Mariah Carey H.A.T.E. U LIVE on david letterman show!!

[SuperAnorexiaNervosa]

how she do that whispery voice ? start from 1.09 :o !

[1995trg]

I live her voice she's amazing and this song is just perfect

[Y49life]

Love this so much...the best , love mariah

[Slipknotfanatic89]

HOLY SHIT, what a voice! Even better live, amazing!

[Giakso1]

i don't understand what are you guys talking about. This is an AMAZING performance, it's all live and very well delivered.Of course not every note is perfect, this song is incredibly hard to sing.Give her a break, she sounded amazing.

[lobregatsean24]

 its oki mimi!

[juliusnina]

if you guys call this as a FLAW then i love her FLAWS!!! i love you mariah <3

[jameld55]

She sounds beautiful

[obinocle]

THAT WHISTLE NOTE AT THE END KILLED IT!!!!!!

[jnsash003]

Warts and all she brought it live. I respect that fully.

[CariocaGaroto]

really "hate you" missed out. but nothing in less than one second she would not recover. this is a nice live show. congratulations!

[myaatilicious]

She's wonderful though she's not in condition. She cant reach the low notes but she can reach the high notes!

[AsherEffendi]

What I like about this performance is that it's ALL live. I prefer a crappy live performance than a good lipped performance, honestly. So good on you, MC.

[TheXwatts]

she's shit in this....., poor mariah

[AdeyOficial]

Mimi is a living legend and not one artist in this world can touch her ! This song is so hard to sing you can't even imagine. Just try to sing along and you will know what I mean. And her voice is so shaky because she probably ( as always ) didn't get enough sleep . She can still blow ur mind at any hour if she want's 2. I am damn proud of this woman that after so many years she is so current and present and her voice is still in such a good shape.

[benny3677]

tag that mouth with a big@#@$



[theslabbxxx]

Finally a Live version. Luv this song. Other so called live versions were obviously vocal over track. Still a big fan Mimi. Since Arsenio 1990.

[FAILriahOBESEarey]

OH MY GOD, she sounds awful

[kissmiss629]

@FAILriahOBESEarey

hater,lol. You will never be her, so deal,lol. MCC forever~

[GarrettMBand]

It seems like to me over the years Mariah has gotten more stage fright. Which is SUPER cute. love her. She is so real.

[luisboricua9]

Damn shes so gorgeous!!! I luv when she whisper..always the best!!!!

[mariahpowerful]

If you don't like her "Why Are You On A You-Tube Video Of Her!" People wonder why she say's "This Is For My Real Fans!" or when she's asked about her fans she say's the "Real Fans," it's because Fans don't turn on you because others have or because you change your Hair or wear more Make-Up than when you were young or because you Change your music style, or because you gain Weight!

[mariahpowerful]

As a Mariah fan i always keep in mind that Mariah doesn't have to sing she's Filthy-Rich! Mariah sings becuase it's what she loves to do! & Whenever i see her Live or listen to her i can tell she cares about her fans & their Opinions, but it's her life & Career! Mariah has alot more to her than just a voice until you find out your not a "REAL-FAN!"

[TheOfficialKJOnDeck]

MC Is Going Old Im Going Miss Her When Shee Stop Singing

[BabiiRii1]

At 2:26 her voice broke & did a great come back..... SHE IS THE BEST

[justinjeydon]

all u people aree haters.

i bet half of u couldnt even sing like tht so stfu.

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

@lc0309 she sounded awful and omg at 2:09, her breath support in her lower register is just, awful, lmfao at her lipsynching the high notes at the end, WHAT A SUPRISE !

[aquamarine11500]

@XTINASDISCIPLE Stop trolling bitch,Mariah has nodules an she sounds better than your screaming ass idol.

Get off her video you bitch ass stan.Also this song i s hard to sing,requires great vocal control,breath support and vocal stamina. Xtina couldn't pull this off,all her bionic era Performances were awful so STFU

BTW the whistle isn't lipped.

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

@aquamarine11500 Mariah couldnt even pull off her own song LMAOOOOOOO @lc0309

[aquamarine11500]

@XTINASDISCIPLE She can and she did pull though.The tight corset was too much,but she pulled through.By the way,every "You lost me" performance by Xtina was wretched,her voice kept breaking and cracking.She could hardly belt without straining.

and stop it with the lc0309,you guys are same person as far as im concerned

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

@aquamarine11500 excuses, excuses #goodbye #dismissed

[aquamarine11500]

@XTINASDISCIPLE #Bye Bitch

[SpearsProductions]

It was clearly that tight corset she had on that affected her voice! She sang this on GMA that same day and her breathing was better, voice was stronger, and her whistle register was used slightly, not her super head voice.

[sixfeetcrew]

pagu bona

[Squizree]

Her breathing sounds irregular

[296218047]

She cant even breathe. The reason why she struggled is she had a tight korsett on.

[whitegirlashley1]

@296218047 actually ur right!!

[sevensilver1]

At 2:26 it seems like Mariah forgot that there would be no backing track to help her out on that day.

I am in the same boat as everyone else who liked Mariah singing live consistently from 1990-1997.

[animalscrossing]

its like i love this song for my bieber fever .....

[WalkFaithSight]

I am not sure what was going on with her, but she was a mess. She strained so much and looked kind of scary at some parts. (so unusual for her)

[DaryllJade]

it's definitely live...the part where she nearly mess up was the time she took her microphone while whistling :) aaah,,ah ah aha ahh,,,

[breebreelala]

It doesn't matter if she's live, her live voice used to be incredible being "lve" isn't an excuse., I'm a Mariah Carey fan and this isn't her best.

[iamtanhoneyb]

that's real "live" love u mariah



so much love your whistle

[iamtanhoneyb]

that's real "live" love u mariah so much love your whistle

[whitireia]

Good on Mariah for attempting this song live.

It's definately a hard song to sing. Her voice probably wasn't up to it on the day either.

[eikekusch2001]

Actually those aren't whistle notes, she starts using her head voice then crosses to her superhead register. It's nice to hear superhead notes from her every once in a while instead of singing all the high notes in whistle register.

[rekupp]

@eikekusch2001 superhead is the same thing as whistle register; whistle register is an extension of head voice.

[nometratesk]

mc is fading away but i still love her

[partyitupyo]

the reason why this sounds so different and peeps think its bad is cuz the version on the CD is auto-tuned. and this is completely LIVE. this song is hard to sing.....low notes with the whisle notes and all in-between. This is still a good performance and proves that she is human. She was prob exhausted and didnt have time to give her voice a rest. Still wonderful tho.

[R0ntay3]

this is def. live lol

[matrixklo]

EVERYONE TYPE IN THE NAME Kathlean Lobban TO HEAR MY REMIX OF THIS SONG. HOPE YOU ALL ENJOY IT. :)

[felipeedoardo]

2:27 is hard to watch... it's a shame her voice waned so quickly, she would have sung circles around that song back around the MTV Unplugged time.

[darrin1701]

Djee compare to even 4 years ago.....her voice is so damaged..

[JDhappy81]

I really do like Mariah but she fucking struggled with that. What is it thats caused it? Is she just singing songs that are not the ideal key for her or has her voice just lost power with age??

[cassiehassan]

@JDhappy81 well the poor thing did suffer from a miscarriage, did go thru stress etc she is humannn

[Soulsurvivor4165]

@JDhappy81: There could be various reasons. She could have been hoarse or she could have been performing somewhere else and hadn't had time to rest her voice.

[xoxLeaLea345]

FTR, this is my favourite performance of this song that she's done..

[xoxLeaLea345]

sounds like she's gonna cry :( I love the fact that she nearly fucked up, makes the song more emotional

[miragebutterfly]

Love it, Mariah completely LIVE OMG! :-)

[asekun022]

amazing :]

[lalettre79]

Not very good !!!!she 's a lot out off key by singing high Chest notes on this song........She just wanted to keep her Whistle register by not removing her nodes but she's mistaken...Chest voice is most important for singing!!! I like this song though.

[lalettre79]

not very at all though i like this song....

[nottheone1978]

I LOVE THIS SONG AND YOU MARIAH.....IT IS A HARD SONG TO SING, SO WHAT U STUBBLED OVER NOTES....LEAST IT WAS LIVE AND DAVID LIKED IT....SCREW THE HATERS !!!

[MusicallyUbiquitous]

Mariah is entitled to have an "off" day. Quit bad mouthing her!

[MirageMC]

Some parts like high notes were lip synched. She always used these pre-registrated parts since 2003. Still the best MIMI.

[pmfa91]

@MirageMC Mariah's high notes are completly live here =D i can tell by the way they sound and the effort and honesty she does them =D

[vvo889092]

i dont give a fuck how bad/good she sounds when singing live. AT LEAST SHE SINGS LIVE, singing live is like a bridge connecting the audience and the artist

<3 MC

[soniakiwi]

She still has it no matter what others say. Her vocals were not perfect in some areas, but that happens in singing. You have your good days and you got your bad days. I tell you something, she's still miles better than other so-called singers out there.

[oOItalianBellaOo]

@Irvinismusic you can trust me im a hardcore beyonce fan and i know every single performance from her. she never did lipsynch or something like that NEVER. you cant watch videos where she sings "Halo" acapella. she killed it without even a mic:D:D just type " Halo NUH Hospital" in youtube

[Irvinismusic]

@oOItalianBellaOo That's fine, but everyone in the bizz does it now. Only old school really take it upon themselves to sing live rain or shine. Those are facts.

[1dreamlover1]

@oOItalianBellaOo hahahahhah thats funny....beyonce does lip sync, wen she sings live especially slow songs like Halo she always has the echo effect turned on soooo high so that people cant tell how flat she sings, and most of her concerts the back up singers and backing track sings for her so she can do wat she calls dancing...she is a fake copycat performer who is an attention whore

[oOItalianBellaOo]

@1dreamlover1 watch the performance of the Iam.Yours DVD when she sings halo, there is a special edition to buy including a CD with her microfon sound, where u can only hear her voice without background, so u can clearly hear her real voice during the concert, its amazing, so get your facts right, also she sang halo in the NUH hospital, ACAPELLA !! without MIC, how can she put any effects to her singing with such an minimal sound equipment ? :D:D LMFAO

[1dreamlover1]

@oOItalianBellaOo ive seen many many performances of hers and i know what im talking about...not to mention the years of singing lessons ive taken and all the professional singers i know...beyonce does have talent but its not as great as people make it sound...im not a fan of hers at all (her personality especially) but i do like some of her songs...but live she either doesnt sing so she can "dance" or she sings with a backing track, echo effect, or with her back up singers

[oOItalianBellaOo]

@1dreamlover1 as i said, she doesnt need to put any effects to her singing because she got it, even if many people dont believe it, she has the voice and the talent, her voice grew so much the last years. and as i said go and buy the iam yours dvd with the cd, then lets talk again, and also watch the acapella halo performance, you can hear voice clearly and its 100 % NATURAL! and i dont understand u, she has one of the most down to earth personas in the whole business, she so nice and humble

[1dreamlover1]

@oOItalianBellaOo i have met her a few times on a personal level and i know how she is...every celebrity acts nice and humble at events....

[oOItalianBellaOo]

@1dreamlover1 yes of course :D:D:D:D:D

[oOItalianBellaOo]

@putada1 thats NOT true, beyonce never lipsynchs, not even ONE time. she always sings 100% live and sounds amazinh

[Irvinismusic]

@oOItalianBellaOo Actually beyonce is known for some of her pre recorded performances. Perez Hilton, Kathy Griffin, and other comedians make fun of her for it cuz she tries and play it off like its 100% live..

[1dreamlover1]

@oOItalianBellaOo lmfao

[SamiFonrouge]

2:27 - 2:42 why doesnt she let go of the mic? its likes shes afraid to let go.

[DanielAvilaAGT]

This is live. and I like this song

[Apolux112]

i think that she should do a litle more easy songs to sing. since she has aged a bit  ithink that her voice isnt as good as before.... its still great but i think that she should sing more easier songs :P ofc thats just my opinion

[MichaelMonroe16]

Mariah Carey doesn't lib sync n The high notes aren't lib sync either this isent the best performence but I thought she did a really great job n I cant sing this for shit LOL n I find it really interesting how she can sing so Amazing she truely has an Angels Voice 

[crystalrowlandb]

DAMN she can still hit that high high note though! I love mariah carey fuck you haters!

[greekactionman]

i love mariah,but why,all these years,records songs that are very difficult to sing live????i mean, i like very much this song,the music and the lyrics,but why she recorded it in the studio the way she did,if she cant sing it well live??it is a pity because she has songs that are so beautiful in her albums but are difficult to sing live,and she doesnt sing them live,because-i think-they are very difficult....and she has the most beautiful voice-for me at least-in the world.......

[putada1]

high notes and end part after 306 is lipped, exactly the same as on the today show

rest is live and terrible

[caszidy215]

@putada1 oh so only the parts that were ruff were live and anything that sounded good to you was lipped.

[putada1]

@caszidy215 well its just fact, its so obvious that she lips the part that sound good, theres such a difference between the quality of those parts and the bits she actually sings. at least she sang some of this, some shows (eg canadion idol of we belong together) she lips along to two pre recorded parts lumped together! I like mariahs music but shes a studio performer now, peace

[caszidy215]

@putada1 I love when someone says something is "fact" but the fact is they don't know if its true or not. If you do know, show the proof where are the receipts? She has sung live plenty of times and done good so to say because she has bad nights she no longer can sing live is a blatant lie.

[putada1]

@caszidy215 look its completely obvious the parts that shes lipping because she uses the same prerecorded track from show to show, They are note for note similar. I would say that 75% of mariahs live performances are lip synched, she is incapable of singing a song from beginning to end without studio pre recorded help, even the hardcore fans know and have accepted this.

[caszidy215]

@putada1 Is that 75% fact?

[putada1]

@caszidy215 100 percent fact, its a known fact that the only artist these days who sings fully live on stage is whitney, all the rest have tricks, pre recorded parts.

[1dreamlover1]

@putada1 actually the first 3 uptempo songs during her come back tour were lipped...theres videos out on youtube u can see

[1dreamlover1]

@putada1 yes but i wouldnt say 75%

[asecute]

for me this performance is really good .. :]

[AtomicFall]

WORLD WIDE LEADER IN PANTS

[fuchsiaheart]

this is an embarrassment, she should have said "no" to doing this performance

[asecute]

@fuchsiaheart its her own song so she can do whatever she wants !!

[anitamariah2008]

don't forget this is a really hard song to sing just like DFAU @ AMA's but she did it anyway and she ROCKS!!!

[XforeverlongingX]

this is a horrible horrible performance

[asecute]

@XforeverlongingX  if this is horrible then try singing it ! then were gonna judge you like you did !

[rubietheone3]

not her best live of this song.obviously she had a problem with her voice this day, which made her look kind of uneasy. she could only hit the high notes.

if you want to see her best live of hate you, copy and past this in the youtube search bar:

Mariah Carey - H.A.T.E U (live Stripped)

here, it's such a good live it almost sounds exactly like the recorded version of the song.

[porcelaincougar]

@rubietheone3 That's because it IS the recorded version!

[butterfly1ob]

@solarlight123 heh well im talking about the way things are :P

[cutejing06]

may part pa nauuna pa xa sa beat...

tsk tsk tsk

[cutejing06]

kasura talaga si mariah pag live..

ang malinis lang na part lagi yung pag tumitili xa..

pero nasa player ko tong kantang to..

[Mannequin2009]

lol a mess

[aldoaldo5]

This is a great! She focused and was steady,... sounded like the album. Remember R&B...soft and slow. It's so easy for her to bust it out. But to soothe us is hardER but she still sounds like an Angel. The low hi low hi notes are !!! 2:20-2:30 are fumazing....!!!!!!!!!!! I love this song. I wuz there Jan 2010 @ Hardrock!!! Amazing. Give the album a chance, and you will quickly love a lot of the songs..it is a great R&B album.

[XforeverlongingX]

@aldoaldo5 2:20-2:30 is fumazing? are u kidding? they sound terrible

[mariahpowerful]

you people watch her for the wrongs reasons.. to judge her wtf.. half the people judgeing cant sing at all!

[IvoryIL]

its live dont hatew at least she attempts to sing live sumtimes some artist makes a carrer out of lip syncing

[tian2009]

she should rest her voice for a couple of years, and then try it again maybe, or she won't be able to speak, all she can do no is just whistle

[kimmy49605]

her microphone wasnt loud enouqqh & she was kinda siCCKK she was lossinq er voice

[jarja1]

god...look like she sick...

the voice didn't came...

still love her antway...

[littlemissinnocen100]

this wasnt that bad i heard worse from her the whistle is live..i can tell from the sound its not play back...and its a tough song to song cuz alot of the song is in head voice..im a r n b singer and i wouldnt even attempt to sing this song to myself let alone live lol...

[jeweldasinger]

ima singer 2 i agree its a hard song to sing...

[prozerfina]

what happen to her 2:26 ?

[mariahpowerful]

this was good i really enjoyed it.. she's so good live on tour cause she's not.. afraid in front of her fans<3 i love you mimi

[UntrainedSizzle]

oh ouch this is painful to listen to, but i still love MC and think she's a great person. but i wouldn't pay to go see her

[jeweldasinger]

you dont have to alotta ppl did...even me... and trust me her on tour is alsome trust me shes a funny good person and her voice is toatlly differnt on tour..... trust me she still has it sumdays she jus have bad days...

[xenman101]

02:26 the whistle isn't even hers and the rest of the performance is terrible

[jeweldasinger]

how do u sound dummie dam ppl are so dumb... how can u say her whistle is not even hers???? are u serious....

[IvoryIL]

agree

[irvinmaraj]

lord.. hot mess.

[IvoryIL]

she's singing live get off her back u can tell cuz she nearly fucked up one part of the song but its good performance.

[butterfly1ob]

like i said this thing that happend at 2:27 shows she lipped the high notes... what the hell happened there? love her but would be better if she lipped it all..

[aryacarey]

She didn't lipped thhat note, she missed the note, so she catched up later.

[butterfly1ob]

you can see that she's still singing "hate u" when the high note comes, come on.

[butterfly1ob]

she didnt even managed to take a breath

[aquamarine11500]

As for the lipsynch it's really hard to tell if she caught up to the whistle part,or if her pre-recorded track started early i should watch it a couple of timez over..hold on.

[TheWowwa]

i just love this song.. fell in love at first time listening to it.

[ThePharaoho]

She's clearly overworked her voice. But I don't know how though. She does'nt really tour often. Her first 2 albums she did'nt tour at all. Her voice seems to be deteriorating. She still has an awesome voice though. One of the most talented women of all times, but she really needs to work on that stage presence. She also looks uncomfortable or unconfident on stage. She needs to rest her vocals muscles and body.

[aquamarine11500]

@ThePharaoho Well it may be over worked but hopefully it doesn't deterioate away.Also to answer your question as to why it seems like a stuggle sometimes to sing,well we all know Mariah has vocals nods and sometimes that can put strain,make the vocals hoarse and dry.If she would rest then she can give spectacular performances just like 2006 grammys.

[hotkian21]

and she is doing great now.. @thepharao cant really decide if he'l come back in being MC fan or hater.. he has to realized that singers get tired too,.. but MC at least very rare to be like this.. not shameful like whitney now.. peace

[stylestar07]

it is amazing even her worst live performances sound better then most of the artist who so called "perform" today.. love this song

[vi94]

I can't stop listening to this song!!...1:51 LOVE THAT PART!! From 2:08-2:21 sounds like she did that part in one breath, that's why she sounds like she skipped some of the vocals, or "cracked". STILL AWESOME...From 3:09-3:24 the voices are just heavenly...I LOVE THIS SONG!!!!!

[kamasutrasun]

It seems like all she can do now is whistle. Her belting, and everything else in between sounds shakey and out of breath. I love her, but she needs to rest her voice. ASAP. Enough albums for now MC.

[elarinque]

great performance. Restored my fandom in Mariah. Her whistle is still beautiful and she can still sing live, phew was worried.

[nichya11]

its fathom not fandom

[DropsOnEye]

Fandom he was coining a word from the root word FAN...not fathom as in fathoms of the ocean.

[Whistleregister99]

did you hear that high note at the middle of the song.... that was completely live unlike the other performances of HATE U