Wing Chun - Dealing With A Top Bong - w Sifu Tom Chi

[wingchun2k10]

More great teaching of Wing Chun science. The more I watch your vids the more challenging Wing Chun becomes, and the more I love the art for it. Strange. Lol!

[giuliocc]

Fundamental flaw at 4:25. Tom has collapsed onto assailant but has assumed the assailant's tan is stationary. If we're talking wing chun, his tan sao would attack as tom collapses.. Tom has overlooked the possibility that assailant will attack from Tan Sao....

[heartslord]

@giuliocc

Excellent comment. However. Having been forced to look at my own video, gasp! I have complete control of the tan due to my wrist-to-wrist contact and holding it slightly to the center. That tan aint going anywhere. Supposedly.

[fanofkimboslice]

So you would never use a bong in actual combat ? But instead a biu-sau or another tool as opposed to the bong unless in chi-sau ?

[heartslord]

@fanofkimboslice

Good question. I would absolutely use a bong. It's a great tool and essential too. What I hopefully would not do is to allow an opponent to close the distance to enter the striking range and overcome my bong due to my ignorance. I also would not go from tan to bong to drive a punch up into my face. Did I make a third point? I don't recall but if I did it was not... to never use a bong in combat. By the way, I too, am a fanofkimboslice.

[LeiTai27]

if the bong has proper forward intent, it will just turn into an attack when your opponent lifts the elbow like that, it will render that hand coming over the bong useless even if it connects (touches) as there's no power/structure behind it. why chase the hand when the way is open to come forward?

[heartslord]

It's not about chasing the hand but instead not mistaking what is really a huen over the bong to be powerless. It takes the bong to the outside & now enters the center from the top. It takes no power to strike the throat and terminate the engagement. None of these circumstances would be a consideration if the opponent was not collapsing and overcoming. With proper distancing and understanding this will never happen. So good kung fu, no problems!