CrossTalk: Afghan Exit 2.0

[AFosterBoy]

This military analyst is totally true....Hats of to you sir

[SpyWizard2]

Taliban not a threat? on the contrary they are a major threat to Central Asia, Caucuses and the Middle East. Soviets are idiots lol

[IAMDOPED]

wow i start to like that show the military analist is nuts

[averageworkinggal]

I'm glad to see that I caused another crackpot to meltdown mentally.

[NativeNYCer]

Walid does an excellent job defending the fight against terrorism. Our enemies are united and vigilant and we need to be vigilant against them. The world needs to know the truth, understand that we will be at war and need to have a presence in the Middle East for a long time. We'd love for our troops to come home but in the world today they will never be coming home, they will be fighting in the Middle East or Africa or anywhere else the enemies of freedom and democracy call their home..

[averageworkinggal]

lousyskier:

I'm not Jewish and I've never been a Democrat so I clearly am not a "neocon" since I don't meet those two prerequisites.

But you sure are a lunatic fringe crackpot

The 9/11 hijackers were AlQaeda terrorists that trained in Afghanistan and the 9/11 attack was run out of Afghanistan by Bin Laden through Yemen, idiot.

Bin Laden was holed up in Afghanistan, idiot.

Afghanistan refuse to turn Bin Laden over to the US so the US had to go get him, idiot.

[Pokhton]

its your own creation because al kaida was supported by american and installed in many countrys used in bosnia etc and i dont think it was al kaida it was your own goverment that blows your yewish people in the twin towers up not 1 afghan was involved in this attack the plan was also not mad ein afghanistan :) but you losing the war in iraq and afghanistan and iam very happy about that you criminal american paying with your life for the mistake to attack the lions in afghanistan

[Pokhton]

great uppload !! great uppload!!!! bravo bravo

[pakhtooni]

@Pokhton afghan should be given to the afghan people. who are the afghans? the arabs? Iranians? Punjabis? Uzbeks? Tajiks? Urdu Speakers? IT makes no difference if the amercan went because We as pashtuns will not be in the driving seat in our own country it would be other muslim natons in the name of islam. Peace in Afghanistan is to unite Pakhtuns on both sides and the official language of the land should be pashto

[PhoenicanSailor]

Funny how they have a Syrian Baathist in there XD

[PhoenicanSailor]

Agreed SpyWizard2, the Cold War is over..

[SpyWizard2]

Taliban is not a threat? wtf is this Soviet Officer saying? I mean really how dumb could Russia be by filling their officer ranks with ex-soviets

[SpyWizard2]

Besides the so-called RT military expert was using American expressions with a heavy Russian accent such as "read my lips," and "cheap shot" looking like an ex Soviet propagandist. The Baathist "lawyer" was out of a state ran TV in Syria. I'd suggest to Professor Phares not to appear on these idiotic shows and I suggest to RT to dire this clown Lavelle before the channel would lose more credibility because of this relic of the Cold war

[JosifVStalin]

more and more americans tune in to rt because they cannot stand the fox cnn bullshit propaganda,deal with it

[PhoenicanSailor]

False i just came a across this while trying to find out what RT had to say..the cold war is over stalin, and communism is failing.

[Pokhton]

and soon american imperialism too.the afghans defeated the soviets and they will defeat your americans

[SpyWizard2]

How unprofessional from Lavelle to act like a a party to the panel and scream cutting Phares off every time he was analyzing an issue. Probably Lavelle thought he was brilliant, not knowing that his show was watched by a majority of English speaking people who railed his method of Cold war propaganda. Afghans I spoke with thought the Taliban propaganda could even do better than RT's Lavelle.

[SpyWizard2]

And he invites Professor Walid Phares, a foremost expert on Jihadi terrorism. Lavelle and his acolytes forms a gang of three against Phares, who by the way fends them off. Viewers, including young Russians have sided with Phares while Baathists, Taliban, and Communists from the KGB era sided with outdated three erratic commentators.

[SpyWizard2]

What a shame for Russia Today to give him air time and let him lower the level of the network. Look at the thuggish setting. Peter Lavelle invite two of his buddies, one who is a Baathist cadre representing the Assad regime in Damascus and the other one is a former KGB officer who had served in Afghanistan and is circulating conspiracy theories about America.

[SpyWizard2]

What a dumb show and what dumber anchor. This guy sounds like the worse anchors on al Jazeera. but he is worse. Because he thinks he is really convincing people and setting traps to experts.

[flyhead2]

Phares was simply out of his depth and humiliated himself in this suicide-mission. He really should venture beyond the safe environs of Fox's Satanic Disney-land dreamscape.

[gimmebullion]

Wow....so many armchair generals who don't even know what troops are actually doing over there.

There's no direction. Troops just walk around using people's property to scope the territory, and anyone who looks at them or takes notice gets a bullet to the head.

Some farmer gets curious....he gets dead from a sniper.

A bunch of simple illiterate farmers in mud walled properties without electricity get sniped from hundreds of yards away while going about their daily lives.

warped....

[FreiheitKampfer]

gahh the host is irritating..

otherwise: GO RT!!

[ChinaRedDrag0n]

He's a French Faggot

[Wasp16mm]

The U.S. will fail in afghanistan, The U.S. will fall and mexico pot-farms whorehouses

trailer parks and drugs will finish off america.

only after the U.S. is gone and the E.U. becomes a 4th reich only then will the world miss U$!

[agubaia]

Yes they did. Even if our government let em do it, they came to our land to kill people, same in London, and even worst in Madrid.

We all know the CIA and FBI done nothing to avoid the terrorist attack to NYC, very suspicious.

But the terrorist were real.

Same with a damn nigger trying to blow a plane in Christmas. What's wrong with this people.

Then when US army invade their country we're the evil invader ?

Al Qaeda want slavery and destruction and people suffering, just like Hussain

[luisnitro91]

The Taliban is a group of local Malissia that resist any foreign or domestic occupation, they are villager gathered together all around afghanistan to difend their country, their land, they call them self Freedom Fighters. They are not terrorist like P.Bush and Obama keeps saying, 9/11 was an inside job. We Americans should learn from the afghanistan people how to difend their country as well with the same patriotism.

[agubaia]

Its simple, If the Taliban is defeated, USA will be out of Afghanistan.

The problem is, nobody, no nation wants to help USA, Means are agree with the terrorists. If the Taliban is not defeated will take over the region again.

Russia should help to stop the Taliban and China, then leave the people of the region alone, let it be a nation

[vtkrey]

agubaia, you are slightly confused, USA is the reason the Taliban exsists, they will not be defeated, so long as the US continues its current policies, Taliban will remain.

[agubaia]

Confused? Why? This is war against terrorism.

This People attacked America, England and Spain. What US current policies has to do with that?  Until there's a proof the Taliban has been defeated, American Troops won't move out of Afghanistan. No matter who's the president or who's in congress or unless America begins another bigger conflict with another nation, it could be IRAN, they are helping the Taliban for sure.

[Sundrumify]

I salute RT to bring this up, although:

Sorry, but this is a very emotional, not necessarily helpful discussion. Why? It lacks so many background infos, aspects. There are a lot of vids out about this topic: Worldwide Drug Business, Geo-Politics, Imperialism?

Why are "we" in Afghanistan?

Lisa from Munich

[luisnitro91]

@Sundrumify Well I believe is a very helpful information from RT cause they are telling the people the truth about Taliban and Alcaeda is American made and is long gone since the death of Mujahideen and Osama Bin Laden since 2001 still after their death they still use these stories to justify 9/11 massacre so they could occupied territory like in Iraq and now Afghanistan to get to Iran. Afghanistan people don't need democracy the Afghan people are already free people in their way not the U.S way

[Sundrumify]

@luisnitro91

Thanks so much for your response. I agree, RT is always helpful. I salute them!

The U.S. has a global military presence and economic lever that it wields with relative virtuosity. It is skillful at aggression without appearing aggressive.

... to be continued

[Sundrumify]

It protects and defends, and sometimes it will do this in a pre-emptive strike and sometimes in a reactive countermeasure that is usually at a force response that is several fold the original intensity. Americas self interests have become the standard of the free world, and there are those who fear it will dominate to the point of imperialism. What about Russia? Oh, that is another question?!

Happy New Year from Munich,

Lisa

[luisnitro91]

Bush senior and Bush son as well Obama have said determinately that they want the New World Order, (ONE WORLD GOVERNMENT) publicly around the world. So yes they want territory occupation ever since they occupied Hawaii then Germany, Japan, Iraq and others including Colombia. Now U.S CIA helped the Taliban and Alcaeda to move the Russians out of their way for the U.S Arab world domination. Taliban and Alcaeda is just an excuse for the U.S justify their presence in the Arab world.

[Sundrumify]

Dear Friend,

co-incidently, I got an excellent vid:

"What motivated the 9/11 Hijackers?" It is available on my channel.

Happy New Year! United we stand, for a better world. Lisa

[thomas290]

Interesting arguments. How can they put in a puppet government and call it stabilizing the region? This nation building is whats costing jobs in the U.S.A Sad! We are going to pay with our soldiers blood and for the sins for murdering innocents.

[Sundrumify]

"His remarks came only a day after the German defence minister said he favoured a withdrawal timetable, amid growing signs that the Germans may refuse to significantly enlarge their troop contingent. 'If the Afghanistan conference in London turns purely into a conference on providing troops, I won't be traveling there,' said Westerwelle in an interview with the German weekly magazine Stern. The report appeared on Stern's website.

[Sundrumify]

At least, German Ministers learned from our history. Mr. Westerwelle should attend that conference and make his point clear there:

Berlin: "German Foreign Minister Guido Westerwelle will refuse to attend next month's conference on Afghanistan if its agenda is limited to discussing a troop surge, he said in an interview published Monday.

... to be continued

[XBionic1955]

Evgeniy doesnt look like human at all, but I loved this guy =))

[averageworkinggal]

This Sabah guy is even more pathetic than Khrushchev.

[averageworkinggal]

Khrushchev just lacks any big picture thinking ability.

Phares gave the clear, coherent big picture view.

Either the US is there helping the Afghans or the Taliban returns and inflames muslim radicalism throughout Asia.

Khrushchev is just pathetic.

[averageworkinggal]

Khrushchev was babbling incoherently in response to Phares.

The USSR was not attacked by Afghanistan.

It invaded.

What happened after it invaded did not change the fact that it invaded.

[averageworkinggal]

Food Fight !!!

[xandras1111]

Man... I wish O'reilly would be the host... he would destroy the anti-war guy

[johnqpublic81]

I think O'reilly would have trouble, he doesn't think these people speak english!

[flyhead2]

I doubt that O'Reilly would do well. One of the pre-requisites for O'Reilly is to have an audience of ignorant brain-dead morons who respond like slobbering Pavlovian puppets to senseless catch-words and regurgitated lies.

[GeminiAzules]

The host keeps interrupting people when he hears something he doesn't like. Anyone who does this knows he can be proved wrong.

Let them speak!

[JukemDrawles89]

Evgeny khrushchev is a wise man he speaks the truth