I'm also a huge Gilmour fan but the guy (Kilmaster) playing the leads on rhe current Wall tour played everything (incl the Comf Numb solo) equal to what Gilmour recorded and actually better than Gilmour played it live (saw him play it 3X) I saw Waters on other tours and would agree with you until this year.
The solo sucked. No one can play Gilmour's solos exept Gilmour. It looked like the guy was playing a Jackson too, with doesn't belong anywhere near Pink Floyd music.
@apage251 i posted a comment a few weeks a go re, waters and his band playing c numb,on the c numb waters you tube hit. i commented that 2 session guitarists could never come close to david. 2 people posted remarks back to me, basically implying that i was harsh and judemental. i am not FACT OF LIFE IS THAT GILMOUR NAILS THIS.no is probably not the most natural in your face guitarist, but he is ,the greatest deliverer of a point or theme with his beautiful blusey guitar solos 2 die for
@bigals1000 I agree, but I think they were just done with it. Too much hype, regardless of who was in the wrong, it wasn't meant to be any longer. Waters/Gilmour will reunite some day....i hope.
i dont doubt that bryan adams isnt the best but i gotta admit that he did a pretty decent job on this song.... cuz both him and gilmour have distinct voices that can carry this tune quite well and it was also recieved with great applause in berlin
This isn't a good recording to judge with. I actually thought that Brian Adams' performance was a rare jewel within the rest of this travesty.
markvz 6 months ago
i wouldnt use brian adams to water my lawn...sheesh
lovedandhis 6 months ago
sounds like a poor cover!
1stchoicemodern 6 months ago
i sing better than this guy to be honest... where do i cant contact roger waters to sing with him ?
lalogamer 11 months ago
I'm also a huge Gilmour fan but the guy (Kilmaster) playing the leads on rhe current Wall tour played everything (incl the Comf Numb solo) equal to what Gilmour recorded and actually better than Gilmour played it live (saw him play it 3X) I saw Waters on other tours and would agree with you until this year.
antrcapo 1 year ago
lol at brian adams
eminded 1 year ago
but Bryan Adams is performing
marcelot12 1 year ago
lolz roger waters walking on stage the intire time
bovb902 1 year ago
The solo sucked. No one can play Gilmour's solos exept Gilmour. It looked like the guy was playing a Jackson too, with doesn't belong anywhere near Pink Floyd music.
apage251 1 year ago
@apage251 Except me...! :P
It´s a joke, but... check it out my tribute videos (playing Gilmour´s solos, The Beatles, withe the band live...).
Regards!.
mateusschaffer 1 year ago
@apage251 i posted a comment a few weeks a go re, waters and his band playing c numb,on the c numb waters you tube hit. i commented that 2 session guitarists could never come close to david. 2 people posted remarks back to me, basically implying that i was harsh and judemental. i am not FACT OF LIFE IS THAT GILMOUR NAILS THIS.no is probably not the most natural in your face guitarist, but he is ,the greatest deliverer of a point or theme with his beautiful blusey guitar solos 2 die for
dazvinci 1 year ago
I CAN'T BELIEVE 1990 WAS 20 YEARS AGO..
Nyusha26able 1 year ago 9
what a great song... lol does anyone else have the feeling that the cameraman was scared of being caught filming waters by waters himself?
R0CANR0L 1 year ago
@R0CANR0L a bunch of cameras were around, so whats 1 more
rushrulez1 1 year ago
As much as I enjoy the man's music, a shirtless Roger Waters does not inspire any kind of lust, young or otherwise.
emotobot 1 year ago
@emotobot ha ha indeed.
MADROCKS212 1 year ago
I read somewhere that Waters tried to get Springsteen to sing this part but he couldent because his wife was about to have their first baby..
chrisbb33 1 year ago
Can't be performed without Gilmour's vocals.
Fail.
donangry 1 year ago
Roger wrote the album, Gilmour has played Roger's songs many times without him
BstrangerUK 1 year ago
@BstrangerUK and viceversa
R0CANR0L 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
For all the Pink Floyd's fans! There's a new version of "IF" (atom heart mother) on myspace gariac. Enjoy it on myspace gariac popmusik!
MrGariac 2 years ago
where did you get this
i was at the show
TEMPmichaelhansen 2 years ago
and who's songs do you think Gilmours been playing??
hotstorm77 2 years ago 3
@hotstorm77 As much as i love waters if he wasnt such a big headed controll freak there would still have been pink floyd so dont put it on gilmour
bigals1000 1 year ago
@bigals1000 I agree, but I think they were just done with it. Too much hype, regardless of who was in the wrong, it wasn't meant to be any longer. Waters/Gilmour will reunite some day....i hope.
AtmaRising 1 year ago
@AtmaRising I think that in the next couple of year they will reunite and do a last tour together and end pink floyd in style (lets hope)
bigals1000 1 year ago
Roger Waters was a great musician and writer but very selfish. they shouldnt have played this without gilmour its just not rite
sdgrdr107 2 years ago
thats david gilmours song, only he should be able to play it
lusitanianxenocider 2 years ago
we all no who's missing
bigals1000 2 years ago 4
idk without david gilmour in the group this just seems like its missing something. there was something magical when all of them were together...
SuperVinylMan 2 years ago 23
genial
alucinaty 2 years ago
rare!
vegunited06 3 years ago
It's funny how much informal Roger Waters is. And by being informal, he gets even more funny.
noveleiro 3 years ago
just beacuse hes Roger Waters doesn´t mean he has to be formal..
Outsidenormality 2 years ago
Thanks for posting! Were might I be able to get the full, uncut version of this?
aximbigfan 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
does anhyone have msn!!! msg me jane23belle
genociding 3 years ago
hey i just redid my profile :)
cwong5 3 years ago
very interesting. Thanks for posting. An air-drumming shirtless roger is certainly an unusual sight.
benjamin308 3 years ago
Este ensayo es muy interesante, bravo por Bryan Adams, Roger Waters es genial!!
Gracias por subirlo.
RogelyW 3 years ago
hehe very roger waters lookin very funny without a shirt ehhe..anway he is the boss! and bryan adams did good job!
flosyd 3 years ago
How many guitar players did they need to replace Gilmour? Sucks!
denning43 3 years ago 2
Bryan Adams sucks. Roger Waters rules, shirt or no shirt.
I saw him in 2007, he's real built now, and he's almost 64!
matt72582 3 years ago 22
i dont doubt that bryan adams isnt the best but i gotta admit that he did a pretty decent job on this song.... cuz both him and gilmour have distinct voices that can carry this tune quite well and it was also recieved with great applause in berlin
ryantheriote 3 years ago 5
that's Bryan Adams singing while Roger shows off the spare tire.
cale67 4 years ago 2
XD one psare to many...i thought the drugs would have made him thin! XDDD still they are all great there.
jacobsanz 3 years ago