Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (357)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • People say there is a RACE problem. People say this RACE problem will be solved when the third world pours into EVERY and ONLY into White countries.

    People say the only solution to the RACE problem is if ALL and ONLY White countries “assimilate,” i.e., intermarry, with all those non-Whites.

    But if I tell that obvious truth about the ongoing program of genocide against White people, Anti-Whites agree that I am a naziwhowantstokillsixmillionje­ws.

    Anti-racist is a code word for ANTI-WHITE!

  • Dersohowitz is to Israel what he was to OJ Simpson: an evasive lawyer with an obviously guilty client.

    The Atzmon book is brilliant. A must read.

  • Alan Dershowitz thinks torture is ok...

  • @insanic1 He's a bold anti-anti-semite.

  • Frankly Mr. Dershowitz is another run of the mill anti-White who uses the Holocaust as justication for the genocide of Whites thru immigration, forced intergration and relentless pressure to intermarry, things he won't subject Israel to.

  • @MrMantraMan He believes in the morality of WHAT IS GOOD FOR THE JEWS. When white people ask what is good for white people the efforts to genocide all white people will likely stop.

  • I would love to see this mere jazz musician clean Alan's clock in a televised debate. Lol!

  • This is a fantastic book. If hateful Dershowitz is upset, that proves Atzmon got it right. Lol!

  • google Dershowitz turnspeak plagiarist

  • WAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!! WAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!! WAAAAAAAAA!!!!! shut the fuck up you whiney elite jew pig!

  • Comment removed

  • @vvnbrnstr (continuation #2) If you followed my reasoning then it's easy to understand the term "invented people". However never Israel denied the right to the arab people in his country nor teached and preached hate on his people. By the contrary, Israel always made very very hard concessions in steps for peace. And that is not the case from the arab side.

    Do you remember the 3 "NO" from Khartoum? ("no Peace with Israel, no recognition of Israel, no (follows on #3)

  • @vvnbrnstr, first thank you sincerely for conceding about the terminology. You mention about the "overwhelming complexity of the conflict", and that is exact. The complexity was big in 1948 and is much bigger nowadays.

    However it was always called the Arab-Israeli conflict by journalists, books, and any kind of analist, until the URSS (Soviets) start pushing the name "Palestinians" in the 60's looking for a new conflict to gain entrance in the Middle East. (follows)

  • @vvnbrnstr, you can't be taken seriously. Watch the terms you use "brainwashed Zionist Israelis". It clearly shows you are full of hate. You or Atzmon can believe in what stupid lie you want, but doesn't make it more truly. And Irgun WAS NOT mainstream Israel. Ishuv and Hagana were, and wanted to build and Peace. All the big lies that Arabs and soviets, also the Departament of Sate, used, are only that: lies. Please shut up now and be carefull no to bit yourself, you can die quicly.

  • Douche-o-witz once again resorts to bold-face lying. Atzmon's book is not anti-Semitic nor does it deny the Holocaust.

  • @Santarchy sorry, but you are quite wrong.

    The book is full of antisemit venom and lies about Israel and the jews.

    You're accussing Alan Dershowitz of what YOU are doing.

  • @ErnestoZeide I've read the book. You and Douche-o-witz obviously haven't. I challenge you to point out something from the book that's anti-Semitic.

  • @Santarchy obviously you don't know how to read and interpret texts.

    I'm unable to answer your question just now, but it will come.

  • I love the debate between Norman Finkelstein and Dershowitz, particularly where Finkelstein accuses Dershowitz of plagiarism and how low Dershowitz grovels. Another very good debate is between Noam and Dershowitz. Dershowitz is caught napping. Two great intellects, Norman and Noam.

  • Dershowitz hasn't even read the book

  • Not only is Dershowitz human garbage, he is also a confirmed plagiarizer

  • Dersowitz is to Israel what he was to OJ: a smooth talking lawyer defending an obviously guilt client.

    The whole world saw through him then and it sees through him now.

    End of story.

  • Hang on a second, this guy defends OJ and then has a go at the book he doesn't like?

  • Dershowitz is 100% Right on this.I am glad he is standing up to such hate and false facts and Jew and America hatred by another Socialist/Communist like Atzmon...who's music is nothing more than Free Form bad vibes...only praised by Far Left Jew and America haters in the media....like the BBC...and FAR Left Marxist Pro-Islamic Jihad orgs in England and elsewhere.He is an insult to 99% of All Jazz Artists.Goebbels would love him& call him a Great artist to.

  • @MrSaxman50

    Wow. It is so rare to find a person who's understanding of politics, religion, music, media and philosophy is so simultaneously as breathtakingly ignorant and insipid. You know less about more things than anyone I have seen in years. Congrads.

  • @pine829 becaue I disagree with this guy doesn't m,ean I know less on the subjcets you decided to thrown in your attacks on me.I know politics extremely well...I am a practicing Catholic...I am a jazz musician and educater with many CDS to my name..have played all over the world and lived in Europe for years recording and performing..I studied philosphy for many years as Theology.You ,when someone disagrees and knows Facts...you do as ALL commies do..throw out factless Personal attacks.

  • @MrSaxman50 If you are not ignorant, then would you please explain the following:

    1) Your characterization of Atzmon's political views are simply flat wrong.

    2) How being you being Catholic is relevant to either Atzmon's politics or his music or any other statement you made.

    3) His music is neither "free form", nor "bad vibe". His latest work is more accurately characterized as bebop and middle-eastern influenced free jazz.

    4) Socialism and Communism are not the same thing.

  • 5) Why an educator would misspell the word as "educater", as you did.

    6) The praise for Atzmon's music is outside the demographic you cite.

    7) Why you don't seem to understand what a "jihad" is.

    8) How it is that you know that 99% of all Jazz Artists are insulted by him.

    9) How it is that so many people seem to be showing up at his concerts.

    10) Why so many people want to read his books.

    11) Why the Wandering Who has received so much critical acclaim.

  • Given the poor quality of your response and your numerous severe errors, my guess is that, in actuality, you aren't Catholic, you can't blow a note, you don't listen to Jazz, you don't live in Europe, you have never performed even a card trick in front of an audience and you know literally nothing about Philosophy or Theology.

    Do yourself a favor, get the book The Wandering Who by Gilad Atzmon.  Read the hard truth. You will see yourself.

  • @MrSaxman50 thank you for preaching the truth my good friend. always fight the good fight. remember, Israel is the little beacon of light, in vast, dark world. we must always continue to fight for its existence, and stand up for the Jewish people. Do not let these anti-Semites and leftwing liberal junkies deplore you, they will have their fair share of hell in the afterlife. Thank you. Shalom.

  • Gilad Atzmon's book The Wandering Who is a brilliant explanation of Jewish identity...or lack thereof and how this drives the current situation in Israel and in the broader Zionist community worldwide.

    In contrast, Alan Dershowitz is playing true to form, a shrill and hateful little man desperately determined to direct attention away from Israels long list of crime...and this book.

    Atzmon is the cool and reasonable intellect, while Dershowitz is the spitting and sputtering crybaby.

  • SHAME on YOU, Dershowitz. Cancel your Israeli citizenship, put America 1st, speak up for all wronged Americans, skewer Israel over the Lavon Affair, USS Liberty and make sure Pollard stays in prison forever. Otherwise shut the hell up and move to your favorite racist state with all the other hypocrites.

  • @Greenyxt I ask you to consider that we all would be much happier if Mr. Dershowitz gave up his American citizenship and left this country for Israel. That way we could all enjoy the peace and quiet that his ranting and raving destroy and he could enjoy a life in which watching Palestinian women and children being fried or killed by IDF Phosphorous bombs from the comfort of a lawn chair is only a short drive away.

    Israel deserves Alan Dershowitz and he it.

  • I am really looking forward to watching Palestinian women and children being fried or killed by IDF poisonous phosphorous bombs, which are a figment of your twisted imagination.On the other hand, I can introduce you to many Israelis who have lost family or themselves been injured by Palestinian terrorist bombs and rockets.

  • @jojobacon The IDF use of phosphorous bombs on Palestinian civilian targets is not an item of debate. It is a fact that not even the IDF disputes. While the use of these munitions is indeed "twisted" it is unfortunately not imagination. Phosphorous munitions were used in Cast Lead among other campaigns according to both witnesses and the IDF itself.

    At least you are honest about your hatred and your support of genocide. Your honesty is an inspiration to your countrymen.

  • @jojobacon Perhaps you could tell us what it is about the use of these horrible and disfiguring weapons that so appeals to you and the rest of your countrymen. Is it the stench of death that you like? Or perhaps the rush of power that you feel when you use such weapons on the sitting ducks you have corralled in Gaza. Nothing like a good smiting, eh? Or perhaps it serves as a distraction from the incredible shame you feel when you contemplate the horrible monster you have become.

  • @pine829

    Your grandfathers stole the land and livelihood from a people that allowed you to live peaceably in their land.

    Your fathers killed their sons and daughters and continue the theft.

    Now, the current generation lays siege to their grandchildren and the last of their land. You have nearly achieved the destruction your grandparents dreamed of.

    Yes, you are indeed the "chosen people".

    Make no mistake: The world see you and your people for what they are.

  • Rev 3:8 “I know your works – see, I have set before you an open door, and no one is able to shut it – that you have little power, yet have guarded My Word, and have not denied My Name.

    Rev 3:9 “See, I am giving up those of the congregation of Satan, who say they are Yehuḏim and are not, but lie. See, I am making them come and worship before your feet, and to know that I have loved you.

  • dershowitz are AN HATEMONGER AND A LIAR !!!

  • Comment removed

  • Enjoy the comments section of this video in which gq902 foul mouths Gilad Atzmon, attempts to disrupt conversation, rationalizes the inane utterances of Alan Dershowitz and Peddles a book on hate created to justify the politics of Israel.

  • Comment removed

  • Son of Hamas: A Gripping Account of Terror, Betrayal, Political Intrigue, and Unthinkable Choices [Hardcover]

    Mossab Hassan Yousef (Author)

    Price: $17.63 & eligible for FREE Super Saver Shipping

    Ships from and sold by Amazon(COM)com. Gift-wrap available.

  • But everything changed when Mosab turned away from terror and violence, and embraced instead the teachings of another famous Middle East leader. In Son of Hamas, Mosab Yousef—now called “Joseph”—reveals new information about the world’s most dangerous terrorist organization and unveils the truth about his own role, his agonizing separation from family and homeland, the dangerous decision to make his newfound faith public.

  • @gq902 Your funny! Everyone knows the MOST dangerous terror organization in the world is israel and their "mossad"! All others pale in comparison!

    Just look at the King David Hotel Bombing, The Lavon Affair, 9/11, 7/7, OKL. City Bombing, Beruit Marine Barracks Bombing, Lockerby, The USS Liberty just to name a few!

    Groups like Hamas, Hezbolla would not exist if not for israeli crimes against goyims all over the world!

    REAL Americans DO NOT support israel anymore "TROLL"/"SHILL"!

  • Since he was a small boy, Mosab Hassan Yousef has had an inside view of the deadly terrorist group Hamas. The oldest son of Sheikh Hassan Yousef, a founding member of Hamas and its most popular leader, young Mosab assisted his father for years in his political activities while being groomed to assume his legacy, politics, status . . . and power.

  • Dershowitz is an idiot and a liar. In this video Dershowitz laughably fails at shouting down thought or debate on Gilad Atzmon's book The Wandering WHo.

    Gilad Atzmon absolutely nails the truth about Israel and the Zionists and it . Atzmon's book, The Wandering Who, is a brilliant expose' on the twisted forces that animate the modern Zionist movement and explain as no other modern book has why this is so.

    An absolute must read book, no matter which side of the argument you are on.

  • @pine829 You come out as a very desperate person.

  • @gq902 No, I come out as a critic of Alan Dershowitz, and as a critic of all those, who like Dershowitz, attempt to silence intellectual examination of the policies of Zionism and those who attempt to whitewash the decades genocide of the Palestinian people.

    On the contrary, it is Dershowitz who is desperate to suppress the truth. He knows that The Wandering Who by Atzmon is a bright light of truth shining on Israel...and he doesn't like what that light shows.

  • @gq902 I know you. I know that in the quiet of your heart when no one is looking that occasionally the magnitude of the Palestinian genocide horror startles you. You see their faces and hear their cries in your sleep. You fight back the truth that you know and hide behind the wall of lies you help maintain. You promise yourself that everything you know to be a crime is for a greater purpose.

    You can lie to the world, and some believe you. But your heart know the truth as do I

  • @pine829 No worries, the Zionist stopped the Jihad terrorism on the Jews long ago since the Jews returned to their ANCESTRAL homeland :) you know one day the Christians will learn from the Jews how to defend themselves against the terrorism that Muslims are doing to the Christians in Egypt, Nigeria, Somalia. Muslims know they can't get away with Jihad against the jews any more :)

  • @gq902 You have an odd concept of "defend". The chief source of terror in the Middle East is Israel. More people figure it out every day.

    It will be interesting to see how long Israel can sustain the lies and avoid facing the music for its crimes. Forever is a long time gq. ;)

    I do have the satisfaction of knowing that one day the Zionists and those who have created the Frankenstein that is Israel will someday face the very God that they exploit. You too.

  • @gq902 I have no worries. Arrogance, hubris, pride, vainglory, wrath and greed are always paid in kind. As the saying goes "The wheels of Justice grind slowly, but extremely fine"

    A single mistake, an untimely discovery or one unanticipated event may undo the entire house of cards

    I patiently wait for that day. That day, I will set up a lawn chair and watch Justice play as did the Israelis who did the same during the phosphorous bombing of Gaza during Cast Lead. Pass the chips

  • @pine829 bllaa blaa blaaa blllaaaa go back reading david duke (dot) com and stormfront.. the Christians in the Middle East will one day learn from the Zionist how to defend against Jihadi terror, such as the coptic Christians being rounded up and slaughtered, of-course your busy reading david duke copy and paste. you ca't even think for yourself, you can only google for yourself.

  • @gq902 So, your argument is reduced to claiming that I am plagiarizing some other guy? Seems to me you are out of bullets. Dershowitz is just like you: arrogant, prideful and hateful....and generally "full"...mostly with yourselves...and sh#t.

    I, like Atzmon, on the other hand, am capable of debating the facts. The facts are my friends. You and Dershowitz in contrast, have a different relationship with facts - they are inconveniences that must be overcome in pursuit of your agenda.

  • @gq902 Would you explain how the systematic killing a civilian population in an occupied country as part of the national policy of that occupier is justified?

    Would you explain how the state sponsored theft and/or destruction of property is justified?

    Would you please explain how you justify the bombing of schools and private homes by a military air force?

    Would you please explain the routine denial of medical and emergency care to the Palestinians?

    Seems like racism to me.

  • @pine829 Just like the Muslims are killing Coptic Christians in Egypt and black Christians in Nigeria, the same Jihadis are ATTEMPTING to kill Jews not only in Israel but in the United States and in Europe. Now go defend Jihad terrorism.

  • The Israeli military regularly targets women, children and other obviously harmless individuals with personal terrorism.

    Israel regularly denies medical, OBGYN and other emergency care to Palestinians based solely on their race.

    Israel has, as a State policy, the regular theft and/or destruction of Palestinian property.

    Israel is the only apartheid state on this planet in which that race based separation and discrimination is a matter of official State policy.

  • The State of Israel has repeatedly lied about its use of these munitions and about the terrorist nature of these acts.

    The founders of the State of Israel were clear that the founding and continuation of country required the expulsion of the native population – the Palestinians.

    The Israeli targeting of the Palestinians is based solely on the race of the Palestinians, thus it is genocide.

  • Those premeditated acts by Israel include the bombing of known civilians.

    Those premeditated acts include the use of munitions banned by the Geneva Convention – Phosphorous based munitions.

    These bombings of civilians populations have included women, children, schools and other obviously non-military targets. They are terrorist acts.

  • The Genocide of the Palestinians is the official policy the State of Israel itself.

    That policy has been a State policy for more than 60 year without interruption.

    That policy of harassment, theft and killing is enforced at the specific direction of the government of Israel using the military of Israel.

    That policy is premeditated and planned in advance unlike the reactionary nature of the events you cite.

  • @gq902 @gq902 There are several drastic differences between the events you cite and the Israeli Genocide of the Palestinians:

    The Palestinians had their land stolen from them by people coming from outside their country - mostly European Jews

  • @pine829 UMM you know very well that Judea, Hebron Bethlehem are all Hebrew names for well over 3000 years not arabic names. the Jews returned to their ANCESTRAL Homeland from Iraq, to Germany Yemen, to Poland Libya to Algeria who actually were kicked out by their HOST muslim countries, just like many Christians in Muslim lands are being persecuted by the muslims to this very day. the people of the land which are jews do not steal their own land :).

  • @gq902 You have several f things wrong again. Islam has existed only since about AD 610, so Muslims could not have kicked anyone out of their land 3000 years ago.

    There were people living in "the promised land" before the Jews arrived, so don't start the whole business of "ancestral lands" crap, its a red herring

    According to the Torah, the bequeath of the "promised land" by God was a conditional covenant. Jews didn't honor it then and they don't honor that covenant with God now.

  • @pine829 LOL the Palestine language is ARABIC because the the Arabs come from A R A B I A not Judea, Islam kills Jews, Christains, Hinud and Bahais, Muslims today cannot live in peace with anyone but the best place to live with muslims is in Israel because Muslims know that he Jewish army wont stand for your muslim Jihad crap, only the Hindus and the Christians are suffering from Muslim terror not so much the Jews now days.

  • @gq902 You are wrong, the Palestinians ARE the original inhabitants of what is now called Israel.

    Israel is killing a RACE of people called the Palestinians. They are the original people. Israel is killing them because of their RACE not their RELIGION, Most of these Palestinian people are Muslims, however, there is a sizable population of them are PALESTINIAN CHRISTIANS.

    Thus, ISRAEL IS KILLING PALESTINIAN CHRISTIANS as part of its national policy too.

  • @pine829 LOL The Hebrew and Arabic language were once the same language...and even funnier, that language came from Africa.

    You guys are killing your cousins.

  • @pine829

    Israel has a right to exist.

  • @esj8341 No country has a "right' to exist. A country in a piece of ground with people that share a common interest in maintaining and defending the borders of that piece of ground. Nothing more. There is no higher authority that dispenses land ownership "rights". Sometimes those people lose the ability to maintain the borders and lose them through conquest. For example, Israel defeating the Palestinians. Sometimes they lose them by losing the common interest. For example, civil war

  • This whole notion that Israel is somehow "special" because their God gave this land to a particular religious group is a preposterous argument. Anyone can cook up an unseen deity who does such things. The odd thing about this line of reasoning among the Zionists and Israel apologists is that a significant fraction of them, and the present State of Israel at large, are not of the Judaic religion at all. Israel is a largely secular state.

  • The most flawed part of the Deity Land Grant argument is that in the Torah they wave in your face while making this argument, the "land grant" is clearly conditional with several very specific provisos. The Zionists, the Judaic religion and the State of Israel separately and together are in violation of these provisos in the very text they use as their "deed" from their God

    By their own text, the ancient Jews broke their "covenant" with God, as do the modern Jews. Thus no "rights"

  • @pine829

    Re: No country has a right to exist."

    Wrong.

    Expert scholars of International Law acknowledge a nation's Right to Exist.  e.g., Oppenheim - International Law. Moreover, numerous leaders from Arafat to Obama have expressly acknowledged that Israel has a right to exist.

    Again, as the President said himself, "Israel has a right to exist."

  • @esj8341 They, and you, can say whatever they wish. There is no group, no body, no authority that is above an individual nation to grant these purported "rights".

    Let me make this very simple for you. The present state of Israel has not surrendered its national sovereignty to any outside entity, thus there is no "law" that either compels them or governs them.

    The notion of "international law" is ridiculous. The only international law is the point of a sword.

  • The President of the US is entitled to an opinion on whether or not the State of Israel is a good idea or is a bunch of swell guys. However, so that we are both clear, the President of the US does not have a Constitutional ability within his own government to grant such status to a foreign government, nor is the US or Israel under the sovereignty of another such that such a statement has any practical meaning

    They are empty words from an empty and befuddled head.

  • Let me make this even clearer for you. If the country of Turkey developed a weapon that made them invincible in war and if Turkey then decided that it would be a good idea to put an end to the whole Palestinian problem by invading present day Israel, kicking out the Jews, creating a puppet state and renaming it Islamopolis, there would no more call in the long run for "international law" than there is today about the Europeans kicking the Indians out of North America. The sword wins.

  • Perhaps the most flawed application of this whole line of reasoning is the foundation of Israel itself. Britain asserts in the Balfour Declaration that it gives Palestine to European Jews.

    Britain had as much "right" to give Palestine to the European Zionists then as Ireland has a "right" to give Iceland to Indonesia today.

    Moreover, if you read the Balfour Declaration you see the uncomfortable proviso about Palestinian rights. Israel has clearly violated these.

  • @pine829 You do know that the US and israel do not even have any type of treaty, etc. right? If we did israel would have to define it's borders which we all know it refuses to do!

    So in other words all this BS aid we are giving them is ILLEGAL! Just though you might want to know this for future ref.

    I don't know about you, but our so called prez DOES NOT speak for me!

  • @m6c9d The borders of Israel are as broad as your imagination. Why stop with the elimination or subjugation of the Palestinians. Perhaps God himself has "deeded" the whole of the Middle-East to the Zionists. But why stop there, perhaps it is God's will that the whole of humanity should be the footstool of Israel.

    As an American, I am pleased as punch to subsidize the genocide of a people I have never met to the tune of several billions per year while my own grow hungry.

  • @pine829 From what I have learned israel's flag, with the two blues lines represent the Nile River on one side, and the Euphrates on the other! The Greater israel!

    Then again from what I have learned "They" want the whole world!

  • @m6c9d I think it is true that there is no drug more powerful than power and that there is no pleasure greater than the climax of conquest. I believe that ALL people are susceptible to this. The 10,000+ wars in known human history are testimony to this.

    The British Empire wanted the whole world, the French wanted the whole world, the Mongols wanted the whole world, the Romans wanted the whole world, the Americans want the whole world.

    Why should the Israelis be any different?

  • @pine829 The Constitution/Bill of rights is supposed to be the rule of the land, but the UNpatriot act, and now the 2012 national defence authorization act (Sec 1031-32) have surpassed them!

    Just for your info they are also setting up FEMA Camps all over the country to detain normal Americans they delcare to be dissents or terrorists! Who do you think had a say in these new so called laws? Same "state" that we're talking about here!

  • @m6c9d Huh, I guess my fate is already sealed. I just hate being tortured and killed.

    I would point every open mind to Gilad Atzmon's book The Wandering Who. It is the best explanation of world events today.

  • @pine829 I have the book, have not read it all yet, but I have a good idea what it says. Been doing this for a little now! All roads lead to the same "chosen people"!

    I would advise you to prepare yourself/family for what is coming! I truly believe it is just a matter of time before Marshall Law is declared, especially if we invade Iran for israel!

    Millions of Americans are waking up! Thus the FEMA Camps, internet kill switches, etc.!

    Please read what I told you about, and pass it on!

  • @m6c9d No corrupt empire...nor any empire for that matter, has survived forever. Hate, hubris and terror are always and eventually paid in kind. In time, every tyrant fades to obscurity.

    Israel as a nation has within itself the seeds of its own destruction. You cannot bully your way to greatness, you cannot threaten yourself into leadership, you cannot intimidate your way into loyalty, nor can you hate your way into peace.

    By their fruits, you will know them.

  • @pine829

    Your argument is not with me but with international law as I did not create international law nor am I responsible for its continued existence. I just wanted to point out that your assertion there there is no such thing as a right of a nation to exist is false on its face.

  • @esj8341 "International Law" is false on its face. There is no such thing as international law because, as all of the "scholars" of such will point out, the entire basis of international law is treaty or convention. There is no sovereign or higher authority that has the ability to enforce it. As such, it is little more than an intellectual curiosity for diplomats and academics.

    There is no person, body, group, sovereign that has the ability to grant a "right" to a nation.

  • Let me give you a simple example. Let us say that Canada wrote a fancy Declaration giving a bunch of diaspora American Indians the present day United States of America. Then Canada, Bulgaria and Burma recognized the "new" state of "Souixland"

    By your argument the new country of Souixland would then have a "right to exist" under "international law". Preposterous.

    Yet this same line of logic is used time and again to prop up the notion that a similar "right" exists for Israel.

  • @pine829

    Two points

    1. For good or bad, International law is a reality. And although it is enforced differently it is still enforced by international bodies, self governing norms, and individual nations.

    2. Treaties are not mere intellectual curiosities. E.g., America treaties have the force of law, and trumps conflicting state and even fed law when the treaty was passed more recently than the statue.

    Israel has a right to exist

  • @esj8341

    1) Preposterous. Which "International body" has the ability to create nationhood for a given person or group of people? If there is such an entity, how do I as an individual apply for my own country? How is this nationhood enforced? In the end you are left with the fact that the strong take from the week. The "laws" are simply rationalizations.

    2) Treaties have effect inside a nation only in that they become part of that nations laws.

    Israel exists by force only.

  • The most interesting part of this wrongheaded "right" that Israel purports to possess is that it is put forward by the exact same crowd of Zionist and Israel apologists who have systematically ignored UN after UN resolution condemning Israels invasion of Lebanon, the theft of Palestinian land through the building of so called "settlements." and so on.

    I can prove to you that there is no such thing as international law by the behavior of the very nation you seek to defend with it.

  • @pine829

    Re: preposterous

    Who is a more qualified and credible judge of whether Israel has a right to exist: The President of the Untied States who also happens to be a lawyer & law professor or pine829?

  • @esj8341 I am always amused by those, like you, who hold the attainment of this "right" so dear. I have always suspected that the root cause of this was the nagging fact that Israel was founded on top of both the land and bodies of the Palestinians. This causes Jews to feel shame for their treachery.

    Apparently, having others complicit in their crimes seems to assuage this shame.

    If the President believes Israel has a specific "right" to exist, he is wrong.

  • @esj8341 So your argument comes down to the thickness and weight of our CV's eh?

    Mr. Obama also invested several hundred million of his taxpayers money in now bankrupt Solyndra. Do you also consider him to to be "qualified" and "credible" in this laughable failure...or do you consider him to be an expert only in those things in which you believe he agrees with you?

    Truth is truth no matter who speaks it.

    Israel's existence ends when it can't defend its borders.

  • @pine829

    Re: "So your argument comes down to the thickness and weight of our CV's eh?"

    Wrong issue. It's not your CV vs My CV, but your opinion against the expert opinion of the President of the United States, legal scholars, and even the former leader of the Palestine Liberation Movement.

  • @esj8341 My, you do seem to be intimidated by "experts"? What is it about you past that causes you to be such a slave to "authority".

    My opinion is not "against" anyone else's opinion. I am simply pointing out the facts to you and showing you where you have made errors in your thinking and analysis.

    The US President is a dolt. Legal "scholars" make their living toe-dancing around the rationalization of opinion and Arafat was worn down by the mill of Israeli belligerence.

  • @esj8341 BTW, this obsession with some purported "right" is addressed obliquely in The Wandering Who by Gilad Atzmon. This is the book that has Dershowitz all snorted up and sputtering and trying to shout down anyone who would agree with Atzmon.

    You should read the book. It is really quite brilliant. His analysis of the Jewish psyche, character and identity explains the forces animating the events of the present like no other book.

  • @esj8341 You make the mistake that because someone can give something a name and describe a structure that a reality exists. Nations, by the definition of a nation are independent and sovereign entities answerable to no other entity. Nations occasionally agree to specific behavior with other nations, however, there is no mechanism of enforcement other than direct war and there is no penalty for violation of any treaty other than bellowing politicians, stern looks or war with that nation

  • The whole Hebrew name/place argument is perhaps the weakest of all possible arguments. Both Hebrew and Arabic are "Semitic" languages. They both share the same root. As such, they share a similar structure, grammar and phonology. Thus, many words share a similar sound/structure

    Thus:

    English/Hebrew/Arabic

    Soul/Nefish/Nafs

    Jewish/Yehudi/Yahudi You/Ata/Anta We/Anakhnu/nahnu

     He/Hu/Hua She/Hee/Hia Why/Lama/Lima

  • @pine829 According to your logic racists attacks by muslim on Jews in France is because Jews are stealing muslim lands in France.

    Besides in Israel the Jews are safe however the Christains in Egypt are NOT safe from Muslim terrorists.

  • @gq902 I have never taken such a position. You are off topic again attempting to drag in clutter.

    The difference between the events we are discussing is that in Israel race based terrorism of the Palestinian people is an official, sanctioned and long established policy, not an isolated event. It is the difference between Black/White racial tension in the US vs an official policy of a white US government rounding up all the Blacks in the US, stealing their homes and shooting them

  • This difference is what the book The Wandering Who by Gilad Atzmon addresses in part, the question of what flaw or problem in the Jewish/Zionist psyche causes an entire nation of people to believe that these crimes are somehow permissible.

    Although Atzmon does not address this point, my own personal belief is that one of the reasons this genocide continues is that the Jewish people are so shamed by their actions that they would rather continue than admit the truth to themselves..

  • @gq902 I am a desperate man for desperate times. :) kisses....big sloppy kisses

  • #4

    Nigerian Islamists Tore Fetus From Womb of Church Woman...

    They shot my father dead, and then came for the rest of the family," Mr Adurkwa's other son Hyeladi, 25, told The Sunday Telegraph the following day. "One chased my brother Moussa and killed him, and the other shot at me, but my mother took the bullet in the stomach instead."

  • #3

    Nigerian Islamists Tore Fetus From Womb of Church Woman...

    The soldiers in the sandbagged machinegun nest outside the church, though, were unable save three members of the flock last week.

    On Wednesday evening, three days after Boko Haram ordered all Christians to leave Muslim-dominated northern Nigeria for good, Ousman Adurkwa, a 65-year-old local trader, answered the door of his home near the church to what he thought was an after-hours customer. Instead it was two masked gunmen.

  • #2

    Nigerian Islamists Tore Fetus From Womb of Church Woman...

    A modest whitewashed spire in a skyline dominated by mosques, for the last month it has had a military guard to defend it from Boko Haram, the militant local Islamist sect blamed for a string of terror attacks nationwide in recent weeks.

  • Nigerian Islamists Tore Fetus From Womb of Church Woman...

    Like many other Christian outposts in the spiritual homeland of Nigeria's "Taliban", the Victory Baptist Church in the northern desert city of Maiduguri no longer just relies on God for protection.

  • Does Dershowitz think he is fooling anyone? He is attempting to stop academics from discussing the book The Wandering Who. Stossel does not seem to recognize this tactic, nor does it appear the he actually read the book. Idiot reporter.

    The book itself is a watershed work. The Wandering Who cuts right to the heart of the issues that cause the Israelis to behave in the way that they do and it explains how millions of Jews worldwide can be persuaded to engage in and/or support genocide.

  • 2012.1.8 Israel attempts to hide from its crimes.

    2012.1.8 The world sees the deep shame of Israel.

    2012.1.7 Gilad Atzmon explains what deep flaw causes Israel to continue its errors in his book The Wandering Who.

    2012.1.6 After reading this book, the world sees Israel and its crimes with a new clarity.

    2012.1.5 Israeli/Zionist apologists like Alan Dershowitz find it increasingly difficult to press their agenda because people do not fall for their lies and twisted logic.

  • 2012.1.12 gq902 still can't follow a point

    2012.1.12 It appears that m6c9d is right, gq909 is an Israeli shill.

    2012.1.12 The Wandering Who by Gilad Atzmon has Alan Dershowitz reeling because the carefully constructed Zionist veil that has been stitched together with lies over the last decades is beginning to unravel and the stained underwear of brutality and racial superiority that animates the state of Israel is being seen clearly by the world.

  • 2012.01.07 (Baghdad, Iraq) - Sunni bombers send two Shiite pilgrims straight to paradise.

    2012.01.07 (Maiduguri, Nigeria) - Two Christian university students are murdered by Religion of Peace gunmen.

    2012.01.06 (Adamawa, Nigeria) - Islamists chanting 'Allah Akbar' barge into a church and massacre a dozen worshippers.

    2012.01.06 (Yola, Nigeria) - Three people at a beauty salon are gunned down by Boko Haram. Six children bleed to death following detonation of a Taliban bomb.

  • @gq902

    2012.01.07 Alan Dershowitz is a Zionist.

    2012.01.07 Gilad Atzmon's book is brilliant.

    2012.01.06 Dershowitz attempts to silence critics of Jewish hegemony.

    2012.01.06 The Wandering Who continues to astonish readers with its clarity of thought.

    2012.1.1 Israel is still occupying Palestine.

    2012.1.2 Israel still have removal of the Palestinians from their land as a state policy.

    2012.1.3 Israel remains deeply ashamed knowing that the world sees their crimes

  • @pine829 There is nothing wrong with being a zionist, in fact Zionism is GREAT concept that Jews don't have to pay Muslim the RACIST Jizya EXTRA taxes, that Muslims imposed on Jews & Christinians and Zionist means that Jews can return to their Ancestral homeland with out Muslim mobs having to round up Jews like in Libya, Algeria, Iraq, Yemen and more... the only legal Palestine is in Texas, and no one pays me to comment :)

  • @gq902 On the contrary, there is everything wrong with the present policies and practice of Zionism as defended by folks like Dershowitz.

    Israel as a country was formed on the back of another people: the Palestinians. Since the forced occupation of their lands by European Jews, these Palestinians have been systematically killed, intimidated, threatened by these Zionist occupiers. They have been are are now having their livelihoods and property stolen by foreign occupiers.

  • Mr. Dershowitz, would are right, we don't have enough shame. Let's have some.

    Israel was formed on the back of another people. Shame on you.

    Zionists blew up the King David Hotel. Shame on you.

    There is a systematic genocide of the Palestinian people going on as a direct policy of the Israeli government. Shame on you.

    Israel continues to seize Palestinian land for "settlements". Shame on you.

    Israel refuses to sign the nuclear non-proliferation treaty. Shame on you.

  • Who is this idiot GQ902? The video is about Alan Dershowitz fuming and sputtering with his trademarked faux incredulity that someone would actually have the courage and good sense to call out the Zionists and the state of Israel (occupied Palestine).

    One of the things I never get tired of watching is folks like Dershowitz reacting to suppress their shame and attempting to twist the facts and engage in name calling when they are caught.

    I point my finger directly at him.. Har, har, har..

  • @pine829 "gq902" is a "TROLL" or "SHILL". These are people hired/trained by israel to divert others from learning the truth about israel/jewish crimes in news stories, youtube, etc.! They will go so far as to personally insult a person to distract them/others. They even pretend to be what you are, Christian, American, etc. to try to gain your trust. Don't fall for it, and inform others please! See my past comments here!

    US Army Veteran,

    Marc C. Daniele

    Hercy, Mo.

  • @m6c9d An interesting charge. What makes you think this other than the fact that it appears that he has watched a completely different video and/or can't seem to follow a discussion.

    Perhaps we could ask gq902 to make a single observation on Alan Dershowitz's sputtering attempt to silence a couple of academics or better yet offer some commentary or criticism of Gilad Atzmon's brilliant upon brilliant book The Wandering Who.

  • @m6c9d I have been poking at gq902 for a couple of days, partly for my own amusement and partly to see if you're right. I do believe that you are right about the shills. In fact, there is now another guy that has entered the arena. Both of them are (or pretend to be) almost completely ignorant of their own history or of the facts.

    The idea that a nation would hire/train people to puff up their image or suppress discussion is fascinating to me. 

  • @pine829 If you have the time to mess with these "TROLL'S"/"SHILL"S" go for it! We need more people to identify them, their motives, and just plain out them to all!

    I can't remember the name of it, but there is even a yt vid about them being trained to do this type of stuff, and even change history on Wikipedia, etc.!

    Bring up the King David Hotel Bombing, The Lavon Affair, 9/11, The USS Liberty all done by israel and see what happens! Then again they may read this so....

  • @m6c9d Thanks for the reply. Thanks for the heads-up.

    It is fascinating that this exists. I have actually brought up a few of these topics already. I have gotten either a change of subject or an appeal to "experts" of some kind. Apparently, most of these Zionist shills have not spent much time actually thinking about the nature of the brutal regime that they indirectly support. Given their ignorance, I suspect that they are young.

    Maybe there is hope for them and the world.

  • @pine829 I'm gald you are still here because I got something brand new for you to read, and pass along to everyone. I haven't even finished it yet!

    Go to the ugly truth dot com, and see the story called The Jewish New World Order Is Upon Us. It will also tell you about the TROLL'S/SHILL'S, and more!

    Let me know what you think about it. Peace!

  • @pine829 When they bring up "experts", tell them about the thousands of Arch's, Engineers, Pilots, Firefighters, Police, etc. that say we have been lied to about 9/11! Let's not forget who was actually arrested that day! ONLY israeli's!

    You can also say that there is more than enough evidence for a court of law, because there is! For most of their crimes!

    The ONLY people you really need to worry about convincing are those on the bubble as such. Many just need to know the REAL TRUTH!

  • @pine829 You can also tell people about who is behind things such as the Wallstreet crimes, ie, Goldman-Sachs, Chase, etc. and who ALL are owned/run by! Most know the names of the companies, but not who owns them!

    Suggest you also see the 4 part Dec. 2001 Fox News report by Carl Cameron about israeli spying on the US, yt vid/s.

    Then look up who owns/runs nearly all of the media in this country!

    Don't forget the Fed, and who it's owned by! Private Jewish Bankers!

    It's global!

  • @pine829 one last thing for now, see who is behind the Gloabl Warming BS! It's a jewish man named Strong (think it's spelled right), friend of Rothschild, who worked at the UN for years!

    It's all another SCAM to make us pay for our own air, etc.! Cap and Trade, etc.!

  • @pine829 I learned about these fools mainly on a MSNBC News story were they even went so far as to threaten to come to my house, yet I was the only one prevented from making new comments! I was teamed up on!

    All I did was point out what israel has done, is not the US's alli, and has hundreds of "secret" illegal nuclear weapons! I also pointed out that it was against US policy, and law to support any nation with these weapons that does not sign the Nuclear Arms Prolif Agreement!

  • @m6c9d Interesting stuff. Although the full weight of what I know you're saying is a little like Tabasco sauce, when you are talking with someone who comes from a rose colored world in which everybody is "just trying to get along". It can be a little much (and counter-productive) to give then the whole does all at once.

    History is a funny thing. The truth can be hidden in plain sight.

  • @pine829 I agree with you. I have learned that if you inform people about the thousands of archs, engineers, pilots, and show them the video, and footage of numerous secondary explosions from 9/11, they will listen. When their listening, then spring the indisputable israeli connection on them! Show the proof though, ie: Dancing israeli's, PNAC, etc., etc.!

    Any person would have a very hard time denying the REAL FACTS!

    Look up Dr. Alan Sabrosky and what he says about 9/11, etc.

  • @esj8341 What? Are you so self absorbed that you do not think I have a life apart from setting you straight? 500 characters is hardly "length".

    What exactly is your question or comment?

    Hopefully, you have an opinion or statement about the subject of this video which is the poster boy of outraged Jewery Alan Dershowitz attempting to silence discussion of Gilad Atzmons's book The Wandering Who....which BTW is brilliant.

  • @pine829

    Thank you.

    The issue is a legal matter of whether Israel has a right to exist.

    You say it does not (and in addition that all international law is false).

    The President of the United States however, who also happens to be a lawyer and former law professor, says Israel does have a right to exist.

    The question again is who is the more credible legal expert, the President of the United States or pine829?

  • @esj8341 You're welcome.

    There is no legal matter because there is no binding structure under which the "law" operates. Simply, it is a jurisdiction problem.  Sovereign nations are not under the jurisdiction of a higher authority.

    I am saying that since there is no mechanism to enforce "international law", that the net effect is that there is no law no matter how loud you shout. A perfect example of this is Israel's complete and utter disregard for UN resolutions and directives.

  • The President of the United States can say whatever he pleases about Israel, but it is irrelevant. He does not have the ability to grant the "right" you so desire to Israel. He cannot do it from his position as the US President because the office of the Presidency does not have the ability to bind other nations to his opinions. He has no other forum/structure in which he, or anyone else for that matter, can grant this "right".

    "Expert" has nothing to do with it. A fact is a fact.

  • Perhaps the easiest way to prove this to yourself it to read the US Constitution under which Obama must operate. In it, you will find no reference to any nation other than the United States. If you read any and every UN document, you will find that the US does not have the ability, by those agreements, to bind any other nation to its opinion.

    Lastly, participation in the UN is voluntary. Nations ignore UN resolutions and directive at will and at their own pleasure.

    No "right".

  • @pine829

    Your reply unfortunately was not responsive. I am not asking whether you find the President's view, or International Law, relevant. We can get to that later.

    Here, again, I am asking:

    Who is the more credible expert in determining the legal question of whether Israel has a right to exist:

    A) the President of the United States -who also happens to be a lawyer and a former law professor- or

    B) pine829?

  • @esj8341 B

  • @pine829

    I guess it much easier to be crazy and not know it than to be sane and have one's doubts.

  • @esj8341 It is even easier to be right. In this case, to be right about there being no "right".

  • @esj8341 Read the book The Wandering Who by Gilad Atzmon. If you read between the lines a little bit you will see where this obsession with some sort of "right" comes from and what flaw in the collective Jewish psyche drives it.

    Look honestly at Israel today: God's "chosen people" killing the women and children who are the rightful owners of the land you stole.

  • @pine829

    Read "Paranoid Personality Disorder for Dummies" by Charles H. Elliott PhD and Laura L. Smith PhD.

    PPD is often marked by strange behaviors, and is related to Schizoid personality disorders. Sufferers of PPD often display a host of odd behaviors including baseless suspicions and conspiracy theories such as those you reveal in your endless comments attacking Jews.

  • @esj8341 Lame attempt at distraction. My issue is not with Jews as a race (although recent genetic evidence may indicate that there isn't one) or Judaism as a religion, but rather with the behavior of the state of Israel and the Zionists that promote it.

    I object to the state sponsored apartheid present in Israel and the race based (Israel on Palestinian) repression and discrimination going on there.

    Do you have a grocery store book for this Zionist syndrome as well?

  • @esj8341 Gilad Atzmon has an interesting quote in his book The Wandering Who - "While in the past an anti-Semite was someone who hates Jews, nowadays, it is the other way around, an anti-Semite is someone who Jews hate."

    Nothing could be more accurate.

    Your charge is ridiculous. Zionists regularly engage in the use of the charge of anti-Semitism to defend whatever they cannot morally or logically defend.

    It is the defense of last resort for an intellect out of bullets.

  • @esj8341 Do you have an opinion on this video in which Alan Dershowitz is sputtering and fuming about the book The Wandering Who by Gilad Atzmon. Dershowitz is attempting to silence and intimidate the academic community into not commenting on this brilliant book.

    Are you for or against this tactic or other academic censorship?