علی شریعتی و مغالطات ایشان - قسمت دوم

[khargooshkhargoosh]

bahram moshiri khodesh ostade maghlatas :)

[setareh70]

dorod be Bahram Moshiri

[MrCheshmak86]

عزیز شما خودت بچه گانه ترین اشکال مغالطه رو به واضح ترین شکل ممکن انجام میدی

خیلی برای شما زوده با این سطح سواد و تحریف تاریخ بزرگ مردی بنام علی شریعتی زیر سوال ببری

[kasra20giv1]

@MrCheshmak86

شریعتی هم در غایت یک اسلامگرا بود که دوای بسیاری از مشکلات سیاسی و اجتمائی و فرهنگی واقتصادی ایران زمان خودش را در اسلام جستجو میکرد منتها به زعم خودش اسلام حقیقی شناخته نشده و فراموش شده که بایستی شناخته میشد و باز سازی میشد تا جوابگوی همه ی مشکلات باشد که در زمان خودش بسیار جذابیت داشت چونکه در ان دوران ایرانیان کمتر می اندیشیدند و بیشتر به دنبال الگوهای انقلابی سیاسی و خیالی بودند که بگونه ی معجزه آمیز همه ی مشکلات را یک شبه حل کند حال دیگر هیچ اسلامی جذابیت ندارد

[persianshadmani]

dorood be bahram moshiri

[persianshadmani]

dorood be ostad moshirie mihan parast

[Kaveh2520]

drood bar shoma.

[mazmaz1981]

age harfi mantegh poshtesh bashe, bacheye 5 sale ya adame 500 sale nemitoone radesh kone... motoasefam ke hanooz mohmalate Ali Shariati ro tooye ketabhaye darsi chap mikonan.

[alikhoda1]

man adam e mazhabi E nistam ! vali bacheye 5 saalam bezaari harfaaye in AHMAGH ro gush bede, mifahme dari sherro verr mige !!!

akhe Moshiri mage tu haddi ye ke bahs kone ?! :)))))))))))))))))

[2009thefreeman]

fekr konam khodet dari shero ver migi vali halit nist boro aghalan tarikh ro bekhoon bebin in eslame azizet che gandi zadeh har ja ke rafte joz gando kesafato tajavoz va koshtan va naboodi kardan be bar nayavardan. yek mamlekate eslami neshan bede ke khoshbakht bashan. kami fekr kon.

[mylilbabygirl1]

fagat ba in video khodeto maskhare kardi jenab...

[hghorbani]

dastet dard nakone. belakhare yeki gir oomad ke ba moghaletate shariati mobareze kone.

age ye zarre adam roshan fekr bashe nahayate gharaz varzi ro too neveshtehaye shariati mitoone bebine. jaye taajjob nist ke ozaye ma alan ine. chera ke kesi mesle shariati ba in harfa bote javoonaye tahsil kardeye oon moghe boode.

doostan ma kheyli chizha hast ke bayad yad begirim.

roshan fekre vaghei besyaar andak dar iran dashte va darim.

dorood bar hameye roshan fekrane vaghei.

[Fravahar]

Bidgani, an mosadeghetan ke damad emam jomee ye tehran bood, mosadegh ghoran dar jib dasht va adat dasht dar majles ghoran az jib dar biare behesh ghasam bekhore, majlese 17 ra mosadegh bast, asle 46 motamam e ganoon e assasi zire paa gozasht, va vaghti ham pesar khaleash mohammed ali shah e ghajar majles ra betoop bast, mosadeh e 24 sale be u tabrik goft, shoma mosadeghollahi hich faghi ba akhonda nadarin, an ha migan ya ali shoma ha migain ya mosadegh lol

[naniva]

shariati was just a foolish and backward guy. dogs may shit upon his grave!

[fooladsakht]

choonetoon nasoozeh hezbolaahihaa, khedtoon ham midoonid ostaad darh rastesh ro migeh.

age mitoonid khalafe harfhaasho saabet konid, nah fohsh bedid.

[fooladsakht]

eyn kharkoseh shariati maghlateh baaz. malichake akhonde haroozadeh. hala ham too beheshte dareh choon mideh be khalkhali.

[dobaremisazamatvatan]

mardake daghal baaze bi savade khole chel!

[123kaveh]

oon esmet ham ke shooare jomhoori nangine eslami hast.

[persianboy333]

راه شریعتی خار راه دشمنان است

[kamy1974]

Fuck ur sister in the ASS with SHARIATI

[markpackard0]

Shariati was British agent, supporter of Akhondz, enemy of Iran and real Iranian heritage.

[mnfard]

Truly foolish talks from this guy as he pass judgment on issues not in his level to discuss.He obviously displays signs of mind truma in his speeches. God help him

[CYRUS2060]

Ageh cheezi mitoni begi begoo,nah albateh keh nah.Ali ham yek bisavad chaghoo kesh vahshi byabangard bood.tu ettelaati ve akhoondha ham mesleh Ali beh goor goh myravid.reedam tu eslam.

[avestak]

heyf e esme Cyrus ke to dashte bashish !

[mnfard]

Mr. moshiri shallow comments do not change facts of history. Very shallow and unintelligent

[korosh1380]

pofyooz chera az nahjolnalagheh nemigi!!!

[iranboy7]

کیرم تو کون مشیری و کون همه طرفدارنش. مادر جنده ها

[disgrace1981]

merci kamar. khosham miad javabe harfe manteghio az kallat nemitooni bedi be kamaret motevasel mishi. ali ham be shamshir motevasel mishod

[persian7300]

kir sag to dahan mathar va tamame emamanet

[kafir1917]

"rbozorgi": For you I wish you learn english language, whilst enjoying your refugee status in the USA, now that you have forgotten the farsi language! You "iranglisi" doesnt impress any one!

[rbozorgi]

Ensane jahel va zaeef vaghti rahi baraye esbate chizi nadashte bashe, dast be tohin mizane, harfi ke hagh nabashe dar goorestane tarikh chaal mishe. Bahrame moshiri bozorgtarin azab baraye to, batlaghie ke daresh hasti, pas bishtar dasto pa bezan ta bebini noghteye payanet kojast!

[gholam654]

azizam boro 1 kam motale kon tohin nakon age nakhoni boro bekhin kojaye harfesh dorghe?khod aham naneshste bebeine azab key be moshiri mire baraye harfe to shariati kheyani kard be in mamlekat?none akhond dari mekhori dege ya tassob dari?akhe shoma ha az hagheghat farar meknid na motale meknid shoma ashghe ali irani hastid hame maha ashghe ali irani hastim ama kesi ali arab ro ta hala nashnakhte azizam to javabe manam ke bkahy bedi ba tohin medi to karet tohine aghaye rbozorgi

[kafir1917]

man ba harfe "persian prince" kamelan movafegham. In koso sher haye ali "kooni" shariati, 30 sal ghabl gool zad chand ta javoone ahmagh ro, keh hamoona alan pashimoonan. alan too iran keh miram ya hich kas ono nemishenase, ya oonha keh mishenasanesh behesh lanat migan! hala shoma chand ta piro patal neshestin to ooropa va amrika hey zer mizanin, migin keh in "intelectual" boodeh (ba licanse gholabie "adabiat" as daneshsaraye tarbiat moalem)!!!

[rbozorgi]

har kasi nazare khodesho dare agha gholam, at the end we all come to conclusion who is right and who is not. For you, all I have is a smile, and wishing you more and more knowledge.

[kafir1917]

"rbozorgi": For you I wish you learn english language, whilst enjoying your refugee status in the USA, now that you have forgotten the farsi language! You "iranglisi" doesnt impress any one!

[persian1princes]

in martikeh divoonast baba :)). halesh khayli kharabeh. in cherto pertaro migeh va bad khodesh mikhandeh be risheh hameye oonayi ke tayidesh mikonan

[kafir1917]

shariati, yek badbakhte oghdei. yek jassose khaene vatan foroush keh as iran farar kard raft pishe arbab haye inglisish. Ridam be ghabre kasife in khaene vatan foroush.

[IRANstyle82]

pas bare chi on SHAH ke ghahre mane shomast, farar kard be MESR pishe hamoon arab hayi ke shoma shabo rooz beheshoon fosh midin!?

[kafir1917]

inghadr shah shah nakon. OOn mord va tammom shod. In vazi keh dar iran darim alan, daghighan be khatere in ashkhase khaene vatann forushe ahmagh mesle in Shariati hastan, keh be yek mosht sadeh del mesle to sabet kardan keh "inelectual" hastan, ba yek "licanse" az daneshgahe tarbiate moalem!!!

[IRANstyle82]

watan Foroush? tanha watan foroush hayi ke man mishnasam wa dar tarikhe iran zabeghe daran hamonn monafeqine Camp-Bisharaf mesle shoma hastan!

[kafir1917]

"iarnstyle", hala to hey zer bezan, mesle "ostade" bacheh koonit, ali shariati.

Boro in koso sher ha ro be nanehe jendat begoo, badbakhte arab parast.

[IRANstyle82]

tanha kasi ke man fekr mikonam nanash jende bashe toni ehtemalan!agar Pedaret yek Savaki boode,baradaret yek Monafeqe Saddam doost ke be Arab haye Sonni koonesh ro mifrooshe wa madaret be har yahoodije pool dar dar Amrika Kos mide wa Khaharet be har siah pooste Amrikayi Koon mide,..maloome ke to ham,ham chin sho'ar hayi ke az un ha yad gerefti incha piyade mikoni! koskhol! tanha Khoobi ine ke, shoma dar hamoon Kharedj pir mischin wa mimirin,wa hitch wakht dige patoon ro dar iran nemisarin!

[kafir1917]

"iranstyle": koso sher haye to , eine koso sher haye "ostade" koonit, (keh as AIDS mord) shriati hast. Hich kas ahamiat nemideh, hata nanehe arab paraste jendat!! Hala to hey zer bezan too internet. LOL

[IRANstyle82]

koskhol on moghe Aids koja bood,ke aslan enghadr farawan nabood mesle alan,ke on ham ino begire wa bemire azesh!Waqehan ghati kardi,mesle in ostade hendi birikhtet ke dare harfe moft zer mizane incha!

[naniva]

ali was not more than a criminal and savage arab rober. stupid are the people who worshipe him as an idol. very pittyful. what a pitty that so many stupids from PERSIAN adore a died violent and reactinar murderer ali

[bijankhan]

hamatoon alan to in donya khafe shid, vaiseed rooze ghyamat khodavande afarydegar yekta hamamoono jam mikone, oon vaght ya mano va yarane ali va khode ali ebne abi taleb ro hamaro mirize to atish ya har kazzabe motekabere gomrahiro. Dar har chi ke goftim shahadat bayad bedim va khodavand khodesh midoone ki gomrahe va eshtebah mikone va ki be hagh.

[iranipoyandeh]

areh hatman to va khomeini ,gilani, khalkhali,va genayatkaraneh digheh hameh be behesht mirin.

[mehrann]

khafe ashghale arab

[khaz6pill]

Vaaaaaaay nagu tarsidam ! Khodaye to ham ashghaliye meseh to va un Ali ke eshghesh adam koshi o adam suziye badbakht !!

[bijankhan]

Vaghan motaasefam baraye moshiri ke in hame ketab mikhoone vali hadaaghal ino nemifahme ke agar ali dar nazde to hiche dar nazde ma molast, va to hamoon behtare az aboobakre daaemol khamr va omare ghatel tarafdary koni, moshiri be rahati tarikh ro az khodesh takzibo tayeed mikone wa hich salahiati dar afkaresh nemibinam

[manajooni]

bijankhan !

toam ke dari tarikho az khodet avaz mikoni ke !! be che haghi be aboobakr va omar ke har do az bozorgtarin mardane tairkhe eslam boodan tohin mikoni? har do az yaraye payambar boodan biji !!!

[mehrann]

khafe asghale arab

[khaz6pill]

To ke ketab khundi begu koja goftan Abubakr o Omar ina budan ??? Tarikh tabari ya mozakhrafiyaate Shie ???

[naniva]

the time of dirty islam is runing off for our pure IRAN

[thebeast1818]

Have you ever read the"Nahjul-balagha"? I'm sure you're not.You can't criticize such a author,scientist and great politician with these words.There are more than 300 million people in his path.Respect,respect...to other's believe.

[alifreedom1]

"Nahjul-balagha" is gathered houndred of years after death of Ali most of the quotes are from Greek philospher and idoms (the samll qoutes I mean not lecutre of Ali in Mosque) it is a false claim those idoims belongs to Ali it was collected houndreds of years after death of Ali by Shikh Razi, all are 6 perecnet of all muslims not 300 million

[alifreedom1]

كلمات قصار نهج البلاغه هيچ مرجع درستي ندارد اينها را قرن هابعد يكي شيخ رضي تمام ضرب المثلهايي كه از كنفسيوس-بودا -ارسطو بود رابه علي ربط داد

[alifreedom1]

البته ختبهاي نهج البلاغه تاحدود زيادي معتبراست چون علي والي كوفه بوده وكاتب داشته ولي كلمات قصار خيلي از انها هيچ تناسخي نه باروحيه تاريخي علي دارد كه در طبري امده نه باختبهاي نهج البلاغه

[mehrann]

ashghal

[bshahpar]

heife-nan, in charadiat chieh migi. chera se sal pish chador saret kareh boodi va naghde ketab nemikardi

[BehzadHamedani]

be tamame ozgalhaye eslami migam, sohbathaye Dr.Moshiri wa Dr.Fouladvand az danesh sar cheshme migirad, shomaha ham berid gom shid hey salawat befrestid, tokhme tarkhaye tazi, ma shomaro jozwe iranian nemidunim. Shomaha farsi zabanani hastid ke az tajawoze arab tokhmetun dar mihane ma gozashte shode wa bayad nabudetun konim

[houmie]

Cheraa tohin mikonin dustaane aziz? Cheraa in ghadr naaraahat mishin? In aghaa dare az ruye Daghighi o Tabari mikhune unwaght shomaa migin sanadesh ko? Jush nayaar, yek dushe abe sard begir, warame magzet bekhaabe. aghleto be kaar begir, ta'asobo bendaaz dur.

In aslan dar morede Shariaty chize haadi nagoft, cheraa jush awordin? Aslan asle matlabe in bahso gush kardind?

Afsus Afsus ke dindaaraane kale khar na gush midan, na khodeshun ketaab mikhunan.

[nimaomega]

vaghean motaasseam ke be chenin adam haye bi shoor va nafahmi forsat dade mishe ke bian vase public sohbat konan, in cherto pertha chie ke bare mardom mikonin, shoma age agahi dari age ettelaatet kafi hast elmi harf bezan, dalile tarikhi biar, sanad biar, barnameye shoma bishtar shabihe comedy e. to che gohi hasti ke bekhay dar baraye dr. shariati ezhare nazar koni.

[enayatkhojasteh]

in mardike halish nist dare chi mige.sar ta paye harfaye khodesh moghalete ast.badbakht un ahmaghaii ke harfaye in yaru ro gush mikonand.