Altman tops MASH with this , i can understand why people get hacked off because it differs from the novel , ive read it and this remains my favorite movie
Dogcrap. Awful. The worst in its genre. A weak, weak imitation of 40's detective movies. The oh-so-uncool-yet-thinks-he's-cool detective mumbles a lot, we waste many minutes of the film viewing his pointless and meaningless existence for no reason like 5-10 minutes wasting time on his stupid cat, but there's almost no crime detecting going on. The case itself doesn't really get going until halfway in, and then it barely stumbles along.
The last minute is aboutthe only interesting thing
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Just saw this terrible film;
Altman has no clue and the story is badly told by an inept screenplay.
There's a silliness here that just reeks of amateur work; the girls next door always showing their tits is just stupid teen age decoration.
Gould seems to sleep walk through the scenes and it's one of the worst performances by the great Sterling Hayden, who was drunk or high in most scenes and rambling through the part.
I wonder if Owen has the great personality to make this role shine beyond the usual film noir. Owen is great at melting behind a role. And if you look at this version for instance, the great thing about it is Elliot Gould's unique personality.
Wow, after reading the book I just watched the film and I was really enjoying it despte all the changes, Im not a stickler for that sort of thing but I could not stand the ending. It was just terrible, uninspired and betrays everything about the book
Still, it was entertaining and if you haven't read the book, this film is worth a watch
OriginalRocketJock, I must be broken. I read every Marlowe book Chandler wrote, and this twisted rewrite was my favorite film adaptation ever. My first runner up was Mitchum's Farewell, My Lovely, which was the most respectful movie Marlowe. Altman's love for the character as written by Chandler shines through the audacious rethinking of his code. Terry Lennox called Marlowe a loser, and the bullet told Terry he was no longer right.
Interesting, I've just started reading the book and while this clearly isn't what I was expecting from the film adaptation, it still looks promising and look forward to watching after the book
Classic "Film Noir" ....only Altman could do it like this ....Elliot Gould does such a great Job as Marlowe bringing his own style to the character....a great film !!!
@tabernavudu ..well yeah it's a classic, just because it's not in black and white and not as popular as "Chinatown" or "The Maltese Falcon" doesn't mean it's not a classic, to each his own I guess !!!
@smizzman I didn't make myself clear: there is a period considered to be the "classic period" of Noir. For example, such films as "The Long Goodbye", "Farewell My Lovely" and "Chinatown" are considered neo-noirs. "Out of the Past", "The Maltese Falcon" and "Double Indemnity" are classic noirs.
It is runs a very very very very very very very very very close second. I obviously hold the two motion pictures in very high regard. My children are third.
(1)CHINATOWN has been compared to OEDIPUS; the concept of incest ruining a town. (2.) i have LONG GOODBYE movie---a gangster breaks a coke bottle on his girlfriend's nose!!! impossible to break a thick glass bottle on a nose (3.) same gangster takes off his clothes to impress marlow! again, not very real, especially since he thinks marlow owes him almost half-million dollars (4.)has a scene of two dogs in mexican town having sex; who wants to watch that.
One of the most underrated movies ever. I'd rate it equal to Chinatown.
crazedmongoose03 16 hours ago
This movie is a big 10.
Ultrisound 6 months ago
Altman tops MASH with this , i can understand why people get hacked off because it differs from the novel , ive read it and this remains my favorite movie
Calburtonreid 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the best film i have ever watched
shlomonew 7 months ago
In this film Marlowe is like the father of the Dude Lebowski: a cocky cool asshole.
TheMorettimatteo 7 months ago 2
best marolwe movie ever
10141991 8 months ago
Reading Marlow novels and imagining him as Elliot Gould all the time!
davko79 11 months ago 3
Anyone notice the similarities between this movie and the Coen Brothers' "Big Lebowski" - so many similarities!
davko79 11 months ago 3
Two people are complete morons...
nemci7v 11 months ago
Comment removed
nemci7v 11 months ago
Cowboy Bebop was probably inspired by this film
nemci7v 11 months ago
Really, really don't see Marlowe with curly hair.
Dinyctis 1 year ago
Dogcrap. Awful. The worst in its genre. A weak, weak imitation of 40's detective movies. The oh-so-uncool-yet-thinks-he's-cool detective mumbles a lot, we waste many minutes of the film viewing his pointless and meaningless existence for no reason like 5-10 minutes wasting time on his stupid cat, but there's almost no crime detecting going on. The case itself doesn't really get going until halfway in, and then it barely stumbles along.
The last minute is aboutthe only interesting thing
RuflessRecords 1 year ago
Doesn't get much better.
RakehellRow 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Just saw this terrible film;
Altman has no clue and the story is badly told by an inept screenplay.
There's a silliness here that just reeks of amateur work; the girls next door always showing their tits is just stupid teen age decoration.
Gould seems to sleep walk through the scenes and it's one of the worst performances by the great Sterling Hayden, who was drunk or high in most scenes and rambling through the part.
Rexicano 1 year ago
@Rexicano you nailed it, I totally agree with everything you said. What a horrible film! The worst detective movie ever made.
Ace Ventura Pet Detective was more exciting.
RuflessRecords 1 year ago
@RuflessRecords
Thanks.
What was also weird about this film;
Arnold Schwarzenegger in a short part as the muscle.
Looking at him no one cudda guessed that he would go on to be one of the biggest movie stars.
Altman is one of the most over rated Directors but he's no Kurasawa.
Rexicano 1 year ago
@strazzy3 bet you didn't see David Carradine (Kill Bill/Kung Fu) as the rambling cellmate? kinda sad they're both uncredited in this film
joeycm 1 year ago
If interested, listen to our podcast on the Long Goodbye:
the link is on my page - see the WEBSITE link on the left hand side of my page.
Cheers.
AnthonyJFrame 1 year ago
Mitchum is the best Marlowe
GhostSnake 1 year ago 2
why?
marloweAUT 1 year ago
One the best films I have ever seen.
Paul
harryn123456 1 year ago
Arnold Swarzenegger is in this film, bet none of you'll knew that !!!
strazzy3 2 years ago 4
Not only did Elliot nail Marlowe but even brought out some sides of him I had not gathered from my own reading.
greatsea 2 years ago
Best Chandler Adaptation.
lucasaccardo 2 years ago 4
Elliot Gould as Marlowe - what were they thinking??
famachris 2 years ago
@famachris yep, he's awful
RuflessRecords 1 year ago
That's Jim Bouton at 1:05
glkanter 2 years ago
That slap that Hayden takes doesn't look faked.
goback3spaces 2 years ago 2
It's time for some new Marlowe films, with someone like Clive Owen in the lead role.
jksonny 2 years ago 5
I wonder if Owen has the great personality to make this role shine beyond the usual film noir. Owen is great at melting behind a role. And if you look at this version for instance, the great thing about it is Elliot Gould's unique personality.
skinwalkerxxx 2 years ago
Good point. The key would be to find either a non-leading man type that can still fill the role or a leading man that can be understated.
jksonny 2 years ago
Did he ever feed his cat?
mpjrdldn 2 years ago
At least once.
integral 2 years ago
He did buy some cat food but the cat refused to eat it because it wasn't "Curry Brand Cat Food" ..haha
smizzman 2 years ago
I guess I meant if he ever brought "Curry Brand Cat Food" home to the cat. I read elsewhere that the cat ran away.
mpjrdldn 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wow, after reading the book I just watched the film and I was really enjoying it despte all the changes, Im not a stickler for that sort of thing but I could not stand the ending. It was just terrible, uninspired and betrays everything about the book
Still, it was entertaining and if you haven't read the book, this film is worth a watch
Bestial1985 2 years ago
Comment removed
Bestial1985 2 years ago
OriginalRocketJock, I must be broken. I read every Marlowe book Chandler wrote, and this twisted rewrite was my favorite film adaptation ever. My first runner up was Mitchum's Farewell, My Lovely, which was the most respectful movie Marlowe. Altman's love for the character as written by Chandler shines through the audacious rethinking of his code. Terry Lennox called Marlowe a loser, and the bullet told Terry he was no longer right.
grayforester 2 years ago
If you like Altman, you'll love this movie.
If you like the Marlowe novels by Chandler, you'll hate this movie.
Therefore, this movie sucks immensely.
OriginalRocketJock 2 years ago
Interesting, I've just started reading the book and while this clearly isn't what I was expecting from the film adaptation, it still looks promising and look forward to watching after the book
Bestial1985 2 years ago
This movie was wild and weird, but ultimately, really well done! It has a good ending and Gould created a great and quirky interpretation of Marlowe.
FoxCityFilms 2 years ago
I loved the movie and I loved the book, but don't watch the movie expecting much of anything from the book.
integral 2 years ago 3
the singer is jack sheldon of schoolhouse rock fame (conjunction function and i'm only a bill)
roscoegino 2 years ago
The man is smoking a cigarette the entire movie.
bigwoode 3 years ago
One of the best film I have ever watched.
mojga1 3 years ago 23
since when was elliott gould so fucking gorgeous??
x
BettyBoopBoots 3 years ago 3
ain't he, though?
writtenrotten 3 years ago 5
Altman and Gould at their finest.
matthewdeloach 3 years ago 3
Classic "Film Noir" ....only Altman could do it like this ....Elliot Gould does such a great Job as Marlowe bringing his own style to the character....a great film !!!
smizzman 3 years ago 5
@smizzman "Classic film noir"?! Preposterous.
tabernavudu 11 months ago
@tabernavudu ..well yeah it's a classic, just because it's not in black and white and not as popular as "Chinatown" or "The Maltese Falcon" doesn't mean it's not a classic, to each his own I guess !!!
smizzman 11 months ago
@smizzman I didn't make myself clear: there is a period considered to be the "classic period" of Noir. For example, such films as "The Long Goodbye", "Farewell My Lovely" and "Chinatown" are considered neo-noirs. "Out of the Past", "The Maltese Falcon" and "Double Indemnity" are classic noirs.
tabernavudu 11 months ago
@tabernavudu ...Well said ..I recently watched" Out of The Past" again ..WOW is all I gotta say, Bob Mitchum could do no wrong :)
smizzman 11 months ago
Not a fan of Altman but this film (and McCabe...) are the exceptions - great: absurd, entertaining, disturbed and stylish
infoim 3 years ago 2
it ain't no chinatown.
sakara18235 3 years ago
no, it`s more brilliant and has that black, desperate atmosphere like the classics "Phantom Lady" or "The Big Combo" or ....
buria04 3 years ago
It is runs a very very very very very very very very very close second. I obviously hold the two motion pictures in very high regard. My children are third.
CheekymarK101 3 years ago
(1)CHINATOWN has been compared to OEDIPUS; the concept of incest ruining a town. (2.) i have LONG GOODBYE movie---a gangster breaks a coke bottle on his girlfriend's nose!!! impossible to break a thick glass bottle on a nose (3.) same gangster takes off his clothes to impress marlow! again, not very real, especially since he thinks marlow owes him almost half-million dollars (4.)has a scene of two dogs in mexican town having sex; who wants to watch that.
sakara18235 3 years ago
Great great film and superb music and a fitting memory to Dan Blocker (Hoss of Bonanza)
walkingbear56 4 years ago
Brilliant! My favorite Altman movie.
Jenny77777 4 years ago 14
What a WONDERFUL film!!!
1Th1617 4 years ago 4
The theme of this movie, "The long goodbye", is by John Williams! I love it. The entire film is a masterpiece
murgiaman 4 years ago 3
Yes this is a fantastic film. He's a 50s guy confused by the 1970s. Google 'long goodbye ebert' for a nice review
dwills68 4 years ago
One of my FAVORITE movies!!
1Th1617 4 years ago 3
"Marlboro" ahahahaha.
I have to check this flick out.
ShinTofu 4 years ago
You should, its a great movie!
EndOfTheUniverse 4 years ago
Gah! I really want to watch this movie, but I can't find it anywhere. I'm going crazy here!
EndOfTheUniverse 4 years ago
Netflix
matthooverdotcom 4 years ago
"It's okay with me."
Pawn2007 4 years ago 2
The best! Too bad the soundtrack is out of print.
rpachter 4 years ago
a wonderfull movie
marlowe's world brilliantly revisited
elliott gould at his best
sterling hayden's so powerful presence
magic of nina von pallandt
not to forget an interesting appearance of arnold schwartzenegger as a bodyguard...
mattttttti 4 years ago
Well, I don't know about "magic" -- Nina was certainly very pretty, but I wouldn't exactly call her an actress.
Does anyone remember how she became a 15-minute celebrity? Hint: It had something to do with author Clifford Irving and Howard Hughes.
scotpens 4 years ago
yes she was with him in acapulco at the time he said he was with howard hughes
encabronx 4 years ago
"Yeah, I even lost my cat."
thetenia 4 years ago
Quick quiz now -- anybody remember Nina van Pallandt (the beautiful blonde in the Mercedes convertible) and how she got famous?
scotpens 4 years ago
Thank YOU! I just saw this movie and I fell in love with Elliot Gould! It's like updated film noir
gypsycafe 4 years ago
Great film. Fantastic title music.
tomolongo 4 years ago
Robert Altman passed away... this film is his greatest
pmeeuwis 5 years ago
Elliott gould is so awesome
tayishere202 5 years ago
Elliott Gould rocks
squishyricola 5 years ago 2
That wig they made Jim Bouton wear was horrendous. Great movie though.
cloycebox 5 years ago
Thanks for that. My favourite film of all time.
ajbuckley 5 years ago
thanks mate!
v8ford 5 years ago
Great Movie. That trailer was choppy and showed too much though. Especially the coke bottle scene.
wildcatelicash 5 years ago
Well at least now we know trailers from the 70s weren't much different from today's trailers...
laterite 5 years ago
One of Altman's and Gould's best.
sorc36 5 years ago
great!
mycroft 5 years ago