Hear the song on the album, it is so intense. You think it is Ian, Trust me Peter can match his voice just the same way he can play the music live just as it sounds on cd.
wow, i've been a JD/NO fan for 20 years or more and i never ealized the hook sang vocals. he's not bad. i've never liked new order live, i think they are best in the studio. but now with you tube i've been getting into their live stuff. it's real, and raw with mistakes and everything. not like todays live music with backing vocal tracks, autotuner and lipsync.
@fleeciewool nope - I would. Super underrated drummer. They guy is f23king intense! Just watch the BBC Radio 1 session of "Age of Consent" to see what I am talking about: /watch?v=0VcGJZpfl1c
ian wrote the ceremony lyrics and the in a lonely place lyrics, but according to 'touching from a distance' he didn't write the lyrics for this one.. so i can't verify it, maybe some one else
I know, I read the book, saw all the lyrics at the back that were attributed to him...its just that of all the New Order songs, which are great, none really had the lyrical depth that this one had, in terms of imagery and theme...they sound so much like Ian's words...
@britdude1961 yeah, Hook should have done the vocals on more songs, esp ceremony(would love to here him on that), love Bernard as writer and guitarist but always been a bit cross about his vocals
They still sound a lot like Joy Division in this song just a bit more electronic they found they hit their stride with "Power, Corruption, and Lies" though. "Movement" is probably my favorite though cause it sounds like Joy Division at that point still.
I think Hooky really brings something great to this song and his voice isn't half bad. But on the studio version, the mix is so lousy you can barely make out the words.
So no one in New Order can sing or play, but who gives a f*ck? Even they admitted that. They chose Bernard as singer out of pure necessity. But they write fantastic songs, which is enough for me to love them. Most pop bands will never manage even one truly great song. New Order has more than I can even count.
ohhh donde sta New ORder falto que viniera a MExico chinagos aca puras bandas culeras que manden a la verga a la choetada de madona jajajja ojala un dia se nos haga
Shergold Marathon 6 string bass with tone controls up, Electro Harmonix Clone Theory chorus pedal, into a Custom Hitwatt 100 amp with a vox or marshall cab with goodman or something else spekers
besides, in my view, even if get the exact same gear, you will not sound the same
Silly me, I always wondered why Bernard sounded different on this track. Seems to be Hooky should have sung more of the bands tracks. Kinda how Martin Gore took the helm with Depeche Mode from time to time.
Hear the song on the album, it is so intense. You think it is Ian, Trust me Peter can match his voice just the same way he can play the music live just as it sounds on cd.
dustnkeys 3 months ago
Excellent!
centurion180ad 4 months ago
never knew gillian played guitar
dogglewop 4 months ago
Wow does this miss Ian Curtis's voice or what?
kingjojothegreat 4 months ago
Okay now I'm going to go rock back and forth in corner now, because how great this is!!! =D
syderwarp 4 months ago in playlist New Wave
super cool footage
intense
GriefTourist 7 months ago
this track is the link!! and that performance was as pure as you could wish for..thankyou!!
zazz63 11 months ago
Only God knows what Joy Division would have gone on to do if Ian...
kris1991 11 months ago
a robotic voice that suits the sound. i love this band. i'll stick pin needles on the number 5
boredbydreams 11 months ago
@scwt89 hello world
inasad1 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
What a great New Order tune from the old days. Not mention Hooky in a tie.
itskyb 11 months ago
What a great New Order tune from the old days. Not mention Hooky in a tie.
itskyb 11 months ago
What a great New Order tune from the old days.
itskyb 11 months ago
wow, i've been a JD/NO fan for 20 years or more and i never ealized the hook sang vocals. he's not bad. i've never liked new order live, i think they are best in the studio. but now with you tube i've been getting into their live stuff. it's real, and raw with mistakes and everything. not like todays live music with backing vocal tracks, autotuner and lipsync.
JubeProductions 1 year ago 2
I like Hook as a singer, he's a great musician. Great band.
ghostscantkill 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
watch it right here a,v,a,t,z.net remove ,
tadnorberto 1 year ago
Is it just me or does Gillian look like Mrs. Fiend from Alien Sex Fiend here? Are they related?
gristleizer 1 year ago
@beforethree i just guessed
scwt89 1 year ago
Am I the only one who would pay just to hear Stephen Morris play on his own?
fleeciewool 1 year ago 19
@fleeciewool nope - I would. Super underrated drummer. They guy is f23king intense! Just watch the BBC Radio 1 session of "Age of Consent" to see what I am talking about: /watch?v=0VcGJZpfl1c
LyndonTCorbett 10 months ago
@fleeciewool Stephen Morris aka "drum Machine"
rookiecrew 2 months ago
@fleeciewool hope u had the chance to do it,,,, i did ,
3 times this year :)
Kelyv 1 week ago
i thinkt hooky is better singer than bernie
S4M3L 1 year ago 3
Love it!!I danced this drunk last night in a club <3
TheFairygirl304 1 year ago
great bands never die !!!!!!
FLORENT2222 1 year ago
totally sick !
conathona 1 year ago
one of my fave, a classic rock music of New Order! Thanks!
mykgeo 1 year ago
Gillian on guitar!
rinconfaber 1 year ago
great concert! wish i was there! thank u so much for this videos
freudastaire 1 year ago
Miss the deeper vocals on this version, but it's just such a good song.
clayguy33 1 year ago
Sick!
transmit13 1 year ago
Only this !!
Zelda36J 1 year ago
Fabby track - hooky at his best !!
Zelda36J 1 year ago
just ate their today...good stuffed cabbage
burns46824 1 year ago
uhm wows. soft slag. don't tune it.
pamaspamas 1 year ago
i love hooky's voice
DankeRainer 1 year ago 3
Great Song just think how it would sound with Ian Curtis sing´n it
sickalb3rt 1 year ago 2
Great Song. Everyone looks so nervous performing though.
JYDIVISN 1 year ago 2
@JYDIVISN they never looked like they liked what they were doing until around the 1990
BMGStammer 1 year ago
geant!!!! new order est un des plus grand groupe au monde
1967drwho 1 year ago
One of New Order's greatest songs - doesn't even need Bernard, the useless throwpiece.
ady10001 2 years ago
singing about ian
urscrewed 2 years ago
I love this song so much that I'm making a short film based on it for my NYU admissions tape. I also recorded a great cover version of song =]
Eyesighttotheblind 2 years ago
Does Hook sing the version on the Movement album and peel sesions? What other songs does he sing?
FlorrieDugger 2 years ago 8
Yes he does. He also sings Doubts Even Here, also found on Movement.
VanishInFright 2 years ago 2
He should have sang on more. Really retains the JD sound. Wonder why he didn't
FlorrieDugger 2 years ago 3
@VanishInFright Do you have a live version of Doubts even here? Would be really kewl
skaterausberlin94 7 months ago
He sings in tune! Go Hooky!
lagowski 2 years ago 2
@lagowski ...Barney eventually took some singing lessons.
weta2000nz 2 years ago
At this album Movement.. peter sings on doubts Even Here too.
russomorrissey 2 years ago
incredible this is just one and a half year after ians death. so cool
Partyphotographer 2 years ago
hookys voice is great on this track cant get enough of it
guitar19904 2 years ago 2
Peter Hook is the man!
bakedzale 2 years ago
I quite like Peter's voice on this it just so different and unusual. Anyway just loooooooooooooooooooooooove New Order to bits.
ColumRogers 2 years ago 3
we all miss ian
boardy777777 2 years ago
sounds very different from the recording but still awesome!!
i like the movement album more than any of their other stuff
icyandrew69696969696 2 years ago
Gillian looking very angular featured lol. Raw as fook here.
NO Forever Wherever..
JonOssett 2 years ago
I'm pretty sure Ian wrote the lyrics for this song before his death...can anyone verify that?
houghmp 2 years ago
ian wrote the ceremony lyrics and the in a lonely place lyrics, but according to 'touching from a distance' he didn't write the lyrics for this one.. so i can't verify it, maybe some one else
Partyphotographer 2 years ago
I know, I read the book, saw all the lyrics at the back that were attributed to him...its just that of all the New Order songs, which are great, none really had the lyrical depth that this one had, in terms of imagery and theme...they sound so much like Ian's words...
houghmp 2 years ago
yeah you're right.. again i say, maybe some one else can verify it
Partyphotographer 2 years ago
@houghmp so true, this song blows my mind musically and lyrically
BMGStammer 1 year ago
These guys can make easy guitar playing sound so awesome!!!
KingBixbi1 2 years ago 3
OMG first time ive seen Hooky singing
he should have been the singer...
ThomD1888 2 years ago 2
he is a dj and plays new and old songs, great.
edsrch3d 2 years ago
0:53 Gillian is gorgeous ;)
belzondium 2 years ago 2
@belzondium, yeah she is. And a sweet girl too !! Lucky Steven.
weta2000nz 2 years ago
I know what happened Hook had a bet he could out lead sing, while singer could out backup guitar to his lead singing LOL BROTHERHOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!
syderwarp 2 years ago
Why can't more music today be this good? It doesn't even have to be this good, just better.
toofargone06 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dang he can't sing but the beat is nice
alaxy22 2 years ago
Hooky should have sung way more!
peaco777777 2 years ago 6
HOOKSTER WE LOVE UUU!!!
karziflora 2 years ago
So do i
BobcatBadcat 2 years ago
i love this song
ejemail 2 years ago
Serious tune! Thanks for loading this Vid, good to look back to 81! (seems like only yesterday)
TheFatOwl 2 years ago
...seems still like tomorrow i guess....
borealico 2 years ago 2
If someone asked me what post punk music sounds like, I'd play him this song. Awesome.
masonjarjar 2 years ago 5
Do'nt they look young ?
Before the drummer started collecting tanks and armoured cars
whyshouldI303 2 years ago 2
On aimerait que le rêve New Order ne prenne jamais fin et que pour la grande réconciliation, Hooky revienne chanter sur la guitare de Sumner...
davidtrz 2 years ago
This was on the first video tape i ever bought sadly long gone but nice to see it again thank you!
amandainboots 2 years ago
yeah it kinda looks like it, but its too dark to tell.
newmoonsamesun 2 years ago
hmm correct me if i'm wrong but given the lyrics it's almost obvious they're singing about ian's last days.. right?
jostube06 3 years ago
you are correct. this is an ian curtis tribute by the band.
vici0usl0u 2 years ago
All but two songs on Movement were tributes to Ian =D
LIL2511 2 years ago
and the title "dreams never end" refers to Ian's lyric in Insight "Guess the dreams always end"
scwt89 2 years ago 26
thank you.
navvvv 2 years ago
@scwt89 and where did you know that ?
beforethree 1 year ago
@scwt89
this is a revelation ! I didn't know this..
labeviamo 9 months ago
@scwt89
what a revelation!! I did not know about that,. Are you sure about that?
labeviamo 8 months ago
is bernard playing a hollow-body?
newmoonsamesun 3 years ago
i don't think so, it looks like he's playing a double cutaway gibson les paul special.
Blompcube 2 years ago
think hookys voice sounds alright---would of liked to hear more of him--
britdude1961 3 years ago 31
i thought it was ian the very first time
standardyarn 2 years ago
that is, on the recording
standardyarn 2 years ago
Wrong.
ShortRoundMcFly72 2 years ago
you're smart
standardyarn 2 years ago
@britdude1961 yeah, Hook should have done the vocals on more songs, esp ceremony(would love to here him on that), love Bernard as writer and guitarist but always been a bit cross about his vocals
carlo88moe 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@britdude1961 Well now you can!
walonsubi 9 months ago
The only new order album i can listen without feeling the urge to bang my head on the wall ^^
Lisbon1906 3 years ago
good points succinctley put nesplayer94 :))
custer1968 3 years ago
They still sound a lot like Joy Division in this song just a bit more electronic they found they hit their stride with "Power, Corruption, and Lies" though. "Movement" is probably my favorite though cause it sounds like Joy Division at that point still.
nesplayer94 3 years ago
Such a great song.
ghosttroop 3 years ago 4
I think Hooky really brings something great to this song and his voice isn't half bad. But on the studio version, the mix is so lousy you can barely make out the words.
So no one in New Order can sing or play, but who gives a f*ck? Even they admitted that. They chose Bernard as singer out of pure necessity. But they write fantastic songs, which is enough for me to love them. Most pop bands will never manage even one truly great song. New Order has more than I can even count.
Jeff6124355432345 3 years ago
I wish hooky had sang more
cowboystitching 3 years ago 7
Hey! I was just about to say that :-D!
FSchouten 3 years ago
Just hear Monaco's stuff...he sings quite a few for that project with David Potts! Download away !!
brilliantos 3 years ago
fantastic song!
iammovingtomexico 3 years ago 2
Shuhster bleib bei Deinen Rappen!!
I LoVe PeTeR !!
laralott 3 years ago
ohhh donde sta New ORder falto que viniera a MExico chinagos aca puras bandas culeras que manden a la verga a la choetada de madona jajajja ojala un dia se nos haga
dusk728728 3 years ago
I kinda consider MOvement to be like a third Jd album, it became more pop, but still indstrial
MrZZiZZler 3 years ago
Best track from their debut LP.Hooky on lead vox for the first and last time in their so far very long career.
abagail4me 3 years ago 3
they are amazing
chromechild88 3 years ago
jj, robert má lepší hlas...
daruda3355 3 years ago
Yeah... I couldn't have put it better myself...!
lioii 3 years ago
wow - goddam - brilliant! thanks for a great upload!
angrylambie 3 years ago
How fuckin brilliant are new order?
Ordsall66 3 years ago 3
its official i got addicted to this album :p
its still very JD stile (lol i think i have commented this album 100 times todayxD)
Lisbon1906 3 years ago
a little more upbeat than JD a great transition album and my personal favourite
juankenon 3 years ago
Great song; I think Robert Smith might owe these four some royalties!!!!! :-)
jogger1976 3 years ago
haha the stile reminds robert smith so much.
im not a fsm of those guys but this albuns kicks ass
Lisbon1906 3 years ago
quite a short song for new order
andyjdking 3 years ago
What is the first song in the concert it is listed as ICB but sounds nothing like it.
movingthejupiter 3 years ago
this is a f*^king gr8 video of a frickin gr8 song - probably defined that era- the rest merely copied -is that what u meant to say petak2 ;->
theclashman77 3 years ago 2
proč ty jsi taková smutná,když to s tebou dělám,máš zavřený oči a já s toho nic nemám.
Wanastowi vjecy - Holčičko
petak2 3 years ago
jojo, výborné :)
WV sú lepší :-),že?
xtinka06 3 years ago
YEAH, TOTALLY RIGHT!! ^^
Lisbon1906 3 years ago
when was the last time this was played?
hannahmwalsh 3 years ago
my fave!
bonezzzz 3 years ago
i like 999999999999999999999999999999 times better hooky's voice than bernies'
its all deep like ian's
JODQ11 3 years ago
i agree! i love hooky's voice
nihilnoise 3 years ago
i wonder if bernard has ever sung lead on this song
joydivstellar 4 years ago
da!! it kill me, how the fuck is doing Hooky to have that such beautiful bass sound ??
chillcrew 4 years ago
Shergold Marathon 6 string bass with tone controls up, Electro Harmonix Clone Theory chorus pedal, into a Custom Hitwatt 100 amp with a vox or marshall cab with goodman or something else spekers
besides, in my view, even if get the exact same gear, you will not sound the same
nihilnoise 3 years ago
Do you think that Robert Smith listened to this before writing "In Between Days"? I sure do.
RGFREI00 4 years ago 2
yeah, this song reminds me alot of the cure
nihilnoise 3 years ago 2
Yeah, New Order took The Cure to court over "In Between Days".
AdobeGillis 2 years ago 2
I thought this sounded like 'The Cure' too.
ClemenzaKimble 3 years ago 2
listen to faith and seventeen secods (early the cure albums) really sound like joy division
mainly the baassyness xd if u will
the song primary was dedicated to ian curtis suposedly
JODQ11 3 years ago
yes, i thought about it too.
the sound of the cures inbetween days is very close to this...
Leitmotivation 3 years ago
absolute class
scotiagroup 4 years ago 3
i love hooky singing
subz6 4 years ago 2
i like to imagine Ian Curtis singing
blabbles 4 years ago
Seriously me too.
KomackinoA 4 years ago
Love that deep bass!
tickertape82 4 years ago
one of only 2 Hooky sung alone, the other being Doubts Even Here.
StyleSessions 4 years ago
Silly me, I always wondered why Bernard sounded different on this track. Seems to be Hooky should have sung more of the bands tracks. Kinda how Martin Gore took the helm with Depeche Mode from time to time.
Procopius1980 4 years ago
shit I always thought it was Ian singing.
ikey76 4 years ago
Who's the chick playing with em? Such a beautiful song.
xfearbefore 4 years ago
it's gillian gilbert, the 4th original member of NEW ORDER
asdras1 4 years ago 3
lol wtf
blabbles 4 years ago
those boyish days
1stofthegangtodie 4 years ago