these musicians cannot teach us iranians about music. the sarod, santur, setar etc are all iranian instruments. we also have a body of literature of persian that is un paralleled. we do not need to go to the british tax payer for any pittance of patron.
@londoniran Brother with due respect to your thoughts, not looking for a Fight here but who in todays world actually like the purest form of classical music ??? The songs based on devotion and the enchanted sounds of the percussions while taking the name of the lord be it Hindu bhajans or Sufi Sangeet ... People now more like the noise like METAL and ROCK ... and instead of pointing fingers at other and looking what they do we must enjoy our rich and varied heritage ...
Respond to this video... Iranian instruments they are for sure ... i don't deny that ... doesn't mean the improvisation on the instrument is also Iranian ... that is personal and varies from person to person ...
In India music is a Science if u go into the intricacies of it .. the shrutis are mere frequencies coming out due to interference of sound ... and the amount of expertise that Indian Music has is just vast and incredible ...
Respond to this video... And lastly YES it is an iranian instrument but the form of music being played is "HINDUSTANI SHASTRIYA SANGEET" so plz i request u not to fight and enjoy the music with us :D
U basterd retard, this instrument is truely indian and Persians/iranians have done theft of most ancient indian concpets of music. Sitar and Veena are mothers of all string instruments in world and Indian Drum Pakhawaj is a percusssion instum. used by lord Shiva, is father of all kinds of drums! Indians have respect for each tradition of music but when buttbrains like u go racist we are not gonna tolerate!
Just because a fascist dictator uses a fascist composer to his ends does not stain the entire world of art and culture. The fact is Hitler is dead and the arts and culture live on! Sooner all those with such tendencies understand the better it will be for all! I have better things to do then sit on the internet indefinitely but it was nice to have this interaction with you. Listen to some good Amjad Ali Khan music and it will calm you down!
@londoniran In that case your concern for the British tax payer is very touching! Thanks but in this country we like to support culture, being the essence of any civilised and broad-minded society.
@londoniran Just because a fascist dictator uses a fascist composer to his ends does not stain the entire world of art and culture. The fact is Hitler is dead and the arts and culture live on! Sooner all those with such tendencies understand the better it will be for all! I have better things to do then sit on the internet indefinitely but it was nice to have this interaction with you. Listen to some good Amjad Ali Khan music and it will calm you down!
@londoniran I think there is nothing fascist about supporting and appreciating arts and culture - they represent the finer sensibilities of human emotions and existence - and if you think Hitler stood for all that then your recollection of history leaves something to be desired. The British have opened their doors to so many nationalities and cultures and supported their activities - yes by way of tax payer support ! And it does not need lecture from you lot!
@londoniran In this country we respect arts and culture - no matter from what part of the world! Be it museums, theatre, music, opera, what have you! And the British tax payers are generally happy to support this as long as it is reasonable. I am not sure from where you come but perhaps presumably there the tax payer is saved this burden hence your views? May be better for you to be a tax payer there?
but it still was at the british tax payer who funded this lot for 20 years- out of which these artistes paid their taxes. so the tax payer paid the money in the first place.
@londoniran With respect not all promoters who bring these artists are financed by the British tax payer except for some organisations which do get Arts Council support. And it is not just this lot, as you call them, who are supported by Arts Council. Far far more money goes towards funding of the Arts in this country to non-Asian musicians. You obviously have your preconceived notions but let that not prevent you from getting your facts right! Asian artists are paid far less relative to others!
I love the way Ustad Amjad Ali Khan encourages the tabla player or the pakhawaj player accompanying him to have a go on their own and show their skills. I see this in almost all his videos and even during a live concert I attended in Mumbai where there were two tabla players...one of whom was Pt. Anindo Chaterjee's son Anubrata. Every now and then, Ustad Amjad Ali Khan encouraged them to engage in a jugalbandi. He understands that a great Tabla solo piece can really liven up any concert.
Wow! Ustadji's sense of Ras is so refined and perfect, that once simply runs out out words while attempting to appreciate his work! No doubt we live in fortunate times to have such a great master amongst us. May god bless him with a long life!
......... i am sorry 2 say this ...... but u know SH**T about music and 2 its depth !!!!!!! u r nthg but a F***ING moron ..................this is MUSIC at its very DEPTH .........the no of awards Ustadji has got is countless ~!!!!!! and he can play his string instrument faster than any lead guitarist n the world!!!!!!!!!
it is quite obvious that sheer insanity has gripped this paagaldas-lets not try to convince this lout on who amjad ali is-lets reinforce his madness-thats the only way spastics get comfort in life.
Why are you guys questioning the brilliance of Amjad ali khan? He is a maestro. And this piece is excellent. I have heard this entire album and it is bliss ful.
He first plays the Mian Malhar in this album and it is heavenly.
Then he has a Raag des composition in rupak taal which is extremely melodious.
sarodfan is absolutely correct in his/her analysis of AAK's musical career.he is a commercial artist only.pulp fiction as below is correct.after watching him play live for over 35 years,i endorse the sad but true views expressed by others.
Sudhir, with due respect to Khan Sahib, Paagaldas does have a point. Any connoisseur worth his salt will agree that Khan Sahib's music has deteriorated progressively, although his sarod technique remains intact. It is possibly because he has stopped thinking about his music - probably because he has no incentive to. People at the top stagnate very easily because they think they have no one to compete against. And then, there are many legitimate challengers to his supremacy now.
Paagaldas is obviously an ignorant lout with no taste for soulful music. Contrary to the crap you write, Ustad Amjad Ali Khan remains a supreme and heavenly force in classical music, a subject you obviously know nothing about. So, take your negative and insane comments and shove them where they shove best. Your name cetainly suits you.
Further clarification: Amjad Ali was such a great sarodiya and wonderful musician in his elements, that it truly pains one to see this colossus in ruins.
Instead of focusing on the greenbacks, a reputable label like Navras ought to focus on quality music: not just recordings of Amjad Ali and Vilayat Khan in their creative twilight. Even at the end, VK retains a lot more class than Amjad Ali. Focus on the future of sarod, and it most certainly ain't Amaan or Ayaan Ali.
Mr. Baxi, it is a disgrace that Navras is releasing the musical equivalent of pulp fiction. Amjad Ali is a spent force, and it seems he knows it quite well. Unable to remain creative, he's routinely resorting to such gimmicks as this ugly threesome with the tabla and pakhawaj guys. I don't blame Rashid and Fateh Singh - they're just earning a living, but this grossly irresponsible "Ustad" needs to be made accountable for hijacking a musical tradition and subjecting us to such vulgarity!
ITs just amazing to listen to it.....i feel bad i cudnt attend any of his shows till now....but all thanks to YOUTUBE we have access to these wonderful musical videos:)
Hello! Thanks for your comments and support. This DVD is already out. We shall be bringing out another Ustad Vilayat Khan DVD in the first quarter around March / April.
My apologies! For some r4eason the CD version of this title has been uploaded but not the DVd. we will address that matter shortly. Thanks for your feedback.
Hi ! No problem for the feedback, I appreciate your work and now the purchase of the DVD is working. What a great piece of news that Ustad Vilayat Khan DVD will be release in March/April ! I have all the DVD from Ustadji and I am waiting impatiently the next one !
Navras Records job is very good...is there any other plans to release other DVD of Ustad Vilayat Khan?..i have all of them and it remains a precious treasure for the soul...
I am waiting also for the release of this one with Ustad Amjad Ali Khan...
Thank you for your feedback. The Amjad Ali Khan DVD "Romancing The Rains" is already available in PAL format and can be ordered from Navras website where there is a great sale on at present. Next Ustad Vilayat Khan DVD is planned for release later this year at the earliest. It will be a performance in Raga Malkauns at Royal Festival Hall, London, accompanied by Pandit Swapan Chaudhury on tabla.
Fateh Singh Gangani (the person on the pakhawaj) was our music teacher in school. A gem of a person and extremely humble and amiable.
We spent so many morning assemblies listening to him on the tabla and when he used to stick "atta" on his pakhawaj to tune it, it was much fun.
nvasistha 1 month ago
Classic!
ra4952 2 months ago
fuck your hitler discussions im here to learn his sarod picking style!
Pierceher 9 months ago
these musicians cannot teach us iranians about music. the sarod, santur, setar etc are all iranian instruments. we also have a body of literature of persian that is un paralleled. we do not need to go to the british tax payer for any pittance of patron.
londoniran 10 months ago
@londoniran Brother with due respect to your thoughts, not looking for a Fight here but who in todays world actually like the purest form of classical music ??? The songs based on devotion and the enchanted sounds of the percussions while taking the name of the lord be it Hindu bhajans or Sufi Sangeet ... People now more like the noise like METAL and ROCK ... and instead of pointing fingers at other and looking what they do we must enjoy our rich and varied heritage ...
darklord47 6 months ago
Respond to this video... Iranian instruments they are for sure ... i don't deny that ... doesn't mean the improvisation on the instrument is also Iranian ... that is personal and varies from person to person ...
In India music is a Science if u go into the intricacies of it .. the shrutis are mere frequencies coming out due to interference of sound ... and the amount of expertise that Indian Music has is just vast and incredible ...
darklord47 6 months ago
Respond to this video... And lastly YES it is an iranian instrument but the form of music being played is "HINDUSTANI SHASTRIYA SANGEET" so plz i request u not to fight and enjoy the music with us :D
Thanks Bro :D
darklord47 6 months ago
@londoniran
U basterd retard, this instrument is truely indian and Persians/iranians have done theft of most ancient indian concpets of music. Sitar and Veena are mothers of all string instruments in world and Indian Drum Pakhawaj is a percusssion instum. used by lord Shiva, is father of all kinds of drums! Indians have respect for each tradition of music but when buttbrains like u go racist we are not gonna tolerate!
deepeshpakhare 4 months ago
Just because a fascist dictator uses a fascist composer to his ends does not stain the entire world of art and culture. The fact is Hitler is dead and the arts and culture live on! Sooner all those with such tendencies understand the better it will be for all! I have better things to do then sit on the internet indefinitely but it was nice to have this interaction with you. Listen to some good Amjad Ali Khan music and it will calm you down!
vibbaxi 10 months ago
but was this not said also by hitler?
londoniran 10 months ago
yes indeed. i am.
londoniran 10 months ago
@londoniran In that case your concern for the British tax payer is very touching! Thanks but in this country we like to support culture, being the essence of any civilised and broad-minded society.
vibbaxi 10 months ago
@vibbaxi weimar republic and wagnar- high clture
londoniran 10 months ago
@londoniran Just because a fascist dictator uses a fascist composer to his ends does not stain the entire world of art and culture. The fact is Hitler is dead and the arts and culture live on! Sooner all those with such tendencies understand the better it will be for all! I have better things to do then sit on the internet indefinitely but it was nice to have this interaction with you. Listen to some good Amjad Ali Khan music and it will calm you down!
vibbaxi 10 months ago
@londoniran I think there is nothing fascist about supporting and appreciating arts and culture - they represent the finer sensibilities of human emotions and existence - and if you think Hitler stood for all that then your recollection of history leaves something to be desired. The British have opened their doors to so many nationalities and cultures and supported their activities - yes by way of tax payer support ! And it does not need lecture from you lot!
vibbaxi 10 months ago
they should all be stopped - all
londoniran 10 months ago
@londoniran In this country we respect arts and culture - no matter from what part of the world! Be it museums, theatre, music, opera, what have you! And the British tax payers are generally happy to support this as long as it is reasonable. I am not sure from where you come but perhaps presumably there the tax payer is saved this burden hence your views? May be better for you to be a tax payer there?
vibbaxi 10 months ago
but it still was at the british tax payer who funded this lot for 20 years- out of which these artistes paid their taxes. so the tax payer paid the money in the first place.
what a sacm !!
londoniran 10 months ago
@londoniran With respect not all promoters who bring these artists are financed by the British tax payer except for some organisations which do get Arts Council support. And it is not just this lot, as you call them, who are supported by Arts Council. Far far more money goes towards funding of the Arts in this country to non-Asian musicians. You obviously have your preconceived notions but let that not prevent you from getting your facts right! Asian artists are paid far less relative to others!
vibbaxi 10 months ago
oi mate, how much money have u received from the british tax payer over the last 20 years?
londoniran 10 months ago
@londoniran
Not as much I bet as you lot! Artist fees are tax deducted at source in the UK for your info before you go on making pathetic allegations on artists!
vibbaxi 10 months ago
amazing,,,,,,,,,
sukhjitsukhi 11 months ago
I love the way Ustad Amjad Ali Khan encourages the tabla player or the pakhawaj player accompanying him to have a go on their own and show their skills. I see this in almost all his videos and even during a live concert I attended in Mumbai where there were two tabla players...one of whom was Pt. Anindo Chaterjee's son Anubrata. Every now and then, Ustad Amjad Ali Khan encouraged them to engage in a jugalbandi. He understands that a great Tabla solo piece can really liven up any concert.
leonine33 1 year ago
@leonine33 thats a mridangam i think
neerajkorde 1 year ago
spellbinding !!
AArora81 1 year ago
Beautiful - once again well done to Navras!
icemish 1 year ago
Wow! Ustadji's sense of Ras is so refined and perfect, that once simply runs out out words while attempting to appreciate his work! No doubt we live in fortunate times to have such a great master amongst us. May god bless him with a long life!
piyaltaru 2 years ago
Comment removed
yojustmoveit 2 years ago
Comment removed
yojustmoveit 2 years ago
Comment removed
yojustmoveit 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
oh my oh my, i almost got stunned by the ugliness of this music
teaser2233 2 years ago
What is ugly about this music? Your insight will be useful.
devnullgnu 2 years ago
nothing at all, it just requires patience.
I mean this kind of music takes time before you start getting into it.
teaser2233 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
......... i am sorry 2 say this ...... but u know SH**T about music and 2 its depth !!!!!!! u r nthg but a F***ING moron ..................this is MUSIC at its very DEPTH .........the no of awards Ustadji has got is countless ~!!!!!! and he can play his string instrument faster than any lead guitarist n the world!!!!!!!!!
yojustmoveit 2 years ago
@teaser2233 UGLINESS?!?! YOU HAVE NO CLUE ABOUT INDIAN MISIC!!!!!
1143460able 1 year ago
Very beautiful.
Mulyanis77 2 years ago 2
it is quite obvious that sheer insanity has gripped this paagaldas-lets not try to convince this lout on who amjad ali is-lets reinforce his madness-thats the only way spastics get comfort in life.
duttalara12345 2 years ago
Just pure losers they remain.
rintrah81 2 years ago
Why are you guys questioning the brilliance of Amjad ali khan? He is a maestro. And this piece is excellent. I have heard this entire album and it is bliss ful.
He first plays the Mian Malhar in this album and it is heavenly.
Then he has a Raag des composition in rupak taal which is extremely melodious.
Mamoni123 2 years ago 2
sarodfan is absolutely correct in his/her analysis of AAK's musical career.he is a commercial artist only.pulp fiction as below is correct.after watching him play live for over 35 years,i endorse the sad but true views expressed by others.
surinder50 2 years ago
What a musican!
haraldji 2 years ago
Sudhir, with due respect to Khan Sahib, Paagaldas does have a point. Any connoisseur worth his salt will agree that Khan Sahib's music has deteriorated progressively, although his sarod technique remains intact. It is possibly because he has stopped thinking about his music - probably because he has no incentive to. People at the top stagnate very easily because they think they have no one to compete against. And then, there are many legitimate challengers to his supremacy now.
sarodfan 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Paagaldas is obviously an ignorant lout with no taste for soulful music. Contrary to the crap you write, Ustad Amjad Ali Khan remains a supreme and heavenly force in classical music, a subject you obviously know nothing about. So, take your negative and insane comments and shove them where they shove best. Your name cetainly suits you.
sudhirs2 3 years ago
Further clarification: Amjad Ali was such a great sarodiya and wonderful musician in his elements, that it truly pains one to see this colossus in ruins.
paagaldas 3 years ago
Instead of focusing on the greenbacks, a reputable label like Navras ought to focus on quality music: not just recordings of Amjad Ali and Vilayat Khan in their creative twilight. Even at the end, VK retains a lot more class than Amjad Ali. Focus on the future of sarod, and it most certainly ain't Amaan or Ayaan Ali.
paagaldas 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Mr. Baxi, it is a disgrace that Navras is releasing the musical equivalent of pulp fiction. Amjad Ali is a spent force, and it seems he knows it quite well. Unable to remain creative, he's routinely resorting to such gimmicks as this ugly threesome with the tabla and pakhawaj guys. I don't blame Rashid and Fateh Singh - they're just earning a living, but this grossly irresponsible "Ustad" needs to be made accountable for hijacking a musical tradition and subjecting us to such vulgarity!
paagaldas 3 years ago
Mr Pagaldas
If you have the courage of your conviction don't hide behind a pseudonym. I will not credit a coward with any other response.
Vibhaker Baxi
vibbaxi 2 years ago
There is no vulgarity on display here. Stop over-exaggerating your points - you're not convincing anyone.
rintrah81 2 years ago 2
ITs just amazing to listen to it.....i feel bad i cudnt attend any of his shows till now....but all thanks to YOUTUBE we have access to these wonderful musical videos:)
maithlily 3 years ago
Melodious......... Regards to Ustad Amjad Ali Khan....
ShidhuRocks 3 years ago
Have to check and revert. Thanks!
vibbaxi 3 years ago
is this dvd available in planet m??
healerneil87 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
can you read this? go to my person--al page to see me n-a-k-e-d (meetyourfling) c o m
2208144
prabhaka
FANXOE 3 years ago
the person on the dholak is fateh singh ji. teacher at mothers international school. gem of a person and an incredible artist.
devysharma 3 years ago
That is not a Dholak Mr. Devysharma. It's a Pakhawaj.
Mryaggi1 3 years ago
incredible
danielconant1 3 years ago
Oh my god... It's melodious...
djandry983 4 years ago
Hello! Thanks for your comments and support. This DVD is already out. We shall be bringing out another Ustad Vilayat Khan DVD in the first quarter around March / April.
vibbaxi 4 years ago
Hello thanks for your answer...
however, this DVD can not be found from the website indicated...am I wrong? thanks again.
Houz23 4 years ago
My apologies! For some r4eason the CD version of this title has been uploaded but not the DVd. we will address that matter shortly. Thanks for your feedback.
vibbaxi 4 years ago
Hi ! No problem for the feedback, I appreciate your work and now the purchase of the DVD is working. What a great piece of news that Ustad Vilayat Khan DVD will be release in March/April ! I have all the DVD from Ustadji and I am waiting impatiently the next one !
Thanks !
Houz23 4 years ago
Hello!
Navras Records job is very good...is there any other plans to release other DVD of Ustad Vilayat Khan?..i have all of them and it remains a precious treasure for the soul...
I am waiting also for the release of this one with Ustad Amjad Ali Khan...
Houz23 4 years ago
Thank you for your feedback. The Amjad Ali Khan DVD "Romancing The Rains" is already available in PAL format and can be ordered from Navras website where there is a great sale on at present. Next Ustad Vilayat Khan DVD is planned for release later this year at the earliest. It will be a performance in Raga Malkauns at Royal Festival Hall, London, accompanied by Pandit Swapan Chaudhury on tabla.
vibbaxi 3 years ago