Eleanor Rigby

[beans328]

wth is it like a requirement at this hs to be a musical beast to attend?

[julianmandrino]

Cantas malll !

[rjmprod]

Not bad but gotta comment on the girl sitting in the middle, she has some serious pitch and phrasing issues. The other 2 were quite good.

[kinversoni]

Song should start like the original, the beatles got the intro right.

[bobfenster]

@kinversoni How boring it would be if every cover was a carbon copy of the original.

[kinversoni]

@bobfenster

In no way did I imply that covers should be carbon copies of originals. However, I think The Beatles knew what they were doing with the form and structure of this song; starting the song with that descending phrase is just not as strong as the way the beatles did it.

[bobfenster]

@kinversoni Fair enough. I appreciated the inventiveness of it. We can agree to disagree.  (Refreshing for a YouTube conversation!)

[khubers]

ohhh keep time pleeeeaase girl playing the guitar with your vocals!

[bubblebrainz7l7]

they should have just used the piano

[RockYouVideos]

the one with guitar has a fantastic voice. . .very serene

[akitolover]

very cool!

[rosedale34211]

Well done. Especially enjoyed Janelle's rendition.

[AvenueQdude]

this is great

its great because you guys strayed away from the string violin version, like most people do it

it sounds great

:-)

[cdheal]

great version

[opeth84]

I like it! The girl with the guitar has a fantastic voice!!

[bobfenster]

Search for Janelle Gendrano for another dozen or so clips.

[writerisland]

this is very good. Girl with the guitar is amazing, the three together sound amazing!

[glowstix813]

Wow, I love this!