Added: 2 years ago
From: AttractionsMagazine
Views: 78,634
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (260)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • American Idol Awards Given to 7 Winners at Walt Disney World (Attractions)

  • It's cool to see them all together like this! I wish they would do this every year. But Carrie and Kelly are the best by far.

  • Kelly got the biggest Cheer

  • KELLY AND CARRIE ARE THE BEST IDOL WINNERS...FOR MALE ONLY DAVID COOK..

  • CARRIE AND DAIVD!!! THE BEST IDOL.....in that order  :)

  • FOR THE RUNNER UPS:

    1.ADAM LAMBERT

    2.KATHARINE MCPHEE

    3.DAVID ARCHULETA

    4.CLAY AIKEN

    5.CRYSTAL BOWERSOX

    6.BLAKE LEWIS

    7.DIANA DEGARMO

    8.BO BICE

    9.JUSTIN GUARINI

  • FOR THE WINNERS OF AMERICAN IDOL:

    1. KELLY CLARKSON AND CARRIE UNDERWOOD

    2.DAVID COOK

    3.JORDIN SPARKS

    4.FANTASIA BARRINO

    5.RUBEN STUDDARD

    6.KRIS ALLEN

    7.TAYLOR HICKS

    8.LEE DWAYZE..

  • @Renzic18 1. Kelly Clarkson 2. Scotty McCreery 3.Taylor Hicks 4. David Cook 5. Ruben Studdard 6. Carrie Underwood 7. Kris Allen 8. Jordin Sparks 9. Fantasia Barrino 10. Lee DeWyze Runner Ups 1. Bo Bice 2. David Archuleta 3. Crystal Bowersox 4. Lauren Alaina 5. Clay Aiken 6. Diana DeGarmo 7. Blake Lewis 8. Adam Lambert 9. Justin Guarini 10. Katharine McPhee
  • Fantasia is the best idol ever came thru

  • @singrosal david had his hand on carrie's shoulder on 5:16. so cute!

  • Carrie seems like such a bitch she acts like she is better than everyone...... Kelly and David were like laughing and talking and Carrie couldn't even crack a smile

  • I LOVE KELLY

  • whyy was ruben booed?

  • @williamj856 He wasn't booed, they were chanting "roo roo" like the audience did when he was on the show.

  • kelly is still the most successful idol....and the best!!!!! billboard even charted them and kelly ranked #1 over carrie. but either way, they are like the top 2 most successful winners. love kelly though. again- she's the best!!!!!!

  • wazzup

    

  • kelly has really gone downhill as of late yikes.. Carrie is definitly the best now.

  • kelly clarkson fan here always and forever.

  • i like carrie and kelly.they are the most successful of thm all.carrie is my fav

  • can u guys tell me why ruben was booed??

    oh and imo

    Kelly

    Carrie

    Jordin

  • @kellyclarksonismygod they were saying ruuuuuuu not booo 

  • kelly and carrie are the best ever!! and all the others cept fantasia are like one hit wonders

  • The best winner of all is Carrie Underwood

  • kelly is the best idol!!!!

  • BTW Kelly's hair is to die for. Theyr'e so gorgeous, beautiful! Just like her

  • Kelly Clarkson is flippin awesome. Suck it carrie!!

  • AND EVERYBODY STANDS UP TO RECEIVE KELLY CLARKSON :D

  • the best idol winner is CARRIE UNDERWOOD :D

  • omg fantasia i love her  aug 10th her new album release

  • i didnt see lee get one when he won?

  • @jungleizmasivv lee won in 2010 and this was 2009, even before kris allen won :D

  • @morticiamelissa but ryan says future winners get presented a trophy when they win the show.

  • Kelly Clarkson is amazing. The best idol yet

  • kelly was the best...

  • ..i love american idol so far, i love them all bec. of them i enc0urage myself to sing again.. but when Jordin sparks j0in the c0ntest and got the idol winner, i h0nestly m0re c0nfident 2 sing again.. and she's my musical influence.. :-)

    g0 j0rdin. g0 u're not alone..

  • very nice video.

  • go carrie!

    you are the best!

  • Kurt Nilsen is better than them all together

  • Go Carrie

  • For me, Carrie is the best among them.. I just can't help loving her.. She's so sweet and fun to be around and a God-fearing humble girl.. what else?

  • Go on my Channel to watch the German Version of "American idol" and see the difference!

  • they are all so cute ;)

    Paris Lo in las vegas

  • kelly clarkson is so pretty and sweet :)

  • I love how kelly gets the biggest cheer! The first 3 will always be the most popular among idol fans.

  • uh, fantasia isnt popular and either is ruben

  • Idol fanatics still have favorable views of them. They might not buy their music but the first 3 seasons of idol were the season where people really became attached. As each season has gone on less and less people are really becoming attacked to idol contestants with the exception of the davids in season 7

  • @JayMe2823 Fantasia got the loudest reaction from the audience! And everybody was saying Ruben's name when he came out. Are you being sarcastic or r u serious?

  • Go Carrie!!

  • never thought i would see the day all the idols on the same stage love this show

  • Its amazing how similar simon cowell and simon fuller are. Fuller better watch out. Idols days are numbered. X factor is set to take its place on fox

  • Wow, Simon Fuller is so shy...silently crosses the stage, doesn't utter a word and then he just vanishes into thin air.

  • David Cook!!!!!!

  • Before "Breakaway," Clarkson fired Simon Fuller, the "American Idol" creator, as her manager, saying that although he was a "great guy," she needed someone who could give her career more attention. She teamed with Swedish hitmaker Max Martin on "Since U Been Gone."

  • THEY ARENT BOOING RUBEN!!!!!! jeez.

    :)

  • Why everyone is against Rubben?

  • @markoVALJEVO their not, they are saying ru not boo

  • aha,ok...:)

  • Not booing - like Isaac Bruce, the wide receiver - BRUUUCE!!! They're shouting - REUUUUUUBEN!!

  • why are people booing Studdard?

  • i guess he was passing the mic to a crew backstage. Hahas. He made it on time to receive his award:))

  • What was cook doing at 2:49 he like left for a second?

  • fantasia all the way

  • Would you want to win american idol?

    I wouldn't

    If I was granted the ability to win it I still wouldn't

    Instant fame is the reason, instant fame.

    It is a horrible thing to get.

    Fame should come gradually, that way you get also respect for your work. American Idol winners won because of votes by others. You are under a strict contract to make a certain way of music, and after the contract you cant just change your style because people know the regular style, which isnt yours even.

  • Kelly is the best american idol winner.

    no one can change this fact.

  • Well it isnt a fact so ha!

  • i dont care for your opinion no one can say that kelly is bad and simon and randy and polla always saied that she is the best and she done an amazing performers and now she is very big pop star and she has a big and long carrere .

    i think no one can do what kelly did so far because kelly is on her way to be a legend .

    that is fact and i dont care for you to deal or not with it .

    gooo kelly

  • dude, calm down. Fine, you like this kelly.

    Though I am pretty sure others have done the same. Like the Beatles.

    Though I think you need to understand the concept of what is a fact and what is an opinion.

    Fact: Something that actually exists and is the same to all.

    Opinion: A personal view of something

  • damn... kelly c. is the best..

  • No problem :). Remember too that Fantasia's music was R&B, so if you're not into that type of music you probably wouldn't know what she's been up to. Since winning AI in 2004, she's been nominated 8 times for various Grammy Awards, the most recent nomination was this year as Best R&B Performance by a Duo or Group, which would have been shared with Jennifer Hudson. In addition to nominations there were wins, so she's definately doing things. Take care :)

  • Yes; Fantasia has and continues to do a lot after idol, including being on Broadway, nominations for multiple grammys, and awards. She's an AI favorite and that is what you hear in the response to her introduction.

  • oo ok see I am not into broadway so this helps alot!! Thanks!

  • im so glad kelly and david finally met!

  • once kelly said that her friend who was very girly makes her used dresses liike this, I want to say kelly change your friend or your clothes, you are amazing and your voice right now is around the world, please come to south-america

  • kelly and carri are the the best

  • From everyone who won, my favorites go in this order: Cook, Clarkson, Allen, Underwood, Sparks, Studdard, Hicks

  • Comment removed

  • My favorite will always be Kelly Clarkson.

    Carrie Underwood and David Cook are amazing as well, though.

  • Comment removed

  • I like how Simon Fuller just sort of disappears like a vampire...you don't see him leave...he just vanishes. Amazing!

  • kelly is busy with other things and maybe she hadnt time for be so inmerse in idols´s world and its winners, seven years later she has a successful carrer and planning to be for 30 years more like simon cowell said, kelly has gained a real career as an artist and the respect of other big artist, that means a lot od time of working.

  • DAVID COOK is the ULTIMATE best!

  • kelly and david are the best!!!

  • DAVID COOK is the best!

  • YES! they went OFF for my girl FANTASIA!!

  • words8 of8 wisdom, where were you all this time or which idol have u watched or listened too, haha, you must be kidding.

  • Love all of them...what a great, diverse group of WINNERS!

  • People booed for Ruban :( I feel bad lmao

  • Why the people say booo to Ruben?

  • no, they are saying are saying "roo" it's what people said when ever he was on Idol. :)

  • they say RUUU for Ruben

  • Taylor Hicks the best!!!

    the best ever are: Clay Aiken and Adam Lambert!!!

    poor Ruben, people say boooo

  • 1. David cook

    2. Kelly Clarkson

    3. Fantasia Barrino

    4. Jordin Sparks

    5. Kris Allen

    6. Carrie Underwood

    7. Ruben Studdard

    8. Taylor Hicks

  • Comment removed

  • is this going to be held this year as well?

    i wanna see david cook and kris allen hang out =D

  • they were not booing at ruben. they were saying "ruuuuuuuuuuuu!" and yea cause theres a throphy this year for the winner which is Kris Allen so it wudnt be fair for the other winners in the 7 seasons not to get it too

  • why did they booed at Ruben Studdard?? i really like that guy! :D

  • they said roo

  • Is an award really neccessary?

  • they one the biggest talent contest in history do they really need a stupid trophy??? GO KELLY BTW

  • Its funny every singer turned out to be very diverse and american idol has changed so much. Whoever wins 09 will come a long way..ADAM!

  • his hands where a little low on carrie for simon...

  • why did they booed studdard?

  • Maybe it's just me, but I thought the audience was cheering, "RUUUUUUUUUUUUUUBEN."

  • I heard that as well.

  • thats messed up how they were with Ruben Studdard .. they should show some respect on the real .. that crap wasnt right !

  • DAVID COOK not cock.. WTF.

  • I know.still the best

  • Comment removed

  • something good will happen to you at 9:10 someone will call you or talk to you online and say i love you or ask you out but heres the catch send to 3 vids

  • did i heard wrong ? i heard that the audiences "BOO" for that season 2 winner ?

  • no, they were saying "too" the winner of season 2 is Ruben Studdard and every time after he performed or whatever they said "roo".

  • wtf? weres adam lambert? lol

  • Wow, the competition never ends does it? LOL Instead of just enjoying the ones you happen to like, it has to be "Oh, she's better than him, or he's better than her." You have to ruin all the fun with such childishness. The only ones up there that I've ever actually purchased their music are Taylor Hicks (including his pre-idol "Early Works," the Idol album, and his latest indie project "The Distance"), and David Cook .

  • Comment removed

  • was this show on one night or was it like a concert thing ? :)

  • i love Fantasia

  • I believe that carrie's voice is pure and the best live singer, not one other Idol can sing live better then Carrie

  • Kelly clarksons the best! <333333

  • I look at that stage and I see massive talent...the pop princess, the R&B teddy bear, the urban songstress who brought Gershwin into the 21st century, the small-town girl turned country superstar, the unique Southern talent, the teen R&B sensation, and the sensitive rocker.

    Awesome, awesome, awesome.

  • yes fantasia did an awsome job at the uncf for patti labelle and got rave review she is the best american idol and the sexiest to love her

  • Yeah. I love this. Fun to watch. They look like they had a blast. Don't forget to watch David on Idol tonight at 8:00 debuting his single, Come Back to Me. I think they are going to show his new video with him kissing someone, but I am not sure.

  • Those of you with the jacked up out ideas about Fantasia check her BET performance out she did recently Done Enough,& Total Praise her mother joins her and her UNCF performance nationally televised (both) The Patti labelle tribute......we keep up with our people!!!!! you got it twisted!!!! all here on youtube!!!

  • Fantasia is OUR American Idolto you prickly racist white folk ...and she got the same award as them and she is a big success to us because we know the playing field is not level and she is stil lin the game only 24 and to you haters the best is yet to come...she wanted to own herself and that is what she has been working on!!!! Getting her duck all in a a row!!!!

  • Carrie has more awards, because country music has their own awards beside the grammys she got.

    Kelly probably sold the most records because she is popular INTERNATIONALLY to europe and asia..unlike any other AI winners..

    Fantasia is not commercially succesful but she is one of a kind and never failed to give wonderful performances

  • shut up with the racial bullshit already!! we are all tired of it.

  • racist? excuse me? did i mention anything regarding race in my comment? i dont think so! so u better read and think carefully before bursting out about ppl making 'racial bullshit'

  • there was absolutely nothing racist about this comment! what an ignoramus!

  • People went insane when they said Kelly's name. She's awesome!!

  • For the girls, I think Kelly is the best, then Fantasia, then Jordin, lastly Carrie(sorry, but I don't find anything special in her voice). For the boys, David, Ruben then Taylor... Over-all: Kelly, David, Ruben, Fantasia, Jordin, Carrie, then Taylor... but don't get me wrong, I love all of them and think that they are all very talented singers.

  • funny enough the other day when kelly was idol ryan said that kelly had sold the most albums than idol alum. and don't even get me started on who has the most awards.

  • dont get me wrong fantasia is amazing but Carrie has them all beat. I think her record sales and awards speak for themselves.

  • clive davis one of the greatest music producers..who founded whitney houston.(who is one of the top 5 greatest singers in the world) said when he heard fantasia sing for the first time.he would give her a recording contract right away.if she wasnt on idol. the whole industry respects fantasia and raves about her voice. i bet they respect carrie and the other idols too.but from what i have seen many "already legends" and music industry pro's have been blown away from fantasia and have said it too

  • david cook is the best idol ! followed by kelly clarkson and carrie underwood

  • yea he rocks but you kidding... carrie underwood is the most succesful follow by kelly clarkson but david cooks rocks thoe...

  • no kelly is the most successful. sold the most, has the most awards, most successful worldwide.

  • I AGREE..i love COOKIE!!

  • how come there are 8 seosons and theres only 7 of them?

  • probably bcuz season 8 winner has not been chosen!!!!

  • umm... the best are Carrie, Kelly from the winners i think.. this is my opinion!!! i like david archuleta too... but CARRIE ROCKS!!!!!!!!111111

  • I'm not gonna lie, I'm kind of skeptical about this attraction. Unless Disney is going to be providing the fee for the winners of each "experience" to come back, I think its a big waste of money, especially for those who don't make it. But then again, you can always go to the other attractions in the park to kill time or go in the shops.

  • They should have sang or something! My fav's are Carrie, Fantasia, Jordin, & Kelly. None of the rest of them, seem to be doing much. The runners up are doing great. Like Clay and David Archuleta.

  • Are u kidding fantasia sucks she's done nothing. Taylor and ruben havent done anything eather cause they suck.Look at carrie' David ;KELLY and so many others who deserved a number one position who did so much more then those 3 losers.

  • hey...ok enough... even the american idol judges think fantasia is one of the best singers that came out of idol... im osrry but fantasia is probably the best idol to ever come out... jus because she hasnt made any popular songs that people like doesnt mean she sucks... actually fantaisa did great in the r&b category..and has been nominated for 9 gammys. plus in a interview simon cowl said that he thinks fantasia and kelly clarkson were probably the best idols that ever won.

  • plus fantasia is probably one of the best vocalist out there right now... whenever she performs she gets standing ovations... actually her last two performance she got standing ovations from patti labelle and kobe bryant... and has gotten a standing ovation from oprah. and why do u think while she was on idol the judges were so fond and impressed by her... they never gave her bad criticism...not once. she was the lead on Broadway in the color purple and has a #1 best selling novel...

  • plus her range is great and her vocal runs and riffs are incredible.... she made elton john cry in a performance once because of the soul and heart she put in it.... he gave her a standing ovation. she has 1 #1 hit and has received numerous awards. im not syaing the other idols are bad... cuz to win idol you have to be good. but fantasia was either the best or one of the best idols ever. jus because they didnt make popular pop commercial songs that get famous and stuff doesnt mean she sucks.

  • fantasia made an r&b hit called "when i see you" i was nominated for a bunch of Grammys. cariie has won grammys and so has kelly... and no other idol has even been nominated for one. david hasnt. fantasia has been nominated for 9...but she is always up against more popular artist like alicia keys and beyonce... so thats why she doesnt win.. cuz alot of times the grammys go by popularity not all the time though..the grammy is the highest honor in music and to even be nominated is incredible

  • umm jordin was just nomniated for a grammy this year for no air ft. chris brown thank you verry much!

  • well my bad ok so jordan got ONE... and she didnt win... im not saying thats a bad thing... jordan is great. you have to be great to win idol... but fantasia is way better then jordan..vocally... and she is much better at entertaining and moving around on stage... im not saying jordan is bad..jus fantasia is better... even ask simon or any of the judges they have all said it. i think it was so great to bring all the idols on one stage :)...

  • well fantasia does have that power voice that not a lot of people have so i will give you that much!

  • You kidding right??? even jordan blows fantasia out of the water but the best ones are carrie and kelly you should know that by now....

  • well yea if you go by record sales and grammys and things of that such both kelly and carrier are beating fantasia but i don't think there's no question that vocally fantasia has the better voice you gotta be kidding me...she just has a voice like no other...and don't get me wrong i absolutely love carrie and kelly i'm huge fans of both of them as well!

  • Comment removed

  • fantasia is a much better singer then carrie...carrie is awesome good too...i saw her idol performance from last night....it was great.....but fantasia has so much soul and power....her runs are more amazing....and everything.... she never got one bad reply from the judges while on the show!! not one! and even simon says fantasia and kelly are the best to come from the show (in a interview)... kelly has much more success but her voice isnt as good....

  • I must disagree with you on this one fantasia she is a good singer im not saying she is bad but you cant compare her to carrie and kelly in my opinion they are the best AI and have a better voice and can hit a high notes flawless and better than the other idols but there all good.

  • she doesnt sing like a mouse.... and she has gotten standing ovations from...stevie wonder.. patti labelle... oprah!!.... kobe bryant.... the american idol judges....and her past recent performances she has gotten all standing ovations...i wanna see carrie get that... and especially from the people i named... fantasia made elton john cry because she did such an emotional performance... you guys are just going by popularity...i go by actual vocals skills and vocal prowess...

  • Well do your research cuz all of your points are WRONG! KELLY has sold the most albums...20+ million world-wide and with Kellys new CD she exceeded carries U.S. sales as well. As far as carrie singing at STAND UP FOR CANCER, doesnt mean shit! cuz ashanti, ciara, nicole, miley, keisha, and mary j. should not even be called singers...they are shit !

  • so dont give me that shit that fantasia hasnt done anything. ruben hasnt done anything your right about that...but he doesnt suck... otherwise he wouldnt have won... and taylor doesnt suck...i dont think hes incredible but he doesnt suck. and why is that in this video when ryan introduces fantasia she gets the biggest applaud and cheers... its cuz fantasia is incredible and real idol fans know that. kelly got a big cheer too... and ryan said "the one and only fantasia"...

  • i totally agree with chngreactn they suck... its carrie kelly david c and jordan are the same.. the other 3 should be replace by clay, diana, and daughtry....

  • well the american idol judges have said they think fantasia is the best... and whenever she comes back for a performance she always blows them away...and gets standing ovations....but i do respect your opinion.... kelly is amazing and so is carrie.