i can see why they cut this. they wanted you to basically hate the phantom if you did no further research after watching the movie. they tried to conform to the "evil is always evil and good always prevails" frame
@AstraeosProductions ALW wrote it for the film, but it didn't actually make it in. You can hear the same tune sung by Minnie Driver in the end credits.
I think they cut this out cuz they knew if they kept it it would make all the people who like the phantom even more upset that she chose the other guy insted.
;( why didn't they put this into the movie?!?!?!? It totally sets the mood of how the phantom wants you to feel. He is sharing with us the majority of his life in 2:18!! It's so sad!! And as always Gerard Butler did an amazing job singing this!!
@BetrayedPunkGirl Erik is the phantom's real name XD and its eriK not eriC (sry i'm obsessed and it drives me mad when its spelled wrong) and its an extra that didnt make it into the movie.
If Eric really was so handsome and sexual, as Butler - Raul would lose, without any word. At Phantom's feet would lie both Christina, and Meg and madam Giry and all other female audience.:)))
This would been cool at the end after the credits as an extra scene after everything had happened, and to show that he will always love christine. Oh how I love this movie!!! what a good song <3
@ASDG3763 A crazy guy who hasn't seen the light of day for years, who pun-jabs people for fun and is something of an arsonist? I wish you both happiness.
Such a beautiful song, even if a tad sad. Such a wonderful voice Gerard Butler has. Makes me swoon when I hear it. Gerard as The Phantom....LOVE <3!!!
Now why the heck would they cut this out?!!! *sniffle* it's almost as heartbreaking as when Erik listened behind the statue to All I Ask of You!!! Awwww!!
they use this song in the movie! they use it before the credits begin and raoul sees the flower that the phantom put on her grave.... just learnt that now :P but gerard butler doesn't sing... :(
yes why??amazing song.......and your speech is absolutly right where is christine listening to this song?????this song made me love him more and more and more
@Anna2bd it was writen my somone else and they didn't get what they wanted and told Mr. Lloyd Webber where to shove it ... thats why this absolutly epic song is not in the film.
er hat eine wundervoll Stimme ich kann nicht verstehen wie jemand von so einem lied unberührt bleiben kann, musik bedeutet soviel mehr, er beschreibt gerade seine Gefühl für sie. keiner würde ihm uhören, nur SIE. es ist das wohl schönste vertonte liebesgeständnis der welt, wie kann man es nicht in den Film aufnehemn?!?!?
Und sonst.. Ich liebe dieses Lied. Ich liebe Die Stimme Von Gerard Butler, Ich <3 Gerard Butler und vorallem seine Rolle als das Phantom. =)
Danke Fürs Reinstellen <3
Im Übrigen finde ichs schade das hier so viele Videos Nich mehr ad oder wegen dem Copyright halt . =( Dann müsste ich immer den film einlegen :O Aber das mag ich nich O.O
Hat villt jmd ne seite mit Gerard Butlers Liedern in Poto ? Danke im vorraus =D
I know how the phantom feels, having Passion and desire to have the one woman you would hive anything for and renounce, the phantom I believe has an obsession of love which can be turned into anger and hate depending on situations, that is how much one man wants and needs a woman he desires and years.
Reminds me of me when I was lonely and isolated in the truck as a truck driver, marisol my bibita was always there for me whenever I needed care , she rendered care and confort, thats why I love her so, no one would listen to my troubles, but she was there, even tho I have never seen her physically just by VIA text and telephone but more text I fell in love with this woman, I loved from the soul and of the heart, and I still do. How do I long the day she feels and loves me.
oh great. yet another scene that makes the fated end of the phantom's heartbreak even more tragic. "she saw my loneliness. shared in my emptiness" she was an orphan. he was an outcast. she alone would listen to his music, so he held on for as long as he could. say what you want. the phantom might have been a villain, but he was not the devil.
this song is at the end of the film but it's sung by a woman and it has completely different lyrics, they probably thought the song was too good to not put it in at all :)
Beautiful song, but taking it out was the right call. It adds a dimension of sympathy for the Phantom that isn't needed. He already gets too much, IMO.
What he called "love" for Christine was really a violent obsession. He constantly manipulated Christine for his own purposes. It was never about Christine; it was always about himself. That, folks, isn't love.
The Phantom was the devil, as Aristarxos85 says, but he was masquerading as an angel--and the character masterfully fools the masses.
Good point. But never underestimate the devil's skills...the fallen angel is perhaps the most seductive character ever, and it makes perfect sense that he knows exactly what he has to do to gain Christine's (and our) sympathy. But leaving the devil out, could the Phantom simply be the perfect example of an outcast, who never gave up the dream of love, though no-one ever cared to teach him what love is? I think that might be his curse...and that certainly calls for sympathy, IMO :-)
@MklintM Point well taken, sir. Certainly, we can't underestimate the Devil's capabilities. :-)
And, yes, one could certainly view the Phantom in the light of an outcast who never gave up love's dream, though I'd still point out that it couldn't and wouldn't excuse his actions.
The ability to look at a story and character from different perspectives is part of what makes art so amazing!
Why on earth did they delete this song from the movie?. . . it would have worked so well since during the credits they play "Learn to be Lonely"~ it would have made it more obvious his reason for loving her. . .
Think so too - it´s a very great song... You can hear the melody in the movie, after the song Masquerade, when gerard butler goes downstairs, a little second before he take christine´s necklace... but the whole video in the movie would be great... don´t understand them...
Why the heck was this cut out of the movie?!?!?!! This shows a lot of His feelings for her and explains so much!!!!! They make him out to be some raging psychopath!!!! This should have been in the movie!!!! >:(
It's sad that this wasn't left in the movie. It shows that the Phantom loved her for more than just her voice, and really adds to his character. It shows that despite him being childish in his mentality, that he understands deeper emotions outside of hate and is able to comprehend what love is... even if he doesn't seem to fully comprehend the purpose of mutual feelings...
@TamaraLee13 Well, seeing as how it's all ready made, I'm assuming they all ready had a place for it. I'm assuming this was made for either before Christine was taken to his lair, or right after she left it.
As I have seen most of Gerry Butlers movies, his singing voice and acting talents are beyond words that I can describe, including some funny commercials he's been in the past. This song should have been kept in this movie for a more personal touch with the phantom's feelings, and Gerry's tone fitted that well, probably even better than any other "phantoms" who have recorded in the past..This changes some viewers of how he really felt(not as a monster), but shows how compassionate he was..
BIG MISTAKE: they NEED to put this in the movie!!! It adds another entire dimension to the Phantom character, and will surely be appreciated by the audience! What a missed opportunity :(
its the tune of learn to be lonely only with different lyrics this one is sung by him ^ (Gerard Butler) learn to be lonely is sung by Minnie Driver (Carlotta)
I'm listening, and thinking, WHY THE HELL DID THEY REMOVE THIS SONG!?!?!?! If there's a really good and emotional part about the Phantom, here it is, why delete??? No really? why??
I think the reason they didn't keep it was that it's such a change of pace from the other songs. Also, I think Andrew Lloyd Webber had total creative rights to the show, and this song was not in the original musical.
OMG! If I had seen that before I would have freaked out!!!! seriously. this is soo beautiful. even when I heard the song from minnie driver (which plays in the end), I almost had to cry... but if I had heard the phantom sing... OMG!!! <3
This probably would have been right before he goes to loosen the chandelier. He's wearing the same outfit. I really wish this could have stayed. I know it wasn't in the musical, but it's just so beautiful and heartbreaking.
Gerald did the best job that he could (given that he was completely miscast...) but I still think his singing voice is too weak and completely disengaging/uninspiring to be the Phantom.
Aghhh this soooo should have been in the movie!!! It would have fit perfectly, and it would help define the Phantom's character even more. It explains -why- exactly he picked Christine, and why he loves her so much. I was kind of wondering that before, and this explains it perfectly.
He trusted her and felt that she understood him, which is why she is irreplaceable to him.
The song also makes him more love-able (not that he wasn't before, but even more so). It should have been kept in.
im suppose to sing these song, but everytime i sing it i cant stop crying, it usually starts when i say, "i learned to listen", im such a baby with this song,lol
where was the song suppose to be? that so should have been in the movie? i think this might to have been shown while christine was singing think of me i bet or while raoul and christine were singing in the chapel befoe don juan
in the german version of this song, sings jana werner ( voice of christine ) the text. it surprised me, that the phatom sings this song in the original version. but...i think gerard butler is a great singer ;)
Gyaaaaaah why can you hit the "Like" button only once???
MrVampireLover18 1 day ago
this needs to be it the movie like if you think they should make anther version with this in it
1969wrestling 6 days ago
I wish they put that in movie
AGWinxKH 1 week ago
i love the phantom, i would listen to him
taekwondo104 1 week ago 2
I want to marry him!
Elisabeth0893 2 weeks ago 2
i would listen...i would understand...
coolahug 2 weeks ago 3
Dear Phantom,
I feel your pain, bro.
AlecZacJustinwWife 2 weeks ago 9
why the hell wasnt this in the movie!!!!!!!
iluvskittles61 3 weeks ago
i listen!
banger4256 3 weeks ago
Someone please get this man a kitten ...
Cooliee2000thecool 1 month ago 34
Maybe they didnt include it in the movie because it wasnt in the original performances?
awsome8118 1 month ago
I want this song!
Derek13241 1 month ago
I listened!You ignored me.My world is shattered.Thanks Erik :(
MeLoveandPeace 1 month ago 3
that one always makes me cry
Kibafan1100 1 month ago
Madam Giry?
TheSpongebobgo 1 month ago
@TheSpongebobgo No, Christine.
DrakeMarwick 1 month ago
this was so cute ;D but why wasnt it in the movie >:(
XxXChikis 1 month ago
Why. Was. This. Deleted? It shows Erik's true feelings and how he isn't an antagonist in the movie. Ugh.
Phantomluvr23 1 month ago
@sandrazocarr because learn to be lonely is the second name for this song o3o
klgrif 1 month ago
i LOVE Gerard Butler
Dullage12345678910 1 month ago
THIS SONG SHOULD BE IN THE FILM!!!! i <3 phantom...
Misaaak123456789 1 month ago
I LOVE PHANTOM! He's soo cute.
SuperPhantomlove 2 months ago in playlist The 2004 Phantom film 4
OMG! And it has the melody of "Learn to be lonely"
Thank you so much for uploading it! :')
sandraazocar 2 months ago in playlist The 2004 Phantom film
So sad. I hear you Erik-3
MikalaS18 2 months ago
This has the same melody as "Learn to be lonely" at the end of the movie O.o"
CosplayChroniclesPro 3 months ago
i can see why they cut this. they wanted you to basically hate the phantom if you did no further research after watching the movie. they tried to conform to the "evil is always evil and good always prevails" frame
ThatRandomArtist 3 months ago 4
They should have left this in the movie... That ticks me off
Darkmystik1 3 months ago 2
i always listen and watch Gerard! swoons :)
LadzMalayangPinoy 3 months ago 2
It. Is. Asam
Emokage15 4 months ago
aaaawwww Gerry :3
VeganFolkFreak 4 months ago
What? is this song in the play?
bnixisbest 5 months ago
@bnixisbest Nope.
leopardstar5556 1 week ago
beautiful. I hear you Gerry!
princessleia19 5 months ago
They should have had this at the end of the end credits o3o
Gahoyify 6 months ago 2
Wonderful song. I almost crying.
♥ Gerard
16DarkLady16 6 months ago 2
I LOVE U GERRY! <3
p3ddomaster 6 months ago
Where did they come up with this...It isn't in the Broadway show.
AstraeosProductions 6 months ago
@AstraeosProductions ALW wrote it for the film, but it didn't actually make it in. You can hear the same tune sung by Minnie Driver in the end credits.
leopardstar5556 1 week ago
He is the best Phantom! And they should kept this song!
NenadlPopovic 7 months ago 4
Why did they delete this! How dare they Delete I song that GB (Phantom) was singing! >:(
Phantomchild97 7 months ago 2
why did they delete this song??? It s beautifull
cyanide336 7 months ago 3
I think they cut this out cuz they knew if they kept it it would make all the people who like the phantom even more upset that she chose the other guy insted.
waterfariy1 7 months ago in playlist angel of music 3
oh my freaken gawd. He is so freaken handsome. unbelievable
34RiverStone 7 months ago
;( why didn't they put this into the movie?!?!?!? It totally sets the mood of how the phantom wants you to feel. He is sharing with us the majority of his life in 2:18!! It's so sad!! And as always Gerard Butler did an amazing job singing this!!
Jodec1994 7 months ago
oh my god :(
leedaine 7 months ago
Questions i <3 Phantom of the Opera but i still dont know
who is this Eric guy?
When does this song appear in the film? or doesnt it is it like a extra they didnt put in?
Please if u know tell me im confused
BetrayedPunkGirl 7 months ago
@BetrayedPunkGirl Erik is the phantom's real name XD and its eriK not eriC (sry i'm obsessed and it drives me mad when its spelled wrong) and its an extra that didnt make it into the movie.
MusicloverJ123 7 months ago
Phantom rocks i would go for him!
kaaazuuuma 7 months ago 3
I start to hate Christine in the end why because:
1. she went for a guy that sings like a girl
2.The poor phantom is left alone with no friends
3.the phantom lived such a sad life she cant just make him happy
kaaazuuuma 7 months ago
@kaaazuuuma AGREED. TOTALLY!
34RiverStone 7 months ago
If Eric really was so handsome and sexual, as Butler - Raul would lose, without any word. At Phantom's feet would lie both Christina, and Meg and madam Giry and all other female audience.:)))
23smell 7 months ago
I wouldve chosen phantom if I were christine
annagirl1996 7 months ago
Aw Erik!! Screw Christine, I'M listening!!
weetoy115 7 months ago 5
This would been cool at the end after the credits as an extra scene after everything had happened, and to show that he will always love christine. Oh how I love this movie!!! what a good song <3
belleoftheball21 7 months ago
If I was Christine I would have chosen The Phantom, no doubt about it.
ASDG3763 7 months ago 2
@ASDG3763 A crazy guy who hasn't seen the light of day for years, who pun-jabs people for fun and is something of an arsonist? I wish you both happiness.
Eruadhiel 7 months ago
@Eruadhiel I am a total Phantom girl...But your comment made me laugh so hard..."Pun-jabs people!" Ahaha! xD :')
EternalchildMJ 7 months ago
he has an angel voice
is his face really scared? under his mask
Miyuke1234 8 months ago
@Miyuke1234 the face isnt even that bad
Ikswotnerkop 7 months ago
This is a really good song i wish that they put it in the movie
Allsortsmoviefan 8 months ago
Such a beautiful song, even if a tad sad. Such a wonderful voice Gerard Butler has. Makes me swoon when I hear it. Gerard as The Phantom....LOVE <3!!!
OperaGhostAngel 8 months ago
Now why the heck would they cut this out?!!! *sniffle* it's almost as heartbreaking as when Erik listened behind the statue to All I Ask of You!!! Awwww!!
NightRoseNightStar 8 months ago 3
I think this is the first Youtube video that I've ever seen that has 0 dislikes!
and for good reason...Gerard Butler is the best Phantom of all time!
oOoAshieoOo 8 months ago 2
Gerard Butler! I've never know that he can sing :D Cool :) it sounds good . I love him ♥
97Putzi 8 months ago
Gerard Butler.....I Love this guy xxxxx
goochibabe 8 months ago
"sniff" Christine, you IDIOT!
shygirl9514 8 months ago 2
aaaaaaaweeeee!!!!!
I LOOOOVE HIIIM!!!!!
<3 poor thing
13nickrock 8 months ago
the phantom is my all time fav. character yours too? like this
phantomsfreak 9 months ago 5
they use this song in the movie! they use it before the credits begin and raoul sees the flower that the phantom put on her grave.... just learnt that now :P but gerard butler doesn't sing... :(
CardiffGirl123 9 months ago
i think i've fallen in love with the phantomm...
I wish i were Christine to make the best decission...LOVE THE PHANTOM 4EVER!!
AzabatrrA 9 months ago 4
yes why??amazing song.......and your speech is absolutly right where is christine listening to this song?????this song made me love him more and more and more
Aya1994111 9 months ago
why is this song deleted??it is amazing and show the sensitivity of the phantom that christine was not able to see!!
Anna2bd 9 months ago 67
@Anna2bd I agree that he is not completely evil, but he kills people just to prove a point. He crazy
perrid13 4 months ago
@Anna2bd it was writen my somone else and they didn't get what they wanted and told Mr. Lloyd Webber where to shove it ... thats why this absolutly epic song is not in the film.
LordBane1701 3 months ago
@Anna2bd Not to mention in the sequel he gambles away their fortune and drinks too much!!! Raoul never deserved Christine!!
PhantomFan1a 3 months ago 3
Omgosh he's so sweet and such a gentleman
Dear Phantom,
I'd listen to you! Any day!
;)
bellydancebabe1234 10 months ago 40
er hat eine wundervoll Stimme ich kann nicht verstehen wie jemand von so einem lied unberührt bleiben kann, musik bedeutet soviel mehr, er beschreibt gerade seine Gefühl für sie. keiner würde ihm uhören, nur SIE. es ist das wohl schönste vertonte liebesgeständnis der welt, wie kann man es nicht in den Film aufnehemn?!?!?
Luem7 10 months ago 3
@Luem7 Ohja, Ich bin ganz deiner Meinung! =))
Und sonst.. Ich liebe dieses Lied. Ich liebe Die Stimme Von Gerard Butler, Ich <3 Gerard Butler und vorallem seine Rolle als das Phantom. =)
Danke Fürs Reinstellen <3
Im Übrigen finde ichs schade das hier so viele Videos Nich mehr ad oder wegen dem Copyright halt . =( Dann müsste ich immer den film einlegen :O Aber das mag ich nich O.O
Hat villt jmd ne seite mit Gerard Butlers Liedern in Poto ? Danke im vorraus =D
Raudifan 9 months ago
Great song
dandalion29 10 months ago
I know how the phantom feels, having Passion and desire to have the one woman you would hive anything for and renounce, the phantom I believe has an obsession of love which can be turned into anger and hate depending on situations, that is how much one man wants and needs a woman he desires and years.
dandalion29 10 months ago
Heart warming song.
dandalion29 10 months ago 3
Reminds me of me when I was lonely and isolated in the truck as a truck driver, marisol my bibita was always there for me whenever I needed care , she rendered care and confort, thats why I love her so, no one would listen to my troubles, but she was there, even tho I have never seen her physically just by VIA text and telephone but more text I fell in love with this woman, I loved from the soul and of the heart, and I still do. How do I long the day she feels and loves me.
dandalion29 10 months ago
oh great. yet another scene that makes the fated end of the phantom's heartbreak even more tragic. "she saw my loneliness. shared in my emptiness" she was an orphan. he was an outcast. she alone would listen to his music, so he held on for as long as he could. say what you want. the phantom might have been a villain, but he was not the devil.
PeaceRocker01 10 months ago 4
It's such a beautiful song. I wish they hadn't deleted it from the movie.
ThePrincessziah1 10 months ago 2
Totally wished that they would have kept this song in. It's absolutly beautiful.
PHOENIXoftheMOON 11 months ago
THANK GOD ITS WAS DELETED TERRIBLE THIS ITSELF PUTS SHAME TO PHANTOM
TheLaurenk12 11 months ago
5 minuits ago I came back from italy!! And I bought a Phantom mask from Vinice!! =DD
SweetDeath777 11 months ago
this song is at the end of the film but it's sung by a woman and it has completely different lyrics, they probably thought the song was too good to not put it in at all :)
StarDancerLB 11 months ago
Beautiful song, but taking it out was the right call. It adds a dimension of sympathy for the Phantom that isn't needed. He already gets too much, IMO.
What he called "love" for Christine was really a violent obsession. He constantly manipulated Christine for his own purposes. It was never about Christine; it was always about himself. That, folks, isn't love.
The Phantom was the devil, as Aristarxos85 says, but he was masquerading as an angel--and the character masterfully fools the masses.
BFarmer1980 11 months ago 2
@BFarmer1980
Good point. But never underestimate the devil's skills...the fallen angel is perhaps the most seductive character ever, and it makes perfect sense that he knows exactly what he has to do to gain Christine's (and our) sympathy. But leaving the devil out, could the Phantom simply be the perfect example of an outcast, who never gave up the dream of love, though no-one ever cared to teach him what love is? I think that might be his curse...and that certainly calls for sympathy, IMO :-)
MklintM 10 months ago
@MklintM Point well taken, sir. Certainly, we can't underestimate the Devil's capabilities. :-)
And, yes, one could certainly view the Phantom in the light of an outcast who never gave up love's dream, though I'd still point out that it couldn't and wouldn't excuse his actions.
The ability to look at a story and character from different perspectives is part of what makes art so amazing!
BFarmer1980 9 months ago
what a background..
When the devil falls in love..
Christine was so stupid to dump such an artist for someone who just cared only for her appearence.
Why did they deleted it?
Instead of that they could delete Raoul thus Christine would stay with the Phantom!
Aristarxos85 11 months ago 3
@Aristarxos85 agree
CandyAndromeda 11 months ago
Why on earth did they delete this song from the movie?. . . it would have worked so well since during the credits they play "Learn to be Lonely"~ it would have made it more obvious his reason for loving her. . .
Momo9357 11 months ago
Think so too - it´s a very great song... You can hear the melody in the movie, after the song Masquerade, when gerard butler goes downstairs, a little second before he take christine´s necklace... but the whole video in the movie would be great... don´t understand them...
filmfreakk13 1 year ago
Christine dumped the Phantom for a guy that sings like a girl!
unicornnnnnn 1 year ago 130
@unicornnnnnn actually, it was the phantom was the one who sang like a girl
quantumXphysikz 10 months ago
@unicornnnnnn .. And looks like a girl ! >.<
Raudifan 9 months ago 4
@unicornnnnnn justin bieber lol
nmuninzo 7 months ago
@unicornnnnnn He looks like one too! :)
LilyBelle1998 3 months ago
damn... if i could, i'd tie myself to the phantom!!
gothchick78 1 year ago
Gerard Butler has the most romantic voice ever listened in the story of cinema...
I THINK I'VE FELL IN LOVE...
AzabatrrA 1 year ago 5
I like this song. :-)
Tattninchen 1 year ago
IS THIS realy mister Gerard Buttler singing?!?! Awsome voice
TheEsti1987 1 year ago 2
Why the heck was this cut out of the movie?!?!?!! This shows a lot of His feelings for her and explains so much!!!!! They make him out to be some raging psychopath!!!! This should have been in the movie!!!! >:(
xXbELLiKiNZXx 1 year ago 2
Do you know about when in the movie this would have been in? By the looks of it, maybe just before Don Juan Triumphant? Maybe?
SongDragonHeart 1 year ago
this is sorta lame
mcmordorable 1 year ago
It's sad that this wasn't left in the movie. It shows that the Phantom loved her for more than just her voice, and really adds to his character. It shows that despite him being childish in his mentality, that he understands deeper emotions outside of hate and is able to comprehend what love is... even if he doesn't seem to fully comprehend the purpose of mutual feelings...
offensivebehaviors 1 year ago 3
@offensivebehaviors dang i agree with you!!!
danitzaedithmejia 1 year ago
If this scene wasnt deleted where would it have gone?
TamaraLee13 1 year ago 3
@TamaraLee13 Well, seeing as how it's all ready made, I'm assuming they all ready had a place for it. I'm assuming this was made for either before Christine was taken to his lair, or right after she left it.
offensivebehaviors 1 year ago 2
As I have seen most of Gerry Butlers movies, his singing voice and acting talents are beyond words that I can describe, including some funny commercials he's been in the past. This song should have been kept in this movie for a more personal touch with the phantom's feelings, and Gerry's tone fitted that well, probably even better than any other "phantoms" who have recorded in the past..This changes some viewers of how he really felt(not as a monster), but shows how compassionate he was..
TheProudmomof4 1 year ago 4
wutda!!...LEONIDAS CAN SING?!..hahahha...but its cool GERRY is a great singer! ^^
PatrickLoveJen21 1 year ago
i love you Gerard!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
xianneh 1 year ago
@xianneh mee too
9092shugga 1 year ago
BIG MISTAKE: they NEED to put this in the movie!!! It adds another entire dimension to the Phantom character, and will surely be appreciated by the audience! What a missed opportunity :(
Mnemosyne01 1 year ago 6
This song shoul have been left in the movie as it's so pretty. God, he's so good
looking-in away you wish she had stayed with him nelliebell49
nelliebell49 1 year ago
I Love This Song, Gerard Did A Fantastic Job it Melted My Heart
AshleyLynn829 1 year ago
Comment removed
ClarissasAngle 1 year ago
Gerard <3
SlowlyJordison 1 year ago
i mean even if they didn't think it fit in with that one scene or the movie they should've put it in the end!!!
SweetLittleElise 1 year ago
Why was this taken outt?!>:O
cazygirl8 1 year ago
Bawling like a baby and being turned on at the same time is a strange yet delightful combination. :D
larrenlew 1 year ago 55
His voice adds to how amazing he is...sigh.
RiotGirlHeather 1 year ago
:D I loove Phantom of the Opera!! I havent seen it in like 3 years!!!!!!!!!!!! They deleted this!!
immamyspacegangsta 1 year ago
i think the reason they deleated it is cos it wudnt fit any where
jaykeincp 1 year ago
I wanna hug him :(
Luenzki 1 year ago 4
so beautiful!! Should have been left in. Why did they take it out? no fair
JoanneLBivone1 1 year ago
its the tune of learn to be lonely only with different lyrics this one is sung by him ^ (Gerard Butler) learn to be lonely is sung by Minnie Driver (Carlotta)
allvideos58 1 year ago
Ohh, It's the same theme from "learn to be lonely" in the credits.
Egsggum 1 year ago
i love this i'm so sorry they deleted this from the movie it would have been so beautiful if they kept it
goldenopera 1 year ago
i think it was in the end
goldenopera 1 year ago
i think it was in the end dontbeanash
goldenopera 1 year ago
When would this have been in the movie? Like, what part?
DontBeAnAsh 1 year ago
@DontBeAnAsh The end...
immamyspacegangsta 1 year ago
They should have kept this in the movie!
sakuramoon17 1 year ago
errr this song is'nt in the orginal song but its a rather good song none the less!!!
CUTHBERT15 1 year ago
I'm listening, and thinking, WHY THE HELL DID THEY REMOVE THIS SONG!?!?!?! If there's a really good and emotional part about the Phantom, here it is, why delete??? No really? why??
Misssticalbook 1 year ago 2
awwwwwwww this song <3
famouskphantom 1 year ago
Hello, my name is Noone, I would listen but theres only 80 people named noone who will listen!
ChristinaDestler 1 year ago
Erik,dont say no one is listening.Im 12 and I definately would listen.
balletluve 1 year ago
this made my heart melt.
xxnikky666xx 1 year ago
@xxnikky666xx mine too.Firt break,then melt.
balletluve 1 year ago
I think the reason they didn't keep it was that it's such a change of pace from the other songs. Also, I think Andrew Lloyd Webber had total creative rights to the show, and this song was not in the original musical.
Shame, though. It's so pretty.
mangobanna 1 year ago
his voice makes my clothes fall off
ycrcoker84 1 year ago 2
he breing a sexyniss to his voie and the mucis i am like paritlised be him every time i here his voie
tori1010ful 1 year ago
I will listen ;'(
SweetDeath777 1 year ago
OMG! If I had seen that before I would have freaked out!!!! seriously. this is soo beautiful. even when I heard the song from minnie driver (which plays in the end), I almost had to cry... but if I had heard the phantom sing... OMG!!! <3
Marmeladenweibchen 1 year ago
@RainbowFirebird i would do more thn hug him too!!!!!lol hes so gorgeous!
huggznkisses1 1 year ago
This probably would have been right before he goes to loosen the chandelier. He's wearing the same outfit. I really wish this could have stayed. I know it wasn't in the musical, but it's just so beautiful and heartbreaking.
woahitsbrooke92 1 year ago
Gerald did the best job that he could (given that he was completely miscast...) but I still think his singing voice is too weak and completely disengaging/uninspiring to be the Phantom.
seattle16song 1 year ago
they should have left this D: its so sad but such a good song he sung a good song D":
TheCamoTurtle 1 year ago
That's what happened to Mr Sparta after his face got ripped out in war.
Agares 1 year ago
It was deleted because no one would listen!? WRONG GERARD! D8 WE LOVE IT! DX AND WE WOULD LISTEN TO IT!
oneshotofcoffee 1 year ago
@oneshotofcoffee this song wasnt deleted, it is in the cemetary scene !
ChristinaDestler 1 year ago
@ChristinaDestler well the scene was deleted
balletluve 1 year ago
where would this be in the movie if it had come with it? and i almost dont hear the guy, cus he sings so low... but i know he sings beautiful :'-)
ziphartstar 1 year ago
If this was in the film, where would they've put it? o.O
iSHiNE2011 1 year ago
i believe it would fit after the scene of ''think of me'' before madame Giry gives the rose to Christin.
it's an amazing scene
eleanavamp 1 year ago
This makes me want to cry :( <3
It should have been left in the movie.
This shows the Phantoms sensitive, but not weak, side.
BurntBridges1910 1 year ago
awww I LOVE THIS!!! why did they delete it???? omg i love i t!!!!!!!! its like my favorite scene and it's not in the movie, typical
101Witch101 1 year ago
Aghhh this soooo should have been in the movie!!! It would have fit perfectly, and it would help define the Phantom's character even more. It explains -why- exactly he picked Christine, and why he loves her so much. I was kind of wondering that before, and this explains it perfectly.
He trusted her and felt that she understood him, which is why she is irreplaceable to him.
The song also makes him more love-able (not that he wasn't before, but even more so). It should have been kept in.
kdog5377 1 year ago
I want to hug him :)
Luenzki 1 year ago
@Luenzki I want to do more than hug him...*drools*
RainbowFirebird 1 year ago
im suppose to sing these song, but everytime i sing it i cant stop crying, it usually starts when i say, "i learned to listen", im such a baby with this song,lol
scencecutie28 1 year ago
where was the song suppose to be? that so should have been in the movie? i think this might to have been shown while christine was singing think of me i bet or while raoul and christine were singing in the chapel befoe don juan
s2468101214 1 year ago
wonderful.
in the german version of this song, sings jana werner ( voice of christine ) the text. it surprised me, that the phatom sings this song in the original version. but...i think gerard butler is a great singer ;)
BeyondBirthdaylove 1 year ago
is there deleted scenes on the dvd.. ?
shep2k7 1 year ago
do you know were in the movie this song fits
anastasiadancer1 1 year ago
Gerard is so handsome.....
Sarinkka1 1 year ago 4
mp3???
otomechan10 1 year ago
@otomechan10 go to