Added: 3 years ago
From: warren13013
Views: 106,513
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (360)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The ONLY GREAT song on the new album. Fez Being Born is also good but other than these 2 songs the abum SUCKS BIG TIME

  • If only it had more Edge!

  • Great song!!

  • Maravilhosa!!!

  • My fave from the new album..and that's a hard call! Thanks so much for the post X

  • the more i listen to the song i think thats the best u2 song ever!

  • Man, this song touches me, just love it.

    Hope they make a clip for it.

  • "feel your soul" this are the only words i can say about this a-m-a-z-i-n-g song

  • damn right!

  • Perfect bass,perfect drums,perfect Edge,awesome Bono here

    PERFECT U2

  • Bellissima canzone da ascoltare al massimo

  • In my opininion the best song on this new album

  • easily pushing for being one of the best U2 songs off all time... which is saying a lot.

  • Sheesh, all this bashing of Colplay and others...fans being mancially defensive, it's all i seem to see. not a good sign

  • DE DONDE SALIO COLD PLAY???

  • jajajajaja ya .. manana si po weon .. onda coldplay ...

  • I'm tired of these comments!

    Who wants to talk about Coldplay (and i like them too), simply don't write here, please...the title is "Moment of surrender", not "Viva la vida"! So let's appreciate this marvelous music and talk about the great band who made it!!!

  • U2 are unique,great!Coldplay are shit..

  • Comment removed

  • I think the comparisons are fair. Chris Martin would suck Bono's dick if he could. He's wanted to be U2 since he was a little kid. When his first baby was born he played "Sort of Homecomming" from the Unforgettable Fire. Coldplay fucking idolizes U2. If it weren't for U2 there would be no Coldplay. So basically every fucking song from Coldplay that you like that comes out... you should fucking thank U2 for it.

  • What you said. :)

  • Amen to drvertigo!!!! You are so right and I feel exactly the same. Nailed it right on the head!!

  • damn why compare to great bands i love both they are both great and will always be great,

  • Lol. U2 and Coldplay are both great bands.

  • You don't need to say they are way better... they just are.

    Oh, nd by the way Coldplay are sellouts too :)

  • Great sound!Deep into everybodys heart!

  • geweldig nummer weer van U2

    Onzettende goede cd

  • ....haha

  • haha... short but very good comment!

  • No comparison to coldplay whatsoever.

    U2 are an outstanding band, unlike coldplay.

  • Stop with the Coldplay comparisons...U2 have been around for 30 years for a reason..if in the year 2028 Coldplay can produce an album like No Line, then we can compare.....as far as I know they have yet produced a Joshua Tree or Achtung Baby album

  • I hope they play this in August...*dies*

  • Everyones intitled to have an opinion. But these morons that compare coldplay to U2 just leave me scratching my head. Seems coldplay fans (and many music fans these days) don't know the world didn't start in 2000. Coldplay is a fly on one of U2's shits. They are simply incapable of this kind of talent.

    This song just blew me away, for me it's their greatest song since With or Without You. Very ambitious, and there's no band out there now that can touch this.

  • Thumbs up - there is something about Coldplay, fine, but I can't remember how many bands have been described as U2stylish by music journalists... The thing is: i already start forgetting the Band's names - and Bono and The Edge are still there :->

  • can you hear yourself ? . . . . sad .

  • Awesome composition by the one and only U2, I love Magnificent and this song. I love the way The Edge uses the slide in these 2 songs. Kudos!

  • its "magnificent" period..

  • This song is good enough to make 71/2 minutes seem like 71/2 seconds. Either your are too young or too ADD to appreciate it. Sorry.

  • Sounded like 7.5nS to me.

  • This song alone is worth buying the album.

  • So many absurd comments here from people who have no clue about innovation and brilliance in music. This song easily transcends the typically mundane pabulum the masses tend to embrace and which ends up receiving so much undue recognition. U2 RULES!

  • fuck off

  • whoa there asshole!

    you're a fucking troll so go take a long walk off a short pier...you wouldn't know a good song since you shit out what little of a brain you had...now go fuck off

  • Alucinantes como siempre, son la mejor banda de la superficie de este planeta...

    lo siento por los chicos malos y por los de Liverpool.

  • 2010 grammy song of the year

  • Ohhh, I think dirtballjohnny has a big old man crush on Bono!!

  • he is secretly thinking..."oh bono...BONE me"

  • a magic album!

    and this is the best song on this album!

    TNX U2!!!

  • not as good as achtung baby I thought everyone knew that

  • whole album is amaizing, tnx U2 i dont know where we got you.

  • dis has to be 1 of U2s greatest songs ever, especaly love d guitar riff at 5:05, the edge has to be 1 of d best guitarists ever

  • Best song on the album, feels like the new One for me lol

  • i agree the new one of the album, and i hope it wins song of the year in 2010

  • dirtballjohnny is lowclass hater

  • this song makes me want to cry it is so moving and U2 does it again love em will go see them at the new Dallas Cowboys stadium in October!

  • They teach you anything else at Oxford University while you were clearly there?

  • i agree probably the best chorus written ever, this is the one of no line

  • At the moment of surrender

    I folded to my knees

    I did not notice the passersby

    And They did not noitce me

    -

    That possibly has to be the best chorus ever written.

  • Got a ticket to see them in Dublin in July,right in front of the stage,can't wait.Coldplay are alright if you like commercial pop,but Chris Martin is downright irritating.Roll on Croke Park, Dublin

  • We are going too! Looking so forward to it...even though I'm Irish it will be first time in Ireland other than a stopover in Shannon airport while going to Greece.

    Enjoy the show!!!

  • im irish, how can you say your irish if you've never been,anyway i hope you have a wonderfull time,and your very welcome here,enjoy your time here

  • LOL!!!! Well I was in Shannon airport for over an hour during a stopover to Greece, but in JULY will be our first time in Ireland for a vacation....thanks for your nice wishes : )

  • going to see them in california rose bowl!

    so..i like u2 more also, if not for u2 there would be no cold play.

  • (@cescfagtorres) Edge has more singing range than Martin... LOL and he is also a guitar genius,hero,master etc etc he can own coldplay by himself.

  • I don't mind the backing tracks of Bono obviously, or Edge's singing at all. I have a problem with Eno and Lanois (?) singing chorus....it drowns out Bonos voice, the cracking etc. and Edge's too....it ruins it almost for me.

  • I think exactly the same. I don't understand how they let them do it.

  • u2 is the number one

  • bono's voice is great and of course edge's voice isnt amazing he's the freaking guitarist

  • Edge's voice is completely amazing. Listen to him sing Van Diem's land on Rattle and Hum and most of the super high falsetto parts in all their songs and you'll find the Edge. He's incredible and considered by some to have an even better voice then Bono (at least technically, not emotionally or with the full color of Bono's untrained yet magical chords). The Edge is a true genius and can do it all!

  • If im not mistaken but Van Diem's land was sung by the edge...check out the actual movie...its the second selection...still a great song

  • amazing song.!!! 30 years carrear always on top no one like them

  • cesctorres you are only here just because you wanna say crap about U2.  Dont waste your time and get a life little shit!

  • I've never heard Bono make that sound when he sings "I tied myself with wires" it's just incredible, and it's evidence that they're still innovative and fresh.

  • I like this song, but the lyrics 'I was punching in the numbers at the ATM machine' annoys me, since ATM stands for Automated Teller Machine. So its as if he's saying '...numbers at the automated teller machine machine.' I know it's podantic, but it shits me up the wall when I hear it! Great song and greatest band nontheless...

  • I have punched the numbers at the ATM machine, to buy that semi-precious stone..i have to say I also have seen that reflection off the little mirror by the ATM...you see a different person filled with guilt, not in control, but you continue...it can be somewhat "podantic" (by the way great word). However for someone who can relate to that moment...its relevant...then again if we have to come down to breaking down one line, it says a lot about the greatness of U2...I agree it is a great song.

  • amazing song, bono hasoutdone himself once again...

  • ha ha ha, they are already my friend. No 1

  • You have to give it time and let it sink in.

    The best way to do it is while driving. Just play the CD and don't think it's U2.....don't even pay attention. Just let the songs play and pretty you'll find your mood being influenced by this music.

  • i couldn't agree more.

  • hermoso tema, como no podria ser de otra manera.

  • prospektormarching you can go with your shitty 3-grammy band to shit im sure you like sweet crap songs from shitplay. vagina

  • pure beauty.

  • Grammy "song of the year"

  • What a fantastic song! My favorite of the new album!

  • You're some asswipe, Prospekt. what are you doing in here, to leave a comment, so? you'll never have the talent to write anything like this song.... Prospekt That.

  • you're a gas man, prospekt, and there's no doubt about it. of course i like this song; I think it's fking brilliant. But, i'll leave you to snow patrol, and the kings of leon, and the sodding zutons, and all those other tepid tosspots. God bless you and your youth, and I envy you inability to discern quality. ..it means you're easily pleased by today's young bands.

  • fuck off back underneath the bridge from where you came,troll

  • DICKWAD! U2 IS THE BEST BAND EVER! even if they are old, they make good music, thats why they are still around, and your favorite SHIT bands wont be for 30years. god find your shit bands and f them all

  • Almost there. U2 Are NOT old. They are CLASSIC

    In any case +1 to your comment :)

  • U2 music present the real time emotions in world, thay touching our time of living, 1990 the world wose in his best year's, love, peace and thay make Achtung Baby, music in No Line On The Horizon include emotions of those year's.That why thay are the best. Other bands for example coldplay, their music is jus't : blablabla...and also other band's don't have The Edge, Bono, Larry and Adam in thay team's.

  • simply the best

  • Not the last.

    U2 - Songs of Ascent coming out December 2009/Early 2010.

  • cesctorres02 are you dumb or what? first go read some news and dont guess probabilities... U2 will release another album next year m8

  • Both Coldplay and u2 are great.

    Stop comparing.

  • colplay = a joke

    NOTHING AND NO ONE COMPARES U2

  • When I first heard Coldplay's song "Clocks" I thought it was by U2

    LIKE, U2 SAVED THE DECADE MAN!

  • ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha.

  • As for Coldplay vs U2 - really? You're really making that comparison? U2's cd Joshua Tree came out over ten years before Coldplay was even a band, and remains one of the BEST albums released in the history of rock. U2's work has impacted more people than Coldplay has ever done, if for no other fact that they have been around for decades longer, and yet are still in the industry making music that touches people. Let's see if Coldplay can say the same thing in ten or twenty years.

  • Great song - the message is powerful and relevant to many young people who struggle with the emptiness of a sex-obsessed culture and yearn for something real and deep. At least thats what I read into the lyrics - what are your thoughts?

  • u2 rules ...............

  • call me when coldplay or any will play song like this , you compare them with U2 , are you joke yourself.

  • come on U2 doesnt sound like coldplay, Coldplay sounds like U2 !!!

  • then that garbage of music videos and millions of views from avril lavigne or jonas brothers tell you they are more succesfull than U2 or even The Beatles... ohhh come on, do me a favour go kill yourself...

  • some people don't half talk bollocks :). People don't realise who's better is just who you prefer not 'who's better' as such..If you get that you'll see it don't matter

  • P.S. - I won't dignify the jonas brothers comment with a response.... lol... please tell me this is some sick tastless joke... lol.... APRIL FOOLS!!!! LOL... Their music sucks, they suck live, and the only people who listen to them are horney little puberty entering girls... lol... I think southpark honestly summed up who they are perfectly.. lol.. when their fans age, they will be in some alley with hanna montana high as hell and beggin for change the next day.. lol.. that was harsh, sorry lol

  • cedars of lebanon, stand up comedy, no line on the horizon... and thats already 8 tracks i feel are really good out of 11.. .. the other three tracks are also good.... can you honestly say that almost all the tracks on viva la vida are great because I feel that all the songs on no line on the horizon are really good... another good collectin of songs by U2... boots was a solid single and is probably the weakest song on the album and thats saying a lot... lol.... anyway, sorry for all the typos

  • Just because the Jonas Brothers have millions of views on their videos on YouTube doesn't make them good.

  • u2 and kings of leon ar the nuts, u2 still up the crown but will pass it to them

  • U2 is up there for me. Totally talented. Some of their stuff, new and old, I CANNOT stand. But then there are songs that are complete gems. I like this one.

  • I would never compare U2 to anybody, they are in a league of their own!!

  • u2 should be compared with radiohead...not coldplay. u2 and radiohead are a level above coldplay.

  • Coldplay's sound revolves around Piano.. their music just isn't as hard as u2.. I do like coldplay but they are no U2.. they will not last 30 years like U2 has.. U2 has been versatile and have adapted to the changing times.. let's see if coldplay can do the same. anyway, going back to voices. Chris martin is a falsetto mostly (The Edge has more singing range than him..lol). No line on the horizon is better than viva la vida (U2 beats them again). very diverse album and has its hard tracks

  • I think to U2 is a little bit better than colplay, but what you say (Emassare1), That no Line on the Horizon better is than Viva la Vida, i think thats not true, at No line on the Horizon are verry good songs, like at the moment of surrender, magnificent ... But at No Line on the Horizon are also songs who can't tip at the normal U2 level, i'm nog saying Viva la Vida is better, its like the same level of quality i think!

  • I'm sorry, i'm NOT saying, i typed it wrong! :)

  • thank you vertigo190 and makarmusic :) anyway, maarteuh everyone is entitled to their own opinion... if u think viva la vida is on the same level... i'll take that... but yeh U2 on't out-do something like joshua tree or achtung abby and neither will coldplay... but i still feel that no line is better than viva la vida :) I just think it has a lot of amazing tracks... maybe you should giove it another listen :) my favorites are breathe, surrender, magnificent, white as snow, crazy tonight,

  • thats true Edge has more singing range than Martin... LOL and he also is a guitar genius,hero,master etc etc he can own coldplay by himself.

  • FOR THE LOVE OF GOD!!!! YOU COLDPLAY FANS NEED TO STOP...Coldplay was influenced by U2 therefore they copy U2..... LOL.... Coldplay cannot do a soulful song like this and chris martin does not have the singing range and soulful voice that Bono has. Furthermore, I hate it when people compare U2 and coldpay to the TEE..... U2 is way more rock than coldplay (majority of sound is based on or revolves around Guitar riffs). BTW, the Edge is a fucking genius...

  • Well said. I mean Coldplay would never say they were better than U2. They don't have one song that rates next to the best of U2. Pride in the name of Love, One, With or Without You, Streets have no name, I will follow, bad, Running to stand still, New years day...I could go on and on but just one of these songs obliterates Coldplay's entire boring catalog. Snore! U2 then Radiohead, then Coldplay and I'm being nice to include these bands with U2 at all. Joshua Tree crushes them both!

  • Forget the Coldplay copying U2 debate people! Coldplay are a good band in their own right and Chris Martin loves U2 so will obviously be inspired by them a wee bit. As for No Line, it's the album of the millenium thus far. Breathe is the best song on the album and has got to be a single!

  • U2 is not the same as it used to be. disappointment reigns over this new album at least for me. I agree that these new songs sound a little bit more like coldplay. U2 used to be more fast-paced than this...now it makes me sleep.

    not going to the concert in chicago to listen to these songs...

  • who gives a shit whether you are going to the concert or not...both shows at Soilder Field ar/will be sold out ...so nobody in Chicago gives a shit what you think

  • anyway i ve heard life in technicolor and lovers in japan i there isnt even a similarity. Dude viva la vida is really a copy from that song of Satriani you can hear the same tune with viva. But comparing this great song with lovers or life in technishit PLEASE!

  • you moron coldplay is a copy of U2 so dont waste your time saying that U2 copy songs from that shit.

  • the rythm, the melody, Bono's voice, the emotions, feelings, simplicity, lyrics... it's magic - impressive piece of art! thank you U2 for giving us such gifts to our lives...

  • Absolutely the best song on the album - it is so full of soul, Bono's voice is so full and from the heart...

  • Bwahahahahahahahahaa....man, just STFU.

  • this has 2 be 1 of the best songs on the album

  • your a copy.

  • Brano magnifico e potente!

  • Comment removed

  • according to an interview, this song was almost entirely made by a jamming session in one shot, where eno, lanois and u2 started off jamming not really knowing what they were doing but it turned into something incredible. eno said himself he had never experienced something like that and that it was like a "miracle". so, this song is definately not a copy :P. before you say something like that, it would be wise to base that statement on a more credible source than yopur own ears. lol

  • Comment removed

  • Brian Eno produced both No Line and Viva records, so there's your degree of separation. Read your liner notes people!

  • yeah this song is copy of song moment of surrender U2 .

  • a copy from which song?

  • Probably crazy tonight and breathe

  • I think what makes this album good or great, is not the beats or melodies but the voices. Bono The Edge and maybe Eno and Lanois if they contributed(which I think they did for this song) all their vocals are just astonishing.

  • wtf, it sounds nothing like coldplay's lost or lovers in japan....

  • Ur weird dude

  • You're an idoit!! Coldplay is a copy of u2's whole catalog!! Chris Martin wants to be Bono so bad, that he probably would get his legs amputated to be the same height!!lol

  • NO - this wont be a single - mainly coz it is too long even for a radio-edit - also the band feel it would not appeal to the general public (ONLY FANS) will understand its structure)! It just wouldnt work as a single!

    After "Magnificent", if there are to be any more singles - I reckon "Breathe" & "I think ill go crazy if I dont go crazy tonite" will be the favorites - I personally would LOVE to see "Fez - being born" as a single - its MAGICAL!

  • so beautiful <3

  • This is what music is all about ~ U2 lives forever

  • sad song...

  • i cannot get enough of this song...there is just something about it...u2 rocks!

  • U2 is U2 and will forever be U2. No other band excites me with new and old stuff.

  • Indeed, one of their very best and that is saying something as they have produced a lot of good music since I first listened to War at school all those years ago.

  • The most soulful sounding song U2 has ever done..yes even more soulful than Stuck In A Moment or I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For

  • The Best Songs in the Album

    Unknown Caller

    Moment of Surrender

    Magnificent

    No Line on the Horizon

    White as snow

  • omg i love this song one of the best songs they ever made

  • Excelente som! Bono está de volta com o agudo de sua voz, incomparável e imbatível! Edge solando como nos velhos tempos, Adam e Larry finalizando, completando a harmonia da mais bela música do álbum!

  • To the rythm of my soul

    to the rhythm of my unconsciousness

    OMG Great lyrics of this song

  • I love this songs... Simply perfect!

  • Bono signs with so much emotion... the best ive seen. I can tell a lot of effort was put into the making in this song, and it was brought to life by bono and u2.