Added: 1 year ago
From: RhinoUK
Views: 1,402,195
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,810)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Im confused about the video... are those Klansmen?

  • @ber06e I think they're monks

  • Clássico do gothic rock !

  • The Jawas from Star Wars!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • A true masterpiece.

    

  • just got 3 minutes in before I realized the song name was atmosphere....not the artist

  • @Canadaeh127 why?

  • sweet, I wish I could kiss all my friends right at their lips while drifting away forever with this song...

  • SO SAD THAT THE GOOD ONE'S ALWAYS GO YOUNG...BUT JOY DIVISION MUSIC IS WHAT WE CALL ALTERNATIVE MUSIC NOW,,,THEY INFLUENCED EVERYBODY! CHECK OUT A BAND CALLED THE HORRORS AND THERE SONG CALLED A SEA WITHIN A SEA..

  • thumbs up if slug brought you here

  • I miss good music like this.

  • OUSO ESSA MUSICA ALGUMA VEZES AO DIA A MAIS DE 3 ANOS .ME LEMBRO SEMPRE DA MINHA PRINCESINHA QUE FOI ASSASINADA UM DIA EU ME VIGAREI .

  • Comment removed

  • oh Ian, love has killed you. And I'm really sorry for you; Rest In Peace <3

  • This song should have way more views! <3 its such a classic! !!!!!!!!!! :)

  • great song and great video by photograph Anton !

    

  • i love ian and i dont even know him am i wrong for that?

  • do you like joy division? search in youtube tab (thieves like us) all of they song are so fucking awesome and they are the same genre and ritm that joys divison have. thumps up so everybody can see it.

  • Anyone who labels this "depressive" is a geek.

  • baylingual.bandcamp

    .com/

    You like free hip hop? then copy this url^^ and download the album by Ookie of Baylingual..

    and if you like it subscribe to my channel

    Peace 1love

    Twitter

    .com/baylingual

  • Nothing is true, everything is permitted

  • @father042 I understand now that our creed does not permit us to be free, it permits us to be wise.

  • omfg i love this song!

  • Thumbs up if Ian Curtis took you here.

  • The kkk dont wear black lol

  • Esos nopales en el minuto 3:08 ya estan chingones para unos bisteces o una cecina de yecapixtla..mmmm!

  • I am Grand Wizard man!

    Born leader of the Ku Klux clan!

    No, they are priests, not Klansmen nor any of their affilates. People forget their history, hahahaha...

  • Là, on est vraiment très très en hauteur... La terre doit paraître bien petite vue par les yeux de ce morceau. La production aide, certainement, mais même avec un banjo et une flute, ça le ferait...

  • I miss you ian !!!

  • thumbs up if your a bellend, enjoy the fucking song

  • The Internet brought me here....

  • IN SIGH LUNSE

  • @SPOREthomas lol

  • i went mad to this

  • @TheYellowellies

    Voices in your head tell me you are still mad.

  • @BoycottIsrahell you know nothing

  • Your confusion ..my illusion

    Don't walk away..

  • thank you misfits <3

  • Like if you're listening to this minutes before your suicide.

  • the last REAL pop legend.... long live

  • @diGITALPh0X what?!

  • Ian Curtis' what do you think his message was !!

  • I love this song. Always makes me cry.

  • I was annoyed when I watched this documentary on ' IAN CURTIS/ JOY DIVISION' I got annoyed when Peter hook was acting like he couldn't give a damn about ian's death.

  • @TheKathleenR Don't be annoyed he does...it's just were all guilty of being a little goulish about his death and he is probably asked about it every day!

  • I love the ending; everyone walking along the beach filmed by what is some type of 8mm camera.

  • I first heard this song on a beach in Alassio (Italy) in 1984. Never tire...it's appeal is ageless. The black and white robed monks represent his polar depression...his heady highs and singular lows. No one understood then but his peers represented it well in this fantastic memorial to a very unique and talented man.

  • RIP IAN CURTIS

    LOVE WILL TEAR US APART

  • This song haunts me to my very core. It's so strikingly shudder inducing and also very beautiful. Without Ian Curtis, i would not be the person i am today.

  • shaun for you mate may you rest in peace

  • I can't see the dislike bar in every video about Joy Division!

    I'm French and i'd like to have some good band like Joy Division in my country

  • lmao the singing sounds like sid vicous!

  • @surfthecentre joy division's main influence was the pistols, although i think they saw them during the glen matlock time.. 

  • Walk in silence, don't turn away, in silence.Your confusion, my illusion, worn like a mask of self-hate, confronts and then dies. Don't walk away...

  • i dedicate this song to my friend William who sadly committed suicide recently... at least your pain is now over, rest in peace William and rest in peace Ian Curtis

  • @MotorsportUK2009 soryy about your friend my dad also commited suicide and its something il never get over i cant listen to certain songs without breaking down

  • The Trip, Coogan/Brydon.

  • @r0galik She was only 16. She was only 16!

  • Thumbs up if music took you here

  • still just as good as when i listened to them on late night john peel. late 78.

  • I'm a huge Joy Division fan and have been since I first heard them. I saw them in Bournemouth in 1979 supporting The Buzzcocks - I was blown away.

    But I've always thought that this video is awful and tacky and adds nothing to the song. A eulogy it may be but I cringe when I see it.

    It reminds me of the opening footage to the '79 Neil Young film, Rust Never Sleeps in which hooded figures also stumble around with large objects occasionally falling over - and for me, that spoilt a fantastic gig.

  • Listen to Hooky and Morris,and recognise the true talent of this band.

    Curtis being the sublime singer/writer,but Sumners ongoing spat with Hooky,is the ruination of this great lineup.

    NO is fuck all without Hooky.

  • Anyone can tell me what's the font used in the beginnig of this videoclip?

  • @MitchKabuza KIMLAN, which is also a soy sauce brand.

  • I've been listening to that song since the day it came out and will listen to it till I die!

  • Fucking beautiful.

  • In silence, don't walk away-

    words to die by

  • The negative and the positive charage. What do they mean? anyone?

    Rammstein says it means don't cover my songs no more. no really  what do thy mean?

    cause it's an awfully silly video for a song that seems to romanticize darkness so well.

  • this video is stunning. just amazing

  • Grande.

  • LMFAO!!! KKK, HUH? U DUMB,DENCE,DOUCHE

  • You can hear the lump in his throat. Jesus.

  • doesn't get any darker than this.

  • is this video directed by Anton Gorbijn? I think so...

  • Druids? Monks? It's Jawas, motherfuckers.

  • Are those people meant to look like the KKK ?

  • Comment removed

  • The Sielence my Friends ,, heres the real meaning of JD .......The Joy Division, a group of Jewish women forced to work as sex slaves in Nazi concentration camps

  • RIP

  • This is definitely one of the most beautiful song ever written

  • Were Joy Division Klansmen? I don't understand the use of such ambivalent imagery.

  • @outsidemendham No Joy Division were not members of the KKK. The white figures are supposed to be wearing burial shrouds. I don't think there is anything to understand however. Isn't that supposed to be the beauty of 'ambivalent imagery'?

  • @outsidemendham They're dressed as Druids or an order of monks in Spain ... fashion counts.

  • @outsidemendham I don't understand your stupidity. What a waste of f-ing humanity. Some group of s--tsticks co-opts certain imagery then no one is supposed to ever use it again? Really? Robes existed long before the KKK, jackass.

  • PERFECT! I love this music!

  • This was the first JD albums I bought as a 12" single with She's Lost Control on the B side. Absolutely amazing sounds.

  • This symbolises Everything .. We must all be able to distinguess opposite .. FFS It is in everything ..

  • Comment removed

  • how can anyone dislike this song?

  • "you confusion ...i ilusion ."

    joy division muito louco !!!

  • Love the vid but hate the ads that surround it. YouTube needs to get rid of that shit.

  • @hoibsh Download Adblock Plus on Google Chrome or Firefox; that gets rid of all of them.

  • @itworks92 excellent, many thanks.

  • @hoibsh I agree bro

  • im a mexican guy i've got my mind like "OH FUCK!" when i've first listened to it

    and this video i think even if in the begining i didnt take care much about the lyrics because it was like oh god this video is fucking strange but then i realize when it ended all the meaning i think joy division puts much more in a song by the way to feel a song... and then i look up for the lyrics and its was fucking brillant so, yeah i think i love this, it's sad to look in the past to see this kind of music

  • @Drope182 .....very well put ....exactly right!

  • @cjuulb Haha, you mean the Jawas? I agree completely.

  • Comment removed

  • @robin9997 obviously you did take notice, as you responded, plonker, I hope that keeps you quiet

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Cool song. The dudes with the hats looks like the ones from star wars dessert.

  • @cjuulb I have spent ages trying to think of Jawa-related dessert puns with no success, so all I can reluctantly say is I think you mean desert.

  • @cjuulb Jawas... or Ku Klux Klan morons :P

  • @cjuulb Jawas, bro. Jawas.

  • @cjuulb FAIL

  • @cjuulb

    Cool song? This is THE greatest song ever written. :) It lies within your soul. :) Love another like you love yourselves. :) The times are coming. :) Wake up. :) Mother earth needs us. :) Love her!!!! looooooove heeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeerrrrrrrrrrr­rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr­rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr­rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr­rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr­rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr­rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr­rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr­rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr­r

  • @cjuulb jawas <3

  • inquietante ma anke bellissima

  • @devotodm Oddio, credevo di essere l'unico italiano a vedere il video di questa canzone bellissima....

  • @tagikistandomina e si lo so..gli italiani ascoltano tiziano ferro, biagio antonacci, gigi d alessio...sta roba qua..

  • dont walk away.....

  • can anybody explain me what is going on in this video?

  • @slipperypessimist the black guys are negative and white ones positive! got the massage?

  • @kitsune090 huh, anything else?

  • @slipperypessimist yes, this is Klu Klux Klain little brother! and Ian was fascinated by nazism, as the name of the band is related to it. read more so next time u dont need to ask anybody like a lost child!

  • @kitsune090 It's not the Ku Klux Klan. It's the outfit used by people that participate in the Holy Week in Sevilla (Spain). It's a Catholic procession.

  • @slipperypessimist imhe people who 'explain' modern art ain't normally worth listening to mate. see what you make of it. And, if you watch it again in 5/10/15 years time, chances are that what you see then will be quite different. that's why i think 'explaining' modern art is a pretty pointless exercise.

  • they will never no.........wee bit special,,,cheers ,,

  • this is dark

  • Great song nothing like the 80's...

  • I've always hated this video!

    

  • @jumblyman Why?

  • @jumblyman  then fuck you.

  • breve vita quella dei joy division, ma musicalmente intensa. Molti gruppi devono dire grazie al loro genio. Grandi!

  • Ho detto a mia sorella che il giorno che non ci sarò più al mio funerale venga suonata questa canzone, questo è il mio volere.

  • Indecipherable for 99.99% of youtube users.

  • @fuckthecuntsonyoutub Well then I must be apart of the 00.01%.

  • KEEP GOOD MUSIC ALIVE. Check out my channel for some Indie Hip Hop. Peace.

  • @sugamwtoxristo Grotesque cunt.

  • @MoreLittleFishies .........well said!!

  • Nice to see the jawas got some work after star wars

  • Great Tune For When Your Depressed And Drunk

  • Superb

  • Poraża mnie to...

  • made the fatal mistake, like i did before.

  • @9999heroin You made a fatal mistake? That's why you're alive to type that, right?

  • @MoreLittleFishies I'm Turk and i'm low level speak english but i think i'm understand. joy division - only fatal mistake :) and my life and ian curtis life the same..

  • don't walk away . . . in silence

  • @sidDkid87 don't walk away

  • @Xenodemic In silence . . . Hey friend, since you like this song may I suggest you check out the following cover of "Atmosphere"?:It's listed as follows on YouTube:

    "Márcio Cirne - Atmosphere (Joy Division Cover)" . . . imho, it's an excellent cover of this great JD tune with a really nice to go with it vid as well - enjoy!

  • os boms morrem jovem ......atmosphere perfeita

  • 85 indiotas 

  • Very fine music.

  • PORQUE LOS GEENIOS SEVAN PRONTO

  • hideous. just atrocious. SAVE DARFUR. end racism.

  • 85 dislikes??? WTF?? If you're searching for Joy Division vids and come across this, how can you possibly dislike it? Some peoples taste is in their asses!

  • @imacpherson3 joy division shook the world with satire. of course people arent going to understand it and dislike it or go crazy about racism.

  • @mediattackrecords the reason ian curtis killed himself also was because he felt like noone could help him escape his extreme drug problems. yes, he was an antiracist ACTIVIST, yes, he shook the world, but he also was desperate for change and the LIBERAL carter administration is a reflection of how POST PUNK really did make a difference. a 22 year old activist is very young.

  • @mediattackrecords SENSITIVITY is not activism. its dying to live. theyre definitely a CORPORATE and slightly militant POP ROCK band. what they did for BLACK people is beyond what most bands would even dare. alot of people think they gave black people MUSIC education. of course. liberals help people thats why im a democrat. we have no party left.

  • @mediattackrecords im not saying everyone has to get recruited into black music but for the most part they gave poor people something to live for and a chance to rise. having a race is an organized revolution its not chaos and anarchy.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @mediattackrecords to have a race or just two is a war. tell me it isnt. i would hope so. canada and mexico has only two races mostly. theyre not at war. im just pointing that out.

  • Comment removed

  • @mediattackrecords how do u know he was a anti-racist activist? is it in the book or somethin. i heard once that he was a casual racist or something like that.

  • I love how the majority of the paintings their carefully carrying, are of Ian. :(:(

  • Achingly beautiful!

  • Scoperta grazie a romanzo criminale *__*

  • I shed a tear at the end of the film Control when this came on, I am so gutted I was born in the wrong era.

    R.I.P Ian Kevin Curtis 1956-1980 Love Will Tear Us Apart

  • Comment removed