Added: 5 years ago
From: nokia3510
Views: 239,668
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (268)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 我覺得最難頂係有D人口臭又要學人講嘢囉!

    口賤得人憎,我覺得最乞人憎嗰個係你自己

  • 欣宜好好啊

  • + oil Joyce! u Can Be The BesT!!!

  • 無問題囉人地,,,你最有問題

  • 人地唱歌關你乜撚事

    你唱呀咁勁 得把口

    好好反省~~

  • ok啊~

  • When I read those unkind, cheap, low and above all UGLY comments, I realize how truly ugly people can be. Ever watched to 'grow with love' (with Myolie Wu)? Isn't the inside that's the most important? I bet most people will say so, but now I see how hypocrite people can be, it scares me.

  • do you believe in karma?

  • I wonder what you all would do if it is you that is being criticized like this?

    At least she is not skin and bones like most HK people who still thinks that they are fat at that point.

  • 我覺得她如果要做幕前,應該行佢呀媽既路線比較適合

  • they purposely put the flashing lights in our faces.. so we cant see her ..lmao

  • 雖然外表平平, 而且她的唱功都有待改善, 但是全面來講我覺得也過得出. 歌詞很有意思, 不錯.... 現在我替她的媽很擔心, 希望她早點康復.

  • OK guy, she sings better than a lot of ppl wow...

    ...but that doesn't mean I don't "dislike" her...

  • her voice ok..mandarin not bad too..much better than jay chou mumbling..

  • her voice is ok.. but the video and lyric so annoying.

  • This MV is a crap! Actually I can't really see the singer clearly because of the stupid dazzling light behind her!

  • the mandarin's okay. it's normal. but i think that the quality of the video is not good? cause there seem to be like noises. anyway, don't know who is she so can't be bothered

  • interesting, she's got a great voice..but i dont really like this song..make more, i might like other ones u make lol

  • Well...her voice sounds oke to me but I have the feeling that it's edited or something like that :S hmmm I just can't stop laughing when i saw this for the first time haha sorry

  • her mandarin is ok... and her voice is ok also... but i dun like how she moves while singing the song...

  • her voice is great, but wth? This MV is messed haha it sux

  • i'm a HKer....to be honest, her singing is not that bad but did her voice get edited or something when the MV was being produced? i mean it doesn't sound like her voice.

  • about her lyrics

    she is talking about herself????

  • Actually, it was not a bad song. And I am impressed by her mandarin. Not bad at all...

  • shes trying to hard...and thats joyce cheung

  • sounds a bit country...reminds me that shes trying to be shania twain or something HAHAHAH

  • soo controversial how people would say they wont let things affect their job..is that whats shes doing? even though her moms condition is like that? theres like two perspectives to look at i guess. HK people are jealous because she gets what she wants..its not that easy being able to get acting scenes and singing..or they just hate the fact that shes still overweight? but yah she did lose alot of weight? the lyrics are really simple..but i guess for a new singer -_-

  • its only 1 min and 33? good thing its not anything longer then that. she gets to make the mv because of her MOMS reputation not HERS. while shes at it, shes using her moms sickness that gains media attention where she has a share of it. yes i guess you can say shes not a caring daughter..didnt her moms condition improve? but still...and i guess its smart to make her mv now..

  • Her singing is not that bad. HK ppl just hate YY cos she was obese and is still overweight. Ppl should give her a chance. If she lost more weight she'd just look like Kary from cookies.

  • Its not that bad. Her singing is abit rough, but I think if more training it would be good. The song is caughty, hmm she needs to work on the dancing though.

  • If she's bad, what makes Janice Vidal so good on dancing?

  • why does everyone hate her so much she didnt even do anything wrong she just went on a diet =.= her singing isnt that bad either

  • her voice isn't bad compared to other hk singers. but PLEASE PLEASE learn how to dance

  • her voice is better than lots singger at HK~

  • woah that's not a nice thing to say

  • i was going to watch this mv and listen to this song with an open mind.. and i don't hate her.. but it's bad...

  • Did you know Faye Faye didn't even know she was filming this MV because Faye Faye was still in the hospital recovering?

  • the song is NOT bad.  if u want bad, listen to songs by most of the hk singers.... shes a lot better than them

  • I think the light effect did a really good job, since we couldnt see her face that clear...and her motion is... i mean...but her songs alright,even better than most of the hk singer, however i know her personality is fucked

  • i cant see her face clearly beacause of the spotlight,well...i think her voice is ok but the MV sucks ,especially the lyrics....unbearable~~~~

    er...why people here attacked her so barbaric?have she ever done sth intolerable?

  • Really that bad? I don't think so. Only the HK Commercial always promote THIN THIN THIN je. Many foreign popstars are not THIN or EXtremely white too. Are they wrong? :P

  • She can improve. A WHOLE LOT!

  • the lyrics is odd and plz~stop skating too much~ maybe it's ok in canada but definately not in hk..and i can't even see her face with the spotlight~ -.-

  • oh my god. the comments suck ass. Has anyone here ever heard her sing live? shes sings better than probably more than half the hk celebrities can sing live. Half the ppl here dont even noe wat they're saying. out of all the ppl who put comments here, who actually noes her in real life, and who has actually seen her sing live. Ok, maybe her looks arent that great, but u gotta admit her singing is better than a lot of ppl.

  • it's not that bad, it's really a shame on the hk ppl that complained her. She just need to stop shaking her body too much. The ones that complsin are very low-life.

  • To be frank. yan yee sings well

    But please

    she should stop shaking and showing off her "precious artificial" body

    and those spot lights are extremely crappy

  • Well, the lyrics and the presentation is a bit odd, but she is better than lots of performers in HK. Give her a break la.

  • ok gum la....at least she's making an effort...look at other 'idol' chicks...

    want to hear her sing live though...

    btw...she's not that fat gwa? like...compared to people outside hk? u'd seen queen latifah?~

  • her live is better than more than half the idols in hk. seriously. ppl should give her a break.

  • hk people are really mean,shame on you guys,she is not pretty but she is not bad,i dont think its funny making jokes on her.

  • wow. shitty comments. i dont think shes that bad at all. she hasnt done anything to offend u guyz or anything.

  • she is my favour singer!

  • Voice is good, but appearance unnatural

  • I ain't a fan / friend of her but she sings a lot better than many HK so-called 'artist' or 'idol' or 'singer'

    Yet, the MV need a better editing skill and director

    Also, if she just be herself and dun pretend, would be a lot 'easier'

  • I am surprised that she sings so much better than many of the Hong Kong singers. Her voice is so much more professional and mature than those who actually cannot sing in live or even in MTVs where producers tried to fix their voices to sound close to perfect or even to the pitch. Hong Kong people only know how to judge others by their looks. Not everyone has the look of a beauty pageant, plus everyone's interpretation of pretty is different from one another.

  • I am surprised that she sings so much better than many of the Hong Kong singers. Her voice is so much more professional and mature than those who actually cannot sing in live or even in MTVs where producers tried to fix their voices to sound close to perfect or even to the pitch. Hong Kong people only know how to judge others by their looks. Not everyone has the look of a beauty pageant, plus everyone's interpretation of pretty is different from one another.