A Promise in the Clouds (AMV - Porcupine Tree - Trains)

[djthe]

FUCK, this was one of my favorite amv's! Damn this copyright bullshit!

[rbred378]

No sound--WTF?!!!!! This clip is such a beaitiful masterpiece and the stupid copy right law just ruined it. UGH!!!

[ducko1988]

why remove the music? copyright laws are pothetic i believe the u.s can take my member

[Agricola556]

f**cking youtube! They just ruined the best AMV ever by removing the sound!

[LordoftheShale]

Don't blame youtube, blame US copyright law.

[rakiztrimitymalhyn18]

the grapihcs are good

its the same w/ the

TALES OF ABYSS xD

awesome work dude..

[Sezzthrazz]

Why has the audio been disabled? This is the most touching amv i've ever seen. And They disabled the video. This is just sad.. I'm sad...

</3

[Apotheosis12]

what the hell....this was..wow...omg XD

Man...great job really...

fucking touching man...you should make more of them...although..dont know if they can get any better than this one XD

[DysthymicHydrangea]

Im trying to get over the shock of how amazing this video was...

The anime and the song really fit together, something Ive rarely seen lately. Makoto Shinkais beautiful art falls wonderfully with Porcupine Trees sound/lyrics. And you actually synchronized them, marked the powerful moments of the song with more dynamic scenes from the anime. You also made the video fit the lyrics/interpretations of the song. Loved 2:40-3:01 & 1:44-1:50. Those seconds actually made me shiver.

Great job.

[Danrod161184]

lol i mean 2:40^^

[Danrod161184]

2:13 great

[AngstSchreeuw]

1:12 -> goosebumps

[Haku548]

OMG, this video combines my two favorite things, anime and Porcupine Tree. Beautiful.

[benjaminbreeg22]

perfect;) keep it up dude..awsome song,brings so many good memories that make me feel perfect

[djthe]

I love the vid ánd porcupine tree, the anime suits it perfectly and I haven't even watched it ^^

[affenarsch87]

this song gives me such a wonderful feeling inside of my heart!

thank you!

[xnextchickx]

Nice amv!!!!!

I love it<3

[M0oM0o1]

5/5! kickass dude

[Lossengwath]

nicely done... it's a really good job!

[drogaz1]

I'm wondering if I should see this movie but I'm not entirely comfortable. Is it as depressing as Shinkai-sans other stuff? Like 5cmPS or Distant Star? Thanks in advanced.

[DrCorndog01]

Distant Star was awful. I mean, it was great, but awfully depressing. And kind of weird, too.

[drogaz1]

Yes, I know but is The Place Promised in Our Early Days as depressing as it or 5cmPS?

[DrCorndog01]

I don't know. I've never seen it.

[darkNinja537]

great song..great job with the video..

[bellyshere]

Fits perfectly. Ace video. Ace song. How are porcupine tree not given the recognition they deserve?

[WesBWMS]

watch and sub for BNSFnick

[ColouredSoul]

great, great great :D

[RickPaniagua]

one of the best made AMVs. BRAVO!!!!

[samos1991]

Who can give me link to this song for download ? But i need this song not other, i just need this! xD

[jes5100]

The song is aweseome. And it gets even more awesome of how much it fits with the video! It owns!

[Fwisky11]

OMG very Nice song !!!

[Fwisky11]

and it is perfectly done !

[TheLabyrinthJareth]

I actually cannot get over how good this is.

I just CANT

[ozit]

Complete perfection.

[Aeaces]

I just repeat this over and over again... good job man *thumps up* :D

[enderwiggin42]

Hehe, me too ive been watching this everyday for months, cant believe this doesnt have a million views :(

[Sean2112bd]

This song has a layered swirling euphoria to it.

[awol1209]

This is brilliant, both the song and the animation.

[mroblongo]

Nicely done!

[Inluminata]

which is the title of this anime?

[Gratymore]

I can't follow the history...-.- but it'S really good

respects!!!

[rbred378]

I feel as if I were watching a short movie... Masterpiece.

[betabandfan]

love this song. i definitely made the part at 3:24 my brother's ring tone. what a great tune.

[emotivenextway]

I simply love it :D

Porcupine Tree <3

[nilzardo]

wow...and the the vid is just a masterpiece.

The part when the plain takes off at 4:25 is just so beautiful :P

[nilzardo]

Shit! I just started listneing to Porcupine Tree

and they rule! This song reminds me of Stairway To Heaven sometimes.

[TheLabyrinthJareth]

That was insanely good you son of a gun.

They're my favourite band, I love them so much,

and that was GREAT!!!!!!

[germanch90]

Impressive work, great sync, and an excelent selection of music and vid... Congrats, and plz keep on going... Good luck.

In some way this video makes me feel so good, and kind of inspired, thanx ^_^

[emmadwiyana]

Oh My God...

So... beautiful...

*speechless*

[emmadwiyana]

This is one of my fave song ever...!

My brother in law introduced me to this band... and this song takes my breath away...

Nice video too... ^^

[chatqueen31087]

wOw  :O

[LuckilyHeDied]

By far the best AMV I've ever seen.

[Majsen77]

haven't seen the movie but this video made me wish that i had :P

and I love the music

porcupine tree is the best ^^

[rbred378]

What a beautiful tribute to this excellent movie. Thank you so much for all your hard work.

[kragnorgrub]

This is honestly one of those AMV's that comes along once in a great while. The song and the movie, fit perfectly in sync with each other lyricly to scene, and the rises in the music itself strike to the scenery of the video, Very well done. An absolute Favorite of mine.

[artkaks]

I talc a lot of jibberish and rubbish sorry :P But did you try to put &fmt=18 ?

[artkaks]

Put &fmt=18 in your URL then listen the music. Its like heaven, better quality. nise video 5*.

[enderwiggin42]

@artkaks

I like the cut of your jib :D

[Tani123123]

Great!

[stewart9893]

wow at 1:12 the music and the vid are put together so perfectly

[RobinKlaassen]

Brilliantly constructed AMV to a great PT song; love it!

[NO1GIVESAFUCK]

every over english band sucks like they have a cock in their mouths but not these exilent

[feedbackofficial]

Haha you havn't listened to much english music have you ? If you're basing it on the mainstream commercial stuff i'll agree. But there are loads of taleneted english bands, check out a band called Muse.

[feedbackofficial]

(That was in response to a comment from "NO1GIVESAFUCK")

[sfwaffle]

Gorgeous video, I love the film, when I watched it, and I like Porcupine Tree, its a perfect match :] It really brings out the mood of the film perfectly

[afuckingname]

Awesome song and amv. Good job!

[azmeda]

se ve q esta chida la serie y con la cancion suena aun mas chido

alguien me podria imformar quien la canta y si es una serie o una pelicula xfa XD

[HRYFIRE]

Que quien la canta?? :S

No lees el nombre del video??

Porcupine Tree.. una de las mejores bandas de rock progresivo de la historia!

[azmeda]

mmm ok pero me regañes me di cuenta ia despues de q puse mi comentario XD

[czatanic]

no mami blue que bien te quedo

[fullmancontact]

Agh.. me parte esta cancion, muy buena cancion... Me hace extrañar a mi noviaaa!!

[brievenbus]

awesome =D

[PhLeGMonA]

simply awesome!

[FutuRENaDiA1993]

oh, ur first? is awesome! and so emotive...really! 5* and put on favs!

[BruceBeefcake]

Nice! I liked how you used scenes from the show and matched them with the lyrics. PT forever!

[tarotcardstothewind]

That was truly amazing. Thank You. The film and music corresponded wonderfully.

[marillionjenn]

this is the first PT song i ever heard.

i was instantly a fan!

[ibladee]

wow the movie and the song just go hand and hand together! 5***** all the way!!!

[batatacollins]

SIMPLEMENTE FANTASTICO !!!

[paulhab12]

this song is brilliant. was swept away off my feet first time i heard it

[betabandfan]

this is such a beautiful song.

[czatanic]

MUY BIEN REALIZADO

[czatanic]

MUY BIEN REALIZADO

[Bloomgirl22]

wow amazing :D 5**** i love this movie

[Comus89]

Best video on youtube. I don't even like anime (what I've seen at least), but I keep coming back to this, fits the music perfectly.

[Rikohness]

I keep on coming back to this AMV. For your first AMV, this is really awesome. good job

[x6Dante9x]

Cool ! I love makoto shinkai animes , and i'm a big fan of porcupine tree.

I was thinkin to make an AMV with the anime "5 centimeters per second" by makoto, and the song "harvest" by Opeth but my PC is being gay these days

awesome job anyway man

[sandiegoecho]

Porcupine Tree should release this under the Roadrunner label. It would be an instant award winner. So well done! What's next?

[dullemen]

after having a lot of thinking behind me, i think this can be one of the best songs in the world

[RyuzakiKaiten]

this song and this anime go together better than white on rice on a paper plate with a glass of milk in a snow storm!

[Rikohness]

def. agree on that. This was the perfect match.

[sorehead83]

Love your work! the song is an excellent choice to this vid! Keep em coming!

[AionsBlade]

This is an amazing song and fits the video astoundingly well. Great job.

[oddysin]

this ,ade me cry =.[

[DuTyJaCk]

And from 4:20 to the end. Juste Love it.

[DuTyJaCk]

You really got that amv :) I really really love the part when the song gets stronger and the kids touch each others hand.

[jenesus13]

its beautiful this amv with this song....your a god...

[FaisalSalim18]

5/5 Stars

Good Job on the AMV, you deserve a high rating ^^

[rushistheband]

Damn, I didn't know AMV'S could have good music.

Splendid video, 5 stars.

[l33tVirus]

I was unaware AMVs could be good.

Great job! I was genuinely moved. 10/10

[InsomniumX]

Yeah, maybe we´ve found the cure to all that Linkin Park running on Otaku´s veins.

[Rikohness]

Oh my gosh. I remember the days when Linkin Park was used for all the AMV's. Especially the Dragon Ball series.

[deaen]

lol they still are, i actually got sick of their song "crawling" cuz EVERYONE used that song in there AMV's and montages it got on my nerves! lol But this is a very nice change.

[GERmobbs]

so awesome *.*

sry for my bad english but I´m from germany !

I could cry when i her this ! I love one girl so much *.* ! hm -.- <3

[baberbekule]

Thanks for video. It's just perfect!

[jenesus13]

beautilful amv with the best song ever^^

[GERmobbs]

awesome ! *.* <3

[DotaPudgeOnly]

?huh?

[Seyxxx]

I said it, but i have to say that again.. this is my beloved song ever. I can listen to it all the time, at !any! mood. That makes this song and this video the best what I have ever seen.

[SerenaBlackCat]

This is right up there in my favorite songs, I repeat it over and over, but I'm also in love with the end part of Anesthetize, that has all the awesome harmony!

[MrsBorat11]

I can listen to this song all the time, too. I never get sick of it.

[bobrulz]

This song is proof that the fact that Porcupine Tree isn't more popular is confounding. Not only is this song beautiful and awesome, it's got radio hit written all over it, and it probably would've been a hit had people actually known about it.

Then again, maybe it's better that Porcupine Tree remain relatively obscure.

[lyjordi17]

no, of course it's not mainstream. it's too beautiful to be mainstream:P

[stanstilpleeze1]

a wonderful song with a touching movie. I once started to watch this movie, but never finished. i believe that only this song could bring to life the feelings of this movie. so thank u s0matic

[wilska1337]

Who the fuck cares about the pokemonvideo mangacrap. :O

Porcupine Tree <3<3<3

[bobrulz]

Ignorance abounds here.

1) Manga is written. It's called anime dumbass.

2) It's nothing like Pokemon.

3) If you don't like anime, there's no reason to diss the video like that. It makes you look like an asshole (and you probably are).

[john437]

i hate to be mister negative but i have and i thought it was bullshit

[MisterAtheistic]

I've never seen this anime, and I too wasn't a fan of Cowboy Bebop. But if you want a good trippy anime to get into, watch Serial Experiments Lain.  Very progressive and abstract and there's no childish bullshit involved. Just pure Mindf*ck.

[john437]

okay some of it may have deep underlying messages and shit but its not entertaining its just weird its so weird its not fun to watch (to me notice i said in my opinion)and all the ones ive seen that arent just trippy and boring were just stupid as fuck like bleach and i even saw one where they turn into wolves or some stupid shit like that. i just cant get into it

[VIPERINFERNO786]

this song is a classic man so ssweet

[KeppoMies]

I instantly fell in love with this song

[emmadwiyana]

My brother in law loves this band so much...

And this video is very very nice...!

[etnies12188]

yo this is great,.

[bananalover666]

Yeah same here it gives me the goosebumps each time i see it!

[chuck4545]

Favorited this a few months back but never commented! Trains has always been one of my favorite songs, but I'd never seen the anime before. Shortly after seeing this video, I actually ended up watching the movie . Wasn't spectacular, but it was good.

Thank you so much for making this music video. I'd have to say it's my favorite of all time. :)

[custombuilt]

you can put this song to grass growing and it will rule. it doesn't matter what's on tv. turn it up and close your eyes.

[john437]

goddamnit like every good song is put to anime oh well i just wont watch the video im sorry but a cartoon thats not funny is just pointless in my opinion

[IrohDOW]

dont be like that, there are soo many good anime out there. you just gotta look, some of them are really deep and very interesting. so saying anime sucks is like saying books suck there are many different genres.

[killboy2119]

haven't heard of the anime but after watching this i really want to!GREAT JOB!!!!

[Withson]

Every time I hear this music I remember this video. For me it is like an "official" clip.

Perfect!

[psyshock918]

10/10 excellent work

[wykh]

definitely the best AMV ever. scenes are matching with the lyrics in a beautiful way!

way to go!!

[Comus89]

I don't usually like AMVs much but this is really great, fits the song perfectly.

[tauren00]

Best AMV i've ever seen. And trust me... i've seen a lot of them.

[jikki90]

Even though I recently bought the song (after hearing it for the first time here!) I still come HERE to watch it with your cut of "A place promised in our early days"... You've really done a flawless job :)

5 stars, every time I visit!

[jikki90]

wow... I'm so impressed! I love this!

I've been here a few times, and I love what you've done each time i visit!

[boxcarguy07]

Beautifully synced.

If you purposely synced half of the things I noticed, that's still phenominal

[Kimeilos]

Very well made AMV. Nice work.

[VentriZ]

This is unbelievable.

Was this anime made for this song?

Or is this Wilson himself behind insubstance?

I loved this video it almost made me cry!

I think this is the best AMV or even the best video i've ever seen on the internet...

[Seyxxx]

This is my beloved song ever. All PT songs are amazing but this, and combined with anime (im drawin manga) its the most perfect song i ve ever heard.

[Killrayon]

What happened to your elfen lied amv? :(

[s0matic]

I've just re-uploaded it :)

Apologies for the unavailability.

[chibiamaterasu]

Truly amazing..you are really talented.

hope to see more from you, fav. 5/5.

[Slash18622]

I dont really like animes, but the combination of that song&video is awesome!!! Really perfect!!! Can´t get enough of it! Thank you for posting!

[ministrant500]

this is completly outstanding, i've never seen something like that. its perfect

[Fullm3tal0ni]

the song is great, the AMV is great, and the movie itself is absolutely amazing.

[marv1an]

This is actually the first amv that i dont hate.

[Phlintlock]

ahaha holy shit yeah he does

[etnies12188]

i love it

[N0d6]

I can listen to this song forever...

[Sparegrisen1992]

I love this song so much, just heard it a few times.

this amv makes it spund and look even better, thank you so much for this AMV :'D

<3

[helgesdk]

Awesome...

Suddenly I want to watch the movie again ^_^

[Theinfinitethought]

Tis is really a work of art. I watched it and was just stunned at how well the lyrics, the music and the movie work together. I immediately wanted to see the movie, so I downloaded an high quality version en moved my pc to the tv for a better quality. After watching the movie I again played this clip. And it actually made me cry 2 tears. Which has never happened to me as a result of a movie or music. It's just so touching.

I'm going to watch it again sometime soon. Hopefully with the one I love.

[im0really0bored]

i've watched this quite a few times. it is great. and now i'm inspired to see what this movie is about. =)

[46lar]

Anyone else think the guy at 5:24 looks a bit like Steven Wilson?

[angprodukz2]

RAHHHH

[Tr1sni]

SO well done... I was blown away at Fanime. Gorgeous editing, concise attention to detail... I had no idea what anime it was from but previous knowledge of it didn't seem necessary to get involved in the music video. Brilliant job. 1:06-1:16 is my favorite bit.

[mort09990]

very VERY nice..

a extremly good link between the movie and the song..

very nice!

[im0really0bored]

wonderfully put together. =)

[Dadutta]

I love the "Hindi" part of the song

[ItOffishul]

"a 60-ton angel falls to the earth"

I think he could possibly be talking about a UFO here. There are a lot of lyrics in music ive suspected as possibly being related to aliens/ufo's and the role many feel they play in religion but this seems to reflect that very well. it makes a lot of sense...ufo sightings are all over the bible you know.

[sufferingindigital]

i think your onto something , i don't really want to tell you why though .

[gropus4]

I also think you're on something, but I don't know what ^^

[TopandoAndo]

Great song!

[sexyinstrument]

Awesome song. And awesome video - how do you make these videos?

[Thundercats567]

Good song

[Illuusion]

This is one of the best songs ive heard! It's relaxing, beutiful and sad, almost makes me cry how beautiful it is...

[crimson5220]

great, thank you

[DrCorndog01]

You could not have picked a more incredible song. Nice job with the video, too. The music really fits.

[Guerillaradio13]

this song is that good