Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (135)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • R.I.P. genius!!!!

  • @TonesOfYou ... I hope this helps you. Heres you a few chords of the song to at least get you started.....

  • @TonesOfYou.. If your tuned to standard its capoed on the 3 fret. (Aside from the little slides, hammer ons and pull offs, which you will figure out as you know what key to be in. ) Pretend your playing a C diminished …then to a G back to C dim then to A minor then to B slide the C dim and then back to original Cdim.

  • @TonesOfYou ..As long as you do those chords, you will find your way with the technical stuff. I hope I explained this right because I don’t really know my chords by name..I just know how to play guitar L

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • me and my girlfriend broke up yesturday....this is the first song i listened to.... cried the whole night.....

  • @antifawins19 Sorry to read this my friend, My fiance ran out on me right after I got the house she wanted. Talk about a kick in the fucking teeth. Absent memories and alcohol are not a good thing. Thank God everything reminds me of her. Ha

  • @Meridianlost she was my fiance and the next day she was out holding hands with one of my friends -_- after i bought her a 1000 dollar ring... Im 18 that shit dont come easy... I told her how much i love her and all she said was "too bad" :( i dont get women they say they want a good man to love them but in truth they lie :/ stories like ours should be told to make women notice how they hurt guys too :/

  • That fucking chord progression fucks with me! And it doesn't have just straight patterns either! Just jumps around all the time, it's ridiculous! (Not being a troll)

  • Elliott Smith makes good music. People on the internet are assholes. Assholes tend to make assholes out of themselves wherever people might be enjoying themselves. People enjoy good music. Assholes flock to Elliott Smith videos to prove that they don't really get the message behind Elliott's music.

    It's about the darker side of life people. It's the sad parts. If anything he sings about has happened to you, you WILL cry over it at least once.

  • this is gorgeousness and gorgeousity made flesh!!! :D

  • i cried the first time i heard this its soo beautiful :')

  • i dont understand what is subtle about this song lol.but i love playing this on guitar.

  • Comment removed

  • 4 people have no heart

  • i remember when i first heard...i didnt talk for two weeks.

  • good guitar work

  • What a fucking artist this guy was he is and always will be soley missed!

  • emo, eh? wrong time frame for one, and most importantly, since when has it become beguiling to divulge one's heart and soul into the medium of music. i'm a pretty emotive dude, but chances are i could make you remind me of a her. and then, who would be overly emotive? don't be afraid of emotion. it's only natural, though there is always a time and place.

  • GREAT AMAZING AND AWESOME FOREVER!!!

  • I wish he would listen to this song and think of me, is that selfish, i listen to this song and think of him.

  • @zombiekillsall23 He probably does.

  • @INERTIAAA Thank you, that means alot. Truly.

  • this song is what noel fielding cries himself to sleep with.

  • timeless song, outstanding lyrics. Pure beauty.

  • @dirksilver

    sure they do

    Everybody cares, Everybody understands

  • @KJ4VGA no they don't if everyone did all we'd be doing is listening to people complain all day...if this song gets to you good i'm happy for you...but keep it to yourself

  • @dirksilver yeah that was kind of a joke

    "everybody cares everybody understands" is another elliott smith song

    i dont honestly care either, but hey thats what the comments section is for

    to leave comments wether you like them or not

  • @KJ4VGA still keep it to yourself

  • I feel really bad for people who can't get the feeling I get when I listen to Elliott Smith, they are really missing out.

  • JDuncanM1369, you sir give Elliott smith listeners a bad name. You make us sound like emo assholes. Although I agree with the latter part of your statement.

  • Comment removed

  • @CarmenitaHOLLA

    you souldn't care about what other peoples say about elliot smith listeners

  • @CarmenitaHOLLA

    Yeah, because only emos cry. -____-

  • @colourfulwithaU i cry

  • I think some might agree that we listen to music for it's cathartic effect on our own personal problems. Catharsis is way to heal and move on in a positive light. His obsession consumed him and eventually brought his own downfall.

    If you listen to "High Times" on New Moon, he sings, "Don't pick me up, I'm fine right where I am". That made people pay attention into his craft. He just sang and wrote in such a graceful fashion that gives us a reason to "not move on", so to speak.

  • Beutiful song...

  • Oh dear....Caroline B ♡

  • this song is soo sad, and i can relate to it entirely too much

  • Beautiful song....

  • Beautiful.

  • Thank God someone introduced to a guitar when he was young!! U the man Elliott!!!!!!

  • we misss you elliot i REALLY NEED TO GO TO VISIT YOUR WALL....AND EVRYONE THAT SAYS THAT YOU SUCK............WHEL .l.

  • Makes me cry that he's not with us anymore:( Talent like this doesn't happen very often.

  • elliot smith 4 the win

  • This song is about you Caroline..Shame you don't know...

  • @okrum This song is for my "caroline" as well, such a shame mate, such a shame...

  • @poguish Yep... Everybody's got a Caroline somehow ;-)

  • Broke up with girl few days ago, EVERYTHING reminds me of her, this song is healing

  • <3

    why is this man not fucking LEGENDARY!?!?!?!

  • @BrittanyRoseWay .. he is

  • @BrittanyRoseWay Because then he wouldn't be :). RIP ES

  • Who said he isn't legendary? His music is loved by people all over the world. For proof, just look at all the comments on the videos of his music, or better yet, the memorial wall in Los Angeles, which has been visited by so many people that there is hardly enough space to write on it anymore (and I'm speaking from experience). You don't need to have ten realities shows on MTV and a teen choice award or whatever they're handing out to be a true hero

  • only the truth release! Elliott Smith should be cannonized

  • ive been listening to this all day

  • wish i could be as indepth and talented writer as elliott was

  • this is such an amazing song. what a gifted guy. to be able to translate true emotion into beautiful music. gotta love it.

  • My heart breaks.

  • he is the best musician ever

  • the beginning is tooo epic

  • This song kills me everytime I hear it. So much true emotion completely realized in one song, it hurts.

  • never heard of this before. i love it.

  • Does anyone know what the lines "The spin of the earth impaled a silhouette of the sun on the steeple" mean or are in reference to? 'cause every time I listen to this song these lyrics stand out to me for some reason.

  • @mkellers

    Spin of the earth line - time passage, shadow's cast, church & steeple play into the preaching line that follows

    Same Sermon.. all you people line - People are always telling him to 'Cheer Up' or asking, 'What's Wrong?'

    It is strong symbolism with few words.

    Maybe someone will see it completely differently-gotta love art.

  • @twistyrodriguez

    thanks man that really helped :)

  • everything, and I mean everythiiiing.......

  • i can't tell if i'm crying because of the song, or because of these annoying things in my eyes.

    oh wait, those annoying things are tears from the song.

  • awesome dude! :D thats a true believer right here!!!

  • @ilovemutemath it's an amazing song... it makes me feel like im floating, i transcend..

  • hell yeah.gorgeous song.repeat is the only answer to this song.

  • Geez, way to be an ego-maniac in your description.

  • A genius that went too early. Sorely missed but still loved

  • i have been listening to this song on repeat and crying for the past hour.

    elliott smith, you were a fucking prophet of truth.

  • I know how you feel.

  • cheer up bud, the play button will always be there

  • This song is so beautiful, simply because it is true...

  • I went on a coffee date with a guy I'd met a few nights earlier, and he let me listen to this while he went for a refill.

    I s'pose he tried to tell me something. It's ironic, every Elliot Smith song now reminds me of him.

  • pacrock i think you right,i think the samme thing.

  • (L)

  • but it is an amazing song, just dont listen to it after a crucial break up

  • this song sucks because i know what its like to feel exactly like this, hopeless

  • Indeed...but it's still a very nice song.

  • This songs incredible because I know what its like to feel exactly like this.

  • Ah, this song is So beautiful.

  • oh my word. why have i never heard this song before? it is bone achingly beautiful.

  • it really is. Elliott Smith can find emotions that I never knew I had.

  • just because some people become numb and lose all emotion after leaving their teen years doesn't mean all do

  • @AlternativeUses

    Hear hear.

    Roger Waters from pink floyd paid some guy to partially deface his monument in LA for some anti-war slogan i think.

    Really sad stuff. He was one hell of an artist for sure.

    R.I.P. Elliott. People still want to fall in love with your ideas man, you are an artist forever. <3

  • or sounds like a genius musician who recently got sober and everything reminds him of her ( the white lady)

  • songs genius

  • i have not loved you for at least two years now Jen. I hope your are enjoying SF. It wasn't too kin dto me but you always had better luck than I did. Tell Canola his facial hair is scary, ugly and just plain wrong. i'm out east now, finally forgetting you and everything you ever stood for. this is the last thing i will ever write about you. I fucked up, but you sucked too. I hope I never see you again until the afterlife.

  • who isn't "chronically depressed" nowadays?

  • is it me or elliot seemed like a guy who was struggling depression all the time?

  • He was chronically depressed

  • i totally know what you mean but know that i read that he was chronically depressed it all makes sense

  • you think that is actually a disease?

    why do people don't take depression as serious as any other disease?

  • because its hard to regard peoples feelings as serious, without being able to explain exactly how you feel and what causes it, no one can ever really believe you... at least thats how it seems to me

  • I actually got to meet Elliot months b4 he died. It was backstage at The French Kicks show in L.A. He was so shy, my friend was talking to him. I was way too shy to talk to him other than hi. He was really interested in starting a foundation for abused children, he gave my friend all the info on a napkin (her husband works in the industry). It was so touching that it meant so much to him and he wasn't interested in talking about anything else.

  • RIP

    i flee to this song and 'somebody i use to know' when she comes to mind.

    its a shame :(

  • a great song, your info/summary was a bit dramatic though.

  • I wish i couldnt relate to this song,but unfortunately ,now i can.

  • Check out my cover of this song: watch?v=Fl0gyYWA1Bk , opinions most appreciated

  • I love this song. It is so beautifully sad, yet very simple.

  • green giant

  • RIP Elliott Smith- you are missed

  • Wherever he is??? Elliot Smith died 5 years ago this upcoming Tuesday, October 21st...

  • No shit, he died. What im pretty sure fernandoruirodrigues was refering to was "Where the fuck do people go when they die?"

  • best musician out there, wherever he is!

    figure 8 is my fav album

  • Ik woon niet in Friesland.

  • great,very sad....

  • Elliott is efkes nar den C1000 om wa erpel te hale.

  • you mean efkes nei de c1000 om wat ierappels te helje?

  • dialect wars

  • Where are you elliott? :'(

  • In ieder geval niet thuis

  • I <3 Elliott Smith, though I love the song Baby Britain more.

  • Favorite

  • i love this song!

  • Beautiful.

  • Sheer brilliance thanks for uploading

  • Genius!

  • One of the Greatest songs ever!!!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more