I get so sad when I see that clip of Fred and George flash by when they're standing together before the castle is invaded. *tear* I wish Fred hadn't died!
I grew up watching all of the Harry Potter movies. And when I whent to watch the last Part of the Series I couldn't help but cry...Just felt part of my childhood being taken away.
You got it reversed; Dumbledore is the honest while Snape is the liar.
Snape lied in order to protect. Dumbledore is honest because he never lies. He simply doesn't tell more than he needs to. Either way, this is AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!
@ladyiris12 He put it that way because dumbledore never told Harry the truth about him having to die and never told harry harry about the story behind Snape, while in fact Snape was the one to reveal everything in his memory thus technically telling Harry the truth.
@harty7able Now that you mention it, that's one way to put it. Well I love Snape anyways so I was quite upset when Mrs Rowling killed him off. =( I thank you for correcting me by the way. =)
@Rosskiposski He's lied many times. From little things like when in SS/PS Harry asked what he sees in the Mirror of Erised and he answers a pair of socks - he really saw his family.
To big things like not telling Harry the prophecy when he knew that it revolved around Harry and Voldemort. Dumbledore manipulated Harry's whole life, and I honestly don't like him.
And I'm about to get a bunch of hateful replies...
@11starmoon I can see what you mean but I think he thought he was protecting Harry even though as you pointed out it would have been a lot easier if he had told the truth
@dixonhpboosh Yes, I don't think that Dumbledore was necessarily aiming to make Harry's life harder, but he certainly could've done things to make Harry's life easier, too.
I'm not saying Dumbledore is a terrible character, because no doubt he did good things, but I think he's not as high-and-dandy as many people think he is.
Perhaps he just got too caught up in "the greater good".
@VeilBloodClaws There is no line that says 'to the victor.' The lines are: to the people, the good and the evil, the soldier, the civilian, the martyr, the victim, the prophet, the liar, the honest, the leader, the pariah, the victim, the messiah. The victim is the closest you can get to 'the victor.'
It's like this ding was written for Harry Potter... THIS WAS SO GOOD. I LOVED it. It was touching, and sad it made me want to go and fight with them... At hogwarys... Sadly that's impossible :( GREAT VIDEO, the beginning was so cool
Snap, Dumbledore as the liar? That took me by suprise and actually totally fits given all the revelations toward the end of the series. xD Nice one. Good video too.
This absolutely amazing, who agrees with me when I say they should create a whole album with different songs that represent the Harry Potter storyline?
Anybody know if there are any "Artilery" or "Mass attack" spells in JK Rowlings world that maybe wasn't shown on Screen?
I mean Nevel? blowing up the bridge was cool and all but causing hundeds of arrroows to materialize and fly, cracking open the ground and having the horde fall in, or a few well placed explosive fireballs (or even those "fire deamons?) could have taken them out too
SPikes comin out of the grond,fields of spinning blades, lightning balls causing chain lightning through crowd?
"That would be what we call "overkill". If those spells existed the battle would be over in about two pages."
It's why they'd had to kill off Dumbledre...yes?
Couldn't have him wiping out the entire army attacking with 4 or 5 flicks of his "fire whip" standing on top of Hogwarts like he did to those Bodaks (or whaever those things were gaurding the necklace..whole place basically on fire)
@DisneySongsSpain Exactly. This is one of the few... I mean it IS the ONLY one that put Dumbledore as the liar and Snape as the honest. Many of the other Harry Potter songs flip-flop them, but I didn't like that. Putting Dumbledore as the liar and Snape as the honest deserves a HUGE double thumbs up :)
ive see this many times before, and ive cried every time, this is AMAZING i love this video, the song fits the scenes perfect , i sure am gonna miss the trio:')
This feels less... Emotional. The more popular of the HP AMVs for this song strikes a chord... I don't feel that here. It's cool, yes. It may be a better video. but it does not strike that chord.
OH MY GOSH OH MY GOSH. this is AMAZING. like WOAHWOAHWAOWHOA!!!!! I've watched it 6 times and i'm still going strong! spectacular ending and the lyrics went so well with the video! Everything matches! LOVE THIS:)
This has to be the best one of this song used for this saga. I love the video. Even thought Lord Voldemort is my favorite character. How you did Dumbledore as the liar, and Severus as the honest that makes sence.
I kind of like this version better than the one with the most views. At least by the titles. Like the leader Neville, the pariah Barty Crouch Jr. The Liar as Dumbledore and the Honest as Snape are good titles even though their attitudes would say otherwise in the books.
@Tanji099 Which person?? I don't know which video you are referring to because there are several versions of this same song with Harry Potter. But anyways...No, I have not stolen anyone else's "mix" of this song.
@Tanji099 There's a couple of hundred videos with this same song. Just because one is more popular than some of the others doesn't mean everybody else who uses the song stole it. :P
@Hbprincez Really? I don't remember that part.. but whatever you say! I'm probably watching DH Part 1 tonight anyway because I have no better way to spend my Friday night...
@Booksareepic If you notice that little clip lasts less than 3 seconds, I don't remember slowing it down but maybe I zoomed in to emphasize it.. Honestly I don't remember.. It's when Harry and Ron are by the frozen lake and Harry speaks Parseltongue to open it and Ron is ready to stab it.. Goes by fast lol
I'm absolutely addicted to this ;w; I've watched it COUNTLESS times since saturday. I'm not just saying this, I've seriously been putting it on as soon as I get home from school and playing it all day ;w; good job :')
very beautiful compliment *w* is the first time I saw it but I have been very impressed ** from now, with that made by agentofCHAOS13x {?v = DFBzZfxkWUg}, has become my favorite video! I liked Dumbledore and Snape madeas the liar and the honest but reversed that Dumbledore is the liar and Snape is the honest. And then the min. 3:03, when I saw Fred&George, I had the bright eyes since what you put is their last moment together before the fight separated. I have no words really compliments *w*
this is the best fan video i've ever seen. the order of it, it takes more then finding clips to make videos for this, you did the most incredible job, this is something that i would convincingly believe was something that should of been on tv! your time and effort really payed off. its beautiful.
One of the best amvs i have ever seen the song is just a perfect fit what more needs to be said? Oh yeah the lair the honest line very clever! Thumbs up
@ Blondgits I can't like the comment enough to show you took the words out of my mouth and I've been watching it for a week and a half. Well put in the comment, and the video was very well done to put it simply. Amazing.
I don't generally leave comments but I wanted you to know that even though this probably has the fewest views of all the Harry Potter videos set to this song I've found it is easily my favorite. I absolutely love what you did with the opening, it was really genius, and the way you cut and edited the clips from the movies into this song is amazing. I have watched this several times in the past few days and I'm about to watch it again! Great job!
Awesome!!! I loved watching Dumbledore while the song was saying "liar". In my opinion, he is the real villain! The only one of the good ones who wanted Harry's death!!! Voldemort, at least, wanted to kill him without secrets!! And Snapes had good secrets, instad!
wow. mind = blown, idk what to even say :D well this is one of my FAVORITE songs, and making a HP video with it is pure genius... wow, this video was done BRILLIANTLY! absolutely stunning and perfect and totally awesome :D
I love the take on liar/honest. Dumbledore hid a lot from Harry and Snape while they were working toward the same goal. Harry would have been able toi defeat Voldemort more easily with more information. Snape had to hide things for other reasons, yet he never really hid who he was as a person.
@obecrazy from my perspective I think Dumbledore and Snape both were Harry's guardians and they both kept secrets from Harry 'til the end, but since Dumbledore was closest to him I thought it appropriate to "brand" him as the 'liar'... it isn't until they meet at King's Cross that Dumbledore exposes all of his secrets
@Hbprincez I think I'd say Fudge/Scrimgeour was the liar. Dumbledore had many secrets, but I wouldn't say he lied. Same with Snape. Oh, and great video. :)
@silverandcold65 I wasn't thinking outside the box when I made it... I was focused on the trio: Dumbledore, Snape and Harry.. but yeah you are right Fudge/Scrimgeour would have fit that description as well
@obecrazy Well, yesterday I was thinking about this song and I had the same idea as HBprincez. Portraying Dumbeldore as the liar and snape as the honest. In the end Dumbeldore wanted to sacrifice Harry but always acted as if he cared so much about him. I think that makes him a liar. And Snape turned out to be good in the end so...
@obecrazy How do you know? I'm not so sure about that. I still don't get that scene in heaven or where ever it is anyway, so maybe you can explain it...
@dansjuf88 when dumbledore talks to harry about his mother's sacrifice and when voldemort (in the goblet of fire) used harry's blood to "reborn" establishing a further link between them... and harry asks to dumbledore something like: "and you knew for all this time?" dumbledore says: "i supposed it, but usually my assumptions are very good!"... i think that this is the proof that dumbledore knew about everything... all dialogues are of the italian version of the book, so sorry about my english!
cant talk too busy crying
ThisIsHarryPotter 4 days ago
I get so sad when I see that clip of Fred and George flash by when they're standing together before the castle is invaded. *tear* I wish Fred hadn't died!
TroubleTwin2 5 days ago
harry potter IS my childhood. i couldn't ask for anything better than this to represent that. thankyou XD
XIamSHERlockedX 1 week ago
i got chills every 2 seconds...
amazing job :)
ramonaaaaaa93 1 week ago
I like how you put Dumbledore as thel liar and Snape as the honest. It is true, and paradoxical as well. It makes you think. Thanks for this!
wayfarer365 2 weeks ago 2
i didn't grow up with harry potter, i just found it recently, but i wish i did.
altrockloverNo1 2 weeks ago 5
Neville my hero :3
8sanny8seddie8 3 weeks ago
Harry, Ron , Hermione , Neville , Luna , Ginny and other , the bravest hero of a fantastic saga.
Hermieline 3 weeks ago 4
The best movie ever made!!!
OtakuOf89 4 weeks ago 4
I grew up watching all of the Harry Potter movies. And when I whent to watch the last Part of the Series I couldn't help but cry...Just felt part of my childhood being taken away.
OtakuOf89 4 weeks ago 9
I've got chills all over my body
MissDemiFreak 4 weeks ago
I liked it. I just found the other one the other day and I've been addicted to the song. This is a good video. Thank you for it. :D
WizardyWizard93 4 weeks ago
For some reason, this video won't load past the 50 second mark for me. Any idea what's wrong?
seatbelttruck 4 weeks ago
Always.
misscloud96 4 weeks ago
this is war
dkkauwe 1 month ago
is dumbledore a liar ??
mikle391 1 month ago
I love this video :)
TimetoliveFiction 1 month ago
STP IT OMGF I'M GOING TO DROWN IN MY TEARS OK ARE YOU HAPPY NOWW
vrcriss 1 month ago
The song alone makes me cry, why put Potter in? you wanna make me loose all body fluid in tear form?
taliakahlanleto 1 month ago
You got it reversed; Dumbledore is the honest while Snape is the liar.
Snape lied in order to protect. Dumbledore is honest because he never lies. He simply doesn't tell more than he needs to. Either way, this is AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!
ladyiris12 1 month ago
@ladyiris12 He put it that way because dumbledore never told Harry the truth about him having to die and never told harry harry about the story behind Snape, while in fact Snape was the one to reveal everything in his memory thus technically telling Harry the truth.
harty7able 1 month ago
@harty7able Now that you mention it, that's one way to put it. Well I love Snape anyways so I was quite upset when Mrs Rowling killed him off. =( I thank you for correcting me by the way. =)
ladyiris12 1 month ago
This was astounding. Job well done.
Joh7X 1 month ago
Like if you cheered when Neville sliced off Nagini's head.
NevillesGran1 1 month ago 4
So weird... Dumbledore is the liar and Snape is the honest... hmmm, I think we have a really harry potter fan here
well, awesome
claborges 1 month ago
this song (and video!) sums up the whole Harry Potter series-no easy feat!
jnor2096 1 month ago
how come when i watch something that's really good, I always get chills, and am really feeling the characters?
FoxieWox 1 month ago
they got it wrong the iar is Dumblledore ??? He should be the leader, goddamit !!!!!!
melediv 1 month ago
@melediv if you actually read the story, he lied to harry about Voldemort from the very start. Dumbledore's plan was for Harry to die.
FoxieWox 1 month ago 3
really amazing!!!!!!
AntoniaTheGreekGirl 1 month ago
wont pause :L
DuckyDooDoo122 1 month ago
Perfect timing on everything, thank you for this. Literally thank you.
Photura7 1 month ago
OMG THIS IS AMAZING!!! I siriously started crying :') it fits so together, like WHOA! I'm going to go publish links to this thing everywere <33
ViccyPotter6 1 month ago
This is brilliant! Love your song choice, thank you for sharing.
roadtoglory 1 month ago
I dont have words to describe what Im feeling right now o.o
dogasebear 1 month ago in playlist Liked videos
Dumbledore is not a liar. He didn't tell the truth, but he never, ever lied.
Rosskiposski 1 month ago 52
@Rosskiposski
if u r talking about the pic in the vid that is mr lovegood
ThisIsHarryPotter 4 days ago
@ThisIsHarryPotter never mind wrong part.
ThisIsHarryPotter 4 days ago
@Rosskiposski He's lied many times. From little things like when in SS/PS Harry asked what he sees in the Mirror of Erised and he answers a pair of socks - he really saw his family.
To big things like not telling Harry the prophecy when he knew that it revolved around Harry and Voldemort. Dumbledore manipulated Harry's whole life, and I honestly don't like him.
And I'm about to get a bunch of hateful replies...
11starmoon 2 days ago 3
@11starmoon I can see what you mean but I think he thought he was protecting Harry even though as you pointed out it would have been a lot easier if he had told the truth
dixonhpboosh 8 hours ago
@dixonhpboosh Yes, I don't think that Dumbledore was necessarily aiming to make Harry's life harder, but he certainly could've done things to make Harry's life easier, too.
I'm not saying Dumbledore is a terrible character, because no doubt he did good things, but I think he's not as high-and-dandy as many people think he is.
Perhaps he just got too caught up in "the greater good".
11starmoon 7 hours ago
Does anyone know where the video is where when it says to the victor, victor krum shows up?
Thank you, and this is an awesome video!
VeilBloodClaws 2 months ago
@VeilBloodClaws There is no line that says 'to the victor.' The lines are: to the people, the good and the evil, the soldier, the civilian, the martyr, the victim, the prophet, the liar, the honest, the leader, the pariah, the victim, the messiah. The victim is the closest you can get to 'the victor.'
DavidbarZeus1 1 month ago
This song is meant to fit in Harry Potter![sorry for my horible English]
FrossoMas 2 months ago
I've been watching this video for a week straight and it still has the same teary-eyed impact as it did the first time I watched it.
Muzikgurl2 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
It's like this ding was written for Harry Potter... THIS WAS SO GOOD. I LOVED it. It was touching, and sad it made me want to go and fight with them... At hogwarys... Sadly that's impossible :( GREAT VIDEO, the beginning was so cool
Ktkraze 2 months ago
The people that dislike are the ones who didn't want this vid to end
fluffyness24 2 months ago in playlist Liked videos
I'm just shamelessly crying. And years from now, if I see this again, I will still cry.
rehmasayedaftabalam 2 months ago 31
im not gonna lie, i just cried a little
Avenged7FoldfoREVer2 2 months ago
@Avenged7FoldfoREVer2 I did too!!!
Muzikgurl2 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
very well done
Muzikgurl2 2 months ago
i am going to grab my wand, use the killing curse *AVADA KEDAVRA* and deal with the nine people that disliked this video. thumbs up if you agree
seanwray1 2 months ago 4
watch?v=84dshojwFLc another HP video :)
liharrypotter 2 months ago
Snap, Dumbledore as the liar? That took me by suprise and actually totally fits given all the revelations toward the end of the series. xD Nice one. Good video too.
Gorthund 2 months ago
No offense but this video is pure awsome.
lucifuge555 2 months ago
No offense but this is the best thing ever.
lucifuge555 2 months ago
I CRYED AT THE END I HAVE ALL THE MOVIES ON MY COMPUTER AND GREAT JOB WITH THE VIDEO
raping8ITCHS 2 months ago
THIS VIDEO IS ABSOLUTELY A-M-A-Z-I-N-G YOU ARE EXTREMELY CLEVER MAKING THIS, IF THIS WAS A PROJECT I WOULD GIVE U AN A***
EdWaRdEoDB118 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
Why doesnt Voldemort wear shoes? bitches feet must be cold.
chiefgoldenbeak 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos 3
THIS IS THE MOST FUCKING EPIC AWESOME AMV ABOUT HARRY POTTER.
Just love it. Really. Adrenaline. I tink i can do everything now. THANK YOU FOR THI FEELINGS.
HelgaFair 2 months ago
Amazing....
PotterAngel 2 months ago
This absolutely amazing, who agrees with me when I say they should create a whole album with different songs that represent the Harry Potter storyline?
This song definately included XD
MsAbixxx 3 months ago 4
@MsAbixxx There probably is a fanmix of the Harry Potter storyline somewhere on the internet already :)
charlolwut 1 month ago
After the last book,I can't stop cry...
Harry Potter??- What I will do without you???
OfekChenOfficial 3 months ago 3
@OfekChenOfficial start reading the Hunger Games trilogy...it helped me cope with the lack of harry potter in my life :(
CrAzYbEaN777 3 months ago
Epic
Obi1Canobe98 3 months ago
This got me all teary <3. Beautiful, just beautiful!
Sharei32 3 months ago
yes.this is rrl epic!:P
It's awesome,amazing job;D
BillKaulitz4ever100 3 months ago
JUST. EPIC. PERIOD.
Avenged7FoldfoREVer2 3 months ago
This gave me chills <3 awesome!
bandgeekjon 3 months ago
good but maybe say it has spoilers but...
9144386 3 months ago
Comment removed
legoboy555555555 3 months ago
Anybody know if there are any "Artilery" or "Mass attack" spells in JK Rowlings world that maybe wasn't shown on Screen?
I mean Nevel? blowing up the bridge was cool and all but causing hundeds of arrroows to materialize and fly, cracking open the ground and having the horde fall in, or a few well placed explosive fireballs (or even those "fire deamons?) could have taken them out too
SPikes comin out of the grond,fields of spinning blades, lightning balls causing chain lightning through crowd?
TheRealArchAngel 3 months ago
@TheRealArchAngel That would be what we call "overkill". If those spells existed the battle would be over in about two pages.
soulstealer450 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
"That would be what we call "overkill". If those spells existed the battle would be over in about two pages."
It's why they'd had to kill off Dumbledre...yes?
Couldn't have him wiping out the entire army attacking with 4 or 5 flicks of his "fire whip" standing on top of Hogwarts like he did to those Bodaks (or whaever those things were gaurding the necklace..whole place basically on fire)
Did that spell even have a name?
TheRealArchAngel 3 months ago
omg!!! <3 it!!! the best !
simone24810 3 months ago
@DisneySongsSpain Exactly. This is one of the few... I mean it IS the ONLY one that put Dumbledore as the liar and Snape as the honest. Many of the other Harry Potter songs flip-flop them, but I didn't like that. Putting Dumbledore as the liar and Snape as the honest deserves a HUGE double thumbs up :)
Sarcon999 3 months ago 3
it's funny how you made appear Dumbledore when the song says: 'To the liar' and and it says 'to the honest' you showed Snape. <3.
DisneySongsSpain 3 months ago
holy. freakin. crap. That was the best thing i think my eyes have ever seen
ColeFang23x 3 months ago
wonderful!
P3PhoebeandCole 3 months ago
it was a good video but the flashing white light over the whole video was a bit distracting
SnapePaper 3 months ago
a couple things: 1) I've never seen the harry potter movies past the goblet of fire or watever its called, Should i watch them?
2) The four people that disliked this can go die in a hole, this is amazing!
3) The song is This Is War and it's my fav song! you really know which songs to choose cuz this fits perfectly with it!!!
firestarfan737 3 months ago
O.O how has this video not gotten more views???
allmightydough 3 months ago 2
This was soo amazing -3 whenever I listen to this on my iPod I think of Harry potter but you just made it 100x better
jazelle2493 3 months ago
ive see this many times before, and ive cried every time, this is AMAZING i love this video, the song fits the scenes perfect , i sure am gonna miss the trio:')
yourbiggestfan345 3 months ago
This is the first time I heard this song, but I still noticed it was 30 Seconds to Mars ;)
"Death has come to Germany and his is Mr. Black." - Make A Wish
//Storm
thunderstorm997 4 months ago
great video!
MultiJuly94 4 months ago
Too much white flickering effect. It's really distracting.
Bek359 4 months ago
The Fred and George clip... makes me depressed all over again, every time. :'(
pandorad24 4 months ago
One of the best videos on Youtube, no joke man I love this one.
PrinzHaldir 4 months ago
This made me cry. Amazing.
22dragongirl22 4 months ago
SOO GOOD!
dogluveryao 4 months ago
this totally filled the hole in my heart of harry potter being finshed!!
URpoopstinks2 4 months ago
This feels less... Emotional. The more popular of the HP AMVs for this song strikes a chord... I don't feel that here. It's cool, yes. It may be a better video. but it does not strike that chord.
CodexEthera 4 months ago
OH MY GOSH OH MY GOSH. this is AMAZING. like WOAHWOAHWAOWHOA!!!!! I've watched it 6 times and i'm still going strong! spectacular ending and the lyrics went so well with the video! Everything matches! LOVE THIS:)
IGottaLoveCereal 4 months ago 60
@IGottaLoveCereal thank youu =D
Hbprincez 4 months ago
@IGottaLoveCereal well seeing that u are obsessed with H.P. I really think this is a great video too :D
cod3roks89 3 months ago
This has to be the best one of this song used for this saga. I love the video. Even thought Lord Voldemort is my favorite character. How you did Dumbledore as the liar, and Severus as the honest that makes sence.
Renelyus 4 months ago
I kind of like this version better than the one with the most views. At least by the titles. Like the leader Neville, the pariah Barty Crouch Jr. The Liar as Dumbledore and the Honest as Snape are good titles even though their attitudes would say otherwise in the books.
ethio93 4 months ago
erm, the good is dolores?
KickYourAssYodaWill 4 months ago
I love how you made Dobby the victor. Beautiful tribute.
iamlikewhatever 4 months ago
"The liar, the honest" was such a good detail and there's so much truth to it.
LanixKay 4 months ago
didn't u steel this video off of this other person?????
Tanji099 4 months ago
@Tanji099 Which person?? I don't know which video you are referring to because there are several versions of this same song with Harry Potter. But anyways...No, I have not stolen anyone else's "mix" of this song.
Hbprincez 4 months ago 25
@Tanji099 There's a couple of hundred videos with this same song. Just because one is more popular than some of the others doesn't mean everybody else who uses the song stole it. :P
PitBullTerrier55 4 months ago 33
@PitBullTerrier55 but your taking credit for it
Tanji099 4 months ago
@Tanji099 How am I taking the credit for it? e_o Nobody here is taking the credit for either videos from what I can see...
PitBullTerrier55 4 months ago
It is impossible to comment on that. It is so incredible beautiful that I don't find words. It made me cry. Almost.
Thank you.
NewYorker176 4 months ago
wow this is quite possibly the greatest video I have ever seen on here
allmightydough 4 months ago
Im glad im not the only one who cried in this.
Bananafarts182 4 months ago
This is beautiful. It's not exactly sad yet it brings me to tears every time I watch it.
MissZoeFelton 4 months ago
I've seen this shit like 50000 times now. And it STILL gives me chills. Very well done clips and goes perfect with the song
divinebadboyharry 4 months ago
This is the story I loved and I will love forever.
Giuclalucver 4 months ago
At 2:16 when the locket opens up. What movie is that from cause I don't think its in any of the HP movies.
Booksareepic 4 months ago
@Booksareepic Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1
Hbprincez 4 months ago
@Hbprincez Really? I don't remember that part.. but whatever you say! I'm probably watching DH Part 1 tonight anyway because I have no better way to spend my Friday night...
Booksareepic 4 months ago
@Booksareepic If you notice that little clip lasts less than 3 seconds, I don't remember slowing it down but maybe I zoomed in to emphasize it.. Honestly I don't remember.. It's when Harry and Ron are by the frozen lake and Harry speaks Parseltongue to open it and Ron is ready to stab it.. Goes by fast lol
Hbprincez 4 months ago
Best, BEST HP video EVER. And I'm not joking.
EverDreamer95 4 months ago 2
the Harry Potter story and clips go with this song like Peanut Butter to Jelly....
divinebadboyharry 4 months ago
This is the most fucking beautiful video I've ever seen in my life.
Damn, it must take a life to find all the clips!
You have all my respect, really.
HexOwl73 4 months ago 5
@HexOwl73 lol thank you and yes, it does take time to find the clips XD
Hbprincez 4 months ago 3
this is incredible. i'm almost in tears.
DramaGirl297 4 months ago
I'm absolutely addicted to this ;w; I've watched it COUNTLESS times since saturday. I'm not just saying this, I've seriously been putting it on as soon as I get home from school and playing it all day ;w; good job :')
dreamcat101 4 months ago
Just one word... EPIC!
Pepcounisko 4 months ago
I'm in tears.
This is brilliant.
Just... oh my god.
MissZoeFelton 4 months ago
This is bloody beautiful and so wonderfully thought out:D
AMAZING JOB
harleydavidsonlove 4 months ago
Awesome!
ggirl20121 4 months ago
30 seconds watching this and i cried ;__;
GrEaTvIdGirL 4 months ago
Is that flashing a bug? Its a little annoying but otherwise this is an amazing tribute. Truly!
SuperXD25 4 months ago
1:32 The only time Voldemort says NYEAH in an actual movie....
SuperXD25 4 months ago
You did an amazing job... good job fitting people with the descriptions. Overall awesome editing... awesome everything. :)
findmeharry2 5 months ago
very beautiful compliment *w* is the first time I saw it but I have been very impressed ** from now, with that made by agentofCHAOS13x {?v = DFBzZfxkWUg}, has become my favorite video! I liked Dumbledore and Snape madeas the liar and the honest but reversed that Dumbledore is the liar and Snape is the honest. And then the min. 3:03, when I saw Fred&George, I had the bright eyes since what you put is their last moment together before the fight separated. I have no words really compliments *w*
lashleyxX 5 months ago
this is the best fan video i've ever seen. the order of it, it takes more then finding clips to make videos for this, you did the most incredible job, this is something that i would convincingly believe was something that should of been on tv! your time and effort really payed off. its beautiful.
theresjulia 5 months ago 6
@theresjulia thank you =D
Hbprincez 5 months ago
Bloody Brilliant. This is perfection. I mean, it's beautiful.
LoVeR6141 5 months ago
One of the best amvs i have ever seen the song is just a perfect fit what more needs to be said? Oh yeah the lair the honest line very clever! Thumbs up
JonnySniper1988 5 months ago
Comment removed
JonnySniper1988 5 months ago
I LOVED how Dumbledore was the liar and Snape was the honest! Fantastic video!
RavenclawStudent 5 months ago
AWESOME VIDEO I LIKED HOW YOU SHOW NEVILLE AS THE LEADER And snape and dumbledore honest and liar.
jacob0945 5 months ago 4
@jacob0945 lol thank you!! I think Neville deserves to be recognized as the leader ^.^
Hbprincez 5 months ago
This is so unbelievably great because of its perfect fit!
AllesInDunkelweiss 5 months ago
Propably the most beautiful and epic Harry Potter tribute in Youtube,congratulations!
santoouin 5 months ago
@ Blondgits I can't like the comment enough to show you took the words out of my mouth and I've been watching it for a week and a half. Well put in the comment, and the video was very well done to put it simply. Amazing.
divinebadboyharry 5 months ago
I don't generally leave comments but I wanted you to know that even though this probably has the fewest views of all the Harry Potter videos set to this song I've found it is easily my favorite. I absolutely love what you did with the opening, it was really genius, and the way you cut and edited the clips from the movies into this song is amazing. I have watched this several times in the past few days and I'm about to watch it again! Great job!
BlondGits 5 months ago in playlist Liked
@BlondGits Thank you so so much!! you're very kind ^.^
Hbprincez 5 months ago
Dobby's the victor!
EatSleepSk8LYFE 5 months ago
Awesome!!! I loved watching Dumbledore while the song was saying "liar". In my opinion, he is the real villain! The only one of the good ones who wanted Harry's death!!! Voldemort, at least, wanted to kill him without secrets!! And Snapes had good secrets, instad!
MatteoSobrero 5 months ago
wow this is amazing!! great job!!
athena606 5 months ago
This was absolutely incredible! It captured Deathly Hallows perfectly! Great job!
Luckiegurll 5 months ago
Its like this song was written for Harry Potter :')
VegetarianDinosaur1 5 months ago
this is probably the best on youtube. great job ;)
cheeseitzrule231 5 months ago
@cheeseitzrule231 totally agree :D
dansjuf88 5 months ago
@dansjuf88 yeah. I should've said "this is the best on youtube. great job <3"
cheeseitzrule231 5 months ago
@cheeseitzrule231 thank you guys!! It means a lot =D
Hbprincez 5 months ago
yah i was like shouldnt snape be the liar and dumbldore the honest but then i read ur lil comment thing this is pretty good
tpetru1123 5 months ago
wow. mind = blown, idk what to even say :D well this is one of my FAVORITE songs, and making a HP video with it is pure genius... wow, this video was done BRILLIANTLY! absolutely stunning and perfect and totally awesome :D
smotheralltheshades 5 months ago
I love the take on liar/honest. Dumbledore hid a lot from Harry and Snape while they were working toward the same goal. Harry would have been able toi defeat Voldemort more easily with more information. Snape had to hide things for other reasons, yet he never really hid who he was as a person.
meisha285 6 months ago 3
Great job!
62896dude 6 months ago
I ACCIDENTALLY clicked the dislike button!
AH!!! ONE OF THOSE DISLIKES IS A LIE!
I actually favorited this XD
WTH22foreveralone 6 months ago 5
and why dumbledore-liar?
obecrazy 6 months ago
@obecrazy from my perspective I think Dumbledore and Snape both were Harry's guardians and they both kept secrets from Harry 'til the end, but since Dumbledore was closest to him I thought it appropriate to "brand" him as the 'liar'... it isn't until they meet at King's Cross that Dumbledore exposes all of his secrets
Hbprincez 6 months ago 29
@Hbprincez ok ok... i think that pettigrew would be more appropriate... however, great video!
obecrazy 6 months ago
@obecrazy ovviously pettigrew-liar sirius-honest
obecrazy 6 months ago
@obecrazy lol you're right
Hbprincez 6 months ago
@Hbprincez I think I'd say Fudge/Scrimgeour was the liar. Dumbledore had many secrets, but I wouldn't say he lied. Same with Snape. Oh, and great video. :)
silverandcold65 5 months ago
@silverandcold65 I wasn't thinking outside the box when I made it... I was focused on the trio: Dumbledore, Snape and Harry.. but yeah you are right Fudge/Scrimgeour would have fit that description as well
Hbprincez 5 months ago
@obecrazy Well, yesterday I was thinking about this song and I had the same idea as HBprincez. Portraying Dumbeldore as the liar and snape as the honest. In the end Dumbeldore wanted to sacrifice Harry but always acted as if he cared so much about him. I think that makes him a liar. And Snape turned out to be good in the end so...
dansjuf88 5 months ago
@dansjuf88 but dumbledore knew that harry would have survived!
obecrazy 5 months ago
@obecrazy How do you know? I'm not so sure about that. I still don't get that scene in heaven or where ever it is anyway, so maybe you can explain it...
(maybe I sound hostile here but I'm not)
dansjuf88 5 months ago
@dansjuf88 when dumbledore talks to harry about his mother's sacrifice and when voldemort (in the goblet of fire) used harry's blood to "reborn" establishing a further link between them... and harry asks to dumbledore something like: "and you knew for all this time?" dumbledore says: "i supposed it, but usually my assumptions are very good!"... i think that this is the proof that dumbledore knew about everything... all dialogues are of the italian version of the book, so sorry about my english!
obecrazy 5 months ago 2
Absolutely sublime [: I've watched this about a dozen times now and it's by far one of my favorite HP videos <3
LestrangeChild 6 months ago 2
@LestrangeChild thank you ^o^
Hbprincez 6 months ago