Rise Against - The Good Left Undone

[simpsonjoshua]

The cave and castle-like scene... Didn't you film that in Machern by any chance? : D

[Whibleyffs]

so...deep



[TheWhiteUchiwa]

what a.....weird video.....

[BigLiam123]

Rise against are the best band ever

[KnightStorm1988]

Much better than the official video. I didn't care much for this one either but it is definitely better.

[lightofday86]

obviously the "top comments" know nothing of what this video means. I am fairly certain that the artist who wrote the song would be able to sufficiently produce a video that reflects his intent.. aka get over yourself, not a bad video but come on.. really ?

[scoott04]

@lightofday86 I agree, both videos in my opinion reflect the meaning of the song and are very good but you can't just say the real music video doesn't fit the song, obviously it does since the artist put it out. but great song!!

[AllEyezOnDenIli]

that water tower is in russia in some abondoned city

[pippop190]

They are the only band.. That can sing the truth about the true world...

[thomasperkins101]

this is the best videa

[MurderedtheAlphabet]

Not only is Tim McIlrath a singer and a guitarist....above all, he is a poet.

[penguinsrox87]

OMG I love it! AMAZING!

[icullen1]

whats up with the symbols on their hands when they meet then are torn apart

[guitarownerlol]

thumbs up if you dislike this reaction.

[TheLobster324]

but still a good video

[TheLobster324]

i cant tell if this video takes it the way i do but i feel this is what its saying...

he has never found a girl that seemed great.. but he loved her too much and started ruinung her life so he had to let go to save her, bu he is waiting for her to come back to him ... by thats just because of my past.. :/..

[SgtPepper1993]

@TheLobster324 Exactly what I'm going through right now.

[TheLobster324]

@SgtPepper1993 ya it sucks.. she never went back with me and i finally moved on... which shouldnt be surprising since that comment is two months old haha

[ibprophin]

was it just me, or did any of you beat the shit out of the replay button

[MuzzLikesMusic]

wait, this isn't official? O;

jk, but it's good enough to convince people.

[rillera25]

How people dislike this I may never know...perhaps people really did miss the like button....

[oocotter]

@rillera25 it's called an opinion. Not everyone has to think what you do.

[rillera25]

@oocotter Yes, but I was just expressing how amazing it is. Im not like one of those people that say "6 people need to die" or "BlahblahblahJustinBieberB;ahb­;ah Thumbs if you agree". Its great that people like other things, but how they dislike it is just...

[scoot24925]

wtf? is this video?

[pooopsicle]

he runs like a welshman

[ihatelauryn6]

Meaning: A boy finds a girl that wants him apreciates him and loves him for him. But hes a monster to her and in a desperate attempt to save her from himself he leaves her. This choice hurts him everyday and he always thinks about her. She is a real angel to him, not one with wings or a halo but one who can show him his true path in life, walking beside the girl he will forever love, never leaving him no matter what.

[miguelito3dp]

@ihatelauryn6 I gave you a thumb down coz I miss the reply button. (sorry for that).

I was gonna say that the part of "pulling until the roots gave in" may not be about being a monster, but maybe taking this girl away from the life she had, could be carrier, family or friends, & then the guy realizing that being with her makes the girl lose some chances in life. Maybe this can be about someone who has the opportunity to go live abroad, & wants to take his girlfriend, for example...

[TheGoodLeftUndone27]

this, dear people, is mighty impressive. :)

[jaihind10886]

good effort guys

[devilkill9]

this video sux. in my opinion. i like what the video is actually showing... but the timing of it compared to the song and genre dont fit together. and i just like the other one alot more.

[acase13]

whoever dislikes this has aids.

[96Ostin]

who can dislike this song?

[lilcris159s]

NOOOOOOO NOOOOO y 6 people dislike NOOOOO

There idiots -.-

[redie66]

good vid man

[DjKuberxD]

<33333333333333333333333333333­3333 Rock FOREVER!!!!!!!!!

[PoolKattt]

i know a few other people had said this but this should've won or whatever it is.

[Call4meWT]

youtube.com/watch?v=Lp2SYO2n1M­4

[darkangel364]

This song changed my life

[herpes1903]

228 people Support the 6 Aids Victims in There NeighborHood..

[Torroja1]

srry if my english is bad, i am just 14 and from swe

[Torroja1]

buddha was a real person and he didn´t want to seen like a god

[orangejuicekidd]

woo!

[ThelcecreamMan]

I think the girl uses a speed-hack...

or she's Niinja ^^

[CaroKowalewicz]

geiles video.!! ;D

[therealgraywolf]

this songs fits me perfectly

[irishbmx5]

Tim =God

Zach= Jesus

Joe= Allah

Brandon = Buddha

i.e rise against=musical religion!

[ThelcecreamMan]

@irishbmx5 and I pray every day

[xxxR3m3mB3erxxx]

@irishbmx5 haha dude Buddha is not a religous figure its a fully enlightened being but u wouldnt know tht now would u but i agree this band is fucking amazing

[ollimschrank]

haste schick gemacht :)

[SystemOfAMetallica1]

AMAZING. This is pure awesomeness.

[UncivilizedSerpent]

The video doesn't go with the song...

[nhealalcarnen]

@UncivilizedSerpent

this video totally goes with the song, think about the meaning of the whole lyrics and not the meaning of every single word and you'll see yourself

[UncivilizedSerpent]

@nhealalcarnen Okay, I think I went through it too fast the first time :) Thanks.

[astonishedcrowd]

awesome! damn good job on this <3

[229Rey]

B-E-A-U-T-I-F-U-L

[Silver2301]

sehr schönes video :=) habt ihr euch viel mühe gegeben.. bravo ^^

naja und das lied is sowieso geil ;)

[PinkPinkie2000]

the part about never sleeping but when he does its about drowning in the ocean is really good lyrical imagery!

[mediahater]

this so is so touching x3 :) i smoked a little bit of weed and startet listening to their text, i gotta say its realy poetic. Rise Against is with Soad/Serj the best Social-Critizising-Rock-Band :) bless

[brideath]

amazing job!

[FreaksOnTour4x]

hammer songtext!!!hab mir grad die übersetzung angeschaut!!!!

[LahLahLand011]

BEST SONG/LYRICS EVER<3

[XXxfightforpeacexXX]

good job schaulustiger23 on the vid its nice,

did you take any classes on filming or something?

[funnybunnypissed]

the lyrics to this song might be the most Beautiful and most poet that Rise Against has ever written. straight up

[socksket]

@funnybunnypissed amen

[Mzbianka011]

BEST SONG EVER!!!!! NO DOUBT =]

[ShreddinFreak]

I think that they wanna express that they don't belong together [perhaps anymore]

I don't really know it, but it seems to be a quite locigal answer for that

by the way: Really Really good vid; new Fav !!!

[GingaALE0697]

so amazing! i love it

[PeacennLove]

this is wicked. i love it!

[hera2day]

wow, this is waaaay better than the officail video. Great job. ^-^

[greenangelthree]

i agree with "hera2day" this video is a lot better then the official video. mainly because for some reason the real video does not have anything to do with the song its self where this is almost dead on with the meaning

[toastedfilms]

Really? I saw the meaning it just wasn't as obvious and i loved the directors idea of the band playing in the dirt.

Now this video it's self is the best rise against fan video i have seen yet! just amazing!

[codarkstarxx13]

@greenangelthree You don't know that at all. How could you know the band's true meaning behind the video? There's always more than meets the eye in a work of art. Just because a video doesn't follow a song line by line doesn't mean the meaning has changed, just the way you must perceive it to feel its concept.

[SeriousGamer2009]

@greenangelthree Brilliant, although to me this video and the official one are a bit similar.

[miguelito3dp]

@greenangelthree the official video is mostly the band playing...

[sunstridingblade]

@greenangelthree and whats the meaning?personaly i think meaning in music is different to everyone else

[IRISHDRUNK1243]

@greenangelthree well there is one point where the girl pulls the flower out revealing the light, setting them free, like how he was feeling and thinking during that time

[IRISHDRUNK1243]

@IRISHDRUNK1243 also, i think the flower symbolizes the girl being set fre from the dark cave she was in

[ShReaDHeaD23]

dude this is pretty good

[RiseAgainstFan741]

good video

that guy has hair almost like time kinda

its cool

[Mesmo08]

great job!!!!!!!!!

[KJD120690]

i thought this video was really good. was it supposed to be like romeo and juliet or was that my imagination?

[RAswinglifeaway]

very good video, but it cant top the real 1

[Pepsidude069]

WOW amazing video! I really like it

[Eagle1337]

awesome video, do more guys!

[PiaggioRyda]

This video is fucking amazing....

very good effects.....

Greez

[theyseeus]

This is better than the official video :)

[gregoreomaximo]

that was amazing

[zwansson]

great song (=

[elspector1234]

kick ass song and video.

great job

[freedomfigh3r]

wow.

that was very good!:)

5 out of 5 stars from me!

[theiraqikid]

Shes hott Good video really did like it I can see it being the official music video for the song BTW as for the song my fav chorus ever is when he says All because of you I believe in angels. Not the kind with wings, no, not the kind with halos; the kind that bring you home when home becomes a strange place. I'll follow your voice; all you have to do is shout it out!

[SmackdownRanger]

Awesome Song!

[Clarklikescereal2]

congrats on winning :)

[jackdude911]

love this song

xD

[frozahh]

Awesome.

[jonathonzuniga]

that was an amazing video, although i agree with the others, at times the guy seemed kind of out of it

[GunMetalNocturne]

The guy seemed a bit lethargic, especially when running but good video none the less.

[arthur2387]

GREAT JOB! NICE VIDEO

[Wrrohm]

I liked the Romeo and Juliet theme that kinda went behind it. I'm only disappointed that someone else noticed before I did. ;p

Good job!!

[5knightsproductions]

Very nice video and well done!! I love the yellowish and dramatic look to it! Very cool!!

Check out the one I made. I put it as a video response.

[gowst]

HEy well done nice vid. :- ) , the song too ;-)

[tomthetrain]

you guys won!!

[timcl]

Wow great video, shows a creative outlook on the song.

[freakwhoseestheworld]

the girl is hot

[freakwhoseestheworld]

dude! how the fuck did u actually do this awesome shit with a dvx100! ya guys are awesome.

[SkairKro13]

dude i dont know how u do it but these video r frickin aweseom! 10 outta 5!

[EastCoastKillers]

This is an AMAZING video... love the work, hope to see more from you in the future

[snapmasterV]

Well. . . if you look at the website. . . schaulustiger23 actually did win. . . (not counting the mixup)

[MyrmidonZero]

That was, honestly, a thousand times better than the one that won. You deserved it for the shots on this, the camerawork is awesome, and it's a fine bit of editing to!

[XxUberSoccer]

i honestly say that this is better than the other one

[whyamibored]

....that video was AMAZING, 10k+ Kudos lol, amazing editing as well, 12 out of 10

[perfection001]

holy crap O.O That was SO freakin awesome. Amazing job~

[badesoflink]

this one should have won the other one was all over the place and had nothing to do with the meaning of the song.

but this one was very well done, they made it to win.

[Delanelano]

kind of confusing, but non the less, vary well done!

[joep01234]

congrats on winning the contest, very nice work

[Antynerdboy]

This video should have won the contest tbh :) I think this is the best one!!!

[ytoxx]

@tiffany007

ich glaub du hast da was falsch verstanden, RA haben ihm den sieg nicht aberkannt weil er ein deutscher ist.

und abgesehen davon: es ist "nur" ein video, also da würd ich nix mit gutem glauben verbinden, das vid hat ja nichts mit ihren ansichten zu tun -.-

[Tiffany007]

achso!^^° komisch wo ich das erfahre habe, dass irgendwas geändert wurde stand eben da, dass sie ihm den Sieg aberkannt haben und jetzt dieses andere video gewonnen hat. ect. alles so verwirrend. @.@

[ytoxx]

ja, also sie haben ihm den sieg ja auch aberkannt, aber es gab nen computerfehler und weil das vid aus deutschland kam ging es nicht durch iwelche sicherheitsschranken und kam dann einfach so in die auswahl rein^^

zumindest hab ich es so ähnlich verstanden, wenss falsch ist, korrigiert mich.

aber RA schreiben auch, dass sie dieses vid trotzdem noch lieben xD^^

[Tiffany007]

Also, ich finde es sehr ungerecht, das sie dir den 1Platz abdanken, nur weil du ja aus Deutschland kommst. Da achtet man doch vorher drauf, weil sie ja das Argument gebracht haben, dass sie es vorher nicht bemerkt hätten?! Hallo?!. Und auserdem hat RA dich ja als Gewinner selber gewählt und die wussten ja das du aus D kommst. Naja, wenn sie meinen es wäre so besser dann lassen wir sie mal an ihrem "Guten Glauben" verrecken, denn die Gerechtigkeit siegt immer. (man was für ein spruch. -.-*)

[zacktsvids]

this video s way better than the new winner

[riseagainst05050]

i cant beleive this video won!! that's so great!!! conragulations, it's a real honor to get such a compliment from rise against!!!

[deathmasta25]

Glückwünsche auf Gewinnen des Wettkampfs. Ich bin von Kanada aber meine Großeltern sind deutsch. Froh, einige anderen Leute zu sehen, als Amerikaner und Kanadier, die den Wettkampf eintragen,. sowieso ich habe das Video geliebt.

[thommydertomtomtom]

Glückwunsch :)

[falunitedstandivided]

congrats on the contest win, awesome vid!

[JimPanseRise4Ever]

@ tthournir:

"The film is a no-budget production (besides inevitable costs for driving, eating and drinking) and was shot with a Panasonic DVX100 in progressive mode."

Nochmal Respekt! Hau rein!

[ki11erkeenan]

congrats at the contest win!

[parker4pope]

that was AMAZING

Grats on the contest winning.

[tthournir]

Well done, awesome cinematography, what camera did you use?

[fL0urish]

well done! i saw it some time ago nd just noticed the fact that i will not compete - now it won and YES!

[JimPanseRise4Ever]

Yeah!

Junge, das Video ist verdammt geil! Mach weiter so und du hast denn Sieg echt verdient! Klasse! Wenn Lust hast schick mir mal weitere Projekte von dir!

Stark!

[Asikari]

Very nice video, you deserved the win. Don't let that talent go to waste!

[TayJC]

fuckn ace!

must have taken ages, well done to the winner

[amandamonarch]

Amazing video, congrats on the win!

[Jwmbike14]

way better than the actual music video! haha

i hope this can get you a long way because it shows lots of talent!

[niboladona]

AWESOME vid! really loved it!

and congrats on winning. you totally deserved it!

xoxo

[tux0ofunk]

congrats on winning, pretty awesome vid

[ryanblackhoward]

Congrats on the win, nice video

[seanmcc]

nice win. that chick is a babe.

[FlameofSaiha]

grats on the win man, sweet vid

[Jwmbike14]

great video! you definitely deserved to win... i just didnt like the whole romeo and jliet twist to it, great idea... but i can really relate to this song and what is going on in my life (identical) and it just doesnt seem like the romeo and juliet scenario is right for it.... seems to me more like a "love lost"

[don1400am]

Great vid bro! Great use of dramatice changes and use of close-ups! You deserve the win.

[TUNIT42]

dude freaking awesome! congrats on winning the contest! ur a great director! i will watch ur future videos! haha

[WEBneon]

hehe nette romeo und julia interpretation...

nice vorallem die sache mit den "tattoos" auf der hand!

nice video, congrats fürs gewinnen!

[gradyhess]

I can definitely see why you won. You definitely deserved it. This video is so moving and is a great take on a great song. Congrats on first.

[xchangezz]

thumps up

[Scarecrow915]

This video is totally awesome. Nice effects and editing :D

and ongratulations on winning!

[af4caster]

Kick ass video Markus! Great Job! Congrats!

[akinatsu]

that was amazing- congrats on winning the contest :]]

[joedaddyfoo]

Congrats on winning. You deserve it

[rocksteady443]

great viddd, congrats

[jamie111guitar]

yea im with most of them

myspace :P

but man that was awesome

very creative.

[darlingihaveseenlove]

This is great.Congratulation on winning.

[bflyte]

congratulations dude, this is amazing =)

[ActNone]

CONGRATZ ON WINNING!

[mmdgirard]

dude, this is sick...add some clips of the band playing and it would deffinately be better than the original

[crueldreams]

Wow, amazing video :] Good job

[DeadKennedys007]

nice job man i seen the comment on myspace this is v geed

[riseagainstxxx]

that was awesome. you won the contest!

[LnKnPRkSarah]

Wow, very nicely done. I saw the bulliton from Rise against on Myspace too and decided to check out the winner. It was well deserved, good job. =]

[getnwaywitmurdr]

damnn you did a really good job on this congrats on winning!

[summerfrost2001]

i saw the bulletin on myspace from Rise Against, so i thought i would check this out.

it's amazing.

you deff. deserved the win.

[metalguitarist1504]

is that you in the video by any chance? or did you just direct it.

[RiseAgainst713]

Dude that was freaking amazing. you got some amazing talent. I can see why you won.

[Rush8558]

dude that was sweet what type of operating sytem do you use for editing

[TinasAwesome2]

Wow, I checked this out aftrer reading a bulletin about it from Rise Against.

Amazing job, no surprise you won. With this quality and hard work, I think you deserve it.

[DUfire]

Awesome job.

*Thumbs up*

I'm with ElJefe, good luck :D

[burymetotheend]

congrats. i was rooting for you!

[eljefe2016]

Dude, what an amazing job!!! Hear that? That swoosh?? That was your career taking the fuck off. Congrats man, you deserve it!!!

[crew1323]

wow, great job man.

deff. deserving of the win

[eljefe2016]

Dude amazing job. Here that? that swoosh!!! it was your career just taking the fuck off!!! Great job man and congrats!!!

[peanutbutter619]

gratz on thw in man you deserve it

[punkrockprincess5289]

Lucky You! Congrats! The Video Is Awesome!

[x666xstxjimmyx]

That video is AMAZING!

[pearceftw]

that movie was amazing, you really got talent

[ohyouradolll]

thats amaaazing! great job!

[rastapasta77]

great job on the win :)

[xViper472x]

Nice job, congrats!

[snowsports357]

good job on the win! love it

[HazardSFGF]

Congrats man. You deserve the win