Leona Lewis version^^

  • I certainly won't! This is the original and the best, IMHO :)

  • i completley agree! the original is the best! and this is one of my most favourite videos on youtube

  • I agree

  • Yes!

    Leona Lewis makes it sound so mainstream :( She's good, but this wasn't the song for her.

    Snow Patrol all the way.

  • Brilliant video, very emotional towards the end :(

  • great vid and great song :D

  • this vid goes so gr8 with the song--love it!

  • What is Rose saying under the music at 1:47-1:51?

  • What you hear her say is 'i saw the whole of time and space'.

  • this version of run is SOOO much better than leonas!

  • my thoughts exactly!

  • i agree aswell! she doesnt even sing it properly! half the words towards the end of the song are held on for too long and she doesnt actually say the whole word! :\ she goes way ove the top :\

    this vid is awesome tho :D

  • i know S:

    i like leona, she has a good range and all, but her voice is kinda weird and it DOES NOT suit this song at all tbh

    and yeah, amazing video (:

  • i completely agree! shes good, but she should stick with songs that NEED covering. unlike this one. which was brilliant when Snow Patrol sang it

  • Amazing video :D!

    Amazing song :D!

    Amazing show  :D!

  • shit!! i just cried watching this, outstanding!!!!

  • Nicely done, as a Dr Who fan, and a fan of this song by Snow Patrol, I approve!

  • Doc who and run patrol, what a good mix

  • love this song, love doctor who great mix :)

  • best. show. ever. excellent vid. love the song choice.

  • i was just listenn to the song mate

  • i completely agree hevvss, if you have nothing good to say... DON'T SAY ANYTHING AT ALL!!!!!!!!

  • Don't watch Dr. Who vids if you don't like Dr.Who :)

  • An episode with ghosts and robots in wich Rosie separeted from Doctor forever is this the last season and episode or there have more?

  • that was a great vid. very sad. the song fitted perfectly. nice 1 :{)

  • I'm so glad Rose got her happy ending in the last series... she really deserved it. One hundred percent. ^_^

  • Omg!! I Love it!

  • leona lewis's version of this song is total crap. this is the true and most beautiful singing of the song.

    Snow Patrol Rock!

  • i agree..she totally ruins it

  • OMG yay!! A person who sees sense! :D <3333

  • This is a great vid. Well done! Well done u.

  • i thank you.

  • Just looking at the song, I knew this was going to make me tear up. I love the way you made this video. The clips are perfect, and the timing is fairly good, as well. Good job on a heart-breaking vid.

  • love it!!!:D

  • So sad. Can I make a request? Where'd you Go - Fort Minor

  • I. LOVE. IT.

  • its brilliant utterly utterly briliant love it 5/5  thanks for puttin it up